Crisis of Civilisation

I judge people to a large extent on their past behavior and reputation.
No doubt, had you met Isaac Newton personally, you would have dismissed his laws of motion as just another crackpot theory. (His research on biblical prophesy alone would have had you running around screaming "CT").
 
For every Isaac Newton there are thousands of loonies convinced they are right.

Sorry, but I can't take a truther seriously in any way. If one said the sky was blue, I would go outside to check.
 
I'm afraid that doesn't count for much, given that the JREF operates on "mob mentality."

It's also not all that relevant, since the claims you are talking about aren't made in the film we are discussing and his currently stated position seems perfectly fine to me. Unless you are still pushing the line: "he once said something I disagreed with published a book with paranoid theories that were completely non-factual in basis , therefore I can't be bothered to listen to anything else he says."
Fixed.

For every Isaac Newton there are thousands of loonies convinced they are right.

Sorry, but I can't take a truther seriously in any way. If one said the sky was blue, I would go outside to check.
Indeed.
 
For every Isaac Newton there are thousands of loonies convinced they are right.
That doesn't address the fact that if your word had carried any weight in his day then Newton would have burned at the stake.

The funny thing is that even though you won't read a "crackpot" post, it doesn't stop you expressing an opinion about it. Fortunately, there are JREFers who rely on more than just ad hominems to decide on the merits or otherwise of a post.
 
Oh right -- gas goes to eight bucks a gallon and hey presto up go the nuke plants and windmill farms and out come the electric cars and everybody carries on as if nothing much important happened.

Thanks for illustrating my point.

You were making it a point to demonstrate poor reading comprehension? Glad i could help:rolleyes:
 
That doesn't address the fact that if your word had carried any weight in his day then Newton would have burned at the stake.

The funny thing is that even though you won't read a "crackpot" post, it doesn't stop you expressing an opinion about it. Fortunately, there are JREFers who rely on more than just ad hominems to decide on the merits or otherwise of a post.

A see your ad hom and raise a non sequitur
 
Still not buying it. Sounds intuitive, but a simplistic explanation.

A couple things:

1) we (i.e. consumers) largely take for granted the potency of oil as a fuel. How we drive, heat and cool our home is partly an unconscious resposeto that potency. Drive a couple hundred miles for a weekend vacation? No problem - fill 'er up and go.

we sure do. I like the Chris Martenson valuation technique of a gallon of fuel- put your family and a load of luggage in a car and drive it is far as a gallon of fuel lasts, then turn round and push it back again.

whats it worth to you then? more than $4 I suspect.

2) Those alternatives - or cargo cult fantasies as you put it - have prices at which they are viable. Thus, volatility in the medium and long-term has its limits. Oil goes to $8 a gallon? Cool - more electric cars, solar water heaters, nuclear power plants, windmill farms, etc will be produced.

and of course, at that point with everyone screaming in pain with not being able to run their usual lives any more, they'll all have the cash to switch to new electric cars and solar & wind infrastructure wont they?

this might happen if people were taking the threat seriously now, IMO what will happen is a period of big problems as people realize they are not ready and needed to start thinking much more seriously about doing it a long time before they were forced to.
 
I don't know about you, but I judge people to a large extent on their past behavior and reputation. For instance, I have formed opinions on people who start "look, look, we are all doomed" threads supported by pronouncements of nutters.

Well, what you are doing doesn't have anything to do with skepticsm or critical thought.

I repeat: you must judge what people say on its own merits, not on an opinion you formed of them because of something else you once heard them say in a different context.

Think of it the other way around. Imagine somebody who says: "This person once said he thinks homosexuality is wrong. Now he's telling me there's a bomb in the next room. I see no reason to take anything he says seriously. After all, he's a homophobe!"

Who is the bigger fool - him or you?
 
Last edited:
we sure do. I like the Chris Martenson valuation technique of a gallon of fuel- put your family and a load of luggage in a car and drive it is far as a gallon of fuel lasts, then turn round and push it back again.

whats it worth to you then? more than $4 I suspect.



and of course, at that point with everyone screaming in pain with not being able to run their usual lives any more, they'll all have the cash to switch to new electric cars and solar & wind infrastructure wont they?

this might happen if people were taking the threat seriously now....

It might have happened if people took the threat of climate change seriously twenty years ago.

Unfortunately, most humans aren't very good at accepting bad news.
 
Do you really think so?

Yes. See: climate change denialism.

The media is filled with bad news. The truth of the matter is though that humanity today is better off than ever before.

That depends what you mean by "better off." We have more material goods and flashy toys than ever before (thanks to the near-slave-labour of Chinese people who have no control over their own lives.) Unfortunately, if we take a cold, hard look at things, what we lack is any sort of security or hope for a sustainable future. There is a whole generation of people growing up right now whose future has been stolen from them. They have very little to look forward to. In the UK, somebody who is now 15 is looking at not being able to get a job, never being able to afford to leave the parental home, not being able to afford to go to university, no hope of ever getting on the "property ladder", no hope of being able to save money (interest rates lower than inflation), no point in saving for a pension.... They are well and truly buggered.
 
There is a whole generation of people growing up right now whose future has been stolen from them. They have very little to look forward to. In the UK, somebody who is now 15 is looking at not being able to get a job, never being able to afford to leave the parental home, not being able to afford to go to university, no hope of ever getting on the "property ladder", no hope of being able to save money (interest rates lower than inflation), no point in saving for a pension.... They are well and truly buggered.
And yet, all four of my children (aged between 16 and 24), and all of their peers do not fit that stereotype. My eldest has graduated and works for a software firm, dividing his time between Japan and London. He's already on the property ladder having bought a flat in London. My next two are at university, and my youngest is at college and is applying for apprenticeships as he isn't interested in university. All of them have had part time jobs while studying and do not anticipate problems in finding full-time careers once they have graduated. It's not just my children making successes of their lives but also all the other young people they know who are the same age. I am sure that some young people fit your doom-laden stereotype but a "whole generation"? That's completely overblown hype.
 
And yet, all four of my children (aged between 16 and 24), and all of their peers do not fit that stereotype. My eldest has graduated and works for a software firm, dividing his time between Japan and London. He's already on the property ladder having bought a flat in London. My next two are at university, and my youngest is at college and is applying for apprenticeships as he isn't interested in university. All of them have had part time jobs while studying and do not anticipate problems in finding full-time careers once they have graduated. It's not just my children making successes of their lives but also all the other young people they know who are the same age. I am sure that some young people fit your doom-laden stereotype but a "whole generation"? That's completely overblown hype.

I am glad your own family are doing well, although I question the morality of having four children in the first place. I assume you do understand that what I am saying does indeed apply to many others of their generation, and that the prospects of those coming through behind them are even worse.

I do not believe I am overblowing the seriousness of this situation, or where it is heading. The economic problems you've seen so far (since 2008) are just the hors d'oeuvre. The main course is yet to be served.
 
You question the morality of having four children? On that basis I question the morality of you living in the UK. Wouldn't you have a smaller footprint living in, say, New Guinea?

Who are you to question the morality of anything?
 
You question the morality of having four children? On that basis I question the morality of you living in the UK. Wouldn't you have a smaller footprint living in, say, New Guinea?

Who are you to question the morality of anything?

I question the morality of (certain) Australians on a regular basis :D
 
Moralizing is for the pulpit.

Oh, wait, preaching is what some of you are doing. Not everyone is a convert, sadly.
 
You question the morality of having four children? On that basis I question the morality of you living in the UK. Wouldn't you have a smaller footprint living in, say, New Guinea?

Oh dear....

Slight difference, lionking. People CHOOSE how many children they have (at least they do in the developed world). They do not choose where they are born.

Who are you to question the morality of anything?

I'm a human. It is part of my human rights to be able to question morality, and if you attempt to deny me that right then you are morally bankrupt yourself.

EDIT to add: the above quoted statement/question is probably the single most bone-headed, offensive thing I've seen posted on this board so far. It is actually trying to make it sinful/immoral to ask moral questions. Unbelievable.
 
Last edited:
You were making it a point to demonstrate poor reading comprehension?
What's to comprehend? Your statement was simple and straightforward:

"Oil goes to $8 a gallon? Cool - more electric cars, solar water heaters, nuclear power plants, windmill farms, etc will be produced."

Certain "alternatives" do indeed become more viable as the price of oil increases. Walking, for example. Others become less viable, because they depend on a whole bunch of stuff that doesn't exist, and producing that stuff takes money, energy, and time. What you are implicitly suggesting is that if our economy came under a great deal of stress, it would respond vigorously with an enormous wave of new investment, and consumers would be standing in line to purchase all of these electric cars and solar water heaters which would appear instantly.

You're hallucinating.
 
Questioning my morality (something which you have little right to do, and less information on which to base your judgement) does not alter the fact that your assessment of today's 15 year-olds in this country as "buggered" is easily refuted.

Some 15 year olds who lack education, drive, ambition and stable backgrounds fit your doomsaying stereotype. Plenty of people in the UK are working to help these young people (NEETS) in order to get their lives back on track so they don't become part of the underclass, and some will escape the destiny you've mapped out for them. Some won't and it's a tragedy for them, but it's not something that has ever been different. The vast majority of young people do not fit your stereotype, and will leave school to go to university or go directly into employment and remain productive members of society throughout their working lives.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom