Crisis of Civilisation

UndercoverElephant

Pachyderm of a Thousand Faces
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
9,058
http://crisisofcivilization.com/watch/

I thought this was rather good (I agreed with pretty much the whole film). A lot of the topics covered have come up on this board recently.

http://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/review-crisis-civilisation/

The Crisis of Civilization, due to premiere tomorrow, is a documentary film that is remarkably pleasant to watch considering its subject matter: the looming destruction of civilisation as we know it.

The film looks into how “global crises like ecological disaster, financial meltdown, dwindling oil reserves, terrorism and food shortages are converging symptoms of a single, failed global system.”

Over less than 80 minutes of running time, Dr Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed, the principal narrator of the film – and author of A User’s Guide to the Crisis of Civilization: And How to Save It – draws a compelling portrait of the emerging economical, political and environmental trends that are likely to shape our common future over the next few decades.

His thesis is devastating in its simplicity: unless structural changes are introduced to the way we run our world, we won’t make it past this century, possibly not even the halfway mark. This might not strike readers as particularly different from mainstream environmental orthodoxy. However, CoS adopts a bold set of starting premises.

First, only by observing the trends as a whole, Ahmed argues, can we really get a sense of the sheer urgency of the situation. Whereas anthropomorphic climate change is in itself a very serious threat, the true extent of the unfolding horror can only be apprehended if you combine it with, for instance, the arrival of Peak Oil.

[continues]
 
Peak oil has a lot of evidence going for it.

As pointed out in the film, "peak oil" is a historical fact. Hubbert predicted that US oil production would peak in the early 1970s, was ridiculed, and was then proved correct when it actually happened. Hubbert's theory is therefore proven to be sound - it is not "just a theory." There is no question that the global version will also happen (or has already), the only question is when. And the evidence is stacking up for a date of 2005 or 2008, depending on precisely what you mean by "oil."
 
no, but it almost certainly means a radical change to our current world of cheap easy energy and all that follows on from that.

Yes, like the use of alternative energy sources that become economically viable when the price of oil rises.
 
Yes, like the use of alternative energy sources that become economically viable when the price of oil rises.

The more "economically viable" the become in terms of extraction/generation (the price of energy goes up, making it possible to make a profit out of that energy source), the less economically viable it becomes in terms of actually keeping the economy going (because everybody has to pay more for their energy, which acts as a generalised destroyer of economic activity.)

In other words, nothing is "economically viable" if the customers can't afford to buy it, even if the alternative is getting cold or going hungry.
 
Yes, like the use of alternative energy sources that become economically viable when the price of oil rises.

it is not about "the price" they can print money, it is about how much energy is used to create these new sources.

and there are currently zero viable (EROEI) alternatives for liquid fuels for transport, at any "price"

plus, when you factor in all the other things oil is used for apart from just fuel, well, people haven't really grasped this properly yet IMO
 
As far as I know, diesel engines can still be converted to run on vegetable oil without damage to the diesel engine so peak oil is overrated. Natural gas and ethanol will pick up slack eventually and so will hybrids. We need cars that can take multiple fuel sources reliably.

Financial meltdowns happen all of the time and civilization goes on. Natural disasters like supervolcanic eruptions could happen and I don't think there's much we can do about them.

We need thorough monitoring of the power grid to shield for solar flares and a strong emergency electronics supply in case of EMP from attacks, but neither of these are likely to collapse civilization.

For better and worse, civilization is amazingly resilient.
 
The more "economically viable" the become in terms of extraction/generation (the price of energy goes up, making it possible to make a profit out of that energy source), the less economically viable it becomes in terms of actually keeping the economy going (because everybody has to pay more for their energy, which acts as a generalised destroyer of economic activity.)

In other words, nothing is "economically viable" if the customers can't afford to buy it, even if the alternative is getting cold or going hungry.

If you know the economy is going to get much worse in the future, be that because of energy shortage, paying more today by borrowing from the future is a stimulative activity. It increases economic activity today while avoiding a collapse in the future.

I know we typically think of investment as spending today to make more in the future, but it can also be about spending today to ensure that you don't make less in the future.
 
As far as I know, diesel engines can still be converted to run on vegetable oil without damage to the diesel engine so peak oil is overrated.

The vegetable oil was until recently an unused "waste product" from restaraunts, and using that sort of oil as fuel is certainly a good way of recycling (sort of), but it has no impact on peak oil. If the vegetable oil was produced by industrialised farming then it required crude oil in its own production and distribution. We can't replace crude oil with vegetable oil. That would just cause an even bigger food crisis, and it is an inefficient use of the crude oil required to grow the vegetable oil. You might just as well just use the original crude as fuel instead of using it to grow vegetable oil.

Financial meltdowns happen all of the time and civilization goes on.

Nothing like this has ever happened before. The scale of the problem is on a new order of magnitude. The whole global system is going down, not just a localised part of it.

For better and worse, civilization is amazingly resilient.

Civilisations faced with the sort of resource problems we're up against usually collapse.

Humans are very resilient though. I've heard this response many times: "But humans are the most innovative and adaptable species ever! We've overcome every obstacle nature has put before us in the past, what is so different this time?"

The answer is in the question. We are indeed a tenacious lot. We're devious, we're tough, and we don't give up without a fight. Evolution may only have provided us with one sort of survival strategy (brainpower), but it turned out to be a world-beater. From an ecological point of view, this can't possibly be the solution, because it's the root cause of the problem. The greatest threat to human survival on this planet is not climate change, ocean acidification, water insecurity, deforestation, soil erosion/depletion, collapsing fisheries or loss of biodiversity. It's not even Peak Oil. The greatest threat is the likely behaviour of eight billion individual humans finding themselves plunged back into a strange new version of the process which created them in the first place: survival of the fittest. (Not that it is obvious precisely what "fittest" means in this case, given that the original version of that process created humans to live in small tribal units and almost nobody lives in such units today. Survival of the fittest what?)

This time it is different because this time the problem we are faced with is our own "amazing resilience." We can't fix this by using any of our normal strategies for dominating the rest of the ecosystem. We have to voluntarily go in the other direction, and we're no good at that.
 
Last edited:
If you know the economy is going to get much worse in the future, be that because of energy shortage, paying more today by borrowing from the future is a stimulative activity. It increases economic activity today while avoiding a collapse in the future.

I know we typically think of investment as spending today to make more in the future, but it can also be about spending today to ensure that you don't make less in the future.

You cannot spend money you don't have, unless somebody is willing to extend you credit...
 
The end is nigh!

Where have I heard it before?:rolleyes:

Except this time really is different, and all you have to do to realise that is watch the news and try to understand what is already happening. The film refered to in the OP is not about a religious prophecy; it is a detailed analysis of what is what is presently happening in the world by a person who has a very good grip on it. If you don't agree with him, perhaps you might explain why? Have you watched it?
 
So, short of a cull of humanity or a global government does Dr Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed have any bright & original solutions to offer?
 
So, short of a cull of humanity or a global government does Dr Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed have any bright & original solutions to offer?

He explains why that isn't really appropriate at the end of the film.

My answer, which I suspect he'd largely agree with:

In order to stand the best chance of being able to do something about it, as many people as possible need to be as well-informed as possible about the true nature of the problems. What is needed is holistic thinking, both in terms of all the individual aspects of the situation, and how those aspects are inter-related. The solutions, if there are any, will have to be both top-down and bottom-up at the same time. The whole system has to change, and that is going to require top-down reform, but those reforms have got to deliver more control to local communities to manage their own affairs and (crucially) their own land/resources. It is no good trying to design some grand top-down scheme where the state runs absolutely everything. Many of the solutions will have to come from the communities themselves, tailored to the individual circumstances of those communities.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom