This is what Julian Simon was saying 30 years ago. History shows economically free people will rise to the challenge.
If that's so, can you spell it out? What case, specifically, can you make from history that shows that "free people will rise to the challenge"?
It's worth noting that today's challenges are not yesterday's challenges: fusion, for instance, is
hard, and may be harder than was the development of coal as a fuel to replace wood. We don't know how hard fusion is, so it's odd to assert that we are necessarily capable of figuring out how to do it with the resources we have in the next, say, 30 years.
Of course, there are other options than fusion:
Solar is viable in that the energy necessary to power our civilization is
there. But the cost of the infrastructure (and it's maintanence) to develop solar as a viable power source in this sense is
huge. Do we have the wealth necessary implement it as a solution?
Fission seems to me the most viable, but again there are certainly issues. The start up costs
are quite high. There's an argument to be made that a high percentage of those start up costs are due to unnecessary regulation, and another argument to be made that if the crisis we are facing is as dire as some posit, that even the reasonable regulations are overestimating costs and underestimating benefits associated with fission. But even if fission is a viable solution to maintain energy production in rich nations (like the USA), its another issue entirely whether it is viable in poorer and less stable nations. Finally, if our energy production shifts to nuclear, there are very real issues of
infrastructure change, (for instance, electric cars? As well as improvements to the grid to get that electricity to the cars).
Other options like wind, tidal, biofuel, etc. seem to me to be even less viable.
My view, however, is that we will likely find some way to combine both improvements in our energy production (like fission) with changes in energy use and infrastructure. At least, I think that's the most viable solution. It certainly remains to be seen if it will be implemented.
But, the fact is that as the price of oil goes up, there will be greater investment in these sorts of technologies. Personally I'd prefer that such investments are made before the need arises: I'd like to see a major program of developing nuclear power in the US now, not next year or next decade. When, as dynamic points out, we've still got the cheap oil to power that development.
Economically, $4 a gallon gas just barely begins to scrape the bottom of calling into existence these other technologies. No government intervention needed to "help".
I agree with you that the economic reality is that as the price of oil increases, we'll see investment in replacements for oil. We can't assume however, that this will necessarily solve all of the problems. I think one side puts too little stock in this activity, but on the other hand you put too much: there's no gaurantee that the level of investment that ensues will avert the "crisis", and we can't know one way or the other without real analysis of this particular case.