Crisis of Civilisation

There is no crisis here. In 20, 40, 100 years, the cars you drive will be better and more plentiful than today. Maybe they will be mostly gas. Maybe they will mostly be something else. But there will be no crisis. The only crisis would be if government tried to ration cars, or gasoline, or oil.
The problem (according to the OP) is that we have a system that requires us to consume this planet at ever accelerating rates in order for everybody to have a living. Even a static rate of consumption would cause wide scale hardship in this system.

Unless there is a nuclear fusion breakthrough, we are going to reach a point where the world can't produce enough energy to prop up this system - government or not.
 
The sun comes to us in the form of a "fine mist" whose rate we cannot alter.
Luckily the total energy in that "fine mist" is immense, so I don't think we're likely to hit any hard limits there soon.

If you think about it, coal and oil and gas are really "concentrated sunlight". That's why, until recently, they've been so very convenient. You can take out as much as you want on demand.
Well, you can take our as much as you can with the resources available to you.

With solar you can build more solar panels but past certain limits you can't alter the rate at which they generate electricity.
And building more solar panels it similar to developing more coal mines (or building more coal fired power plants): both require an investment to start up.

The issue is that solar is more expensive on a $/Watt basis, not that there's something fundamental about solar power that makes it unmanageable.
 
This is what Julian Simon was saying 30 years ago. History shows economically free people will rise to the challenge.
If that's so, can you spell it out? What case, specifically, can you make from history that shows that "free people will rise to the challenge"?

It's worth noting that today's challenges are not yesterday's challenges: fusion, for instance, is hard, and may be harder than was the development of coal as a fuel to replace wood. We don't know how hard fusion is, so it's odd to assert that we are necessarily capable of figuring out how to do it with the resources we have in the next, say, 30 years.

Of course, there are other options than fusion:
Solar is viable in that the energy necessary to power our civilization is there. But the cost of the infrastructure (and it's maintanence) to develop solar as a viable power source in this sense is huge. Do we have the wealth necessary implement it as a solution?

Fission seems to me the most viable, but again there are certainly issues. The start up costs are quite high. There's an argument to be made that a high percentage of those start up costs are due to unnecessary regulation, and another argument to be made that if the crisis we are facing is as dire as some posit, that even the reasonable regulations are overestimating costs and underestimating benefits associated with fission. But even if fission is a viable solution to maintain energy production in rich nations (like the USA), its another issue entirely whether it is viable in poorer and less stable nations. Finally, if our energy production shifts to nuclear, there are very real issues of infrastructure change, (for instance, electric cars? As well as improvements to the grid to get that electricity to the cars).

Other options like wind, tidal, biofuel, etc. seem to me to be even less viable.

My view, however, is that we will likely find some way to combine both improvements in our energy production (like fission) with changes in energy use and infrastructure. At least, I think that's the most viable solution. It certainly remains to be seen if it will be implemented.

But, the fact is that as the price of oil goes up, there will be greater investment in these sorts of technologies. Personally I'd prefer that such investments are made before the need arises: I'd like to see a major program of developing nuclear power in the US now, not next year or next decade. When, as dynamic points out, we've still got the cheap oil to power that development.



Economically, $4 a gallon gas just barely begins to scrape the bottom of calling into existence these other technologies. No government intervention needed to "help".
I agree with you that the economic reality is that as the price of oil increases, we'll see investment in replacements for oil. We can't assume however, that this will necessarily solve all of the problems. I think one side puts too little stock in this activity, but on the other hand you put too much: there's no gaurantee that the level of investment that ensues will avert the "crisis", and we can't know one way or the other without real analysis of this particular case.
 
Do not personalize the argument. Keep it on topic, keep it civil and do not import arguments from other threads.

Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis

I don't understand that last bit. Surely if an argument from somewhere else is relevant here it would be ok, no ?
 
I realise that much of this debate is now about how we are likely to respond to peak oil, but if anyone is interested in evidence for the timing of peak oil, please take a look at the link at the middle of this post.

I presume that most people already realise that Saudi Arabia is by far the most important oil-producing nation. When Saudi Arabia peaks, the world peaks, because there just isn't anywhere else with Saudi-sized reserves. What fewer people may realise is that most of the oil the Saudis have exported over the last 50 years has come from just one enormous field, known as The Ghawar.

I first heard about Ghawar in 2001, when I came across the following short piece written by Chip Hanes:

http://www.newcolonist.com/ghawar.html

Chip Hanes said:
I can picture a Mercedes Unimog lumbering alongside pipelines in the desert, stopping at each well head. At each stop, a man climbs down from the machine and walks over to the well. He looks and records a number from the gauge, then returns to the truck. This scene plays out over and over. It would take days to record all the numbers from the wells in the Ghawar. Still, it must be done. Those hand-written numbers are given to a field technician who dutifully records them, one well at a time, in a computer database. All that data gets sent to the Saudi government, where the numbers are studied, analyzed, and agonized over. If the figures are the same as or higher than the last figures, life is good. If not, then what?

What if the Ghawar IS dying? It would be easy enough to play with the numbers for a year or two--until the decline rate starts to speed up and the loss can't be hidden. After that? Plan B might call for a declared "voluntary reduction" in oil production to "stabilize the market at the optimum level." Yeah, right. How in the world would you ever know exactly how much oil is being pumped or shipped from a country half way around the world to other countries you've never seen? The answer is obvious: You wouldn't. You never will. C'est la vie.

That was written eleven years ago. The charts in the link below, which contain the most recent data availalble, show us that production from the Gharwar has fallen every year since 2003. The Ghawar is already in terminal decline. But this is only part of the story. Maybe even more importantly, have a look at the line for their internal consumption of oil, which is following the rapid expansion of their population.

http://www.theburningplatform.com/?p=31870

CHARTS OF TRUTH

I hate to interrupt your regularly scheduled dose of MSM and government misinformation and propaganda, but this just in – GAS PRICES ARE HEADED HIGHER.

As usual, if you want some facts and truth about the world of oil, you go to the Oil Drum website.

This first chart shows that Saudi Arabia and these other key OPEC nations have doubled the number of oil rigs pumping oil since 2003 and oil production is absolutely flat. Zip. Nada. A 100% increase in oil rigs and 0% increase in production. Ever heard of peak oil?

Now for the coup de grace. This is a busy chart but tells the whole story. The Ghawar oil field is the biggest in the world. It generates 50% of all Saudi Arabian production at 4.5 million barrels per day. It started producing in 1951. That makes it 61 years old. Please observe the production line on the chart. Do you notice a trend?

Please check out the cumulative discoveries. Do you notice a trend?

Look at how many oil rigs it is taking to keep oil production flat.

And now the factor no one is taking into account. Saudi Arabia is consuming more of their own oil as they become more modern and their population grows dramatically.

What we have here is a big problem for the U.S. of A. Saudi Arabia will never produce the 12.5 million barrels per day that they say they can. Their current level of 9.8 million barrels per day is straining their oil rigs. Gharwar is in terminal decline. They are consuming more oil and exporting less.

Get used to $4 gas as a floor. Of course, if you elect Gingrich, you’ll pay $2.50 a gallon. He has a plan. The numnut Republican candidates have a plan. Drill, drill, drill and bomb, bomb, bomb. That should work.

Supply and demand sure is a bitch.


Chip Hanes in 2001 said:
You're Invited to the Funeral

Measured up against the big scheme of things, the death of Ghawar and our oil-powered industrial civilization will fall somewhere between the Black Plague of 14th Century Europe and the meteor that wiped out the dinosaurs. Unlike the plague, this will effect humans world-wide, but unlike the meteor, it will effect only humans. Chickens may some day cross the road with impunity. Animals both large and small will prosper (Hey, you try whaling in a row boat!) And the earth will undoubtedly cool off a bit. Too bad we all won't be here to enjoy it.

With the death of Ghawar will undoubtedly come the deaths of humans. Many humans, it would seem, the result of probably unavoidable wars for the last remaining oil to the much-predicted pandemics and mass starvation. Estimates on the sustainable limit to humans on this planet have ranged from an utterly dismal 1/70th of the current population (about 100 million) to an almost cheerful (by comparison) two billion. Keep in mind there's six billion of us here right now, so some of you will have to leave. You'll stay for the funeral, though, won't you? I mean, after all, Ghawar is dying...
 
Last edited:
But peak oil is not an uncontroversial concept. If the concept is false, how are your predicitions affected?
 
But peak oil is not an uncontroversial concept.
Neither is evolution, which has been described as: "Hotly debated -- in trailer parks across America".

Among oil industry experts, the only debate over peak oil is concerned with the timing.
 
But peak oil is not an uncontroversial concept. If the concept is false, how are your predicitions affected?

There's nothing controversial about the concept of peak oil. As Dymanic suggests, just like evolution, the controversy is generated outside the field of expertise in the issue, not inside it.

Hubbert's theory is rock-solid science. It has met the requirements for mainstream scientific acceptance by making predictions which proved accurate. But the reality is that it ought to have been accepted even before then, because it is so obviously true once you take the basic facts about oil geology into account. Well...one fact in particular: the bigger an oilfield is, the easier it is to find.

Take Ghawar for example. It is 280km x 30km. It is hardly surprising that when people started prospecting for oil in Saudia Arabia, it didn't take them long to find the Ghawar.

The only other thing you need to know is about the lag between discovery of a field and the point of maximum production, and the shape of the production bell curve at every level from an individual field to the entire global supply.

The only legitimate scientific debate here is about the precise timing (and possibly about what exactly counts as "oil.") And I think that debate is nearing its conclusion. There are signs of an emerging consensus. Some people put the peak in 2005, others in 2008. Additional factors have come into play since 2008, and it is these that have provoked the emerging consensus. The first of these is "demand destruction" caused not only by consistently high oil prices, but by the general economic chaos since the crisis of Autumn 2008. The second is the impact of the blowout in the Gulf of Mexico and the resulting delays in the development of deepwater drilling. Both of these factors have led to a slowdown in investment in new fields and new technology. They have tipped the balance so that quite a lot of the people who are watching this stuff have become convinced that the peak of 2005/2008 will prove to be the high-water mark of global oil crude oil production. Saudi Arabia has peaked and there is zero probability that production increases elsewhere can offset their declines. And that means Peak Oil has already happened.
 
Last edited:
UE, there is one other issue though that I think you miss in your above post (which I generally agree with): the possibility of advances in technology opening up previously inaccessible reserves.

Oil sands, for instance.
 
UE, there is one other issue though that I think you miss in your above post (which I generally agree with): the possibility of advances in technology opening up previously inaccessible reserves.

Oil sands, for instance.
The reason we've only recently come to count those as "reserves" at all is not so much that they ever really were all that inaccessible, or that getting at the energy they contain really demands any particularly advanced technology. It's that the extraction process itself consumes so much more energy than is the case with conventional sources that it would have been absurd to even consider large-scale efforts to go after that energy while the much higher quality stuff was still flowing freely from conventional fields in ever-increasing amounts. Now that that is no longer the case, there are obviously going to be continued efforts to find new ways to scrape the bottom of the global oil barrel with more efficiency, and small successes will be announced with much fanfare, but it's hard to get too excited about all that while keeping in mind the reason those efforts are being made in the first place.
 
The reason we've only recently come to count those as "reserves" at all is not so much that they ever really were all that inaccessible, or that getting at the energy they contain really demands any particularly advanced technology. It's that the extraction process itself consumes so much more energy than is the case with conventional sources that it would have been absurd to even consider large-scale efforts to go after that energy while the much higher quality stuff was still flowing freely from conventional fields in ever-increasing amounts. Now that that is no longer the case, there are obviously going to be continued efforts to find new ways to scrape the bottom of the global oil barrel with more efficiency, and small successes will be announced with much fanfare, but it's hard to get too excited about all that while keeping in mind the reason those efforts are being made in the first place.

Maybe, but if "the bottom of the global oil barrel" contains more oil than all those easily accessible reserves, that certainly changes the picture that's presented.

Does it? I don't know, I couldn't find any estimates of total conventional oil reserves. But we certainly need to do that analysis rather than saying "since it's harder to get, it must not be meaningful in comparison to conventional oil." That doesn't make sense.
 
Maybe, but if "the bottom of the global oil barrel" contains more oil than all those easily accessible reserves, that certainly changes the picture that's presented.
Not really. The size of the reserves is not what counts. If that were the case, then solar energy would solve the whole thing quite handily, because the total amount of solar energy that falls on the surface of our planet exceeds our total energy needs thousands of times over. The reason solar energy can't replace oil in our present energy economy is that the rate at which that energy can be captured is not very good compared to the rate at which energy in the form of conventional oil can be extracted from the ground. For a number of decades, we have treated that oil as inexhaustible. We have gambled more than we can afford to lose on its inexhaustibility, and because simply walking away from the table is not an attractive option, we're doubling down on our bets in the hope that we can somehow win it all back.

Does it? I don't know, I couldn't find any estimates of total conventional oil reserves.
There are good reasons to question the honesty and accuracy with which the size of some of the most important reserves have been reported anyway, and the same is true of the claims currently being made regarding the size of unconventional sources like oil shales and tar sands.

But we certainly need to do that analysis rather than saying "since it's harder to get, it must not be meaningful in comparison to conventional oil." That doesn't make sense.
It does if you understand that "peak oil" refers to the point of peak oil production. I have seen some claims regarding the size of some of these unconventional "reserves" that are well past the optimistic and well into the sensational, especially when the information is packaged for consumption by potential investors. But the claims tend to be much more modest when it comes to the projections for actual production, even when the required technologies and infrastructures are fully developed. That won't be for some decades, and all the while, production from maturing conventional fields will be continuing to decline.
 
Dynamic, one of the points you make in response to other forms of energy generation (beyond fossil fuels) is that we don't have the infrastructure in place to do it: both in terms of the generation and in terms of turning that power into useful forms for, for instance, transportation.

That's quite valid. But in the case of unconventional oil, for instance, that argument no longer applies. Clearly, yes, there is some infrastructure needed, but the necessary investment is no where near that for, say, nuclear. Most of the infrastructure is the same as what is used for conventional sources of oil today.

So, what do you expect to happen with regards to unconventional sources of oil as the price of oil goes up? You don't think that more of it will be taken out of the ground?
 
The question is not; When will oil run out?
It is; When will oil get so expensive that we'll finally tell those envo-weenies to STFU and start building those goddamn nuke rectors?
 
Dynamic, one of the points you make in response to other forms of energy generation (beyond fossil fuels) is that we don't have the infrastructure in place to do it: both in terms of the generation and in terms of turning that power into useful forms for, for instance, transportation.

That's quite valid. But in the case of unconventional oil, for instance, that argument no longer applies. Clearly, yes, there is some infrastructure needed.
A whole bunch, I'm thinking.

...but the necessary investment is no where near that for, say, nuclear.
That seems to need the support of some actual number crunching, but I expect you're probably right.

Most of the infrastructure is the same as what is used for conventional sources of oil today.
Not really. Bitumen is fiendishly uncooperative stuff compared to conventional crude oil. You have to flog the ground pretty hard just to get at it (throwing back into the process a lot of the energy potential you just worked so hard to obtain), and then you have to do some more fancy and expensive tricks to get it to flow through the pipelines that will carry it to the refineries -- that is, once you've built the special pipelines required, since ordinary pipelines can't handle the higher temperatures and pressures and caustic properties of the product.

Of course, if you're continually relying on the promise of "advances in technology opening up previously inaccessible reserves", then as soon as you get all of that infrastructure in place, you'll probably be looking at tearing a lot of it right back down again so as to make way for the latest upgrade.


So, what do you expect to happen with regards to unconventional sources of oil as the price of oil goes up? You don't think that more of it will be taken out of the ground?
Absolutely. And profitably, too. We're seeing that already. But our vehicles don't run on oil company profits. They run on oil-derived products. So the question is: How much more? And since we have a daily requirement for transportation fuels, the question needs to be answered in terms of daily output. U.S. consumption is around 20 million barrels per day. The wiki link you posted has 2006 bitumen production in Canada averaging 1.25 million barrels per day. If they can increase production by roughly that amount every ten years, (these guys seem to think that's reasonable) it will just about offset the decline in US production.

That beats a poke in the eye, but as for it changing the picture as far as the peak of global production goes, I have to stick with my earlier response: Not really.
 
The problem (according to the OP) is that we have a system that requires us to consume this planet at ever accelerating rates in order for everybody to have a living. Even a static rate of consumption would cause wide scale hardship in this system.

Unless there is a nuclear fusion breakthrough, we are going to reach a point where the world can't produce enough energy to prop up this system - government or not.

And therein lies the flaw of the physical scientist's argument - they are the ones with the static analysis, drawing not just unwarranted economic conclusions, but regularly disproven ones.

The free market solves these issues faster than they become a serious problem, where this is defined as cost of resources in a long-term trend with minimum 10 year granularity.

Your very statement that fusion is required belies a static analysis. Theodore Roosevelt once decried the coming timber crisis because railroads with their rotting ties would obviously consume all lumber at their current replacement rate.

Capitalism said no, and invented creosote coating of ties. The "crisis" is a fraudulent notion of politicians and physical scientists who, like anyhody else, can't prognosticate what humanity is cleverly capable of.
 
Last edited:
The free market solves these issues faster than they become a serious problem...


Hmmm, and when did this free market decide on its own to tackle the matter of acid rain? Oh, that's right, it didn't. It was only the threat of the government stepping in with heavy legislation that prompted the idea of cap and trade as a free market-like mechanism to try and deal with the problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom