his concern, even if correct, is irrelevant in a free society, barring government intervention and rationing, which exacerbates the issues...
capitalism, which is to say, economically free people, barring government intervention, will rise to the occasion, and here's the counter-intuitive part, will do so faster than the issue becomes a serious problem, as measured by actual resource scarcity as measured by costs.
Your faith in the Invisible Hand of the Free Market is touching, but somehow I don't think Anarchy is the answer.
If we had a 'free market without Government intervention' and all the oil ran out tomorrow, its 'actual resource scarcity' certainly would be 'measured by costs', so then everything would be Hunky Dorey, right? In Libertopia it might be, but in the real world it would be a disaster.
You assume that resources only run out slowly enough for us to develop replacements (even 'faster than the issue becomes a serious problem"!), and that there are a sufficient number of visionaries willing to 'rise to the occasion' and put aside short-term profit motives in order to improve our future. But nothing about capitalism guarantees that this will be so.
What if all the capitalists just carry on with 'business as usual' and
don't think about tomorrow? Many of them are quite happy just making tons of money so that they can live in the lap of luxury until the end of their own short lives, and to Hell with everybody else. So Peak Oil already happened, but rather than develop alternatives the oil companies are simply finding new ways to keep the oil flowing - and us dependent on it.
What's worse is that we don't even
know how much oil is left in many of the largest fields. It's quite possible that some oil producers are overstating their resources in order to avoid panic, perhaps to stop people switching to another energy source (and thereby tanking the oil price). One day we might suddenly discover that there just isn't any left...
The true cost environmental costs of oil usage are
still not being accounted for, and 'absent government intervention' the pace of alternative energy development would be pathetic. You think this doesn't matter because the price of oil will always reflect its scarcity, so when eventually it becomes too expensive the alternatives will then become viable, right? But what if when the crunch comes, we have neither the time nor the resources to rapidly develop those alternative technologies?
If certain conservative/libertarian talking points are to be believed, 'green' energy is a boondoggle, and the only viable alternative is nuclear. But to develop enough nuclear plants to replace oil will take
at least 10~20 years, and few are currently interested in doing so due to the enormous up-front costs (and that's
with 'government intervention'. I hate to think what state the nuclear power industry would be in now if it was in private hands). Meanwhile, in order to build those plants we need the oil to keep flowing for another 10~20 years. So even
if there
were enough capitalists willing and able to 'rise to the occasion', chances are that they would
not be able to do it 'faster than the issue becomes a serious problem'.
I predict that 'absent government intervention' few will be willing and able to 'rise to the occasion', the alternative energy market will remain marginalized, and the price of oil will simply continue to rise until it seriously damages the world economy. It might cause even
more wars, and I'm sure that more people would die because of it. But who cares? So long as the price reflects it's scarcity, everything will be just fine!
The Invisible Hand is blind. It has no direction, no goal other than profit. I will
not trust
my future to it.