Crisis of Civilisation

The end is nigh!

Where have I heard it before?:rolleyes:

Last year.

And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.

etc...
 
The end is nigh!

Where have I heard it before?:rolleyes:

That sounds suspiciously like Famous Last Words to me.

I can imagine the Romans of, say, about 450 CE saying that. Technically, we can do almost anything science allows. Politically, we cannot find our ass with both hands.
 
Last edited:
Except this time really is different, and all you have to do to realise that is watch the news and try to understand what is already happening. The film refered to in the OP is not about a religious prophecy; it is a detailed analysis of what is what is presently happening in the world by a person who has a very good grip on it. If you don't agree with him, perhaps you might explain why? Have you watched it?

Do prophecies have to be religious in nature? If you look around, there is "the rapture of the geeks", that is, those folks who believe in the imminent coming of a hypothetical technical singularity.

I haven't watched the movie. Maybe I will later. But the description gives me Zeitgeist vibes.
 
That sounds suspiciously like Famous Last Words to me.

I can imagine the Romans of, say, about 450 CE saying that. Technically, we can do almost anything science allows. Politically, we cannot find our ass with both hands.

this. complacence never lasts forever.
 
no, but it almost certainly means a radical change to our current world of cheap easy energy and all that follows on from that.

They said the same thing when Europe began running out of trees in the 1600s
 
This time it is different because this time the problem we are faced with is our own "amazing resilience."
An important aspect of which is our very advanced ability to work together in enormous co-operative groups to accomplish (for good or ill) things that cannot be accomplished individually or in smaller groups. So, in that regard, those of our problems that arise out of an exessive ability to dominate ecosystems may ultimately be at least partially self-resolving with the collapse of the massive, complex organizational structures that support that domination.

To be sure, large populations suddenly forced to turn to their own devices may inflict a lot of damage on the land (and on each other) in their desperate struggle for survival, even if they are equipped with nothing more sophisticated than hand axes for cutting firewood (or whatever). But only for a while. Eventually things are sure to find some equilibrium, most likely with the emergence of some form of (mostly agrarian-based) feudalism or even tribalism.

This view is similar to the picture painted by James Howard Kunstler in his (fictional) book, "World Made By Hand", and I'd like to think it represents something close to a worst-case scenario for life in the US after a collapse of the economy and centralized government. That's me being about as optimistic as I can manage.
 
As pointed out in the film, "peak oil" is a historical fact. Hubbert predicted that US oil production would peak in the early 1970s, was ridiculed, and was then proved correct when it actually happened. Hubbert's theory is therefore proven to be sound - it is not "just a theory." There is no question that the global version will also happen (or has already), the only question is when. And the evidence is stacking up for a date of 2005 or 2008, depending on precisely what you mean by "oil."


Fair enough. We like predictions.

Now watch as what he says is irrelevant. The link says why, based on gigatons of historical data.

There's a reason that guy was mocked in the '70s. And deservedly so. And will continue to be as his concern, even if correct, is irrelevant in a free society, barring government intervention and rationing, which exacerbates the issues.


In any case, the guy you quote remains a crackpot.


Don't take my word for it -- just file it away and watch as history develops, as it always does, in ways that show Julian Simon correct and the Doomsayers incorrect. Why? They are not economists, and shortages, and their effect on society, are economic issues, which physical scientists don't understand*.

With a granularity of a decade or so, capitalism, which is to say, economically free people, barring government intervention, will rise to the occasion, and here's the counter-intuitive part, will do so faster than the issue becomes a serious problem, as measured by actual resource scarcity as measured by costs.



* Again, proven over and over (and over and over and over and over) again by their economic impact predictions of their physical observations being faulty on the level of an end-of-the-world 2012 predictor.


These things are beyond sad at this point.
 
Last edited:
Last year.

And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.
And the year before that.

etc...
I wonder if you'd have heard it every year during the last years of the Minoan civilization.
Or the Aztec.
Or the Sumerian.
Or the Babylonian.
Or the Phoenician.
Or the Mayan.
Or the Toltec.
Or the Maurya.
Or the Inca.
Or the Ancient Egyptian.
 
There's a reason that guy was mocked in the '70s.
He wasn't mocked very dang far into the '70s, because it became clearer with each passing day that his model had quite accurately predicted the 1970 peak of US production, and had done it fifteen years in advance.

In any case, the guy you quote remains a crackpot.
Hubbert was a thoroughly credentialled geologist who worked for Shell oil for more than twenty years, and as a senior research geophysicist for the USGS for another twelve. The Hubbert Curve and Peak Oil theory is only one among several important contributions he made to geology, geophysics, and petroleum geology. You want to dismiss him as a crackpot because you don't like the message, that's fine, but know this: most geologists and petroleum experts do not.

Don't take my word for it -- just file it away and watch as history develops, as it always does, in ways that show Julian Simon correct and the Doomsayers incorrect. Why? They are not economists, and shortages, and their effect on society, are economic issues, which physical scientists don't understand*.
Hubbert's theory is based on the realities of geology and petroleum engineering. By itself, it says nothing whatsoever about economic impacts.
 
I wonder if you'd have heard it every year during the last years of the Minoan civilization.
Or the Aztec.
Or the Sumerian.
Or the Babylonian.
Or the Phoenician.
Or the Mayan.
Or the Toltec.
Or the Maurya.
Or the Inca.
Or the Ancient Egyptian.

I'd disagree with the notion that the Sumerians, Babylonians or ancient Egyptians faced a sudden collapse. Rather, these civilizations declined and eventually lost their political independence. This doesn't mean their culture disappeared. The worship of Egyptian gods became widespread in the Roman Empire.
 
They said the same thing when Europe began running out of trees in the 1600s

Yeah, they sure did. Did they run into massive political insult when they went to oil? Did they get told that burning oil will cause the Earth to explode in flames? The problem's not with technology; it's with ourselves.
 
You cannot spend money you don't have, unless somebody is willing to extend you credit...

I assume you mean from the consumer's perspective. That's true, so it means you use less of whatever it is use are buying. Still, buying less of the new thing rather than more of the old thing, means that you can buy more of the new thing in the future than what's left of the old thing.

Back in late '90s and early '00s some talked about gasoline surtax to get people jump started on the more fuel efficient vehicles. Looking back it may have been a good thing as the vehicle fleet would now have a better overall fuel economy.
 
The vegetable oil was until recently an unused "waste product" from restaraunts, and using that sort of oil as fuel is certainly a good way of recycling (sort of), but it has no impact on peak oil. If the vegetable oil was produced by industrialised farming then it required crude oil in its own production and distribution. We can't replace crude oil with vegetable oil. That would just cause an even bigger food crisis, and it is an inefficient use of the crude oil required to grow the vegetable oil. You might just as well just use the original crude as fuel instead of using it to grow vegetable oil.

Hmmm...check the efficiency statistics. I don't know much about vegetable oil production, but I bet far less crude oil would be used if every new car in America were powered by vegetable oil. Mechanical extraction doesn't seem to use crude oil at all as it uses screw presses, according to Wikipedia at least. It would not necessarily cause a greater food crisis as people would produce much more vegetable oil. Peak petroleum probably can be delayed a lot and technological advances can render it irrelevant.


Nothing like this has ever happened before. The scale of the problem is on a new order of magnitude. The whole global system is going down, not just a localised part of it.

The Great Depression comes to mind, but I'll talk about the Long Depression because it's more interesting. Beginning in 1873, the Vienna market crash caused global recession and massive bank failures world wide for about 15 years. This was felt throughout Europe and the UK, their colonies, China, and the United States. Hundreds of banks shut down in the United states from 1873-1896. Somehow, wages rose 23% in the United States while prices actually dropped somewhat from 1879-1889 so the economy managed to grow in real terms despite being hit hard by a global financial meltdown.
 
his concern, even if correct, is irrelevant in a free society, barring government intervention and rationing, which exacerbates the issues...

capitalism, which is to say, economically free people, barring government intervention, will rise to the occasion, and here's the counter-intuitive part, will do so faster than the issue becomes a serious problem, as measured by actual resource scarcity as measured by costs.
Your faith in the Invisible Hand of the Free Market is touching, but somehow I don't think Anarchy is the answer.

If we had a 'free market without Government intervention' and all the oil ran out tomorrow, its 'actual resource scarcity' certainly would be 'measured by costs', so then everything would be Hunky Dorey, right? In Libertopia it might be, but in the real world it would be a disaster.

You assume that resources only run out slowly enough for us to develop replacements (even 'faster than the issue becomes a serious problem"!), and that there are a sufficient number of visionaries willing to 'rise to the occasion' and put aside short-term profit motives in order to improve our future. But nothing about capitalism guarantees that this will be so.

What if all the capitalists just carry on with 'business as usual' and don't think about tomorrow? Many of them are quite happy just making tons of money so that they can live in the lap of luxury until the end of their own short lives, and to Hell with everybody else. So Peak Oil already happened, but rather than develop alternatives the oil companies are simply finding new ways to keep the oil flowing - and us dependent on it.

What's worse is that we don't even know how much oil is left in many of the largest fields. It's quite possible that some oil producers are overstating their resources in order to avoid panic, perhaps to stop people switching to another energy source (and thereby tanking the oil price). One day we might suddenly discover that there just isn't any left...

The true cost environmental costs of oil usage are still not being accounted for, and 'absent government intervention' the pace of alternative energy development would be pathetic. You think this doesn't matter because the price of oil will always reflect its scarcity, so when eventually it becomes too expensive the alternatives will then become viable, right? But what if when the crunch comes, we have neither the time nor the resources to rapidly develop those alternative technologies?

If certain conservative/libertarian talking points are to be believed, 'green' energy is a boondoggle, and the only viable alternative is nuclear. But to develop enough nuclear plants to replace oil will take at least 10~20 years, and few are currently interested in doing so due to the enormous up-front costs (and that's with 'government intervention'. I hate to think what state the nuclear power industry would be in now if it was in private hands). Meanwhile, in order to build those plants we need the oil to keep flowing for another 10~20 years. So even if there were enough capitalists willing and able to 'rise to the occasion', chances are that they would not be able to do it 'faster than the issue becomes a serious problem'.

I predict that 'absent government intervention' few will be willing and able to 'rise to the occasion', the alternative energy market will remain marginalized, and the price of oil will simply continue to rise until it seriously damages the world economy. It might cause even more wars, and I'm sure that more people would die because of it. But who cares? So long as the price reflects it's scarcity, everything will be just fine! :rolleyes:

The Invisible Hand is blind. It has no direction, no goal other than profit. I will not trust my future to it.
 
Last edited:
It's quite possible that some oil producers are overstating their resources in order to avoid panic, perhaps to stop people switching to another energy source (and thereby tanking the oil price).
With OPEC countries, it has to do with the quota system under which the amount each country may export is determined in part by the size of its estimated reserves. Those self-reported estimates saw a sharp spike on implementation of those rules, though there was no corresponding increase in new oil discoveries.
 
I wonder if you'd have heard it every year during the last years of the Minoan civilization.
Or the Aztec.
Or the Sumerian.
Or the Babylonian.
Or the Phoenician.
Or the Mayan.
Or the Toltec.
Or the Maurya.
Or the Inca.
Or the Ancient Egyptian.

Many of those civilzations were just pwned by someone more powerful.
 
Good point. (Things are seldom that simple, but still).

To a first approximation, oil = power. Wouldn't you agree?

yes.

the mighty US empire wouldn't be all that if the toys all ran out of fuel.
 
I assume you mean from the consumer's perspective. That's true, so it means you use less of whatever it is use are buying. Still, buying less of the new thing rather than more of the old thing, means that you can buy more of the new thing in the future than what's left of the old thing.

That's true, but it assumes that some new thing is out there which can replace oil, and no such thing exists. Oil is very special because of its physical and chemical properties, which are themselves a result of its biological origin.

Back in late '90s and early '00s some talked about gasoline surtax to get people jump started on the more fuel efficient vehicles. Looking back it may have been a good thing as the vehicle fleet would now have a better overall fuel economy.

It would have been much better if the world, especially the US, had taken climate change seriously 20 years ago instead of arguing with the scientists.

Those developed countries currently in the least-bad situation wrt peak oil are the ones who took climate change the most seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom