Crisis of Civilisation

Hmmm...check the efficiency statistics. I don't know much about vegetable oil production, but I bet far less crude oil would be used if every new car in America were powered by vegetable oil.

Only if half the world's population were starving at the same time because of the amount of land now dedicated to fuel production.

Growing fuel is not a solution. I believe future generation will look back at the brief era that "biofuels" were believed to be a solution as the height of our craziness. With hindsight, it will look totally insane.

Mechanical extraction doesn't seem to use crude oil at all as it uses screw presses, according to Wikipedia at least. It would not necessarily cause a greater food crisis as people would produce much more vegetable oil.

Using what land? And what fertilisers? And what would power the machinery?

Peak petroleum probably can be delayed a lot and technological advances can render it irrelevant.

I think you need to watch the documentary. It addressed all these questions, which are asked by many people when they first start trying to understand what peak oil is about.

The Great Depression comes to mind, but I'll talk about the Long Depression because it's more interesting. Beginning in 1873, the Vienna market crash caused global recession and massive bank failures world wide for about 15 years. This was felt throughout Europe and the UK, their colonies, China, and the United States. Hundreds of banks shut down in the United states from 1873-1896. Somehow, wages rose 23% in the United States while prices actually dropped somewhat from 1879-1889 so the economy managed to grow in real terms despite being hit hard by a global financial meltdown.

There are some similarities to these two episodes in financial history, yes. There are also some very important differences. In both the cases you've described it was at least possible to have some sort of "reset" of the system and then get back to growing our way to prosperity. This was only possible because the developed powers had no shortage of resources and space available to them.
 
Last edited:
Only if half the world's population were starving at the same time because of the amount of land now dedicated to fuel production.

Growing fuel is not a solution. I believe future generation will look back at the brief era that "biofuels" were believed to be a solution as the height of our craziness. With hindsight, it will look totally insane.

Using what land? And what fertilisers? And what would power the machinery?

I think you need to watch the documentary.

It addressed all these questions, which are asked by many people when they first start trying to understand what peak oil is about

or take the Chris Martenson crash course 17 (a) and (b) which succinctly explain exactly the problems with all these incorrect and irrelevant counter arguments.



 
Dynamic said:
I wonder if you'd have heard it every year during the last years of the Minoan civilization.
Or the Aztec.
Or the Sumerian.
Or the Babylonian.
Or the Phoenician.
Or the Mayan.
Or the Toltec.
Or the Maurya.
Or the Inca.
Or the Ancient Egyptian.
Many of those civilzations were just pwned by someone more powerful.
And those which did not, never had "last year". They gradually declined over generations, without any catastrophic die-outs. Logically, British Empire belongs on the same list with Babylonias, Phoenicians, Sumerians and Egyptians.
 
it is a detailed analysis of what is what is presently happening in the world by a person who has a very good grip on it

A detailed analysis in "over less than 80 minutes"? I don't think so. You could probably spend 80 minutes on just a summary analysis of nuclear power, for example. You've watched the film; does it spend even 8 minutes on nuclear power?

From what I've seen so far, it really looks like a guy executing the classic business plan of, "buy my book about how to understand my movie, and watch my movie about why you should buy my book". It's a doomsayer's Harry Potter.

Pretty soon we'll be seeing AGW/Peak Oil slashfic. Me? I'm a Wind/Solar shipper.
 
A detailed analysis in "over less than 80 minutes"? I don't think so. You could probably spend 80 minutes on just a summary analysis of nuclear power, for example. You've watched the film; does it spend even 8 minutes on nuclear power?

Not 8 minutes, but it is covered (I think...I've watched a few of these recently and I'm losing track of what was in what.)

The problem with nuclear is that the entire process of getting hold of the fuel and building the power stations is itself fossil-fuel intensive, and also that if everybody started building new nuclear power stations to mitigate the decline in all production we would just run out of recoverable uranium in about ten years.
 
And those which did not, never had "last year". They gradually declined over generations, without any catastrophic die-outs.

A gradual decline is still a decline, and a gradual collapse is still a collapse, and "gradual" does not necessarily mean "smooth". Hollywood has us conditioned to think in terms of sudden and spectacular catastrophies. Or maybe it just responds to our natural proclivity for that sort of thing. Either way, if you want box office receipts, aim a hundred-foot tsunami at New York City. One of the many proposed explanations for the collapse (some scholars prefer to call it a "decline") of the Classic Maya civilization, for example, is a 200-year drought. Base a movie on that, and you'll have to wake the audience up so you can clear them out and close the theater for the night.

When demand for oil exceeds supply, the stuff gets expensive. Economic activity declines, and with it, demand for oil. Naturally, the price of oil then comes down, and oil production is scaled back. At the lower price, economic activity begins to revive, demand increases, and the cycle repeats. The Saudis in particular have expressed a willingness to mitigate this destructive lashing back and forth by increasing their production to minimize scarcity, but recently it has become increasingly apparent that they no longer have the reserve production capacity to do this as effectively as they once did.

The Hubbert curve does not predict a sudden and dramatic decline in global oil production, but in order for the global energy situation to become increasingly chaotic, a sudden and dramatic decline is not necessary. All that's necessary is for us to reach the point at which increased demand can no longer be effectively met by increased production. We appear to be approximately at that point now.

What makes this situation different is that we have no viable alternatives we can develop quickly, and none that could easily replace oil as a source of energy-dense liquid fuels on any time frame, and the global economy is more dependent on the availability of those fuels than has ever been the case with any single commodity. The problem is self-perpetuating, because developing alternative energy sources and creating the infrastructure that would permit us to utilize them is an undertaking which itself incurs an enormous cost in energy, so the more volatile the situation gets, the more difficult it will be to mitigate the damage. It's going to be a long ride to the bottom, and it's going to be bumpy.

That's before we even start talking about climate change.
 
A gradual decline is still a decline, and a gradual collapse is still a collapse, and "gradual" does not necessarily mean "smooth". Hollywood has us conditioned to think in terms of sudden and spectacular catastrophies. Or maybe it just responds to our natural proclivity for that sort of thing. Either way, if you want box office receipts, aim a hundred-foot tsunami at New York City. One of the many proposed explanations for the collapse (some scholars prefer to call it a "decline") of the Classic Maya civilization, for example, is a 200-year drought. Base a movie on that, and you'll have to wake the audience up so you can clear them out and close the theater for the night.

When demand for oil exceeds supply, the stuff gets expensive. Economic activity declines, and with it, demand for oil. Naturally, the price of oil then comes down, and oil production is scaled back. At the lower price, economic activity begins to revive, demand increases, and the cycle repeats. The Saudis in particular have expressed a willingness to mitigate this destructive lashing back and forth by increasing their production to minimize scarcity, but recently it has become increasingly apparent that they no longer have the reserve production capacity to do this as effectively as they once did.

The Hubbert curve does not predict a sudden and dramatic decline in global oil production, but in order for the global energy situation to become increasingly chaotic, a sudden and dramatic decline is not necessary. All that's necessary is for us to reach the point at which increased demand can no longer be effectively met by increased production. We appear to be approximately at that point now.

What makes this situation different is that we have no viable alternatives we can develop quickly, and none that could easily replace oil as a source of energy-dense liquid fuels on any time frame, and the global economy is more dependent on the availability of those fuels than has ever been the case with any single commodity. The problem is self-perpetuating, because developing alternative energy sources and creating the infrastructure that would permit us to utilize them is an undertaking which itself incurs an enormous cost in energy, so the more volatile the situation gets, the more difficult it will be to mitigate the damage. It's going to be a long ride to the bottom, and it's going to be bumpy.

That's before we even start talking about climate change.

yea, thats all true, but, well, it'll be ok, it always has been, so far.. :rolleyes:
 
Not 8 minutes, but it is covered (I think...I've watched a few of these recently and I'm losing track of what was in what.)

The problem with nuclear is that the entire process of getting hold of the fuel and building the power stations is itself fossil-fuel intensive, and also that if everybody started building new nuclear power stations to mitigate the decline in all production we would just run out of recoverable uranium in about ten years.

another massive problem is the waste. "into eternity" is a good documentary about onkalo (nuclear waste disposal burial chamber) in finland.

fun fact from it is that for china and india to reach western levels of energy consumption using nuclear power in the next 20 years they'd have to start 3 new generators a day.
 
That's true, but it assumes that some new thing is out there which can replace oil, and no such thing exists. Oil is very special because of its physical and chemical properties, which are themselves a result of its biological origin.

There are enough things that can partially replace petroleum such as ethanol, natural gas, and improved solar power that it's not going to cause a "collapse" of civilization.

It would have been much better if the world, especially the US, had taken climate change seriously 20 years ago instead of arguing with the scientists.

Those developed countries currently in the least-bad situation wrt peak oil are the ones who took climate change the most seriously.

How has the US been seriously hurt by climate change? Rising sea levels have hurt some countries, but the US hasn't been hurt that much by it. As for Hurricane Katrina, there isn't enough evidence to say that it was caused by climate change. Powerful hurricanes happen. Surely, climate change didn't cause Hurricane Gilbert and the Labor Day Hurricane.
 
There are enough things that can partially replace petroleum such as ethanol, natural gas, and improved solar power that it's not going to cause a "collapse" of civilization.

I'm guessing you probably haven't watched the documentary yet. Don't you think the author has thought of this sort of possibility already?

How has the US been seriously hurt by climate change? Rising sea levels have hurt some countries, but the US hasn't been hurt that much by it. As for Hurricane Katrina, there isn't enough evidence to say that it was caused by climate change. Powerful hurricanes happen. Surely, climate change didn't cause Hurricane Gilbert and the Labor Day Hurricane.

It is impossible to link a specific storm with climate change. Specific storms are weather, not climate.

The main impact of climate change so far has been at the poles.
 
another massive problem is the waste. "into eternity" is a good documentary about onkalo (nuclear waste disposal burial chamber) in finland.

fun fact from it is that for china and india to reach western levels of energy consumption using nuclear power in the next 20 years they'd have to start 3 new generators a day.

Yes.

I'm still undecided on the issue of nuclear power. It's a tough call, which is why it has split the environmental movement down the middle.
 
There are enough things that can partially replace petroleum such as ethanol, natural gas, and improved solar power that it's not going to cause a "collapse" of civilization.
Suppose we back up a step or two and talk first about what it takes to collapse an economy. I know this may sound crazy, but just for the sake of argument, imagine that a war erupted the middle east involving several of the major oil-producing nations, and this caused serious and widespread disruption of oil shipments, with the result that the price of oil doubled within a period of days and tripled or quadrupled over a period of months. Do you see the US economy being in good shape to withstand a blow like that?
 
it is not about "the price" they can print money, it is about how much energy is used to create these new sources.

and there are currently zero viable (EROEI) alternatives for liquid fuels for transport, at any "price"

That is flat out wrong, you've been reading too much woo. For one, bioethanol can be made with a net energy gain. For two, non-liquid fuels can be used for transportation. For three, any energy source can be converted to a liquid fuel (obviously at an energy cost) for use in transportation.

plus, when you factor in all the other things oil is used for apart from just fuel, well, people haven't really grasped this properly yet IMO

You haven't grasped the facts, only a small fraction of oil goes into things other than fuel, those other things can be made without oil (but at a higher cost).
 
The more "economically viable" the become in terms of extraction/generation (the price of energy goes up, making it possible to make a profit out of that energy source), the less economically viable it becomes in terms of actually keeping the economy going (because everybody has to pay more for their energy, which acts as a generalised destroyer of economic activity.)

In other words, nothing is "economically viable" if the customers can't afford to buy it, even if the alternative is getting cold or going hungry.

The thing is, we are almost there. The price of oil doesn't have to go up by too much more to make other sources viable.
 
Good point. (Things are seldom that simple, but still).

To a first approximation, oil = power. Wouldn't you agree?

No. Oil is useless without the knowledge of how to harness it. African and middle eastern tribes had oil under their feet for thousands of years and it did them little, if any, good. Practical application of knowledge (technology) is the undisputed champion in most affairs. Same as it ever was.
 
Yes.

I'm still undecided on the issue of nuclear power. It's a tough call, which is why it has split the environmental movement down the middle.
If your indecision on the issue of nuclear power has split the environmental movement then hadn't you better make up your mind so the healing can begin? :D
 
That is flat out wrong, you've been reading too much woo. For one, bioethanol can be made with a net energy gain. For two, non-liquid fuels can be used for transportation. For three, any energy source can be converted to a liquid fuel (obviously at an energy cost) for use in transportation.

lol @ too much woo. so bioethanol's EROEI is? evidence please?

and "any energy source can be converted" ? really?

so convert me some coal to liquid fuel for my car then. or some solar power please.

You haven't grasped the facts, only a small fraction of oil goes into things other than fuel, those other things can be made without oil (but at a higher cost).

somebody hasn't grasped the facts. plastics for example, I don't think the CO2 experimentation is quite ready to take over global plastics use just yet, do you?

and so this list is going to be replaced by what, bioethanol?

http://www.californiagasprices.com/crude_products.aspx

What Does One Barrel Of Crude Oil Make?

One barrel of crude oil contains 42 gallons - About 46% of each barrel of crude oil is refined into automobile gasoline. In the US and Canada an average of 3 gallons of crude oil are consumed per person each day

The US imports about 50% of its required crude oil and about 50% of that amount comes from OPEC countries

Product Refined Gallons/Barrel
Gasoline 19.3
Distillate Fuel Oil (Inc. Home Heating and Diesel Fuel) 9.83
Kerosene Type Jet Fuel 4.24
Residual Fuel Oil 2.10
Petroleum Coke 2.10
Liquified Refinery Gases 1.89
Still Gas 1.81
Asphalt and Road Oil 1.13
Petrochemical Feed Supplies 0.97
Lubricants 0.46
Kerosene 0.21
Waxes 0.04
Aviation Fuel 0.04
Other Products 0.34
Processing Gain 2.47

Source: EIA March 2004 Data
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom