Crisis of Civilisation

The JREF operates on evidence. You may have missed that.

The JREF theoretically operates on evidence. The reality is rather different. I'm sorry, but the generally-prevailing level of discussion on this board is rather poor, especially given that it is supposed to be dedicated to critical thinking. The problem was summed up a long time ago when the religion and philosophy forum was put here (I might add that it was put here as a result of a request from myself in the very early days of this forum). "Who could have an opinion on these topics?" says the subtitle. Well, you might be able to get away with dismissing religion like that (although it's hardly "critical thinking") but you certainly can't get away with dismissing philosophy like that. Philosophy is critical thinking, but on this board it is treated as "woo".
 
The JREF theoretically operates on evidence. The reality is rather different. I'm sorry, but the generally-prevailing level of discussion on this board is rather poor, especially given that it is supposed to be dedicated to critical thinking. The problem was summed up a long time ago when the religion and philosophy forum was put here (I might add that it was put here as a result of a request from myself in the very early days of this forum). "Who could have an opinion on these topics?" says the subtitle. Well, you might be able to get away with dismissing religion like that (although it's hardly "critical thinking") but you certainly can't get away with dismissing philosophy like that. Philosophy is critical thinking, but on this board it is treated as "woo".

No, woo is treated as woo. I have noticed that if we don't agree with people like you then our level of thinking is dismissed as being below par. I dismiss religion because I have never seen any evidence of the existence of any god or gods.
 
No, woo is treated as woo.

And what, pray tell, do you personally think the word "woo" means?

Because it actually means "something I personally find unbelievable or crazy" and nothing more. The term "woo" is used within the "skeptical community" in the same manner as the snake alarm call of the vervet monkey. It is a mechanism by which mob rule is enforced. It has precisely nothing to do with critical thinking.

I have noticed that if we don't agree with people like you then our level of thinking is dismissed as being below par. I dismiss religion because I have never seen any evidence of the existence of any god or gods.

You dismiss far more than just religion. At no point have I asked you or anybody to believe in any god(s). In fact, according to most definitions of that word I'm an atheist.
 
Luckily we have years.

We won't be out of oil in a day, from what I understand of peak oil, the downward slope is shaped pretty much like the upward slope. Which means that there is time for us to make the transition slowly. Initially (at this stage would be best) we really only need alternative fuels, or alternatives to liquid fuels (like electric cars) to take up the growth in usage. Over the next few years they should begin to get a higher and higher share of the total use of liquid fuels. By "should" I mean that's what I'd like to see happen, not what I expect to happen.

This is what Julian Simon was saying 30 years ago. History shows economically free people will rise to the challenge.

Economically, $4 a gallon gas just barely begins to scrape the bottom of calling into existence these other technologies. No government intervention needed to "help".

There is no crisis here. In 20, 40, 100 years, the cars you drive will be better and more plentiful than today. Maybe they will be mostly gas. Maybe they will mostly be something else. But there will be no crisis. The only crisis would be if government tried to ration cars, or gasoline, or oil.
 
Last edited:
And what, pray tell, do you personally think the word "woo" means?

Because it actually means "something I personally find unbelievable or crazy" and nothing more. The term "woo" is used within the "skeptical community" in the same manner as the snake alarm call of the vervet monkey. It is a mechanism by which mob rule is enforced. It has precisely nothing to do with critical thinking.



You dismiss far more than just religion. At no point have I asked you or anybody to believe in any god(s). In fact, according to most definitions of that word I'm an atheist.

No, but you have constantly said that we should take your word for it, without providing any tangible claim of your evidence. Then cried fault every time people didn´t took you seriously. It´s like trying to convince a T-rex to be vegetarian.

Every time people ask you for evidence you say "do your research" or "I would but it´s too long." Buddy, if you want to be taken seriously, start providing evidence.
 
This is what Julian Simon was saying 30 years ago. History shows economically free people will rise to the challenge.

Economically, $4 a gallon gas just barely begins to scrape the bottom of calling into existence these other technologies. No government intervention needed to "help".

There is no crisis here. In 20, 40, 100 years, the cars you drive will be better and more plentiful than today. Maybe they will be mostly gas. Maybe they will mostly be something else. But there will be no crisis.

I think you are both (Beerina and Roborama) failing to appreciate the significance of the peak.

Firstly, it is not yet clear whether the downslope will look like the upslope. There are two reasons for this. The first is the tendency to really clobber oilfields in decline with hi-tech techniques for keeping production levels up. This keeps it going at full pelt for a little longer, but is followed by a very sharp decline. Google the Mexican oilfield Cantarell for more details on this. It's the reason why the Saudis are reluctant to push their own fields harder at the moment.

Secondly, the Export Land Model comes into play, where the few remaining oil-exporting nations protect their own populations from the price rises elsewhere, fuelling internal consumption and rapidly reducing their export capacity to zero. This has also happened in several places, the best example being Indonesia. It results in a disproportionate early affect on major oil importing nations.

At the point of peak oil, the whole dynamic of oil economics turns upside-down. It is the point where nobody is in control of the price any more, because nobody can simply turn on the taps (don't believe what that idiot Donald Trump says about OPEC. OPEC are no longer in control of the price.) Instead, the price is determined by what the customers are actually willing and able to pay for their oil-related consumption.

What I'm trying to say is that complacency at this point is very dangerous. The effects of being on the downslope in global production, especially if you are a major oil-importing nation, are going to be felt almost immediately. We are already seeing them start to appear, although right now the signal is being obscured by two sorts of noise (economic chaos caused by the monetary system collapsing and leading to unpredictable demand for oil, and speculators who think they can make money out the supply/demand problems sending the price even higher than it would otherwise be.)
 
No, but you have constantly said that we should take your word for it, without providing any tangible claim of your evidence.

Total rubbish. I have not asked anybody to take my word for anything at all. Not only have I not "done this constantly" - I haven't done it at all. Go back and read the thread and try to find an actual example of what you are accusing me of "constantly doing."
 
Last edited:
IF you two wouldn't object to a brief returning to the actual subject of the thread:

This is what Julian Simon was saying 30 years ago. History shows economically free people will rise to the challenge.
I'd say that what history shows is that people in general will exploit the easiest and most accessible resources first, and only when those resources show clear signs of impending depletion will they show the least inclination to rise to the challenge that presents -- and that even when a new resource or technology offers considerable advantages over an older one, resistance to the transition will be seen in the considerable inertia exerted by existing cultural norms and by the deep political and economic entrenchment of special interest groups.

Economically, $4 a gallon gas just barely begins to scrape the bottom of calling into existence these other technologies.
Even if $8 a gallon gas would have it bleeding through its trousers, I don't see any guarantee that these new technologies would cooperate by quickly responding to that call. It's magical thinking. Cargo cult thinking.

No government intervention needed to "help".
I wonder how you feel about the removal of government intervention in the form of massive subsidies to the petroleum industry?

In 20, 40, 100 years, the cars you drive will be better and more plentiful than today. Maybe they will be mostly gas. Maybe they will mostly be something else.
Yeah. Like maybe bicycles, or horse-drawn carts.
 
Do not personalize the argument. Keep it on topic, keep it civil and do not import arguments from other threads.

Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Oh no! You irrational doomer! We are all going to be driving round in flying cars!!!
Probably depends a lot on which of the proposed timeframes we're talking about: 20, 40, or 100 years. If we are able to effectively manage economic contraction over the next 20 years, then maybe by the 40-year mark -- and surely by the 100-year mark -- we'll finally have fusion power. I mean, come on. Even with decreased funding for research. (And assuming that there isn't some yet-unappreciated fundamental barrier). On the other hand, if we can't manage that contraction, it's not hard to picture scenarios in which most technological progress comes to a virtual standstill. Science tends to cost money.
 
There is no crisis here. In 20, 40, 100 years, the cars you drive will be better and more plentiful than today.


Leaving aside the question of the fuel for the cars, the bolded presents its own set of problems. Unless you like gridlock, more cars would necessitate more roads and highways.
 
And what, pray tell, do you personally think the word "woo" means?

Because it actually means "something I personally find unbelievable or crazy" and nothing more. The term "woo" is used within the "skeptical community" in the same manner as the snake alarm call of the vervet monkey. It is a mechanism by which mob rule is enforced. It has precisely nothing to do with critical thinking.



You dismiss far more than just religion. At no point have I asked you or anybody to believe in any god(s). In fact, according to most definitions of that word I'm an atheist.

Woo means a claim without any objective evidence to back it up.
 
Woo means a claim without any objective evidence to back it up.

Right. And do you think if I asked a general question "what does woo mean?" that most people would agree with your definition? Because I've tried it on similar boards in the past and the result has been such a wide variety of responses that everybody ended up agreeing that the word "woo" has no consistent meaning.


http://www.rationalskepticism.org/philosophy/woo-t9372.html

Woo: Mostly things that use long scientific-sounding words to convey a nonsensical idea that has no evidential basis, or doesn't actually mean anything.

Woo: Anthropic god thingies. The idea that there is something anthropically intelligent or teleological behind the curtain.

Woo: I have had total success equating "woo" with "********".

Woo: I think that "woo" refers to an element of supernaturalism, or - at the very least - something in direct contradiction to pretty much everything we know about how the world works. At least that's how I use the term, if I ever use it.

Woo: Weirdly obfuscated offal.

Woo: Human language repeated deliberately to confuse another.

Woo: I would label something as woo that is an unsubstantiated and unfounded idea someone uncritically believes in.

Woo: Pseudoscience

Woo: I think I read once somewhere that the term "woo" came from the sound effects used in 1950s SciFi B movies, which were produced with a theremin.

Woo: any belief that projects our pitiful blob-of-gooism onto the universe and I think that is evil only because it exhibits such a severe lack of imagination.

Woo: I think that "woo" is a particular type of ******** which is supposed (supposed, primarily, by the one advancing the ********; and his target audience) to be terribly profound or “deep”. Woo is usually a variety of pseudo-scientific, mystical, or "spiritual" verbiage, including claims about reality. Woo is any ******** advanced with the intention of causing a bewitched audience to murmur: "woooooooooooo...!" This may distinguish woo as a distinct species of ********.

Woo: Homeopathy, chakra's, praying, magic dust and wands, believing that someone can be raised from the dead after brain stem death.

And on it goes, until somebody finally gets it:

I'd accept that there's no rigorous definition, but that's cause to reject the term imo, it makes it the scientistic equivalent of "sin".
I think UE is asking to get people to think about this point, rather than to actually get a rigorous definition.
 
Last edited:
Right. And do you think if I asked a general question "what does woo mean?" that most people would agree with your definition? Because I've tried it on similar boards in the past and the result has been such a wide variety of responses that everybody ended up agreeing that the word "woo" has no consistent meaning.

So your opinion is set in stone and mine is mere conjecture?
 
There's a guy in our village who runs his car on vegetable oil. He collects the used oil from the local frituurs. Every time he passes the street stinks like a chip shop for about ten minutes. Still, that's a small price to pay, I suppose.

my old Toyota also runs happily on WVO which is freely available where I live, and this year a friend and I are going to (attempt to) convert his diesel electricity generator to run on it too, as we are now producing more (collected and filtered) than we can both use driving.

and if you think its bad when a car drives past, driving one makes you permanently hungry.
 
Last edited:
So your opinion is set in stone and mine is mere conjecture?
Doesn't have to be that way. All you need to do is provide objective evidence to back up your claim that the definition you provided represents the only correct interpretation of the term. If you search around, you'll find that there have been lots of threads on the subject right here on JREF. I don't think you're going to be able to do that, but I would not regard that as sufficient for your claim to meet my understanding of the meaning of the word "woo" -- even though it would be enough to meet yours.
 
Doesn't have to be that way. All you need to do is provide objective evidence to back up your claim that the definition you provided represents the only correct interpretation of the term. If you search around, you'll find that there have been lots of threads on the subject right here on JREF. I don't think you're going to be able to do that, but I would not regard that as sufficient for your claim to meet my understanding of the meaning of the word "woo" -- even though it would be enough to meet yours.

Woo is such a broad term. Woo is so subjective that is impossible to give an objective, all-encompassing definition. Who was it who said '' I don't know the definition of the word obscene but I know it when I see it?''
 
Last edited:
Woo is such a broad term.
I agree -- but it's not infinitely broad. I would say that it is a colloquialism used broadly to describe a certain type of thinking about certain types of subjects.

Your definition: "Woo means a claim without any objective evidence to back it up" lacks the support of objective evidence -- but I still wouldn't call it "woo", because it lacks a certain hard-to-describe quality: there's no magical thinking involved. It's just an unsupported claim.

And that's all I have to say about that. If you want to explore those depths further, I suggest you do so in one of the threads dedicated to that topic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom