Crisis of Civilisation

If your indecision on the issue of nuclear power has split the environmental movement then hadn't you better make up your mind so the healing can begin? :D

HEMP, raw Hemp, Cannabis for smoking, juicing, paper, building construction, hemp oil to run in cars and as medicine, as a dietary nutrient and as a skin remedy are all great uses for the Herb. Cannabis grows fast, sequesters CO2 quite well (if one of your concerns is AGW) and is just an all around fascinating plant that has anti-oxidant properties, anti-cancer properties and also has of course the safest of analgesic properties known to human-kind.

Just my take.

ETA: It might be just the thing to avert Civil Collapse, if that is what is coming.
 
Last edited:
No. Oil is useless without the knowledge of how to harness it. African and middle eastern tribes had oil under their feet for thousands of years and it did them little, if any, good. Practical application of knowledge (technology) is the undisputed champion in most affairs. Same as it ever was.
Yeah, okay. Knowledge is power; same as it ever was -- though, as you note, not knowledge alone, but practical application of knowledge (technology). But here's the thing: We currently are long on knowledge and short on application.

Modern idea-space is richly populated with imaginary energy technologies and infrastructures that all suffer from the serious drawback that they do not yet exist. Ask most people what they think our collective response would be to the sort of scenario I outlined above involving a sudden oil shock, and they'll start waving their arms around in the air as though drawing pictures on a virtual storyboard for a Buck Rogers comic; maglev trains, electric cars zipping around on nuke-generated power, etc. So I'd go one step further: Knowledge is power when it is related to practical application of currently existing technology. At present, that's mostly oil. The rest is cargo cult fantasy: "Technology will arrive just in time to save us".
 
If your indecision on the issue of nuclear power has split the environmental movement then hadn't you better make up your mind so the healing can begin? :D

My personal indecision has nowt to do with it.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17404438

It's just a very tough, complicated call to make, both morally and economically. It's also very important that as a country the UK makes its mind up how to keep the lights on, if it wants to keep the lights on.
 
Whether or not you expect oil to get much, much more expensive in the next couple of decades, Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed is probably not someone you should be citing around here. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2478733

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1m4YhpPAkY

Play the ball, not the man, please. I believe his stance about 9/11 is a rational, sensible one: "Let's stick to what we actually know, and not get carried away with unsubstantiated theories."
 
Last edited:
HEMP, raw Hemp, Cannabis for smoking, juicing, paper, building construction, hemp oil to run in cars and as medicine, as a dietary nutrient and as a skin remedy are all great uses for the Herb. Cannabis grows fast, sequesters CO2 quite well (if one of your concerns is AGW) and is just an all around fascinating plant that has anti-oxidant properties, anti-cancer properties and also has of course the safest of analgesic properties known to human-kind.

Just my take.

ETA: It might be just the thing to avert Civil Collapse, if that is what is coming.

lol, you are going to have to grow an awful lot of it to make up for multi million BPD, way more than the 3 plants were allowed to grow in the garden here for personal (oil replacement obviously) use
 
lol, you are going to have to grow an awful lot of it to make up for multi million BPD, way more than the 3 plants were allowed to grow in the garden here for personal (oil replacement obviously) use

True enough. It is a matter of yield and how industrious we are at using any such yield. There are perhaps other plants that would be more suitable for use as a fuel in cars. I looked over the internet and many of the answers I found on the question of replacing petroleum with Hemp oil were that Hemp production could not keep up with current usage.

I am not sure myself as there are so many things to consider. If Peak Oil is true, then one fear would be that going off petrol could be quite a shock to many societies. If such is the case, some kind of substitute (besides coal for instance) for petroleum would be required.

It seems much more clear to me, however, that status of the other uses for Cannabis are much more secure in terms of evidence for their long term usefulness to society (medicine, food, clothes, building products...).

I found this set of forum posts on another website:

http://www.scienceforums.net/topic/6757-how-much-land-to-replace-petroleum-with-hemp/
 
Last edited:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1m4YhpPAkY

Play the ball, not the man, please. I believe his stance about 9/11 is a rational, sensible one: "Let's stick to what we actually know, and not get carried away with unsubstantiated theories."


From his 9/11 book.
Deconstructing the findings of the 9/11 Commission Report and the Joint Congressional Inquiry, he exposes disturbing liaisons between American, British and European intelligence services and al-Qaeda operatives in the Balkans, Caucasus, North Africa, Middle East, Central Asia and Asia-Pacific - liaisons linked not only to 9/11, but also to prior terrorist attacks including the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and the 1998 US embassy bombings.
Dude connects a lot of dots. Not all dots need to be connected.

ETA - in his other 9/11 book, he wrote about a bunch of debunked canards like military exercises, NORAD stand-down, Mineta timeline, stock-shorting profits, etc. This guy seems to have been a reasonably influential figure in creating the 'truth movement.'
 
Last edited:
If Peak Oil is true

peak oil is absolutely true, harvesting of any finite resource must reach a peak at some point and then decline, the only question is when, and where are we now on the curve, that's where the whole debate is, and how much longer we have in the face of demand based around exponential growth.
 
peak oil is absolutely true, harvesting of any finite resource must reach a peak at some point and then decline, the only question is when, and where are we now on the curve, that's where the whole debate is, and how much longer we have in the face of demand based around exponential growth.

One of the ugly bits about the Hubbert curve is that the top is very smooth. Quite difficult to tell you're past the peak until you get on the steep part of the downslope.
 
From his 9/11 book.

Dude connects a lot of dots. Not all dots need to be connected.

ETA - in his other 9/11 book, he wrote about a bunch of debunked canards like military exercises, NORAD stand-down, Mineta timeline, stock-shorting profits, etc. This guy seems to have been a reasonably influential figure in creating the 'truth movement.'

Hilarious. A truthers opinion on anything can be safely discounted. A "rational, sensible" stance on 9/11? Crap.
 
From his 9/11 book.

Dude connects a lot of dots. Not all dots need to be connected.

ETA - in his other 9/11 book, he wrote about a bunch of debunked canards like military exercises, NORAD stand-down, Mineta timeline, stock-shorting profits, etc. This guy seems to have been a reasonably influential figure in creating the 'truth movement.'

I have not read what he has written about 9/11, but I am willing to accept what he has said in that video clip as an acceptable way forward. Let's just stick to what we know, and not go around insisting on a version of events that cannot be verified anyway, because it leads to division between people who have the same long-term goal of overturning the existing political/economic system. I think that is good advice.
 
A truthers opinion on anything can be safely discounted.

Yet another example of what passes for critical thinking around here.

When presented with some sort of thesis, it should be assessed on its merits. Under no circumstances is it justifiable to ignore that thesis on the grounds that you disagree with something else that person once said about a completely different subject.
 
Yeah, okay. Knowledge is power; same as it ever was -- though, as you note, not knowledge alone, but practical application of knowledge (technology). But here's the thing: We currently are long on knowledge and short on application.

Still not buying it. Sounds intuitive, but a simplistic explanation.

Modern idea-space is richly populated with imaginary energy technologies and infrastructures that all suffer from the serious drawback that they do not yet exist. Ask most people what they think our collective response would be to the sort of scenario I outlined above involving a sudden oil shock, and they'll start waving their arms around in the air as though drawing pictures on a virtual storyboard for a Buck Rogers comic; maglev trains, electric cars zipping around on nuke-generated power, etc. So I'd go one step further: Knowledge is power when it is related to practical application of currently existing technology. At present, that's mostly oil. The rest is cargo cult fantasy: "Technology will arrive just in time to save us".

A couple things:

1) we (i.e. consumers) largely take for granted the potency of oil as a fuel. How we drive, heat and cool our home is partly an unconscious resposeto that potency. Drive a couple hundred miles for a weekend vacation? No problem - fill 'er up and go.

2) Those alternatives - or cargo cult fantasies as you put it - have prices at which they are viable. Thus, volatility in the medium and long-term has its limits. Oil goes to $8 a gallon? Cool - more electric cars, solar water heaters, nuclear power plants, windmill farms, etc will be produced. There are obviously areas that will feel more acute pain than others, as oil is readily tranportable, energy dense, etc. I don't personally think we need to impose measures to increase the price of oil for this reason. It will happen naturally, and will be headed off as new alternatives become viable at higher price points.
 
I have not read what he has written about 9/11, but I am willing to accept what he has said in that video clip as an acceptable way forward. Let's just stick to what we know, and not go around insisting on a version of events that cannot be verified anyway, because it leads to division between people who have the same long-term goal of overturning the existing political/economic system. I think that is good advice.

He was dead wrong on nearly everything 9/11. The claims he made could certainly have been verified by himself. Instead they were debunked on places like the JREF forum. He's a paranoid nutter. Ignore him.
 
Instead they were debunked on places like the JREF forum.

I'm afraid that doesn't count for much, given that the JREF operates on "mob mentality."

It's also not all that relevant, since the claims you are talking about aren't made in the film we are discussing and his currently stated position seems perfectly fine to me. Unless you are still pushing the line: "he once said something I disagreed with, therefore I can't be bothered to listen to anything else he says."
 
Those alternatives - or cargo cult fantasies as you put it - have prices at which they are viable. Thus, volatility in the medium and long-term has its limits. Oil goes to $8 a gallon? Cool - more electric cars, solar water heaters, nuclear power plants, windmill farms, etc will be produced.
Oh right -- gas goes to eight bucks a gallon and hey presto up go the nuke plants and windmill farms and out come the electric cars and everybody carries on as if nothing much important happened.

Thanks for illustrating my point.
 
It seems much more clear to me, however, that status of the other uses for Cannabis are much more secure in terms of evidence for their long term usefulness to society (medicine, food, clothes, building products...).
I dunno. All the hemp product shops that I have seen seem to go out of business pretty quickly. And all the talk about establishing (THC free) hemp farms seems to end at the talking stage.
 
Last edited:
Yet another example of what passes for critical thinking around here.

When presented with some sort of thesis, it should be assessed on its merits. Under no circumstances is it justifiable to ignore that thesis on the grounds that you disagree with something else that person once said about a completely different subject.

I don't know about you, but I judge people to a large extent on their past behavior and reputation. For instance, I have formed opinions on people who start "look, look, we are all doomed" threads supported by pronouncements of nutters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom