ThunderChunky
Master Poster
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2007
- Messages
- 2,456
Since you posted that in response to a question regarding the ERoEI of bioethanol, I must assume that you are willing to provide some kind of summary of that study's findings. The best I can come up with is: It depends. Those guys are all over the place.
The paper is open access. A summary would be the abstract. "In this report, we summarize the agricultural energy input costs, biomass yield, estimated ethanol output, greenhouse gas emissions, and net energy results. Annual biomass yields of established fields averaged 5.2-11.1 Mg x ha(-1) with a resulting average estimated net energy yield (NEY) of 60 GJ x ha(-1) x y(-1). Switchgrass produced 540% more renewable than nonrenewable energy consumed." I am willing to discuss the paper further if you would like. I don't see where you get the impression that they are "all over the place."
The success of any bioethanol project depends on what you're growing, and how, and where, and on the weather. On how well some of the recent efforts in enzyme development succeed, and how well they scale up to industrial production levels.
To address you first points, this paper followed "10 farms across a wide precipitation and temperature gradient in the midcontinental U.S." Why would recent enzyme development matter to this study? This study is based on data from the year 2000, if anything the enzymes and processes (including nonenzymatic ones) are improved, meaning an even greater net energy today.
At present the ERoEI of ethanol from switchgrass is similar to that from corn (just barely better than break even, if that). There certainly seems to be a great deal of promise for improvement -- to 4:1, 5:1, 8:1 -- who knows? It depends -- on more things than we appear to be able to calculate at present. My earlier observation that "we're long on knowledge and short on application" does not quite apply to cellulosic ethanol from switchgrass; in this particular instance, it looks to me like we're short on both.
Why are you just making **** up now? TEN years ago the net energy was 5:1, earlier studies estimated the net energy to be around 3:1, some simulations estimated it to be >7:1 (refs in the paper). It looks to me like you are full of ****.
