Crisis of Civilisation

There is a whole generation of people growing up right now whose future has been stolen from them. They have very little to look forward to. In the UK, somebody who is now 15 is looking at not being able to get a job, never being able to afford to leave the parental home, not being able to afford to go to university, no hope of ever getting on the "property ladder", no hope of being able to save money (interest rates lower than inflation), no point in saving for a pension.... They are well and truly buggered.
I've been reading UndercoverElephant's posts for months now, trying to decide if he is worth listening to or not. The above grotesque generalization finally tipped the scales for me.

He only sees what he wants to see, and is not worth listening to.
 
Last edited:
Anecdotal evidence isn't going to answer the question. There must be plenty of stats around that show how much of a problem the underclass is and whether it is getting better or worse. Admittedly, a sudden change in economic conditions (whatever the cause) would render the stats meaningless.

As for the question of young people not leaving home, all the stats that I have seen suggest that young people are staying home before leaving longer than ever but they are still leaving.
 
It is quite true that anecdotes are not evidence; however one anecdote is sufficient to destroy the contention that all 15 year olds are looking at a lifetime of unemployment.

It is an unfortunate fact that one in five young people aged 16-24 are unemployed in the UK. Some (around a quarter) of those one in five are in full time education and looking for part time work, rather than seeking full time work. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15747103 As there is a proposal to raise the school leaving age to 18 in England, the numbers of unemployed people who are actually in education but seeking part time (weekend) work will actually increase.

However, that does mean that the majority of 16-24 year olds are not part of UE's overblown hype of a "buggered" generation.
 
In the UK, somebody who is now 15 is looking at not being able to get a job, never being able to afford to leave the parental home, not being able to afford to go to university, no hope of ever getting on the "property ladder", no hope of being able to save money (interest rates lower than inflation), no point in saving for a pension.... They are well and truly buggered.


Wait a minute...

Why should not being able to leave the parental home be a problem? Isn't people wanting to leaving the parental home and getting on the property ladder (thus causing a proliferation of low-occupancy high-energy separate housing) part of the cause of the crisis? Isn't expecting a majority to go to university, historically an expensive luxury, instead of just the absolutely necessary elite few, also part of the cause of the crisis?

Living sustainably in the past to avoid the present or future crisis would have meant, among other things, many fewer people doing those energy-expensive things (going to university, being on a property ladder, having high-productivity jobs that can fund pensions) all along.

Of course, that would have avoided the employment and pension problems too. When you're living in an extended family household you don't need a pension (as long as you have children or nephews and nieces), and without high energy use there should be plenty of manual labor available, which in turn doesn't require university education and can usually be done close to the family home.

So people doing things like living in their own homes and going to university was part of the cause of the problem, and yet people not being able to do those things in the future is a tragedy? If their parents had stayed at home and did manual jobs and not squandered all those resources then their children, the current fifteen year olds, would be able to own homes and go to university and squander the resources now instead. But that just puts the problem off another generation, doesn't it?

"If only people had lived sustainably in the past, their children would be able to live unsustainably now!" is an oddly self-defeating lament. If we'd been living sustainably in the past, then such things as pensions, higher education for most, and home ownership for most would never have been possible in the first place!

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
What's to comprehend? Your statement was simple and straightforward:

"Oil goes to $8 a gallon? Cool - more electric cars, solar water heaters, nuclear power plants, windmill farms, etc will be produced."

Sure, if you have reading comprehension problems. Had you been able to read and analyze more than one sentence at a time, you would've seen that i was referring to medium and long term limits in volatility in the price of oil. Sure, if we woke up tomorrow and gas was $8/gal, we'd have problems. I've never said otherwise, and didnt think i had to, as it's mental masterbation.

What you are implicitly suggesting is that if our economy came under a great deal of stress, it would respond vigorously with an enormous wave of new investment, and consumers would be standing in line to purchase all of these electric cars and solar water heaters which would appear instantly.

Like when people line up to buy hybrids when gas hits $4/gal?

http://www.scpr.org/blogs/environme...ng-gas-prices-drive-toyota-prius-sales-spike/
http://www.usatoday.com/money/autos/2011-04-06-prius-tops-one-million-in-sales.htm

Are we not in the middle of the fastest rush to increased fuel efficiency in decades?Will people not need water heaters in this post-apocalyptic future you're envisioning?

Its already happening, and will continue to. That's capitalism.
 
Last edited:
Sure, if you have reading comprehension problems. Had you been able to read and analyze more than one sentence at a time, you would've seen that i was referring to medium and long term limits in volatility in the price of oil.
And had you read the previous page, you would've seen that I wasn't:

Dymanic said:
Suppose we back up a step or two and talk first about what it takes to collapse an economy. I know this may sound crazy, but just for the sake of argument, imagine that a war erupted the middle east involving several of the major oil-producing nations, and this caused serious and widespread disruption of oil shipments, with the result that the price of oil doubled within a period of days and tripled or quadrupled over a period of months. Do you see the US economy being in good shape to withstand a blow like that?

I understood perfectly well that you were talking about medium and long term solutions to an immediate problem. That's my reason for dismissing it as fantasy. While having a heart attack, one might resolve to begin eating healthier and exercising more, and that's all fine and good -- but the nature of some problems is that if you can't deal effectively with them in the short term, you don't even need to worry about the medium and long term.

Ichabod said:
Will people not need water heaters in this post-apocalyptic future you're envisioning?
There are lots of ways to heat water. Humans have been doing it for thousands of years. Compared with the impact a major oil price shock would have on our ability to move people and goods from one place to another, its impact on our ability to heat water is not even worth mentioning.

Its already happening, and will continue to. That's capitalism.
Whether the agent of our salvation is purported to be Technology or Capitalism, it's still cargo-cult thinking if you're treating it as some wise and benevolent spirit that will come to our rescue because it has our best interests at heart.
 
Fisher-Tropsch based synthesis of artificial hydrocarbons powered by nuclear energy.

Problem solved.
Like I said: Modern idea-space is richly populated with imaginary energy technologies and infrastructures that all suffer from the serious drawback that they do not yet exist.
 
Like I said: Modern idea-space is richly populated with imaginary energy technologies and infrastructures that all suffer from the serious drawback that they do not yet exist.

Did you read the quote he was responding to:
and there are currently zero viable (EROEI) alternatives for liquid fuels for transport, at any "price"
Do you disagree that the ability to sythesise fossil fuels shows that EROEI is not the meaningful value when it comes to energy sources for transportation?

This doesn't mean that nuclear will solve all our problems, or that building such transportation infrastructure is easy or even likely to be done, but it does mean that there are viable solutions.

If not, what exactly do you think stops this process from working?
 
Oh dear....

Slight difference, lionking. People CHOOSE how many children they have (at least they do in the developed world). They do not choose where they are born.
You may not have chosen where you were born, but you certainly do choose where you live. I can promise you that could easily move to china, if you wanted.
Having moved here you could certainly find a job teaching english and make enough to get by.

I'm a human. It is part of my human rights to be able to question morality, and if you attempt to deny me that right then you are morally bankrupt yourself.
How exactly do you think lionking could possibly even be capable of denying you that right? His saying that he disagrees with what you are saying is very different from somehow forcing you not to say it.
 
Do you disagree that the ability to sythesise fossil fuels shows that EROEI is not the meaningful value when it comes to energy sources for transportation?
I agree that it is not the most meaningful when applied to nuclear-generated electricity. Whether synthesis of liquid fuel represents the most efficient use of that electricity (or the energy potential of the feedstock) is a more complicated question.

This doesn't mean that nuclear will solve all our problems, or that building such transportation infrastructure is easy or even likely to be done, but it does mean that there are viable solutions.
To me, the word "viable" implies something that is at least likely to be done. "Easy" isn't even on the table. If we were to immediately embark on a crash program -- with a degree of single-minded cooperation comparable to the effort put forth in the US during WW2 -- we'd be looking at years before it would start making a real difference.

If not, what exactly do you think stops this process from working?
The process of actually creating the infrastructure which, at this point, is merely fantasized? Deep ideological differences, tepid investor interest, and widespread energy illiteracy.
 
To me, the word "viable" implies something that is at least likely to be done. "Easy" isn't even on the table. If we were to immediately embark on a crash program -- with a degree of single-minded cooperation comparable to the effort put forth in the US during WW2 -- we'd be looking at years before it would start making a real difference.
Luckily we have years.

We won't be out of oil in a day, from what I understand of peak oil, the downward slope is shaped pretty much like the upward slope. Which means that there is time for us to make the transition slowly. Initially (at this stage would be best) we really only need alternative fuels, or alternatives to liquid fuels (like electric cars) to take up the growth in usage. Over the next few years they should begin to get a higher and higher share of the total use of liquid fuels. By "should" I mean that's what I'd like to see happen, not what I expect to happen.


The process of actually creating the infrastructure which, at this point, is merely fantasized? Deep ideological differences, tepid investor interest, and widespread energy illiteracy.

What is it that makes you suspect this infrastructure can't be built? The fact that they aren't now? There's no reason that they would be, given the relative cheapness of oil. The start up costs? What time-line are you envisioning?

I admit that I am only somewhat optimistic about this. I recognise that you are presenting valid concerns, and I'm not convinced that we'll get through this painlessly, or even avoid major crises, but I'm also not convinced that we won't either.
 
And had you read the previous page, you would've seen that I wasn't:



I understood perfectly well that you were talking about medium and long term solutions to an immediate problem. That's my reason for dismissing it as fantasy. While having a heart attack, one might resolve to begin eating healthier and exercising more, and that's all fine and good -- but the nature of some problems is that if you can't deal effectively with them in the short term, you don't even need to worry about the medium and long term.

Right - you were spinning fiction, which you admit 'may sound crazy,' and i seriously replied to the idea along the lines of 'that's not going to happen and here's why' and you thought it wise to respond to that with more delusional fiction?

In any case your oil = power nonsense has shown to be false, and we didn't wake up to $8/gal gas (actually it was about $.05 cheaper today - 3.72 down from 3.77).

There are lots of ways to heat water. Humans have been doing it for thousands of years. Compared with the impact a major oil price shock would have on our ability to move people and goods from one place to another, its impact on our ability to heat water is not even worth mentioning.

More Mad Max delusions. Hey man get your bunker ordered and keep the guns loaded! I guess its more interesting than dealing with reality. In the future, the cost of oil will be such that we heat our water in a small hole dug out of what used to be our kitchen, and feed the flames with clothes we used to buy at things called department store. But that was before the war...:covereyes



Whether the agent of our salvation is purported to be Technology or Capitalism, it's still cargo-cult thinking if you're treating it as some wise and benevolent spirit that will come to our rescue because it has our best interests at heart.

Riiight. You'd rather handwave increased fuel efficiency, nuclear power, and the like away because they disturb your 'what if' fantasies.
 
Last edited:
Luckily we have years.

possibly, yes, but probably not nearly enough.

We won't be out of oil in a day, from what I understand of peak oil, the downward slope is shaped pretty much like the upward slope. Which means that there is time for us to make the transition slowly.

nope, you're not grasping flattening production meeting exponential growth, when it comes, it will come very quickly. like going bankrupt.

What is it that makes you suspect this infrastructure can't be built? The fact that they aren't now? There's no reason that they would be, given the relative cheapness of oil. The start up costs? What time-line are you envisioning?

I admit that I am only somewhat optimistic about this. I recognise that you are presenting valid concerns, and I'm not convinced that we'll get through this painlessly, or even avoid major crises, but I'm also not convinced that we won't either.

I think you are somewhat optimistic too, just my opinion, obviously.
 
Last edited:
Luckily we have years.
Oh sure, I mean it's not like we've ever seen the price of oil quadruple within a period of months, or shortages that necessitated implementation of measures like gasoline rationing, and the oil-producing nations in the middle east on whom we depend for more of our supply than ever before are enjoying an unprecedented period of peaceful relations as well as internal political stability, and the current US and EU economies are best described as "robust" and "resiliant".

We won't be out of oil in a day, from what I understand of peak oil, the downward slope is shaped pretty much like the upward slope.
The map is not the territory. That theoretical curve does not feature all of the zigs and zags one always sees when graphing real-world data because the model does not even attempt to encompass all of the myriad factors that would be required to predict those. I still say that the downslope is likely to see a lot of price volatility, and a lot of struggling for control over the remaining reserves, with supply becoming increasingly spotty and unreliable.

What is it that makes you suspect this infrastructure can't be built?
I'd say that what is most pertinent is that this infrastructure hasn't been built.

There's no reason that they would be, given the relative cheapness of oil.
And the enormous start-up costs (and the impossibility of accurately predicting decomissioning costs so far in advance) and the persistent and pesky issues with waste handling and concerns about accidents, and the public's largely irrational fear of the mysterious invisible force known as "radiation". But you're right: there's no economic incentive for tackling all of that as long as the price of oil remains relatively cheap and more attractive investment opportunities exist. That's a lot of the problem.

You know, until the unsinkability of the Titanic was fully tested by its encounter with that iceberg, there wasn't a lot of incentive for counting the lifeboats to see if there was enough capacity to handle all of the passengers, either. When I watch that movie I can't help but think how many more might have survived if an organized effort had been made to grab every bouyant object on board that ship and begin lashing it all together to form a big, crude raft (or a bunch of smaller ones). The deck of a sinking ship is evidently not an environment conducive to clear thinking -- but then, most of the passengers were oblivious to the fact that there weren't enough lifeboats to accomodate them.
 
Right - you were spinning fiction, which you admit 'may sound crazy,' and i seriously replied to the idea along the lines of 'that's not going to happen and here's why' and you thought it wise to respond to that with more delusional fiction?
Gosh, I guess you're right. It's not like Israel and Iran are teetering on the brink of open war or anything. And it's completely delusional to suppose that the US might easily get sucked into a thing like that, or that Iran might, say, retailiate with attacks on Saudi oilfields or anything. I should have my head examined.

Riiight. You'd rather handwave increased fuel efficiency, nuclear power, and the like away because they disturb your 'what if' fantasies.
If it were a matter of choice, I would actually very much prefer to live in the fantasy world where all of that stuff does exist. I've been hoping for that ever since spending time waiting in those long lines to buy gasoline back in 1973 -- it's just that at some point I began to find it necessary to strike some kind of balance between what if and what IS.
 
lol @ too much woo. so bioethanol's EROEI is? evidence please?

Sure here's a PNAS paper from 4 years ago and based on technology from the year 2000 (keep in mind that the technology has only gotten better in the last 10+ years). So yeah, you must have been reading too much woo to be wrong for so long.

Net energy of cellulosic ethanol from switchgrass.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18180449

and "any energy source can be converted" ? really?

so convert me some coal to liquid fuel for my car then. or some solar power please.

Energy (any source) ---> electricity -----> hyrdrogen/electrons -----> methanol/ethanol (a liquid fuel for your car).

For coal you also have the option of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_liquefaction



somebody hasn't grasped the facts. plastics for example, I don't think the CO2 experimentation is quite ready to take over global plastics use just yet, do you?

Oil isn't going to be gone just yet is it? The production will slowly decrease, alternatives need only to make up for that difference (plus growth). The fraction of oil used for plastics is small. Bioplastics (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioplastic) are one option, but any petrochemical can be made synthetically. Oil is just the most convenient source currently.

and so this list is going to be replaced by what, bioethanol?

http://www.californiagasprices.com/crude_products.aspx

There are more alternative than just bioethanol and not everything on that list will necessarily need to be replaced.
 
Last edited:
Net energy of cellulosic ethanol from switchgrass.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18180449
Since you posted that in response to a question regarding the ERoEI of bioethanol, I must assume that you are willing to provide some kind of summary of that study's findings. The best I can come up with is: It depends. Those guys are all over the place.

The success of any bioethanol project depends on what you're growing, and how, and where, and on the weather. On how well some of the recent efforts in enzyme development succeed, and how well they scale up to industrial production levels. At present the ERoEI of ethanol from switchgrass is similar to that from corn (just barely better than break even, if that). There certainly seems to be a great deal of promise for improvement -- to 4:1, 5:1, 8:1 -- who knows? It depends -- on more things than we appear to be able to calculate at present. My earlier observation that "we're long on knowledge and short on application" does not quite apply to cellulosic ethanol from switchgrass; in this particular instance, it looks to me like we're short on both.

Cars don't run on promises. Where's the infrastructure?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom