YEC's and Evolution

You feel that science should continually question its assumptions? Really? How on earth would we ever progress if we continually repeated the analysis and experiments of the past? Do you continually check that gravity still works before you leave the house just in case?

Surely you only need to question your assumptions when you find some evidence that they may be incorrect? If your assumption always works all the time what's the point in questioning it again?

Hmm... I would argue that science does do exactly that. Replication is a mainstay of the scientific method, as is meta-analysis of past experimental work when one is seeking historical precedent for a new hypothesis (e.g., the story of quarks).

It's true that not every experiment requires that the experimenter re-invent the wheel from component parts before proceeding further. There are, however, whole institutions which maintain departments devoted to the continual and ever more refined verification of already established physical constants (e.g., the speed of light). NIST is one such institution (and was formerly known as the National Bureau of Standards).
 
ACtually one things you have to udnerstand is that tehre is no A, there is no B, there is no Z. Those are steps that *WE* human put as to more easily classify animal, genus, and evolution. In reality to take your example, starting with A a proto bacteria billion of years ago, going toward single cell animals which are A*++-+*, that WE human calssify as B, going forward one branch goes to multicellular carnivore protozoaire A*++-+*//*-+ which we classify as B and algaes like organism which we classfiy as C but inr eality is A++*-+/**-+-- and then going forward are the first plant which we qualify as D but are in realiy A++*-+/**-+--++-++- and then also parallel terrestrial moos which areA++*-+/**-+--//*/* but q

I think this is basically the thing we need to convince Avalon of. He doesn't necessarily accept this.
 
I'm not sure what you are seeing as the limit then?

If all living things are effectively made of DNA of different sequences and evolution can change any particular part of that sequence then why should any particular change not be possible?

Can it? I mean, you certainly don't believe that EVERY change is immediately possible. None of the E. coli bacteria currently under test are going to develop into a human embryo tomorrow.
Evolution is about heritable variations. The question is, WHAT variations, under WHAT conditions? The conventional wisdom is that ALL the variations that we see originally came from the same simple source.
 
The question isn't, how does it "know" when to stop; rather, it's what sort of changes does this mechanism reasonably provide for?
Look at birth defects in humans, or any animals. All kinds of things can go wrong. I would say limitless. It's just that some of these "wrong" things turn out to be positive changes in terms of reproduction of the species, because of the environment they happen to occur in.
 
And why does genetic analysis, morphology and our examination of the fossil record seem to give 'similar' results?
Evidence, please.
First of all, I notice that you totally ignored the 2 other questions I asked. (And these questions were similar to ones other people have asked.)

Namely:

- Just how much 'variation' do you think is possible in a species? For example, you suggested something like a 'proto-shrew' could change, but not enough to change into a proto-hominid. So how 'close' could it get? What limits the amount of change?

- Is it possible for individuals in a species to vary so much that they cannot interbreed?

If you really want to get any sort of respect, you should actually deal with questions like that which are asked. After all, others here have been willing to answer your questions.

Secondly, regarding the fossil record, morphology and chemcial analysis giving 'similar' results: I'm thinking specifically of a couple of cases:

- The fossil record suggests that birds and dinosaurs are closely related. (For example, the fossils of Archaeopteryx and Velociraptor show characteristics of both birds and dinosaurs). When protien from a T-rex skeleton was analyzed, it was most closely related to birds. If birds and dinosaurs were created 'separately', why did this commonality occur? Why did the protein from T-rex closely resemble a bird and not, for example, an elephant, or whale, or some other group? Why the coincidence?

See:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=t-rex-protein-sequenced-similar-to-chicken
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/09/070920145402.htm

- When we look at the fossil record, we find creatures that appear to be intermediates between modern whales and land animals. If we look at modern morphology, we find that the bones in the whale fipper are the same as the limbs of land animals. If the creation of whales were some separate 'event' from the creation of land animals, why would the flipper have such a similar bone structure to that of land animals? Why didn't god use some other bone arrangement? (Or even create a flipper with no bones, as other sea creatures have?)

See:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/A1283186
http://www.allaboutscience.org/anatomical-homology.htm

- When we look at humans, the species we share the most in common with genetically is the Chimpanzee. When we look at the fossil record, we have what appears to be a divergence of human ancestors from the line that became the chimpanzees. Why did that happen? If the creation of humans was a seperate event from the creation of other apes and monkeys, why isn't our DNA more similar to the Orangutan? Or even totally unique?

See:
http://www.pnas.org/content/100/12/7181.full
 
The question isn't, how does it "know" when to stop; rather, it's what sort of changes does this mechanism reasonably provide for?

That's still a question of limits. The "alphabet" of DNA is extremely variable (as evidenced by the diversity of life now and in the past), so the ability of DNA to provide vast solutions for various problems is no obstacle to evolution.

And gene duplication is a well known and documented phenomenon; an entire gene can be duplicated. So now you have more genetic material to work with, random mutations supply the changes and natural selection ensures that any beneficial mutations will stick around.

So it's a question of limits, what limits this mechanism from producing changes above a species level?
 
Can it? I mean, you certainly don't believe that EVERY change is immediately possible. None of the E. coli bacteria currently under test are going to develop into a human embryo tomorrow.
Evolution is about heritable variations. The question is, WHAT variations, under WHAT conditions? The conventional wisdom is that ALL the variations that we see originally came from the same simple source.

Nobody argues that every change is immediately possible. Its a slow gradual process of change.

However, its possible to get from any particular sequence to any other particular sequence by changing things a bit at a time. Just like you can get from pretty much any word in the language to another word by changing one letter at a time.

Your argument seems to be that at some point A can go to A+ A- but NOT A*; do you have any evidence to support this or is it your position that it is up to evolutionists to provide evidence that every single sequence can be obtained from any other sequence and document the processes?
 
Well, yes. Considering that it's just a re-statement of a claim for common ancestry, that's exactly what I'm not yet convinced of.

So what is it that makes certain sequences special and how is this encoded within the sequence?

It seems that you are happy enough that a proto-cat can evolve into a tiger, lion and Tiddles and every other variation up to and including one tiny step away from actually being a dog.

What stops the sequence then making that one final mutation and actually being a dog?
 
Can it? I mean, you certainly don't believe that EVERY change is immediately possible. None of the E. coli bacteria currently under test are going to develop into a human embryo tomorrow.
Evolution is about heritable variations. The question is, WHAT variations, under WHAT conditions? The conventional wisdom is that ALL the variations that we see originally came from the same simple source.

Well no of course not, that would be far too many changes to the genetic code at once.. if that DID occur that would be clear evidence of God.

There's a LOT of time involved, changes happen a tiny bit at a time, but accumulate over time. Populations evolve, not individuals.

Check out info on ring species, where you can see a populations evolve slowly such that eventually the individuals at each end of the ring cannot breed with each other, but individuals all along the ring can breed with their neighbours. Where before there was one species, there are now two. If those two species get separated from each other (i.e. the ring is broken), those two species will continue to evolve further and further apart genetically, becoming a branch in the nested hierarchy.
 
Evolution is about heritable variations. The question is, WHAT variations, under WHAT conditions? The conventional wisdom is that ALL the variations that we see originally came from the same simple source.

You are aiming at an impossible task. What you ask for is basically an exact, detailed description off all events beginning at the big bang until today. We can not ever know all of the variations that happened, and the exact conditions they happened in. This is simply because some organisms got extinct, while others survived.

Since we don't have any and all organism that ever existed at hand, and since we don't have detailed records of all conditions (like weather, for example) that have ever been, you simply ask for the impossible here.

Basically, due to random mutation of genes, pretty much everything is possible under pretty much any condition, as far as those conditions allow, of course. In addition to that, take into account the age of the earth, or the universe, and it becomes pretty clear that the possible number combinations of genes is a damn high number.

Also, keep in mind that evolution from A to B does not mean that all organisms of type A changed into the same direction, to evolve to B. Imagine a sea containing billions times billions of a single species alone. That allows for the same number of random mutation _at_once_, in a very short period of time. Now, one mutation survives and reproduces. In a year you have billions times billions of that species in the same sea. At which point you can again randomly mutate every one of them differently, again giving you billions times billions different mutations.

Again, take into account the age of the earth. During that time up until today there have been so many mutations that printing out the number would possibly kill this forum's database.

Really, you can not look at a single species and think that in one step a single mutation occurs, is "tested" if it can survive, and then either goes extinct or survives. It happens in parallel, allowing for incredible many mutations in a very short time.

Greetings,

Chris
 
Last edited:
It seems that you are happy enough that a proto-cat can evolve into a tiger, lion and Tiddles and every other variation up to and including one tiny step away from actually being a dog.

What sequence of beneficial variations in cat traits move you to "just short of" a dog?
 
What sequence of beneficial variations in cat traits move you to "just short of" a dog?
I think Fraggles is confusing the matter. The cat and the dog start out as something different from each, and like the branches of a tree, they go their separate ways to cathood, or dogdom.
 
What sequence of beneficial variations in cat traits move you to "just short of" a dog?

I don't know, it's irrelevant to the question, dog and cat were examples try A and B again if it helps you. You accepted evolution within a species so I thought you were happy that a proto-cat could evolve into any type of cat including one that is one step away from being something else (say a dog) but not make the final step to actually being something else.

Have I misunderstood your position?
 
Well, yes. Considering that it's just a re-statement of a claim for common ancestry, that's exactly what I'm not yet convinced of.

Even in the absence of any other evidence, would not the fact that pretty much all forms of life on Earth share a trememdous amount of DNA in common suggest a common ancestry to you?
 
AvalonXQ, if I understand you correctly, you accept evolution as an existing mechanism, but ask for evidence of common ancestry - i.e. that all life is related, rather than having evolved from a set of unrelated ancestors (as the existence of the mechanism alone obviously doesn't allow to decide which is the case).

In addition to that, you have special requirements about the kind of evidence you want.

Normally, I would recommend someone interested in evidence of common ancestry to start with the short overview at Wikipedia (Evidence of common descent) and continue with the excellent summary at Talk.origins.

I wonder which of the following is true? (You can answer for each link separately.)

- You have not read these, but you are going to.
- You have not read these, but you don't need to, because you are already familiar with the information contained within.
- You have not read these and you are not familiar with the information contained within, but you're still not going to read them, because you want something else.
- You have read these, and you are not satisfied with the information contained within, and you want something more/something else.
- Some other variant that I haven't thought of.
 
I don't know, it's irrelevant to the question, dog and cat were examples try A and B again if it helps you. You accepted evolution within a species so I thought you were happy that a proto-cat could evolve into any type of cat including one that is one step away from being something else (say a dog) but not make the final step to actually being something else.

Have I misunderstood your position?

I think so.
The basic idea of "types" is that the range of variation that is expected is not unlimited; it's the range of variation usually expected within a species. Dogs, for instance, vary greatly in size and less in shape, but no matter how carefully you breed them, you're never going to get a cat or a cow. All of the organism's traits will be variations of existing dog traits.

EDIT: Thabiguy, I have read them.
 
Last edited:
I think Fraggles is confusing the matter. The cat and the dog start out as something different from each, and like the branches of a tree, they go their separate ways to cathood, or dogdom.

I think you are right that my example confused. My point was that evolution doesn't know dog or cat. The process just goes from proto-cat to many different mutations of proto-cat some of which WE decide to call cats and some WE decide to call dogs.

Avalon seems to be arguing that evolution can tell the difference and that proto-cat DNA would somehow be limited to only the sequences of things that we call cats.
 
Again, I wasn't interested in debating the authority of scientists; I was answering the questions that were asked me. I'm trying to keep an open mind, but assaults on my background or the origin of my beliefs aren't valuable in this (or really any) discussion.

There weren't any "assaults" on your background. Someone just took a statement you made about other people's backgrounds and applied it to yours. That's not an assault.
 
Avalon seems to be arguing that evolution can tell the difference and that proto-cat DNA would somehow be limited to only the sequences of things that we call cats.

Right. Not that evolution is an intelligent thing that cares about our distinctions, but that the range of variation available isn't going to take us from dog to cat; it will take us from dog to smaller dog to dog with different shape of snout or color of coat. It will not give us a dog with the ability to speak, or opposable thumbs, or retractable claws, or tapeta (tapetums?).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom