Dr H
Muse
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2004
- Messages
- 835
You feel that science should continually question its assumptions? Really? How on earth would we ever progress if we continually repeated the analysis and experiments of the past? Do you continually check that gravity still works before you leave the house just in case?
Surely you only need to question your assumptions when you find some evidence that they may be incorrect? If your assumption always works all the time what's the point in questioning it again?
Hmm... I would argue that science does do exactly that. Replication is a mainstay of the scientific method, as is meta-analysis of past experimental work when one is seeking historical precedent for a new hypothesis (e.g., the story of quarks).
It's true that not every experiment requires that the experimenter re-invent the wheel from component parts before proceeding further. There are, however, whole institutions which maintain departments devoted to the continual and ever more refined verification of already established physical constants (e.g., the speed of light). NIST is one such institution (and was formerly known as the National Bureau of Standards).