YEC's and Evolution

As I've mentioned in another thread, the more I read the less convinced I am that any moderate amount of study is going to result in an educated conclusion. It's going to take a massive amount of effort for me to get to a point where I can understand what the evidence is and how to evaluate it properly.

Well, at least you're no longer appearing to reject evidence out of hand. But there may be a way to shorten the effort and reduce the amount of education.

Simply compare the amount of evidence in favor of and against YEC.

I'm quite serious. Take two sheets of paper, write "Evidence for YEC" at the top of one, and "Evidence against YEC" at the top of the other.

I'll even get you started. The evidence for YEC would start with "(Some interpretations of) the Bible demand an Earth of 10,000 years or less."

The evidence against YEC would start with
  • Some rocks have been dated via radioactivity measurements to be more than a billion years old
  • There is an unbroken series of tree rings to more than 8,000 years available in bristlecone pines and more than 10,000 years from southern Germany.
  • There is an unbroken set of yearly deposits of snow available in glacial cores to more than 400,000 years
  • Swedish varve chronology has established more than 12,500 consecutive annual deposition cycles

What else can you put on the "for" list?
 
Radiometric Dating III

It's going to take a massive amount of effort for me to get to a point where I can understand what the evidence is and how to evaluate it properly.
Since I know nothing about you, I have no idea how "massive" the effort will be. The more science/physics/geology background knowledge you have, the better. Meanwhile, I will seriously repeat an earlier recommendation.

I recommend the book Radiogenic Isotope Geology by Alan P. Dickin (Cambridge University Press, 1995 & 1997; there may be a more recent edition, but this is the one I have). The science of radiometric dating is well described in detail here. You can also try my online Radiometric Dating Resource List, though I suspect it could use an update that I have been too lazy to do.

The references on my webpage are at best peripheral, though not without value. However, Dickin's book is a primary source and probably the best bet as a rallying point to focus on. There is a chapter on the basic nuclear physics, followed by chapters that describe all of the various specific isotope schemes (e.g., Rb-Sr, U-Pb, K-Ar, U-Th & etc.) and chapters on geochemistry. If you plow through this book, making side trips to other sources when you run into areas you can't follow, then I think you will have a strong basis in understanding the specific science of radioisotope dating.
 
  • There is an unbroken set of yearly deposits of snow available in glacial cores to more than 400,000 years
  • Swedish varve chronology has established more than 12,500 consecutive annual deposition cycles
How do you know where one year's snow stops, and another year's snow begins?

Similarly, how can you be sure that a layer of sediment represents a year and not simply a flash flood?
 
Varves are relatively unique sedimentological features. While it sounds somewhat obscure to the lay person, a sedimentologist worth his sieves can spot one pretty quick.

Don't like those? Okay. We have beaches with placer deposits (heavy minerals deposited during winter [and for the life of me I don't remember if it's because there are more storms or fewer] every year) that number more than 10,000.

There's also angular unconformities. There's simply no way to deposit a few kilometers of rock, tilt it, and erode it in a single flood event (or even in 10,000 years, for that matter).

The continents (and, consequently, sea floor magnetic patterns) would require more than 10,000 years to form.

Then there's the fossil record, which covers WELL more than 10,000 years. In fact, by definition if it's less than 10 ka it isn't a fossil.

If you want to step outside of this planet, the fact that we can see 15 billion light-years into space is strong evidence that our universe is 15 billion years old or so--light travels at a fixed rate, after all.

Meteor impacts, both on Earth and on other planets, are easily dated if they're large enough. The big ones punch through the crust and leave magma behind, and igneous rock can be dated.

Weathering rinds on minerals frequently take more than 10,000 years to form, and are also remarkably common. Common enough that the first thing a geologist says when looking at a Moon rock at high magnification is "Wait, where are the rinds? This just got weird...."

Devitrified obsidian takes more than 10,000 years to form. By "devitrified" I mean that it starts off as glass and then, due to reactions with water and other minerals, becomes something else. It's the process by which Apache Tears form. You can find some really good deposits on the north side of Ruby and Sugerloaf Mountains in Colorado.

The pyramids of Egypt were built using a stone with a lot of very large foraminifera shells (forams are a type of single-celled bug that creates a shell, in this case calcium carbonate). These are several thousand years old, and mined in an area pretty far from any ocean, the only place forams are found. Obviously the formas must be older than the pyramids (Principle of Inclusion in stratigraphy); equally obviously, it takes a long time to form shells that large, deposit that many of them, and then to cement them together. It's qualitative, but fairly clear.

I'll try to think of others later.

If radiometric dating is beyond you that's okay. There are enough other lines of evidence that you don't need it, really--the concept was proven well before radiation. In fact, if you can get your hands on a copy of a book titled "Darwin's Century" you can get a pretty good overview of the lines of evidence leading to the theory of evolution, along with some additional references to check (a number of them being primary sources). Radiometric dating is icing on the cake at dessert, not really the main meal here.

I strongly suggest enrolling in a geology course from an accredited university. The introductory classes ('Rocks for Jocks", as we jokingly call them, which should tell you the level of effort generally required; the fact that you actually WANT to know something puts you head and shoulders [and heals and toes] above 99% of the class) should answer your questions fairly satisfactorily.
 
As I've mentioned in another thread, the more I read the less convinced I am that any moderate amount of study is going to result in an educated conclusion. It's going to take a massive amount of effort for me to get to a point where I can understand what the evidence is and how to evaluate it properly.
So, in practice, I'm simply moving my position to agnostic about the whole thing. It will likely stay there for the near future.


Ok, keep us posted and I hope you take advantage of the book recommendations here. I have read the first quarter of Coyne's book and find it a very clear and interesting read.
 
How do you know where one year's snow stops, and another year's snow begins?

Because it stops snowing during the summer, but the wind doesn't stop blowing dirt. So a snow-dirt-snow double transition represents two winters and one summer.


Similarly, how can you be sure that a layer of sediment represents a year and not simply a flash flood?

Because flash floods happen during the wet season when layers are ordinarily deposited; during the dry when the sediment layers harden, there is by definition no flash flooding.
 
Varves are relatively unique sedimentological features. While it sounds somewhat obscure to the lay person, a sedimentologist worth his sieves can spot one pretty quick.

Don't like those? Okay. We have beaches with placer deposits (heavy minerals deposited during winter [and for the life of me I don't remember if it's because there are more storms or fewer] every year) that number more than 10,000.

There's also angular unconformities. There's simply no way to deposit a few kilometers of rock, tilt it, and erode it in a single flood event (or even in 10,000 years, for that matter).

The continents (and, consequently, sea floor magnetic patterns) would require more than 10,000 years to form.

Then there's the fossil record, which covers WELL more than 10,000 years. In fact, by definition if it's less than 10 ka it isn't a fossil.

If you want to step outside of this planet, the fact that we can see 15 billion light-years into space is strong evidence that our universe is 15 billion years old or so--light travels at a fixed rate, after all.

Meteor impacts, both on Earth and on other planets, are easily dated if they're large enough. The big ones punch through the crust and leave magma behind, and igneous rock can be dated.

Weathering rinds on minerals frequently take more than 10,000 years to form, and are also remarkably common. Common enough that the first thing a geologist says when looking at a Moon rock at high magnification is "Wait, where are the rinds? This just got weird...."

Devitrified obsidian takes more than 10,000 years to form. By "devitrified" I mean that it starts off as glass and then, due to reactions with water and other minerals, becomes something else. It's the process by which Apache Tears form. You can find some really good deposits on the north side of Ruby and Sugerloaf Mountains in Colorado.

The pyramids of Egypt were built using a stone with a lot of very large foraminifera shells (forams are a type of single-celled bug that creates a shell, in this case calcium carbonate). These are several thousand years old, and mined in an area pretty far from any ocean, the only place forams are found. Obviously the formas must be older than the pyramids (Principle of Inclusion in stratigraphy); equally obviously, it takes a long time to form shells that large, deposit that many of them, and then to cement them together. It's qualitative, but fairly clear.

I'll try to think of others later.

And this, ultimately, is what my point is/was all about.

Yes, I suppose it's possible that Slartibartfast rolled the glacial cores out like phyllo dough when he put the glaciers in Greenland six thousand years ago, because otherwise they wouldn't have looked right. (Slartibartfast was, if nothing else, a detail-oriented workman.) But the point of science isn't to prove itself beyond all possible doubt, but simply to come up with the best and most sensible explanation for what we see.

The legal eagles use the term "preponderance of the evidence" to describe this. What does most of the evidence say? A few of us could simply sneak off to talk.origins and snarf'n'barf pages and pages of physical evidence that is at least superficially incompatible with a young earth. What physical evidence is there that is incompatible with an old one?

I submit that there's none. The only "evidence" against a young earth is some narrative in a book chapter -- a chapter that also includes a talking snake. If AvalonXQ (or anyone else reading) can provide evidence against an old earth, I'll happily read and consider it. But the simple fact is -- I've put (some of) my cards on the table; Dinwar has put some more cards, and I've got a whole other deck in my back pocket if I need it. I'm not sure that the YECs even have a second card.
 
The only "evidence" against a young earth is some narrative in a book chapter -- a chapter that also includes a talking snake. If AvalonXQ (or anyone else reading) can provide evidence against an old earth, I'll happily read and consider it. But the simple fact is -- I've put (some of) my cards on the table; Dinwar has put some more cards, and I've got a whole other deck in my back pocket if I need it. I'm not sure that the YECs even have a second card.

Nicely put :)
 
This thread was brought up elsewhere, and I thought it was time to revisit it.

So, in practice, I'm simply moving my position to agnostic about the whole thing. It will likely stay there for the near future.

I'm curious if you still feel this way.

Also, reading one of the posts in this thread made me consider another line of evidence for an old earth: the moon is covered in impact craters. The surface of the earth is not. The standard explanation is that the moon has no atmosphere and no dynamics that would cause the erosion of such features. The earth, on the other hand, has a relatively thick atmosphere with relatively dynamic weather patterns. Rain, wind, mudslides, vulcanism, subduction, etc. all play a role in the changing and smoothing out of major features of the landscape.

But these things all take a relatively long time, and thus this explanation only makes sense in light of an old earth. Is there any YEC explanation for the difference between the earth and the moon in this regard?
 
This thread was brought up elsewhere, and I thought it was time to revisit it.



I'm curious if you still feel this way.

Also, reading one of the posts in this thread made me consider another line of evidence for an old earth: the moon is covered in impact craters. The surface of the earth is not. The standard explanation is that the moon has no atmosphere and no dynamics that would cause the erosion of such features. The earth, on the other hand, has a relatively thick atmosphere with relatively dynamic weather patterns. Rain, wind, mudslides, vulcanism, subduction, etc. all play a role in the changing and smoothing out of major features of the landscape.

But these things all take a relatively long time, and thus this explanation only makes sense in light of an old earth. Is there any YEC explanation for the difference between the earth and the moon in this regard?


Just proves that god made the earth just for us/YEC off.
 
Also, reading one of the posts in this thread made me consider another line of evidence for an old earth: the moon is covered in impact craters. The surface of the earth is not. The standard explanation is that the moon has no atmosphere and no dynamics that would cause the erosion of such features. The earth, on the other hand, has a relatively thick atmosphere with relatively dynamic weather patterns. Rain, wind, mudslides, vulcanism, subduction, etc. all play a role in the changing and smoothing out of major features of the landscape.

But these things all take a relatively long time, and thus this explanation only makes sense in light of an old earth. Is there any YEC explanation for the difference between the earth and the moon in this regard?

You'll also note the hemisphere of the moon tidally locked with earth has far fewer craters than the "dark side" of the moon. This suggests that the Earth has been taken a lot of asteroid impacts for the moon, further widening the difference between the too.
 
You'll also note the hemisphere of the moon tidally locked with earth has far fewer craters than the "dark side" of the moon. This suggests that the Earth has been taken a lot of asteroid impacts for the moon, further widening the difference between the too.

I figured that the earth had probably taken some share of the moon's hits, but I wasn't aware of that demonstration of this fact, very interesting, thanks!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom