YEC's and Evolution

How about evidence of the common ancestry of humans, chimpanzees, gila monsters, and E. coli?
Random nucleotide substitutions in primate nonfunctional gene for L-gulono-gamma-lactone oxidase, the missing enzyme in L-ascorbic acid biosynthesis.

Ohta Y, Nishikimi M.
Department of Biochemistry, Wakayama Medical College, Japan.
Humans and other primates have no functional gene for L-gulono-gamma-lactone oxidase that catalyzes the last step of L-ascorbic acid biosynthesis. The 164-nucleotide sequence of exon X of the gene was compared among human, chimpanzee, orangutan, and macaque, and it was found that nucleotide substitutions had occurred at random throughout the sequence with a single nucleotide deletion, indicating that the primate L-gulono-gamma-lactone oxidase genes are a typical example of pseudogene.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10572964
 
I need persuasive evidence of a starting event to get the clock running, persuasive evidence that the current conditions are at a predictable length of time from the starting event, and step-by-step explanation of the data analysis that gets us there.

I'm not sure I follow this exactly.

Let's look more closely at the formation of granite.

A starting event to get the clock ticking : is "the granite formed" such an event? We have a pretty good understanding of how granite forms; magma cools underground and therefore crystallizes, which more or less locks the various elements into the crystal matrix of the rock. In particular, there will be a particular proportion of uranium to lead, and among the various isotopes of uranium.

Persuasive evidence that the current conditions are at a predictable length of time from the starting event : again, I'm not sure I understand what you're asking for. We don't "predict" the age of rocks; we discover them by analysis. So on to the analysis....

There's a very good step-by-step explanation of the process of the data analysis for "isochron dating" at this site. Essentially, we observe that the ratio between two substances at any one time is fixed, representing their proportion in the original rock, which we can represent graphically as a horizontal line. As radioactive decay occurs, the proportions between those substances will change, and result in the horizontal line 'tilting' when the actual proportions are measured.

But -- and here's the key insight -- the process demands that the line remain straight.

Getting back to the "persuasive evidence,".... we've done those experiments. And the line remained straight, and illustrated (in some cases) multibillion year ages.
 
I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the scientific community that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.
However, to briefly address the post as to my own personal opinion: it's (a), mistake, and definitely not (b), dishonesty.


To what extent does biology make common ancestry assumptions rather than simply assumptions for natural selection across a distinct population? To what extent are the processes of biology reliant on these assumptions?

I was carefully trying to avoid appeal to authority, I was more trying to explore what you think about the motivations of science/scientists.

No amount of authority necessarily makes evolution right but its worth bearing in mind what your argument logically entails ... that the many thousands of scientists who have studied in depth biology and evolution have missed something that you, a layman, have identified with only a cursory knowledge of the subject at hand.

This may well be the case, but it would me stop and consider the possibility that my objections have probably already been made, addressed and moved beyond.

It does seem that you are at least open to that possibility as you are asking questions.
 
No amount of authority necessarily makes evolution right but its worth bearing in mind what your argument logically entails ... that the many thousands of scientists who have studied in depth biology and evolution have missed something that you, a layman, have identified with only a cursory knowledge of the subject at hand.

It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively TACKLE these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
I'm much more interested in discussing the evidence here; people are being happily forthcoming with it.
 
Last edited:
It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo.

Ka-ching! Bingo! That is exactly what's going on here. What you don't seem to realize is that you're talking about yourself.
 
Ka-ching! Bingo! That is exactly what's going on here. What you don't seem to realize is that you're talking about yourself.

The possibility has not escaped me.
It always disturbs me that, between myself and those of my associates who have spent more time in academia than I have, I'm the only one who considers the possibility of personal indoctrination.
(BTW, I put laca on ignore.)
 
Last edited:
I was wondering if anyone would choose the ad hominim path. Disappointing.
It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively TACKLE these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
I'm much more interested in discussing the evidence here; people are being happily forthcoming with it.
I'll let Avalon's own words speak for itself.
 
Again, I wasn't interested in debating the authority of scientists; I was answering the questions that were asked me. I'm trying to keep an open mind, but assaults on my background or the origin of my beliefs aren't valuable in this (or really any) discussion.
 
Evidence, please.

Look at the primate family tree.

It should be obvious from morphology that humans are more similar to apes than to monkeys, that humans and apes collectively are more similar to old world monkeys than to new world monkeys, that old world monkeys collectively are more similar to each other than they are to apes, and so forth. You can confirm this for yourself with a visit to any decently equipped zoo.

The corresponding tree as obtained from genetic studies can be seen here. (The actual citation is : A Composite Estimate of Primate Phylogeny, by Andy Purvis Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences © 1995 The Royal Society.)

Note the similarities. See in particular figures 8 and 4, which show that "humans are more similar to apes than to monkeys, that humans and apes collectively are more similar to old world monkeys than to new world monkeys, that old world monkeys collectively are more similar to each other than they are to apes." And so forth.
 
It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively TACKLE these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
I'm much more interested in discussing the evidence here; people are being happily forthcoming with it.

You feel that science should continually question its assumptions? Really? How on earth would we ever progress if we continually repeated the analysis and experiments of the past? Do you continually check that gravity still works before you leave the house just in case?

Surely you only need to question your assumptions when you find some evidence that they may be incorrect? If your assumption always works all the time what's the point in questioning it again?

This is not argument from authority, I am not stating evolution is true because of this. I am examining your worldview and the logical consequences of it. If you feel its an inappropriate path then I thank you for at least humoring me.

I'll predict now that no amount of evidence presented in this thread will change your view. In my opinion, the issue is not with the lack of evidence its with how you choose to process that evidence and your expectations of how that evidence should look and how the scientific community should present it and deal with your objections.
 
Again, I wasn't interested in debating the authority of scientists; I was answering the questions that were asked me. I'm trying to keep an open mind, but assaults on my background or the origin of my beliefs aren't valuable in this (or really any) discussion.

Why is it that you find that statement an assault on your background and beliefs when directed at you and yet an acceptable logical criticism when directed at scientists?

We established that you hold God and Science to different standards of evidence but also to different standards of behaviour???
 
I'll predict now that no amount of evidence presented in this thread will change your view. In my opinion, the issue is not with the lack of evidence its with how you choose to process that evidence and your expectations of how that evidence should look and how the scientific community should present it and deal with your objections.

That may be. Nonetheless I appreciate the evidence being presented -- and even more than that, I appreciate any outline of a PROCESS by which I can arrive at evidence that "should" be persuasive.
The articles already cited and linked to should provide plenty of information for me to digest; some reflect phenomena I was familiar with before and some reflect phenomena that are new to me. All (to be honest, actually just most) seem worth my time to examine.
The thread seems to be devolving into bashing me as ignorant since you brought up the scientific community, so I'm not sure how much longer I'll be able to stomach sticking around, but I at least appreciate the discussion so far.
 
I'll predict now that no amount of evidence presented in this thread will change your view. In my opinion, the issue is not with the lack of evidence its with how you choose to process that evidence and your expectations of how that evidence should look and how the scientific community should present it and deal with your objections.

That's harsh. Not necessarily unwarrantedly harsh (in light of the forum's previous experiences with YECs), but definitely harsh.

How about we wait and see how AvalonXQ responds to the evidence presented (e.g., in posts 19, 26, 39, 41, 43, and 53)?

I believe that most of his concerns about evidence have been addressed; if there are any specific concerns he wishes to raise, we should be able to address them as well.

In a civil fashion.
 
Last edited:
Clearly a tiger and a leopard are different animals today. Could they both have evolved from a common ancestor? How about a hyena and a wolf? I am just pointing out that often what we as humans perceive to be similar animals (wolves and dogs for example), are just an extension of what can be proven to be the same phenomenon in other species. The proof is in the genetics. Let's say that evolution is not true, but all the evidence that we use in modern medicine points to its validity, then it may as well be true, just by Occam's razor.

I agree that bashing is out of place in this thread. This is getting very interesting. I actually see AvalonXQ's point, since he is quite articulate.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom