YEC's and Evolution

Why is it that you find that statement an assault on your background and beliefs when directed at you and yet an acceptable logical criticism when directed at scientists?

I brought up a mechanism that is commonly at work, and gave it as a reason why a community of knowledgeable and intelligent people could arrive at a mistaken conclusion. The next post was a simple, "Ah! Gotcha! Actually, that's exactly what YOU do!" Which, when applied to me personally, is pretty clearly intended to be a mean-spirited attack.
And the back-and-forth on my ignorance continues. I'm just happy we made it fifty posts before it became personal.
 
I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the scientific community that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.

You are making the common mistake of assuming that the logical fallacy of appealing to authority means that -all- appeals to authority are fallacious. This is not the case.

Appeal to authority is fallacious if a) the authority in question is not an authority on the topic under discussion; or b) if the appeal is made that "X" is true primarily or exclusively -because- "Y" says so, and "Y" is an authority on "X".

It is /not/ fallacious, however, to support an argument for "X" by citing work done by those who are authorities on "X", where that work is a) supported by objective evidence, and b) the work is independently replicable and verifiable. Published, peer-reviewed scinetific research meets these criteria.

The scientific community accepts the theory of evolution as valid, -not- as "a historical fact,", but based upon the accumulated physical evidence of controlled, replicated, peer-reviewed research. To reject the conclusions of that community out-of-hand as an "appeal to authority" is to commit a logical error akin to denying the existence of Europe on the basis that you haven't been there yourself, and aren't willing to accept the authority of people who live there.
 
How about my earlier question... how do you decide what is thing A and thing B and when two things are different or the same fundamental thing?

I think another poster answered that one pretty well -- you look to the genetics, see what sorts of variation exist, and determine whether the available variation is sufficient to explain the differences in a given situation.
My understanding is that, when evolutionists apply this method, they come to the conclusion that the available variation is sufficient to explain ALL differences among living organisms.
 
That may be. Nonetheless I appreciate the evidence being presented -- and even more than that, I appreciate any outline of a PROCESS by which I can arrive at evidence that "should" be persuasive.
The articles already cited and linked to should provide plenty of information for me to digest; some reflect phenomena I was familiar with before and some reflect phenomena that are new to me. All (to be honest, actually just most) seem worth my time to examine.
The thread seems to be devolving into bashing me as ignorant since you brought up the scientific community, so I'm not sure how much longer I'll be able to stomach sticking around, but I at least appreciate the discussion so far.

I'm certainly not trying to bash you as ignorant, I'm just trying to ask questions to make you think about your point of view. Ignorance is not necessarily an insult anyway, its just an assessment of your or my current level of knowledge of a topic.

I'm assuming that you, like me, don't have a doctorate in biology which probably renders us both ignorant to some extent on the finer details of this topic.
 
Avalon, please don't take the following wrong. But you should be aware that what you are complaining about, is exactly what you yourself do.

Let me give you two examples of your posts, and then let me change only a few words.

I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the scientific community that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.

I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the religious community that accepts the theory of creation as historical fact. "A whole lot of religious men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.

It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively TACKLE these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.

It's easy to make mistakes when your starting beliefs are wrong, when you've been taught those beliefs as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a religious environment where questioning those beliefs is taboo. The more I see that religious leaders actively TACKLE these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're religious; you're an atheist " is the argument, and it's a poor one.


See, what i want to say is that, in my opinion, you make the wrong arguments here, simply because the very same arguments can be made against your side as well. This, in the end, will lead to nothing.

You said that you recon that wolves are the common ancestors of dogs. So, there you have a small part of evidence right before your eyes. You have something called A that evolved into B. Yet, you also argue that you can not accept that this would happen on a larger scale. But it happened, happens now, and will happen tomorrow.

See, where do you want to draw the line between A and B? Thing is, there is no sharp line. Live evolves, split's into different directions, undergoing slow changes. Sure, we can look back X years and say "Organism Y was very different at point X in time from what we have now". But what if you divide the time between X and now into single years, and follow the evolution of said organism? Do you think that Y would change suddenly between a certain date and the year before?

It's more like a gradual, slow change. Some species got extinct back then, others continued to exist. What if apes got extinct, and only humans survived? Would you then accept that apes and humans come from the same "line of evolution", and there isn't that much difference between them and us? Is it that you reject that simply because apes are still alive today?

Greetings,

Chris
 
Evidence, please.

Here's a good summary of one line of genetic evidence.

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/section4.html#retroviruses

With links to the papers involved. EDIT: The Lebedev one in particular.

You'll notice the illustration with the specific ERVs insertions, branched according to what the ERV insertions dictate, mirrors the same evolutionary branching that was determined via morphology, and the fossil record as well though I can't think of a link about that directly off the top of my head.

The nested hierarchy of ERVs in the genetic code only makes sense in the context of evolution. If each species is created separately, then having this nested hierarchy of genetic code from dead viruses makes no sense; in fact it's misleading! If all species are created by God, the only reason God would have put those ERVs where he did was to mislead people intentionally...
 
Last edited:
It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo.

Does that not describe the transference of Biblical knowledge from generation to generation, to a -T- ?
 
That's harsh. Not necessarily unwarrantedly harsh (in light of the forum's previous experiences with YECs), but definitely harsh.

How about we wait and see how AvalonXQ response to the evidence presented (e.g., in posts 19, 26, 39, 41, 43, and 53)?

I believe that most of his concerns about evidence have been addressed; if there are any specific concerns he wishes to raise, we should be able to address them as well.

In a civil fashion.

I wasn't trying to be harsh so apologies if it reads that way.

I am assuming, maybe wrongly, that Avalon has probably seen SOME good evidence for evolution in the past but remains unconvinced. My hypothesis then is that the problem is not with the evidence but with the 'convincing' part. It would therefore pay more dividends to explore the process of convincing and Avalon's expectations on being convinced than it would to keep putting more and more evidence in front of him.

I could be wrong though, I'm neither a biologist nor a psychologist.
 
I think another poster answered that one pretty well -- you look to the genetics, see what sorts of variation exist, and determine whether the available variation is sufficient to explain the differences in a given situation.
My understanding is that, when evolutionists apply this method, they come to the conclusion that the available variation is sufficient to explain ALL differences among living organisms.

Yes.

The evidence on which they base this is pretty compelling, too. For example, all life on earth share the same genetic code (e.g. GGU corresponds to glycine in all cases); the genetic structure of even extremely different life is very similar (for example, both humans and fruit flies have identifiable Hox genes; humans share both alpha- and beta- globin genes with all other amniotes, and so forth. Even plants have alpha-globin-like genes in the form of leghemoglobin.)

So it appears that simple tweaking of human hemoglobin genes can produce plant proteins. We've found no plant proteins that can't be expressed in terms of animal genetics, or vice versa. In what way is available variation NOT sufficient?
 
I think another poster answered that one pretty well -- you look to the genetics, see what sorts of variation exist, and determine whether the available variation is sufficient to explain the differences in a given situation.
My understanding is that, when evolutionists apply this method, they come to the conclusion that the available variation is sufficient to explain ALL differences among living organisms.

This is what science does and science decided that it IS sufficient.

I was more interested in your personal definition of thing A and thing B and why, for example, you are unwilling to personally accept that a significantly evolved proto-shrew is actually an orangutan?

How does evolution know when to stop?
 
It would therefore pay more dividends to explore the process of convincing and Avalon's expectations on being convinced than it would to keep putting more and more evidence in front of him.

I agree. I'm not willing to dismiss any of the presented evidence out of hand, so I will already take a considerable amount of my time to genuninely understand everything that's been linked to. Piling more and more of it up isn't going to help, since I don't accept its source as a priori authoritative.
 
I think another poster answered that one pretty well -- you look to the genetics, see what sorts of variation exist, and determine whether the available variation is sufficient to explain the differences in a given situation.
My understanding is that, when evolutionists apply this method, they come to the conclusion that the available variation is sufficient to explain ALL differences among living organisms.

Pretty much all life shares the same basic genetic code, and there's an infinite amount of variation possible (well not infinite, there's probably some kind of reasonable limit to the size of a genome).

Do you have a more detailed example of what you are saying here, I don't really understand what it is you are saying scientists do.
 
I agree. I'm not willing to dismiss any of the presented evidence out of hand, so I will already take a considerable amount of my time to genuninely understand everything that's been linked to. Piling more and more of it up isn't going to help, since I don't accept its source as a priori authoritative.

Well, this gets back to the question of what you want.

I already provided what most people would accept as an "authoritative" citation for the existence of rocks too old to fit into a young earth:

Bowring, S.A., and Williams, I.S. (1999) Priscoan (4.00-4.03 Ga) orthogneisses from northwestern Canada. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, 134(1), 3-16.

What is it about the source that you find less than compelling? Do you disbelieve the journal? Do you disbelieve Dr. Bowring? Do you believe that he falsified his measurements? Do you believe that he took the measurements but made errors in his processing? Do you believe that he obtained the measurements he describes, but that he is misinterpreting them?

And what would you need to see in order to find this paper compelling? You can probably fly to Dr. Bowring's lab -- he's in Cambridge, at MIT. It's a little late in the year to fly to northwestern Canada if you want to collect the rocks yourself.....
 
I am assuming, maybe wrongly, that Avalon has probably seen SOME good evidence for evolution in the past but remains unconvinced. My hypothesis then is that the problem is not with the evidence but with the 'convincing' part.

And indeed - no *one* piece of evidence for evolution is particularly convincing. It's easy to dismiss any given point of data in the absence of supporting data. Someone who looks at a few (or many, to be fair) pieces of evidence and dismisses each in turn without ever considering them in a broader context can quite easily convince themselves that they have seen no evidence at all.

The evidence for evolution is overwhelming, and much of what we observe in the world only makes sense in the context of evolution and natural selection. But its easy for an individual - even a well-intentioned individual as the OP seems to be - to miss this if their focus is narrowed down to find that *one* bit of data that will make them go "Ahah! This is the proof!"
 
ACtually one things you have to udnerstand is that tehre is no A, there is no B, there is no Z. Those are steps that *WE* human put as to more easily classify animal, genus, and evolution. In reality to take your example, starting with A a proto bacteria billion of years ago, going toward single cell animals which are A*++-+*, that WE human calssify as B, going forward one branch goes to multicellular carnivore protozoaire A*++-+*//*-+ which we classify as B and algaes like organism which we classfiy as C but inr eality is A++*-+/**-+-- and then going forward are the first plant which we qualify as D but are in realiy A++*-+/**-+--++-++- and then also parallel terrestrial moos which areA++*-+/**-+--//*/* but qualifeid as F etc... until you get to human which have so many modification, expansion, inclusion, substraction of the genetic code, that nothing from the start is recognizable is a a chain of /**-+ too long to print that we qualify as Z but is a very very long tree with parallel branch.

To put it bluntly, there is a set of small change going on for the last 2 billion years, but WE human can only catch in the fossile record steps because the probability of saving all steps is nearly NIL. But we are lucky enough we can in some case keep some steps and find fossile. Look for example horse evolution, or heck human evolution with a proto ancestor and branch evolving out.

Basically genetic code is also really helpful for this. Some of the gene we have in common with our "cousins" some we do not have because they were overwritten by virus/mutated. And if memory is correct one of our chromosome also split etc...

This is a link showing such genetic evidence and is not at all an argment from authority. It clearly shows why we think there is a common ancestor

http://www.gate.net/~rwms/hum_ape_chrom.html

The following observations can be made about similarities and differences among the four species. Except for differences in non genetic heterochromatin, chromosomes 6, 13, 19, 21, 22, and X have identical banding patterns in all four species. Chromosomes 3, 11, 14, 15, 18, 20, and Y look the same in three of the four species (those three being gorilla, chimps, and humans), and chromosomes 1, 2p, 2q, 5, 7 - 10, 12, and 16 are alike in two species. Chromosomes 4 and 17 are different among all 4 species.

SNIP

Now, the question has to be asked - if the similarities of the chromosomes are due only to common design rather than common ancestry, why are the remnants of a telomere and centromere (that should never have existed) found at exactly the positions predicted by a naturalistic fusion of the chimp ancestor chromosomes 2p and 2q?
 
Last edited:
The question isn't, how does it "know" when to stop; rather, it's what sort of changes does this mechanism reasonably provide for?

I'm not sure what you are seeing as the limit then?

If all living things are effectively made of DNA of different sequences and evolution can change any particular part of that sequence then why should any particular change not be possible?
 
Piling more and more of it up isn't going to help, since I don't accept its source as a priori authoritative.

So what is it exactly that you reject then? Do you distrust the scientific process? The peer review process?

A scientific journal doesn't exist in a vacuum... it's been vetted by peers, it's transparent, and other scientists will reproduce it to try and disprove the conclusions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom