YEC's and Evolution

AvalonXQ

Unregistered
Joined
Sep 25, 2009
Messages
11,831
It was suggested over in R&P that a thread where a YEC explains what he knows about evolution would be useful/enjoyed, so I made one.
My general understanding of the Theory:

One or more mechanisms allow for living organisms to include randomly-generated heritable variations. Some of these variations affect the survivability of the organism. Variations which aid survivability of the organism are (more likely to be) carried on and perpetuated, while those that harm survivability are not.
These changes account for all of the present diversity of life on earth. All life on earth shares a common ancester.

How's that? What would be useful for me to explain next?
 
It was suggested over in R&P that a thread where a YEC explains what he knows about evolution would be useful/enjoyed, so I made one.
My general understanding of the Theory:

One or more mechanisms allow for living organisms to include randomly-generated heritable variations. Some of these variations affect the survivability of the organism. Variations which aid survivability of the organism are (more likely to be) carried on and perpetuated, while those that harm survivability are not.
These changes account for all of the present diversity of life on earth. All life on earth shares a common ancester.

How's that? What would be useful for me to explain next?

I'm impressed. Most YECs can't even get that much right.

So why do you reject that theory?
 
I'm impressed. Most YECs can't even get that much right.

So why do you reject that theory?

1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

At the threat of a derail why do you find the evidence for evolution less compelling than you find the evidence for God?

More to the point above where do you feel the evidence is lacking? What evidence would convince you that evolution as a process is a fact?
 
What evidence would convince you that evolution as a process is a fact?

I don't know. That's why I'm trying to read, learn, and gather all of the evidence that I can.
The key, though, comes from a distrust of "digested" conclusions. I want primary sources; to be convinced, I need the evidence itself.
Easy example: I wouldn't find "this rock is 2 million years old" to be convincing; that's a conclusion. However, I might very well find "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" to be convincing. Does that make sense?
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.
What would be "persuasive" evidence?
 
I don't know. That's why I'm trying to read, learn, and gather all of the evidence that I can.
The key, though, comes from a distrust of "digested" conclusions. I want primary sources; to be convinced, I need the evidence itself.
Easy example: I wouldn't find "this rock is 2 million years old" to be convincing; that's a conclusion. However, I might very well find "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" to be convincing. Does that make sense?

Hmm, well since we are talking science here the data and working is publicly available, its not hidden. Of course most people would not think starting from zero is the place to start, presumably you accept some tenets of science without seeing the data?

Could you be more specific in terms of which parts of evolution you are unconvinced of? Maybe start with your definition and point out which parts you accept and which parts you don't?
 
I'm like most IDers and creationists: I accept the mechanism, but not the history. Heritable variation is fact. Common ancestry is what I don't accept.
 
Could you be more specific in terms of which parts of evolution you are unconvinced of? Maybe start with your definition and point out which parts you accept and which parts you don't?
Seconded.
Do you accept common descent?
What about change in gene allele frequencies in a population?
 
I'm like most IDers and creationists: I accept the mechanism, but not the history. Heritable variation is fact. Common ancestry is what I don't accept.
Why? Unless you say why, we won't know what to present as evidence.
 
I'm like most IDers and creationists: I accept the mechanism, but not the history. Heritable variation is fact. Common ancestry is what I don't accept.

What is your specific issue with common ancestry? And what is your alternative hypothesis?

You accept that thing A can evolve into A-, A+ and A* what then is A if not a common ancestor of A-, A+ and A*?
 
What is your specific issue with common ancestry? And what is your alternative hypothesis?
I don't see the evidence that shows that the current diversity of life on Earth could or did arise from common ancestors. My alternative hypothesis is that many different organisms were created independently.

You accept that thing A can evolve into A-, A+ and A* what then is A if not a common ancestor of A-, A+ and A*?
The issue is whether A can also evolve into B, which seems wholly different than A in a way that A-, A+, and A* does not.
 
It was suggested over in R&P that a thread where a YEC explains what he knows about evolution would be useful/enjoyed, so I made one.
My general understanding of the Theory:

One or more mechanisms allow for living organisms to include randomly-generated heritable variations. Some of these variations affect the survivability of the organism. Variations which aid survivability of the organism are (more likely to be) carried on and perpetuated, while those that harm survivability are not.
These changes account for all of the present diversity of life on earth. All life on earth shares a common ancester.

How's that? What would be useful for me to explain next?

This is true, but more than "survivability", my understanding is that it is the ones which reproduce the most that are perpetuated. If an organism merely survives without reproducing, then the variation is lost.
 
I might very well find "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" to be convincing. Does that make sense?

Sure. But geological research is already full of "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" results which show the ages of the rocks -- decades worth of such results. We've dated most of the geologic column to great precision. All of the geologic research from is available for you to examine. Just visit a university library and have a look at the journals in the collection.

Likewise, the results of ~100 years of genetic study are available, not to mention ~50 years of DNA research, including the comparative genetics used to build the phylogenetic tree.

Jerry Coyne's Why Evolution Is True and Richard Dawkins's The Greatest Show On Earth both outline the evidence behind evolution, but if you want primary sources, read the geologic, biologic, genetic, and evolutionary journals. There are, literally, tens of thousands of papers presenting this primary evidence, each building on the ones that went before.

Be prepared for very dense, technical writing, though.

AvalonXQ said:
In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

Why default to that particular text, and not another? If you reject evolutionary biology, cosmology, geology, and so on, you still have thousands of creation stories to choose from.
 
This is true, but more than "survivability", my understanding is that it is the ones which reproduce the most that are perpetuated. If an organism merely survives without reproducing, then the variation is lost.

Thank you for the clarification; I agree.
From what I've read, some folks divide heritable traits into "survival advantages" and "reproductive advantages", while others consider the distinction to be improper. But I do understand the distinction and your point.
 
Sure. But geological research is already full of "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" results which show the ages of the rocks -- decades worth of such results. We've dated most of the geologic column to great precision. All of the geologic research from is available for you to examine. Just visit a university library and have a look at the journals in the collection.

Likewise, the results of ~100 years of genetic study are available, not to mention ~50 years of DNA research, including the comparative genetics used to build the phylogenetic tree.

That sounds excellent. Can you help point me in the right direction as to which discussions and articles to look for that have primary data?
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.
Would you be more likely to accept the body of evidence (of which there is much--whether it is "persuasive" is subjective) for evolution if the concept of evolution did not in any way contradict the teachings of the Bible?
 
Would you be more likely to accept the body of evidence (of which there is much--whether it is "persuasive" is subjective) for evolution if the concept of evolution did not in any way contradict the teachings of the Bible?

Yes I would.
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.
Let's start simply.

How about evidence of the emergence of a bacterial adaptation that had not previously existed?
For instance, the ability of a new strain of bacteria which is capable of digesting byproducts of nylon products.

http://www.pnas.org/content/81/8/2421.long
"Birth of a unique enzyme from an alternative reading frame of the
preexisted, internally repetitious coding sequence" PNAS V 81, p 2421-2425.


 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

Have you taken a class in biology?

There are multiple independent lines of evidence that evolution by natural selection is an accurate account of life on Earth. The evidence is so overwheleming that this theory is the central organizing principle of the study of biology.

ETA: Even if you were ignorant of such evidence, how would ignorance support the teachings of the Bible? Why the Bible and not some other culture's creation myths?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom