YEC's and Evolution

You are prepared to say Evolution can do A, Evolution can do B, Evolution can do C but at the same time you are arguing that Evolution cannot do D.

And, at the same time, you're telling me that evolution cannot do E, which seems to be in the same category as D.

A, B, and C, are all small changes; we have evidence for them. D is a change of a much more different and drastic kind. I understand that the wisdom is that D is just A repeated over millions of years, but I need direct evidence of D. A just isn't convincing of D.
 
Last edited:
I began this thread by request. If you feel it's pointless, stay away. If the general consensus becomes that it's pointless, I'll happily refrain myself. But noncontributing posts are not appreciated.

I'm pointing out that your entire style of arguing is disingenuous and guaranteed to lead nowhere. You are free to ignore me, of course, but you could also change your style of arguing to one that is more honest and productive.

All you need do is make some positive claim as to why evolution cannot result in speciation (something other than "of course it can't" or "I don't believe it"). Then you will be making an actual argument--one that can be tested. At the moment all you are saying is "I refuse to believe this." That might be an interesting thing for your friends to know about you, but it is of no possible intellectual interest whatsoever.
 
How many people have to believe something before trusting them becomes a valid argument, tantamount to evidence? What credentials do they need to have?
And can we have this discussion elsewhere?

Again its not argument from authority its the rather sensible presumption that if you are going to announce that all those thousands of people who dedicated their life to studying this specific thing have made a mistake then you might want to actually bring something to the table with some data or evidence to discuss that shows where there mistake is, rather than the argument that 'I can't imagine it happens that way'
 
... which is precisely what this thread was originally designed to ferret out, was my understanding of evolution and places where it's lacking.
I've been hearing, from multiple people on this thread, that there is no intrinsic limit to the amount of change possible in the genome. Apparently, though, it's impossible to get from a dog to a cow. So, there are limits in what changes are possible.
This demonstrates a complete ignorance of the process of evolution.

Nobody is saying that a dog could evolve into a cow, because a cow is a unique animal with a specific genetic makeup, which evolved over millions of years.

What IS possible is for a dog to evolve into an animal with similar characteristics... a large-size, grazing herbovore if there is an advantage for that to happen.

You see, you have things backwards - The issue is not "Can species X turn into species Y", the issue is "Can species X change enough so that it no longer can be viewed as species X".

The question is, empirically, what are these limits, and what changes have historically occurred?

First of all, I find it ironic that you would be raising these questions, since you have been asked multiple times just how much variation YOU think is possible and what exactly limits further changes.

Secondly, there are a few basic rules:
- changes must not violate any physical laws (e.g. you'll never see a 1 mile high animal since it is unlikely that an animal of that size would have the bone or muscle structure to support itself)
- an animal is unlikely to evolve into a previously occupied niche (hence you won't see dogs evolving into cows because we already have various species of large land-based herbivores)
Apart from that, the issue isn't so much what the limits are, but how much time is available.
 
Yes, it is.
Thanks for your time today.

No, it isn't.

If you bring some evidence to the table that shows those scientists to be wrong then you will win. No matter how many thousands of them agree.

You have failed to do this so far. Your entire argument is 'I don't believe them'
 
Forgive me while I delve into the land of analogy. I'll be using language for this example.

A change from Classical Latin to modern French would be a drastic change. But nobody claims that Classical Lating changed immediately into modern French. Classical Latin evolved into Vulgar Latin through a few minor changes. Vulgar Latin evolved into Old French through a few minor changes. Old French evolved into Middle French through a few minor changes. Middle French evolved into Modern French through a few minor changes.

Simultaneously, Vulgar Latin evolved into Old Spanish, then Medieval Spanish, then modern Spanish.

Could Classical Latin evolve, in only a few generations, into Modern French or Modern Spanish? No. Can Modern French evolve into Modern Spanish, or vice versa? No. But nobody doubts that Modern French, Modern Spanish, Modern Portuguese, Modern Italian, and Modern Romanian, among others, evolved from Classical Latin.

Does that analogy make sense? Do you see how it applies, crudely, to biological evolution?
 
I've been hearing, from multiple people on this thread, that there is no intrinsic limit to the amount of change possible in the genome.

Right. However, only so much of the genome gets changed with every mutation. No one ever claimed that very big parts of the genome will change in a single step.

Apparently, though, it's impossible to get from a dog to a cow. So, there are limits in what changes are possible.

Wrong. It is perfectly possible to get from a dog to a cow. Just not in a single step. It would happen over a long period of time, through billions of billions of small mutations in the genome.

The question is, empirically, what are these limits, and what changes have historically occurred?

Theoretically i would say (attention: uneducated guess) the only limit is 4 (the four bases GATC) to the power of the maximum number of them possible in a single genome. Like, the limit of an 8 bit binary number is 256 possibilities, or 2^8. However, unlike a binary number, not every combination makes sense and is able to "exist".

What changes have historically occurred? That is again asking for the impossible, since we simply don't know, and will never know, what combinations ever existed successfully, much less which combinations have ever been tried due to mutation but didn't survive.

Greetings,

Chris
 
On aspects of evolution...
Again its not argument from authority
Yes, it is.
Thanks for your time today.

Sooooo... in other words, what you're saying is that not only are you ignorant of what the theory of evolution is, you are also ignorant about what an "argument from authority" is...

From Wikipedia:
... a statement is correct because the statement is made by a person or source that is commonly regarded as authoritative.
...
This is a fallacy because the truth or falsity of the claim is not necessarily related to the personal qualities of the claimant, and because the premises can be true, and the conclusion false (an authoritative claim can turn out to be false).
...
On the other hand, arguments from authority are an important part of informal logic. Since we cannot have expert knowledge of many subjects, we often rely on the judgments of those who do. There is no fallacy involved in simply arguing that the assertion made by an authority is true. The fallacy only arises when it is claimed or implied that the authority is infallible in principle and can hence be exempted from criticism.


Once again, when we talk about evolution, we are not basing our understanding on the statements by a single individual (or group of individuals)... we are basing our understanding on the work of thousands upon thousands of individuals, working through the process of peer review.

Perhaps you should go back and take a remedial science course.
 
The key, though, comes from a distrust of "digested" conclusions. I want primary sources; to be convinced, I need the evidence itself.

Do you therefor share similar doubts regarding the findings of chemistry, astronomy, nuclear physics, etcetera?
 
Nobody is saying that a dog could evolve into a cow, because a cow is a unique animal with a specific genetic makeup, which evolved over millions of years.

What IS possible is for a dog to evolve into an animal with similar characteristics... a large-size, grazing herbovore if there is an advantage for that to happen.

Someone with more knowledge can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it is truer to say that there is no physical reason why some species of dogs could not evolve into animals that were genetically indistinguishable from (and interbreedable with) modern day cows. The point is that it is vanishingly improbable. The series of steps that would require such a "targeted" evolution are each astronomically improbable. Multiply each improbability by the next and you have the kinds of improbability that make macroscopic quantum effects look commonplace.

But I don't think there is any inherent limit to the plasticity of a dog's (or any other animals) DNA code.
 
You seem to have little problem with argument from Biblical authority.

Again, an argument from authority is an argument from authority; it's useful if you trust the source, and not useful if you're looking for evidence. When I quote the Bible as a source of authority, I'm making an argument from authority; I usually do so in the context of explaining Christian beliefs and/or my beliefs rather than as any sort of "proof" that the ideas are objectively correct.
I'm aware that most people here accept the scientific consensus as authoritative, and therefore that using this consensus without additional evidence can often be useful (as the Wikipedia post indicated). However, without presenting the underlying facts themselves, it's still engaging in an argument from authority -- and, in this case, the source is one that I do not accept as authoritative in all areas. It doesn't mean that I won't look at the underlying evidence; it means that the underlying evidence and not the conclusions of others are necessary to convince me in these matters.
I know that bothers a lot of atheists and other science-minded people, so I didn't really want to go into it here. But there you go.
I regret starting this thread, because rather than attempting to explain what I understand and get feedback, it became something else entirely -- first, a "why don't you accept evolution?" and then a "how can you be so ignorant/stupid/incredulous/unscrupulous/hypocritical as to not accept evolution?" However, thread degeneration aside, I'll definitely learn something from reading some of the linked articles, so that's a plus. It's also helped me know some of the names that should go on my ignore list, so that's a plus as well.
I'm done here, at least for now.
 
Last edited:
It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively tackle these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
I'm much more interested in discussing the evidence here; people are being happily forthcoming with it.

HMM, just musing here, but I WONDER - why exactly does the above line of reasoning NOT apply to your buybull and YEC theory!? After all YOU want to talk about an environment where certain assumption are taboo!?

"They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.

Really, WHY!? I mean I understand the falacy of argument from authority and what it means, but not only do you NOT seem to understand it you're headlong deep into using it here!

And do you really assume that your understanding of this subject, or for that matter any complex one that envolves multiple lines of evidence and discipline is equal to someone who has spent often decades studying it?. I mean on the one hand YOU ask for evidence and on the other you dismiss the evidence given to you by simply claiming that their word/knowledge of the subject is not any better than yours (someone who displays less than high school level understanding on the subject at hand) What more is there to discuss here? You pretend that you want evidence but when given to you and explained that it is backed by papers written by and reviewed by people who have spent decades working in the filed you blow it off because it doesn't mesh with YOUR argument from authority - the bible.

And while we're at it, lets address your total missconception of the scientific community.
From your post above you seem to live under the delusion, probably braught on by your experience being indoctrinated into your cult, that people interested in studying this or any other scientific field come into the discipline begging to please and cow tow to their elders. You couldn't be more wrong! Every scientist, to some degree or another, is an egotist and part of the motivation that drives them to endure YEARS of study, YEARS of field work and research publishing peer reviewed papers is because they want to prove the other guy wrong and discover the TRUE answer! The most famous scientists, including Darwin, are so famous precisely for this reason! They proposed something that was TOTALLY against the norm and dispite all the crap they took and all the efforst of the powers that be THEIR ideas withstood the test of time.

Now I grant you there are people who are disshonest or so commited to an idea that they will lie or hide info _ BUT this is what peer review adn the scientific method is in place for. It seems to me that when it's all said and done, the ONLY evidence that you will accept for ToE is one that is impossible to give because that evidence would actually disprove ToE ala
Originally Posted by Last of the Fraggles
3. Do you think that evolution argues that you should be able to breed modern dogs and eventually get a cat or a cow?
Yes, I do
So in the final analisys you are nothing but the typical xian fundi to damend lazy or dumb to do the actual work for yourself and sell out the easy answer of the big sky daddy.
 
Someone with more knowledge can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it is truer to say that there is no physical reason why some species of dogs could not evolve into animals that were genetically indistinguishable from (and interbreedable with) modern day cows. The point is that it is vanishingly improbable. The series of steps that would require such a "targeted" evolution are each astronomically improbable. Multiply each improbability by the next and you have the kinds of improbability that make macroscopic quantum effects look commonplace.

But I don't think there is any inherent limit to the plasticity of a dog's (or any other animals) DNA code.

My thought, and correct me if I'm wrong, is that for a dog to get to be a cat or a cow would first require the modern dog to mutate backwards to something closely resembling the common ancestor before then evolving down the 'cow' route.

While it might be theoretically possible for this to occur given enough millions of years I don't think there is any process by which the breeding of modern dogs would cause this to happen. At some point wouldn't you need a drastic change in conditions/environment?
 
Someone with more knowledge can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it is truer to say that there is no physical reason why some species of dogs could not evolve into animals that were genetically indistinguishable from (and interbreedable with) modern day cows. The point is that it is vanishingly improbable. The series of steps that would require such a "targeted" evolution are each astronomically improbable. Multiply each improbability by the next and you have the kinds of improbability that make macroscopic quantum effects look commonplace.

But I don't think there is any inherent limit to the plasticity of a dog's (or any other animals) DNA code.

Thank you, I think that clarifies that issue up perfectly.
 
To Avalon and Responders

Complete layman here, except for a high school biology class, so I hope I'm not muddying things further, but I think I see part of Avalon's problem, and it's about a point of evolution that I don't understand myself, so I'll ask it.

Evolution is depicted pictorially as a tree, from a common ancestor to many, completely separate, branches, all of which fork away from each other at different points along the trunk. Each branch occurs when some of the DNA changes enough that the new creature can no longer interbreed with the rest of the branch. Hence, each branch is missing some of the source DNA (or, more properly, it has changed from the source).

The branch labelled "dog" has a different pool of DNA to work with than the branch labelled "cow". Hence, a dog cannot interbreed with a cow. However, large portions of the DNA are the same, since both creatures are still on the main branch labelled "mammal" (or some such).

Therefore, "dog" can never become "cow" because it's missing the necessary DNA; it was lost when the two species split from the "mammal" branch.

Is it also true that said DNA could redevelop eventually through further mutation that reintroduces those changes? Essentially, that "dog" could "unevolve" back to the main branch, then "re-evolve" along the same lines as the current "cow"? Leaving aside any possibilities of that actually occurring, of course, which I understand are staggeringly unlikely, given that there is currently no evolutionary pressure or advantage to encourage it.

This, I think, is Avalon's main point of confusion. Evolution, as he/she understands it, would allow for "dog" to become "cow" without the "de-evolution" part, which I guess could be just as possible if those DNA mutations happened forward instead of going backwards instead, however unlikely that may be.

I think a contributing factor to the confusion is that he/she compares the process to the only method of species change he/she knows of, which is selective breeding. But he/she doesn't take into account that that will never produce "cow" because it can only be done using all "dog" genes. He/she can also only look at the direct results observed over the lifetimes of the people doing the breeding, not over the millions of years necessary for such a drastic DNA change.

Am I anywhere close?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom