It's easy to make mistakes when your starting assumptions are wrong, when you've been taught those assumptions as basic from the beginning, and when you're in a cultural environment where questioning those assumptions is taboo. The more I see that professionals actively tackle these questions without assuming the outcome, the less likely it is that they're making this particular mistake.
But let's not mince words here: you're arguing from authority, plain and simple. "They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
I'm much more interested in discussing the evidence here; people are being happily forthcoming with it.
HMM, just musing here, but I WONDER - why exactly does the above line of reasoning NOT apply to your buybull and YEC theory!? After all YOU want to talk about an environment where certain assumption are taboo!?
"They're experts; you're a layman," is the argument, and it's a poor one.
Really, WHY!? I mean I understand the falacy of argument from authority and what it means, but not only do you NOT seem to understand it you're headlong deep into using it here!
And do you really assume that your understanding of this subject, or for that matter any complex one that envolves multiple lines of evidence and discipline is equal to someone who has spent often decades studying it?. I mean on the one hand YOU ask for evidence and on the other you dismiss the evidence given to you by simply claiming that their word/knowledge of the subject is not any better than yours (someone who displays less than high school level understanding on the subject at hand) What more is there to discuss here? You pretend that you want evidence but when given to you and explained that it is backed by papers written by and reviewed by people who have spent decades working in the filed you blow it off because it doesn't mesh with YOUR argument from authority - the bible.
And while we're at it, lets address your total missconception of the scientific community.
From your post above you seem to live under the delusion, probably braught on by your experience being indoctrinated into your cult, that people interested in studying this or any other scientific field come into the discipline begging to please and cow tow to their elders. You couldn't be more wrong! Every scientist, to some degree or another, is an egotist and part of the motivation that drives them to endure YEARS of study, YEARS of field work and research publishing peer reviewed papers is because they want to prove the other guy wrong and discover the TRUE answer! The most famous scientists, including Darwin, are so famous precisely for this reason! They proposed something that was TOTALLY against the norm and dispite all the crap they took and all the efforst of the powers that be THEIR ideas withstood the test of time.
Now I grant you there are people who are disshonest or so commited to an idea that they will lie or hide info _ BUT this is what peer review adn the scientific method is in place for. It seems to me that when it's all said and done, the ONLY evidence that you will accept for ToE is one that is impossible to give because that evidence would actually disprove ToE ala
Originally Posted by Last of the Fraggles
3. Do you think that evolution argues that you should be able to breed modern dogs and eventually get a cat or a cow?
Yes, I do
So in the final analisys you are nothing but the typical xian fundi to damend lazy or dumb to do the actual work for yourself and sell out the easy answer of the big sky daddy.