YEC's and Evolution

I think so.
The basic idea of "types" is that the range of variation that is expected is not unlimited; it's the range of variation usually expected within a species. Dogs, for instance, vary greatly in size and less in shape, but no matter how carefully you breed them, you're never going to get a cat or a cow. All of the organism's traits will be variations of existing dog traits.

EDIT: Thabiguy, I have read them.
No one with any understanding of the problem has ever said this. If you get hung up on that, you will never get anywhere. This is what guys like Ray Comfort like to spout. They are either misinformed or lying.
It takes millions of years to get what you suggest cannot be done. That's a long time.
 
Right. Not that evolution is an intelligent thing that cares about our distinctions, but that the range of variation available isn't going to take us from dog to cat; it will take us from dog to smaller dog to dog with different shape of snout or color of coat. It will not give us a dog with the ability to speak, or opposable thumbs, or retractable claws, or tapeta (tapetums?).

Why not? What limits this?
 
I think so.
The basic idea of "types" is that the range of variation that is expected is not unlimited; it's the range of variation usually expected within a species. Dogs, for instance, vary greatly in size and less in shape, but no matter how carefully you breed them, you're never going to get a cat or a cow. All of the organism's traits will be variations of existing dog traits.

EDIT: Thabiguy, I have read them.

Hmm we've gone off on a bit of a tangent here then. Many things to clarify now:

1. What is a type? How would I know if a previously undiscovered animal is a new type or an existing one? How do I know that a tiger is actually a type of cat and not a separate type of tigers or big cats?

2. How do you know what variation is expected and what isn't?

3. Do you think that evolution argues that you should be able to breed modern dogs and eventually get a cat or a cow?

4. Do you accept that an ancestor of (and I'm regretting my example now) modern cats and dogs doesn't necessarily need all the traits of all cats and dogs but just some common traits?
 
I think so.
The basic idea of "types" is that the range of variation that is expected is not unlimited; it's the range of variation usually expected within a species. Dogs, for instance, vary greatly in size and less in shape, but no matter how carefully you breed them, you're never going to get a cat or a cow. All of the organism's traits will be variations of existing dog traits.

EDIT: Thabiguy, I have read them.

But it is _us_ who defines the types and species. These categories are somewhat arbitrary. Even more, some species get recategorized over time. Taking your argument, we don't have dogs, but wolves as pets. They share the same traits, to a varying degree. However, it is _us_ who decided that a certain amount of variation is enough to call them dogs instead of wolves.

In addition, the process of breeding, as we do it with animals and plants, is designed to _preserve_ as much as possible of the existing traits/genetics. However, the process of evolution is about _randomizing_ that, it is the exact opposite. After that randomization, some traits/genes stay, others go away, and even others appear new.

Taking the classification game a step further: dog is not the same as dog. We have poodles, retrievers, shepherds, and so on. So, we could in theory say that there is no "dog" at all, but only poodles, etc. It is, again, _us_ who put them in a category and labeled it "dog".

Greetings,

Chris
 
I'm not interested in appeals to the authority ---munity that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.

I am reading all the posts, but I just HAD to jump in and say that the above comment is rip roaringly hularious considering the special pleading the poster has for the "authority" of the buy bull
 
Right. Not that evolution is an intelligent thing that cares about our distinctions, but that the range of variation available isn't going to take us from dog to cat; it will take us from dog to smaller dog to dog with different shape of snout or color of coat. It will not give us a dog with the ability to speak, or opposable thumbs, or retractable claws, or tapeta (tapetums?).

To the best of your knowledge, what is the process or feature of the process or whatever you want to call it that stops a particular DNA sequence mutating to another one?

What's the limiting factor?
 
Right. Not that evolution is an intelligent thing that cares about our distinctions, but that the range of variation available isn't going to take us from dog to cat; it will take us from dog to smaller dog to dog with different shape of snout or color of coat. It will not give us a dog with the ability to speak, or opposable thumbs, or retractable claws, or tapeta (tapetums?).

Once again, please answer the questions...

Just how much variation do you think is possible? What exactly do you think is the limiting mechanism? What is preventing dogs, if there were an adaptive advantage from, for example, eventually obtaining retractable claws? If you think it is impossible, then why do you think its impossible?

And you still haven't addressed the other question: do you think its possible for there to be so much variation in a species that individuals at the 'extremes' no longer have the ability to mate with each other?
 
1. What is a type? How would I know if a previously undiscovered animal is a new type or an existing one? How do I know that a tiger is actually a type of cat and not a separate type of tigers or big cats?
By knowing what sorts of variations are possible, and analyzing traits and history to determine whether these variations likely occurred. IE, observation.

2. How do you know what variation is expected and what isn't?

I don't know that you do, a priori. You take a look at the existing varieties and the genome and see what's possible.

3. Do you think that evolution argues that you should be able to breed modern dogs and eventually get a cat or a cow?

Yes, I do.

4. Do you accept that an ancestor of (and I'm regretting my example now) modern cats and dogs doesn't necessarily need all the traits of all cats and dogs but just some common traits?

I accept that as a rational assertion; not necessarily an accurate one.
 
I am reading all the posts, but I just HAD to jump in and say that the above comment is rip roaringly hularious considering the special pleading the poster has for the "authority" of the buy bull

So you agree that an argument from authority is insufficient for someone looking for evidentiary arguments?
If so, I fail to see the hypocrisy in acknowledging that this fact applies to ANY authority. I don't accept special pleading when I'm looking for evidence.
Perhaps you could stick with substantive contributions, or stay silent, rather than just ridiculing me? You're lowering the tone of the debate.
 
Last edited:
I'm always amazed at the generosity people on this site exhibit with their time and expertise. I mean, here's someone who has one trick and one trick only--the argument from personal incredulity ("No WAY could a whale and a dog have a common ancestor--nuh-UH!") and yet all these intelligent and informed people are engaging with him/her for page after page after page.

Why bother? There's simply no way to engage with the argument from personal incredulity--that's why it's a fallacy. Unless Avalon is willing to make some positive claim (which can either be proven or disproven) this argument is pointless--and, quite literally, interminable.
 
By knowing what sorts of variations are possible, and analyzing traits and history to determine whether these variations likely occurred. IE, observation.

I don't know that you do, a priori. You take a look at the existing varieties and the genome and see what's possible.

Yes, I do.

I accept that as a rational assertion; not necessarily an accurate one.

So we define types by first defining types and then deciding that everything that fits within this type fits within this type? That's basically what you have argued here.

I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding of evolution if your answer to point 3 is true.
 
Why bother? There's simply no way to engage with the argument from personal incredulity--that's why it's a fallacy. Unless Avalon is willing to make some positive claim (which can either be proven or disproven) this argument is pointless--and, quite literally, interminable.

I began this thread by request. If you feel it's pointless, stay away. If the general consensus becomes that it's pointless, I'll happily refrain myself. But noncontributing posts are not appreciated.
 
So you agree that an argument from authority is insufficient for someone looking for evidentiary arguments?
If so, I fail to see the hypocrisy in acknowledging that this fact applies to ANY authority. I don't accept special pleading when I'm looking for evidence.
Perhaps you could stick with substantive contributions, or stay silent, rather than just ridiculing me? You're lowering the tone of the debate.

I think his point was that you are willing to accept your alternative hypothesis without anywhere near the supporting evidence that you demand from the evolution argument. Why is this?
 
So you agree that an argument from authority is insufficient for someone looking for evidentiary arguments?
What you fail to understand is that people don't believe in evolution because people successfully engage in "argument from authority". We believe in evolution because we have seen the details of evolution discussed amongst thousands of scientists (making up virtually the entire scientific community). Furthermore, those discussions are open to the public, and can often be accessed through various peer reviewed publications.

"Argument from authority" suggests that you are basing your beliefs on what just a single (or very small group of people) say. I don't believe evolution because Darwin or Dawkins told me to, I believe it because thousands of scientists have worked on the theory.
 
By knowing what sorts of variations are possible, and analyzing traits and history to determine whether these variations likely occurred. IE, observation.



I don't know that you do, a priori. You take a look at the existing varieties and the genome and see what's possible.

That only tells us what's possible with the current genome. If the genome is different in the next generation, then new things will be possible, and some things that are possible with the current genome will be impossible with the new one. And the same goes with the genome after that, and the one after that, and the one after that.


Yes, I do.

Well, it doesn't, and I'm not sure where you got the idea it did.

It does say that it's possible for a modern dog species to evolve into a species that has very similar traits to a modern cow - but it wouldn't be able to interbreed with a modern cow or a descendant of a modern cow.

For example, whale sharks have some features in common with whales, even though they evolved from very different lineages. But a whale shark can't interbreed with a whale.
 
Last edited:
I think you have a fundamental misunderstanding of evolution if your answer to point 3 is true.

... which is precisely what this thread was originally designed to ferret out, was my understanding of evolution and places where it's lacking.
I've been hearing, from multiple people on this thread, that there is no intrinsic limit to the amount of change possible in the genome. Apparently, though, it's impossible to get from a dog to a cow. So, there are limits in what changes are possible.
The question is, empirically, what are these limits, and what changes have historically occurred?
 
So you agree that an argument from authority is insufficient for someone looking for evidentiary arguments?
If so, I fail to see the hypocrisy in acknowledging that this fact applies to ANY authority. I don't accept special pleading when I'm looking for evidence.
Perhaps you could stick with substantive contributions, or stay silent, rather than just ridiculing me? You're lowering the tone of the debate.

OK, then please, tell us: what are the arguments, having the quality you ask, for a god having created all the life on earth, instead of evolution?

And i too don't accept special pleading, for example to unverifiable books, when i like to see evidence for that.

You know, as a matter of fact it _does_ go both ways. You ask us for evidence for evolution, you define what kind of evidence you accept. That's fine. But we can also ask for your evidence that this didn't happen, but that some god did that all instead.

So, again, please show us your evidence for your side of the view as well. Can you do that?

Greetings,

Chris
 
I began this thread by request. If you feel it's pointless, stay away. If the general consensus becomes that it's pointless, I'll happily refrain myself. But noncontributing posts are not appreciated.

Do you understand his point about incredulity though?

You are prepared to say Evolution can do A, Evolution can do B, Evolution can do C but at the same time you are arguing that Evolution cannot do D.

The evidence for A,B,C and D are the same.

The process is the same.

What evidence do you have that evolution cannot do D?
 
"Argument from authority" suggests that you are basing your beliefs on what just a single (or very small group of people) say. I don't believe evolution because Darwin or Dawkins told me to, I believe it because thousands of scientists have worked on the theory.

How many people have to believe something before trusting them becomes a valid argument, tantamount to evidence? What credentials do they need to have?
And can we have this discussion elsewhere?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom