I don't know. That's why I'm trying to read, learn, and gather all of the evidence that I can.
The key, though, comes from a distrust of "digested" conclusions. I want primary sources; to be convinced, I need the evidence itself.
Hmmm. Well, that's fair enough in principle, but may be a hard standard to meet in practice.
Easy example: I wouldn't find "this rock is 2 million years old" to be convincing; that's a conclusion. However, I might very well find "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" to be convincing. Does that make sense?
It does, but I'm not sure how far you want to take this.
Would you want to see the rock itself to be convinced?
Would you want to see the original lab notebook of the researcher who ran the atomic dating on it?
Would you want to see a photocopy of the lab notebook?
Would you accept a paper written by the researcher in which he said "we found the elements in the following concentrations and therefore conclude the rock to be two million years old"?
Would you accept a paper written by the researcher in which he said "we applied the Snidely-Whiplash method of dating [17] and determined the rock to be two million years old"?
Fortunately, even these are not necessary to refute
young earth creationism. The Grand Canyon (or similar sites, but the GC is worth visiting anyway) clearly illustrates that the Earth is not less than 10,000 years old. (In fact, it clearly shows that the Earth is at least several hundred million years old, but even 10,000 is enough to refute YEC.) And you can pick up primary source data to your heart's content.
Indeed, if you want to date a rock, almost any piece of basalt or granite that you find anywhere in the world will be too old for a young earth. Again, if you're willing to take a trip, head to Pike's Peak, where the bedrock at the top of the mountain is more than a billion years old.
So I guess my question at this point boils down to -- in light of my previous claim, that the rock atop Pike's Peak is more than a billion years old, what would I need to provide in terms of evidence to convince you?
I mean, I could easily provide a rock (just phone a friend in Colorado), but I'm not sure you're qualified to run the radiometric dating. I could with slightly more difficulty provide the name of a lab to whom you could send the rock, but I'm not sure you would be willing to pay the costs of the analysis. I could send you a peer-reviewed paper in which the age of Pike's Peak is discussed, but now we're back to '"digested" conclusions.'
So what do you need?