YEC's and Evolution

I don't see the evidence that shows that the current diversity of life on Earth could or did arise from common ancestors.
Why? A single scoop of dirt in your backyard has more bacteria then the entire population of China. What is the major problem with the current evidence concerning the diversity of life or common ancestry?

My alternative hypothesis is that many different organisms were created independently.
Here is your first major error. Evolution does not deal with the beginning of life so you are asking evolution to explain something it was never meant to do.
 
....


The issue is whether A can also evolve into B, which seems wholly different than A in a way that A-, A+, and A* does not.

The point that might help is that A*****+++++-----, way down the line after thousands of generations of subtle changes, get very close to what we would call B, and eventually A, with all its **'s and sub species etc, no longer is viable, and is completely replaced by B. A'ness vs. B'ness is really in the eye of the beholder. It is not the case that dogs evolved into cats. Something else split off into catlike and doglike animals. Subtle differences at first, but again, after a long time, these differences became more pronounced.
 
I don't know. That's why I'm trying to read, learn, and gather all of the evidence that I can.
The key, though, comes from a distrust of "digested" conclusions. I want primary sources; to be convinced, I need the evidence itself.

Hmmm. Well, that's fair enough in principle, but may be a hard standard to meet in practice.

Easy example: I wouldn't find "this rock is 2 million years old" to be convincing; that's a conclusion. However, I might very well find "these are the concentrations of several elements in the rock, and these are the known decay rates of these elements" to be convincing. Does that make sense?

It does, but I'm not sure how far you want to take this.

Would you want to see the rock itself to be convinced?
Would you want to see the original lab notebook of the researcher who ran the atomic dating on it?
Would you want to see a photocopy of the lab notebook?
Would you accept a paper written by the researcher in which he said "we found the elements in the following concentrations and therefore conclude the rock to be two million years old"?
Would you accept a paper written by the researcher in which he said "we applied the Snidely-Whiplash method of dating [17] and determined the rock to be two million years old"?

Fortunately, even these are not necessary to refute young earth creationism. The Grand Canyon (or similar sites, but the GC is worth visiting anyway) clearly illustrates that the Earth is not less than 10,000 years old. (In fact, it clearly shows that the Earth is at least several hundred million years old, but even 10,000 is enough to refute YEC.) And you can pick up primary source data to your heart's content.

Indeed, if you want to date a rock, almost any piece of basalt or granite that you find anywhere in the world will be too old for a young earth. Again, if you're willing to take a trip, head to Pike's Peak, where the bedrock at the top of the mountain is more than a billion years old.

So I guess my question at this point boils down to -- in light of my previous claim, that the rock atop Pike's Peak is more than a billion years old, what would I need to provide in terms of evidence to convince you?

I mean, I could easily provide a rock (just phone a friend in Colorado), but I'm not sure you're qualified to run the radiometric dating. I could with slightly more difficulty provide the name of a lab to whom you could send the rock, but I'm not sure you would be willing to pay the costs of the analysis. I could send you a peer-reviewed paper in which the age of Pike's Peak is discussed, but now we're back to '"digested" conclusions.'

So what do you need?
 
I don't see the evidence that shows that the current diversity of life on Earth could or did arise from common ancestors. My alternative hypothesis is that many different organisms were created independently.


The issue is whether A can also evolve into B, which seems wholly different than A in a way that A-, A+, and A* does not.

Would you agree that if A evolves into A+ A- and A* then they evolve into A++ A+- A+* A-- A-* A-+ A*- A*+ and A** and so on that you can easily create a huge diversity of different things given enough time? Do you then disagree with the process being able to create diversity or just with the time being sufficient?

For your second point, how do you distinguish between A++++++++++++++ and B? Scientifically, logically or consistently how do you decide when something is no longer thing A but is actually thing B?
 
When is a dog no longer a dog?
Start with a wolf. Breed it to be small. Breed it to very small. Breed it to fear humans. Breed it to be a loner. Breed it to have no fur. Breed it to have no tail. Breed it to have a long neck.

When does this creature stop being a dog?
 
That sounds excellent. Can you help point me in the right direction as to which discussions and articles to look for that have primary data?

I would start at this web page. While it is not itself a primary source, it has links to a number of both primary and secondary sources and it may also help explain the background you will need for primary sources.

If you want a primary source, try :

Bowring, S.A., and Williams, I.S. (1999) Priscoan (4.00-4.03 Ga) orthogneisses from northwestern Canada. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, 134(1), 3-16.

... or indeed, any of Sam Bowring's work. This one (and the work on which it comments) aregood because it discusses a number of different techniques:

Schmitz, M.D., Bowring, S.A., Ludwig, K.R. and Renne, P., Comment on Precise K-Ar, 40Ar/39Ar, Rb-Sr and U/Pb mineral ages from the 27.5 Ma Fish Canyon Tuff reference standard by M. A. Lanphere and H. Baadsgaard: Chemical Geology, v.199 (3-4): p. 277-280.
 
So what do you need?

I need persuasive evidence of a starting event to get the clock running, persuasive evidence that the current conditions are at a predictable length of time from the starting event, and step-by-step explanation of the data analysis that gets us there. I don't think I'll need to run the tests myself; at present, I don't have access to the tools needed to do so anyway.
 
Starting with scientific journals and primary sources might be tough going depending on your background and education.. those are the kind of materials that are written by and for those who have gone through the education process. A biology textbook and popular books like those mentioned might be a better place to start.
 
Would you agree that if A evolves into A+ A- and A* then they evolve into A++ A+- A+* A-- A-* A-+ A*- A*+ and A** and so on that you can easily create a huge diversity of different things given enough time?
If A is a small proto-shrew and B is an orangutan, I'm not convinced that there IS a set of changes to get from A to B. I see a proto-shrew turning into a slightly larger proto-shrew, maybe with different sizes of teeth; about the same amount of variation as we see among modern dogs (all of which are descended from wolves). But I don't see the evidence that shows how these small changes accumulate into changes as large as the diversity we see on earth.
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

Let's try another tack at the same time.

Do you believe that the scientists who support evolution are a) wrong or b) lying?

If a) why do you believe that the many thousands of scientists who have studied this have not pointed out that this theory doesn't work? Someone who disproved evolution would surely be as famous as Darwin?

Do you believe these scientists are not smart enough to find out that it's wrong? Do you think you have found something that no biologist has ever investigated or thought of?

If b) to what end are they lying? Do you think scientists are evil and trying to disinvent God? Do you think scientists benefit from putting forward a lie? Why do you feel nobody within the scientific world has ever exposed this fraud?

This would be a massive conspiracy theory on a par with the 9-11, moon landings and JFK combined!

Finally, why is it do you think that biology which assumes evolution to be a fact works? Is it just a coincidence?
 
I need persuasive evidence of a starting event to get the clock running, persuasive evidence that the current conditions are at a predictable length of time from the starting event, and step-by-step explanation of the data analysis that gets us there. I don't think I'll need to run the tests myself; at present, I don't have access to the tools needed to do so anyway.
Dr.Kitten asked rather specifically this question and gave examples of the details involved.

To avoid too many topics, why don't we narrow down our focus. As you say, you are a YEC.

So, what would you prefer to talk about:

1.) Evidence for an old earth?
2.) Evidence for natural selection?
3.) Evidence for speciation?
4.) Evidence for the emergence of new genes/traits.
5.) Evidence for human evolution?
 
If A is a small proto-shrew and B is an orangutan, I'm not convinced that there IS a set of changes to get from A to B. I see a proto-shrew turning into a slightly larger proto-shrew, maybe with different sizes of teeth; about the same amount of variation as we see among modern dogs (all of which are descended from wolves). But I don't see the evidence that shows how these small changes accumulate into changes as large as the diversity we see on earth.

There is. time.

A 'proto-shrew' may well have walked with the dinosaurs 65 million years ago. Compare to todays great apes, and yes, there seems to be very little in common, especially when you consider the scarsity of fossils and DNA from such ancient organisms.

However, we can follow certain traits in the creatures we do have, and be able to place them along the evolutionary 'bush', so to speak.
And if something new comes along? Well, we might have to re-write what we know.
 
If A is a small proto-shrew and B is an orangutan, I'm not convinced that there IS a set of changes to get from A to B. I see a proto-shrew turning into a slightly larger proto-shrew, maybe with different sizes of teeth; about the same amount of variation as we see among modern dogs (all of which are descended from wolves). But I don't see the evidence that shows how these small changes accumulate into changes as large as the diversity we see on earth.
Why?
And what prevents continued accumulating changes from happening?
 
Let's try another tack at the same time.

Do you believe that the scientists who support evolution are a) wrong or b) lying?

If a) why do you believe that the many thousands of scientists who have studied this have not pointed out that this theory doesn't work? Someone who disproved evolution would surely be as famous as Darwin?

Do you believe these scientists are not smart enough to find out that it's wrong? Do you think you have found something that no biologist has ever investigated or thought of?

If b) to what end are they lying? Do you think scientists are evil and trying to disinvent God? Do you think scientists benefit from putting forward a lie? Why do you feel nobody within the scientific world has ever exposed this fraud?

This would be a massive conspiracy theory on a par with the 9-11, moon landings and JFK combined!

Finally, why is it do you think that biology which assumes evolution to be a fact works? Is it just a coincidence?

I'm not interested in appeals to the authority of the scientific community that accepts the theory of evolution as historical fact. "A whole lot of smart men believe this" does not an evidentiary argument make.
However, to briefly address the post as to my own personal opinion: it's (a), mistake, and definitely not (b), dishonesty.

Finally, why is it do you think that biology which assumes evolution to be a fact works? Is it just a coincidence?
To what extent does biology make common ancestry assumptions rather than simply assumptions for natural selection across a distinct population? To what extent are the processes of biology reliant on these assumptions?
 
If A is a small proto-shrew and B is an orangutan, I'm not convinced that there IS a set of changes to get from A to B. I see a proto-shrew turning into a slightly larger proto-shrew, maybe with different sizes of teeth; about the same amount of variation as we see among modern dogs (all of which are descended from wolves). But I don't see the evidence that shows how these small changes accumulate into changes as large as the diversity we see on earth.

Do you think an ape and a human are 2 different things?

At the level of DNA how different are apes and humans?

Or even more simply... can you imagine a sperm cell turning into a fully grown hairy chested beer-swilling man? That's quite some change isn't it and that's not even evolution.

Can you at least concede that what you can imagine is not necessarily a good guide to what is true and that 'hmm i can't really see that' is not really a compelling argument?
 
Dr.Kitten asked rather specifically this question and gave examples of the details involved.

To avoid too many topics, why don't we narrow down our focus. As you say, you are a YEC.

So, what would you prefer to talk about:

1.) Evidence for an old earth?
2.) Evidence for natural selection?
3.) Evidence for speciation?
4.) Evidence for the emergence of new genes/traits.
5.) Evidence for human evolution?
How about evidence of the common ancestry of humans, chimpanzees, gila monsters, and E. coli?
 
I'm like most IDers and creationists: I accept the mechanism, but not the history. Heritable variation is fact. Common ancestry is what I don't accept.

Ok, a few questions:

- You accept that 'inheritable variation' is a fact. Just how much 'variation' do you find acceptable? How much do you think a species can 'change' before you reach some sort of limit where no more change or variation can occur?

- If you accept that change can occur, can you also accept that there can be enough variation between individuals within a species that individuals at the 'extremes' can no longer interbreed?

- Lastly, if you are discounting evolution because of lack of evidence, how do you explain the results that we HAVE found? Most importantly how do you explain the convergence? Example: how can you explain why astronomers place the universe at 10-15 billion years old, geologists place the earth at ~5 billion years, and earliest multicelular organisms at less than 1 billion? (Why, if evolution and the 'old age' of the universe were not true, do the numbers fit in?) And why does genetic analysis, morphology and our examination of the fossil record seem to give 'similar' results? (After all if all species were created separately, why would birds and dinosaur tissue analysis show the same type of relationship that the fossil records show? How come an all-powerful god did not create dinosaurs with tissues more closley related to mammals, or echinoderms, or any other creature?) Do you think it was all a coincidence or was god playing a trick on people?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom