YEC's and Evolution

This question often comes up, and it's just a silly semantics question. Yes, humans evolved from apes; not the apes alive today, but certainly an animal that would be unequivocally classified as an ape. And, since we are ourselves classified as a species of ape, the question becomes even more pointless.

Also, as a former lurker on this thread, I'd like to know if AvalonXQ has read his literature already, and whether (s)he still thinks the earth is less than 10000 years old.
And if so, what was wrong with the papers.
Read the question Cainkane asked. He said WHY ARE THERE STILL APES. That doesn't say WHY ARE THERE STILL 'OLDER' APES but why there are still apes meaning the apes we know....modern apes.....does anyone read?
 
Also, as a former lurker on this thread, I'd like to know if AvalonXQ has read his literature already, and whether (s)he still thinks the earth is less than 10000 years old.
And if so, what was wrong with the papers.

I promised AvalonXQ on another thread (which was the reason i reopened this), that i'd personally try to keep this about the logic and evidence of evolution only, without turning this into a discussion about his (her?) beliefs.

I would greatly appreciate it if others would do the same.
 
Last edited:
Yes. I'll let you figure out why. In case you forgot the point Cainkane brought up (rather the question) is why there are still apes if humans evolved from them.
Since Creationist do not believe that birds evolved from dinosaurs, I really don't see your point.
 
Read the question Cainkane asked. He said WHY ARE THERE STILL APES. That doesn't say WHY ARE THERE STILL 'OLDER' APES but why there are still apes meaning the apes we know....modern apes.....does anyone read?
Yes I read. The question "why are there still apes" is a stupid question. The thing is, I've seen people argue over the question whether humans evolved from apes several times, and they were people who agreed that humans and chimps share a common ancestor.

So I guess my question then becomes: what is the point of asking this?
 
I promised AvalonXQ on another thread (which was the reason i reopened this), that i'd personally try to keep this about the logic and evidence of evolution only, without turning this into a discussion about his (her?) beliefs.

I would greatly appreciate it if others would do the same.
A little bit up in this thread, Avalon said the only reason for further participation in this thread would be to discuss the evidence. One of the most discussed pieces of evidence was a paper about radiometric dating of rocks.
In other words, don't see how my questions are off-topic.
 
Last edited:
Yes I read. The question "why are there still apes" is a stupid question. The thing is, I've seen people argue over the question whether humans evolved from apes several times, and they were people who agreed that humans and chimps share a common ancestor.

So I guess my question then becomes: what is the point of asking this?

He said creotards ask him that question. His post clearly said that. Did you really read it? If you did why didn't you know why he asked?
 
In other words, don't see how my questions are off-topic.

It isn't, i probably shouldn't have quoted you - my note wasn't aimed at your question really, but rather a common plea to everyone.

As an OT side note, It would be nice to be able to restrict the discussion to one thing at the time though, on complicated matters such as this one.

It would be cool if the forum software had the possibility to "speciate" a discussion to multiple subthreads when various new issues evolve from the mother thread. Otherwise the discussion is a bit hard to follow, as it jumps wildly from one place to another.

Kind of user definable, thread specific subforums - new branches of the tree.
 
He said creotards ask him that question. His post clearly said that. Did you really read it? If you did why didn't you know why he asked?
I don't want to know why creationists ask why there are still apes. I want to know why you asked if humans evolved from apes.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to know why creationists ask why there are still apes. I want to know why you asked if humans evolved from apes.

I asked Simon that because he said humans are classified as apes. Just because they are classified as apes does not mean they are evolved from apes as apes are still living. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes. Just as birds evolved from certain dinosaurs which are now extinct the common ancestor humans and apes both evolved from is also extinct. I find it utterly hilarious that supposed critical thinkers are so brain-addled when it comes to evolution.
 
I asked Simon that because he said humans are classified as apes. Just because they are classified as apes does not mean they are evolved from apes as apes are still living. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes. Just as birds evolved from certain dinosaurs which are now extinct the common ancestor humans and apes both evolved from is also extinct. I find it utterly hilarious that supposed critical thinkers are so brain-addled when it comes to evolution.
Yes, hilarious, except that it isn't all that black and white.
Humans and chimpanzees both definitely evolved from something that cannot possibly be termed anything other than an ape. Humans and gibbons however share an ancestor that is much more like a monkey than an ape.

That is why I said this is a silly semantics question, and the heated discussions on this forum about that very question demonstrate why I find it rather silly to say things like:
I find it utterly hilarious that supposed critical thinkers are so brain-addled when it comes to evolution.
 
For the record it isn't me asking that question. That question is often asked of me when I'm discussing biology and evolution with a creationist. When I am asked this question I say humans evolved from a species of a now extinct ape and that while we share a common ancestry with existing apes existing apes evolved to fit their particular environmental nich. I'm usually interrupted before I can finish or they find my explantaion incredulous. I often finish by saying that humans are themselves a species of ape called gracial ape. That really gets them going but by now I've finished talking to them in disgust.
 
I'd say that the biggest problem for a YEC to accept common descent of lifeforms is the fact that the theory of evolution needs hundreds of thousands to millions of years to split species apart so far they cannot interbreed any more and become different forms.
Since this would mean accepting that these millions od years actually happened that is going against the young in YEC immediately, which in my opinion means that it is impossible to ever convince someone who believes in a young earth of evolution.

No matter how much evidence is show in genetics, archeology, biology, cosmology and other fields about common genes, mutation rates, age of rocks, etc. As soon as this evidence goes beyond 6000 or so years, a YEC will always have to say that the evidence is false/misunderstood/wrong to keep up his/her believe in a young earth.
I'm guessing this is also where the 'micro'-evolution thing came from. Once evolution and mutation had been clearly shown to exist and work in a lab people who cannot for personal reasons accept that earth really is older than 6K years had to find a way to claim that while minor changes happen, major changes don't. And since major changes take far longer than any experiment can achieve, there is no way to positively disprove it since the ones coining the term will be dust by the time its shown.

I would therefore postulate that the only way to prove the existence of common descent and evolution to a YEC would be to change/alter their faith, which is not what science is and should be about.
Unfortunately there seems to be a vocal part of the YEC community that does want their faith imposed on science and which causes the conflicts mainly seen in the US about this subject.
 
I'd say that the biggest problem for a YEC to accept common descent of lifeforms is the fact that the theory of evolution needs hundreds of thousands to millions of years to split species apart so far they cannot interbreed any more and become different forms.

This is false as polyploid speciation has been observed in two generations. The biggest hurdle to creotards is evolution is contrary to what the bible says and god is not necessary to direct things.
 
Does that mean humans evolved from apes?

Yes, from other human (genus Homo) and non-human apes, all of which, along with our fellow apes of non-Homo/Austral lineage evolved from a common ape ancestor.

As far as the stupid YEC non-conundrum goes, I realize it's a pain in the butt to give an answer longer than a pithy quip, but sometimes you have to work to explain a complex idea.
 
Yes, from other human (genus Homo) and non-human apes, all of which, along with our fellow apes of non-Homo/Austral lineage evolved from a common ape ancestor.

As far as the stupid YEC non-conundrum goes, I realize it's a pain in the butt to give an answer longer than a pithy quip, but sometimes you have to work to explain a complex idea.
Humans did not evolve from the apes still in existence which is what I was saying if anyone cares to read the exchange in this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom