YEC's and Evolution

There's a big difference between saying "You should believe X because Sam Bowring said so", and "You should believe X because of this paper that Sam Bowring presented that shows X". The first is an argument from authority; the second is not. The second is good evidence if the paper shows X or presents evidence regarding X.

Both are, in fact, arguments from authority; you note correctly that they are, however, different forms of that argument.

"Because Sam Browning said so," is, indeed, the fallacious form of the arguement from authority.

Assuming certain conditions, "this paper published by Sam Brown shows X," is a valid argument from authority. You are still being asked to accept the conclusions presented in the paper based on Sam Brown's authority.

The difference is that evidence has now been presented that Sam Brown is an expert on X, as determined by the fact that has presented replicable work for review by peers in his field some of whom may also be experts on X, and in their expert assessments they found his presentation sufficiently convincing to approve it for publication and dissemination.

Again, we got derailed when someone asked me why I don't accept evolution simply because the scientists believe it.

Who has honestly asked you to do that?

What has been asked is why you don't accept the collective assessment of the vast majority of acknowledged experts in the field, who upon exhaustive examination of repeated formal observation and controlled replicated expeirments, spanning in some cases anywhere from decades to a century and a half, have concluded that evolution is indeed a valid theory which has withstood the rigors of scientific testing, and furthermore continues produce useful and testable predictions?

Of course they haven't necessarily said it in so many words, because it takes too damned long to type. But even so... :wide-eyed
 
...FWIW, I'm not a YEC and never was; I just don't have a complete picture of evolution myself (it wasn't in my educational track, specifically), and I'm interested in the subject. It has recently also come up in family discussions (my father has suddenly decided that the Bible is literally true), and I need the ammunition to discuss it reasonably. Thank you for helping out.
If you have not already read it, I'd thoroughly recommend Richard Dawkins' "The Blind Watchmaker". It is a very accessible book and clearly conveys the theory and facts behind the process of evolution.

Oh, and for interest sake, read Charles Darwin's "The Voyage of the Beagle", and then "On the Origin of Species". It is actually very interesting to read his original take on the theory and you also become familiar with the root of the theory. You will be then well armed to counter the widely held misconceptions about the theory that seem to be perpetuated by lazy journalism, not just religious bias.

The most common is the misunderstanding of "survival of the fittest".

All of his major works are available free from Project Gutenberg.
Link to Darwin's works: http://www.gutenberg.org/browse/authors/d#a485
 
Last edited:
While we are still going over the argument from authority line I would like to just clarify again that my argument was never 'thousands of people believe this so you should too' that was just Avalon's convenient twist of interpretation.

My point was that 'thousands of people have studied this carefully and come to this conclusion which seems like a pretty robust approach. Given this, remind me again WHY you don't accept this evidence and why you feel they were wrong?'

At no point was Avalon told to believe anything he was asked why he thought they were wrong and whether that was a justfiable position to take given that he wasn't actually able to point out anywhere where he believed the evidence was incorrect or the conclusions were wrong.

His entire argument was that he refused to accept the findings of scientists because.. well, because he refuses to accept them. He wasn't ever able to articulate a sound objection, or even to specify what evidence he would accept.

I was quite prepared to engage with him and discuss his viewpoint but its quite clear he did not have an honest intention to do the same.

The whole argument here is that he doesn't believe in evolution because he doesn't want to and he does believe in God because he wants to. What else is there to discuss? He's happy with his delusion.
 
Wha... you mean I'm wasting 3 hrs a week in the gym? Damn...
I played in a band in my youth. Our drummer was a bodybuilder and a cleanliness freak and germ paranoic. He ate healthily, worked out, obsessed about bowel movements.

I, on the other hand, did no exercise, drank like a fish, smoked like a chimney and generally lived the rock-star life (without the cash, unfortunately).

One cigarette and half a glass of beer would total our drummer, whereas I could go for days on that diet alone!

He might have been fitter, but I was tougher...;)
 
I'll repeat my question to AvalonXQ.Why you accept the bible as an authority,with no evidence?
 
Forgive me while I delve into the land of analogy. I'll be using language for this example.

A change from Classical Latin to modern French would be a drastic change. But nobody claims that Classical Lating changed immediately into modern French. Classical Latin evolved into Vulgar Latin through a few minor changes. Vulgar Latin evolved into Old French through a few minor changes. Old French evolved into Middle French through a few minor changes. Middle French evolved into Modern French through a few minor changes.

Simultaneously, Vulgar Latin evolved into Old Spanish, then Medieval Spanish, then modern Spanish.

Could Classical Latin evolve, in only a few generations, into Modern French or Modern Spanish? No. Can Modern French evolve into Modern Spanish, or vice versa? No. But nobody doubts that Modern French, Modern Spanish, Modern Portuguese, Modern Italian, and Modern Romanian, among others, evolved from Classical Latin.

Does that analogy make sense? Do you see how it applies, crudely, to biological evolution?
While I enjoyed that particular progression, I think it's worth pointing out that languages other than latin (with roots in differing lingual patterns) were in the petri dish with Latin (Germanic and Frankish lingo, as well IIRC as some Celtic strains) and thus significantly influenced how Latin in one strand became French, while in another it became Italian, in another Spanish, in another Romanian.

I didn't see you tying the organisms cross influencing each other in the analogy or not as you presented this, but I may have missed a detail there.

DR
 
It was just an analogy. It works better for microorganisms that undergo horizontal gene transfer, which would be analogous to languages, even unrelated ones, influencing each other. But the analogy only works at a very superficial level, when explaining why a dog wouldn't evolve into a cow.
 
not exactly a very honorable way to sneak out of a debate...
16 vs 1 isn't a debate, it's a dogpile. I noted four posters whose tone was deliberately nasty, and many more posters who were very helpful in tone. The difference is blatantly obvious to a disinterested observer.

DR
 
It was just an analogy. It works better for microorganisms that undergo horizontal gene transfer, which would be analogous to languages, even unrelated ones, influencing each other. But the analogy only works at a very superficial level, when explaining why a dog wouldn't evolve into a cow.
Thanks, dave. :) Would the lingual analogue be that Japanese wouldn't evolve into Basque? :confused: Different zones of the shrub?
 
Thanks, dave. :) Would the lingual analogue be that Japanese wouldn't evolve into Basque? :confused: Different zones of the shrub?

Or to use a real example of more closely related languages: despite the huge impact Norman French had on the English language, Old English did not evolve into French or a dialect of French. It evolved into Middle English and then Modern English. It remained English and structurally Germanic.
 
If you have not already read it, I'd thoroughly recommend Richard Dawkins' "The Blind Watchmaker". It is a very accessible book and clearly conveys the theory and facts behind the process of evolution.

Oh, and for interest sake, read Charles Darwin's "The Voyage of the Beagle", and then "On the Origin of Species". It is actually very interesting to read his original take on the theory and you also become familiar with the root of the theory. You will be then well armed to counter the widely held misconceptions about the theory that seem to be perpetuated by lazy journalism, not just religious bias.

The most common is the misunderstanding of "survival of the fittest".

All of his major works are available free from Project Gutenberg.
Link to Darwin's works: http://www.gutenberg.org/browse/authors/d#a485

Thank you so much for the references! I can't afford the Dawkins book right now; I'll see if the library has it. Yes, it makes perfect sense to read the original author's work. I know Darwin's work has been improved upon over the years; would the Dawkins book tell me about the modifications/clarifications, or is there another source?

I see a whole bunch of "versions" on the Project Gutenberg site (and a THOUSAND THANKS for that wonderful link!!). Many have different subtitles. Which should I start with?
 
16 vs 1 isn't a debate, it's a dogpile.

Why would that be? As long as those 16 remain honest during the debate, I don't see any problem. Guess who was dishonest all along? I'll give you a hint: it was someone from the minority...

I noted four posters whose tone was deliberately nasty, and many more posters who were very helpful in tone. The difference is blatantly obvious to a disinterested observer.

Niceness is not a requirement of a debate. It is desirable, I agree, but just because someone isn't nice that doesn't make a "dogpile" out of a debate. Furthermore, why should anyone expect niceness after showing utter dishonesty in their debating method?

On a funnier note, how would anything be blatantly obvious to a disinterested observer? Why would someone observe if there is no interest on his part? :rolleyes:
 
It is very difficult to debate when you are trying to face 16 or more people at once. Now some people may have been nasty, and I don't think that Avalon has earned it yet. The only sort of YEC that will face these sort of odds is also usually the sort that does deserve nastiness. Avalon seems to be fairly intelligent and a proper debate may change his mind. He does not seem to be as brain dead as the YEC in prison whose name slips my poor brain right now.
 
Kent Hovind ?

From what I have heard of his material, even YEC would have a hard time taking him seriously.
 
Kent Hovind ?

From what I have heard of his material, even YEC would have a hard time taking him seriously.

Yes, thank you. Kent is good for a laugh or two, but after a while he is tiresome. It is interesting to see how in the year or so before his imprisonment he started to try to use the term "theory" correctly when applied to creationism. He still did not get it right, but at least he tried.
 
On a funnier note, how would anything be blatantly obvious to a disinterested observer? Why would someone observe if there is no interest on his part? :rolleyes:

I don't think the word "disinterested" means what you think it does.

It's not a synonym for "uninterested."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom