Dr H
Muse
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2004
- Messages
- 835
There's a big difference between saying "You should believe X because Sam Bowring said so", and "You should believe X because of this paper that Sam Bowring presented that shows X". The first is an argument from authority; the second is not. The second is good evidence if the paper shows X or presents evidence regarding X.
Both are, in fact, arguments from authority; you note correctly that they are, however, different forms of that argument.
"Because Sam Browning said so," is, indeed, the fallacious form of the arguement from authority.
Assuming certain conditions, "this paper published by Sam Brown shows X," is a valid argument from authority. You are still being asked to accept the conclusions presented in the paper based on Sam Brown's authority.
The difference is that evidence has now been presented that Sam Brown is an expert on X, as determined by the fact that has presented replicable work for review by peers in his field some of whom may also be experts on X, and in their expert assessments they found his presentation sufficiently convincing to approve it for publication and dissemination.
Again, we got derailed when someone asked me why I don't accept evolution simply because the scientists believe it.
Who has honestly asked you to do that?
What has been asked is why you don't accept the collective assessment of the vast majority of acknowledged experts in the field, who upon exhaustive examination of repeated formal observation and controlled replicated expeirments, spanning in some cases anywhere from decades to a century and a half, have concluded that evolution is indeed a valid theory which has withstood the rigors of scientific testing, and furthermore continues produce useful and testable predictions?
Of course they haven't necessarily said it in so many words, because it takes too damned long to type. But even so...
