YEC's and Evolution

I asked Simon that because he said humans are classified as apes. Just because they are classified as apes does not mean they are evolved from apes as apes are still living. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes. Just as birds evolved from certain dinosaurs which are now extinct the common ancestor humans and apes both evolved from is also extinct. I find it utterly hilarious that supposed critical thinkers are so brain-addled when it comes to evolution.

Oh, newb's got tewd.

As H' pointed out, it's not that black and white. We did not evolve from any existing species but we share every other characteristic of the hominoidea clade. That means our common ancestor with chimps was something that could only be referred to as an ape. The same applies to our common ancestor with gorillas, with orangutans and with gibbons. We didn't evolve seperately from our fellow apes. We are apes that evolved - along with our living and extinct cousins - from an Ur-ape common ancestor.

The biggest hurdle to creotards is evolution is contrary to what the bible says and god is not necessary to direct things.

And I'm sure treating them with that ***** attitude helps. :rolleyes:

Humans did not evolve from the apes still in existence which is what I was saying if anyone cares to read the exchange in this thread.

I did, and as I showed just above you're trying to make your answer as simple as the Creationists "question". I was just pointing out that it takes more than a quip to explain what really happened/is happening to them.
 
This is false as polyploid speciation has been observed in two generations. The biggest hurdle to creotards is evolution is contrary to what the bible says and god is not necessary to direct things.

Really? Fascinating, I'd appreciate it if you could post/pm the link to that.

However, it only alters the bar a YEC would need to set. I suspect the counter will be along the lines of 'but the species still LOOK the same' or 'You need to show you can get a cow from a dog' or something similar. After all, the evidence supporting the theory of evolution is overwhelming, solid and has been proven reliable and self supporting with each new discovery or scientific branch opening up in the field. And yet a YEC discards all of it because of their faith. I doubt any new discovery will ever convince them because most or all of the major discoveries have been done, its just refinement at the moment.
 
Really? Fascinating, I'd appreciate it if you could post/pm the link to that.

However, it only alters the bar a YEC would need to set. I suspect the counter will be along the lines of 'but the species still LOOK the same' or 'You need to show you can get a cow from a dog' or something similar. After all, the evidence supporting the theory of evolution is overwhelming, solid and has been proven reliable and self supporting with each new discovery or scientific branch opening up in the field. And yet a YEC discards all of it because of their faith. I doubt any new discovery will ever convince them because most or all of the major discoveries have been done, its just refinement at the moment.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyploidy

But I doubt that creotards would count plants that speciate as life.
 
Apes have not evolved into humans for the simple reason humans didn't evolve from apes. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes.

Humans are classified as apes, though.

Does that mean humans evolved from apes?
Yes, it does. Your question is as silly as asking "Does that mean humans evolved from mammals?" We did.

Read the question Cainkane asked. He said WHY ARE THERE STILL APES. That doesn't say WHY ARE THERE STILL 'OLDER' APES but why there are still apes meaning the apes we know....modern apes.....does anyone read?
Everyone here reads. Some take the extra step of understanding what they read.

There is no more justification for inserting the word "modern" in the original question than there is for inserting the word "older". There is no reason to add either qualifier, since we are still apes.

The problem is that the word "ape" is ambiguous. Some use it to mean all species in the superfamily Hominoidea, and in that sense we not only evolved from apes, we are still apes. Others use it to mean only non-human species, and in that sense, while we evolved from apes (the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees was also an ape), we are now considered "something else."

Because of that ambiguity, most scientists prefer to use the term Hominoidea rather than ape.

I asked Simon that because he said humans are classified as apes. Just because they are classified as apes does not mean they are evolved from apes as apes are still living.
Mammals are still living. Eukaryotes are still living. Both our ancestors and we ourselves belong to both groups. We evolved from mammals. We evolved from eukaryotes. We evolved from apes.

Humans did not evolve from the apes still in existence which is what I was saying if anyone cares to read the exchange in this thread.
That may have been what you intended to say, but that's not what you said. You made the unqualified statement "Humans didn't evolve from apes."

I find it utterly hilarious that supposed critical thinkers are so brain-addled when it comes to evolution.
At least you're keeping yourself amused.
 
We are apes that evolved - along with our living and extinct cousins - from an Ur-ape common ancestor.

This is correct - mentioning our extinct cousins reminded me of a logical trap i (and many others) often fall into, when discussing the now gone common ancestor:

I think it's misleading to say that our common ancestor is now extinct. It's obviously not, as we're still here.

More correct way is to say the common ancestor has evolved to us and other apes, and none of it's current descendants are classified as the same species it once was.

The common ancestor is no more, but it's not extinct.
 
Humans did not evolve from the apes still in existence which is what I was saying if anyone cares to read the exchange in this thread.
Well, you may have meant to say that, and I got that pretty quickly, but what you actually said was this:

Apes have not evolved into humans for the simple reason humans didn't evolve from apes. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes.

and
Does that mean humans evolved from apes?
This is why you were misunderstood. You can see that, can't you?
 
Last edited:
It's disappointing, but not surprising, that the necro'd thread would go from a decent conceptual starting point to worthless bickering in less than two pages.
You guys can't even stay civil to each other in these threads; what possible incentive do I have to contribute?

Halsu: thanks for your explanations, which are reasonably cogent but don't really offer anything new to my understanding of evolutionary theory. As I've tried to express from the OP, I think I understand the theory and the arguments reasonably well (although it was nice to get some criticism of my understanding of the particulars). I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.
 
...
You guys can't even stay civil to each other in these threads; what possible incentive do I have to contribute?

There is a little triangle button with a [!] in it which will enable you to report "incivility" to the mods. You might want to use it with caution though, since abusing the reporting feature is against the rules.:)
 
There is a little triangle button with a [!] in it which will enable you to report "incivility" to the mods. You might want to use it with caution though, since abusing the reporting feature is against the rules.:)

Is it against the rules to abuse the rule against abusing the rule against incivility? :)
 
I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.

Ok - could you elaborate: if you specify which of those factual claims lack proof, i might be able to help you find the evidence?

In other words, is there any specific part of the explanation of common ancestry you find unconvincing?

Or is it more about the whole explanation, the whole body of evidence in general?
 
Is it against the rules to abuse the rule against abusing the rule against incivility? :)

I don't make the rules. Part of the outcome of participating in an honest forum is bound to be a bit irritating to those with strongly held beliefs, but accusations of incivility should be made with great care. Otherwise, one can look like a crybaby, and his arguments may appear vacuous as a result.

You have been treated with respect, in my opinion, since you complained that you were treated with incivility. Now to criticize other posters for being uncivil with each other, and not having the strength of your convictions to report it seems a bit disingenuous. It gives the appearance of your trying to find a face saving way out of something you never wanted to get involved with.
 
It's disappointing, but not surprising, that the necro'd thread would go from a decent conceptual starting point to worthless bickering in less than two pages.
You guys can't even stay civil to each other in these threads; what possible incentive do I have to contribute?

Halsu: thanks for your explanations, which are reasonably cogent but don't really offer anything new to my understanding of evolutionary theory. As I've tried to express from the OP, I think I understand the theory and the arguments reasonably well (although it was nice to get some criticism of my understanding of the particulars). I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.

There are some people here with abrasive styles, but don't let them distract you. As you well know, you can simply ignore bickering and keep focussed on the subject. For example, there's no need to respond to my post.
 
It's disappointing, but not surprising, that the necro'd thread would go from a decent conceptual starting point to worthless bickering in less than two pages.
You guys can't even stay civil to each other in these threads; what possible incentive do I have to contribute?

Halsu: thanks for your explanations, which are reasonably cogent but don't really offer anything new to my understanding of evolutionary theory. As I've tried to express from the OP, I think I understand the theory and the arguments reasonably well (although it was nice to get some criticism of my understanding of the particulars). I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.
I hope you don't find me uncivil when I say you have fairly thin skin.

Also, I would hope you have read some of the papers presented to you, in the past 9 months. Do you still find it unconvincing when scientists say: "This rock is 2 billion years old"? If so, what aspect of the evidence is unconvincing?
 
That is an incorrect use of the term extinct.

Could you elaborate?

Our ancestors never faced an extinction event, they're pseudoextinct rather than extinct:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudoextinction

The funny thing is, even though our ancestors were a different species from us in our taxonomy, there's no exact point when the change of species happened. There's no specific generation where the parents are the ancestor species, but the children are human. The children are always the same species as the parents.
 
Last edited:
Just read through the whole thread. I remember participating in a similar thread with AvalonXQ about 6 months ago, and the outcome was similar: he's a tone troll.

It all boils down to him being able (or not) to answer the simple question that others have posed many times in this thread: do you understand (not BELIEVE) that there is overwhelming evidence that some rocks are billions of years old?
 
And, worth a separate post: all those beautiful images from Hubble and Chandra that illustrate that the universe is billions of years old. Does AvalonXQ imagine that astronomers are part of some vast conspiracy that spends all their time making this stuff up for perverse kicks or something?

To be a YEC is to deny a substantial portion of reality, and is also a failure to appreciate that unspeakable beauty can occur naturally. To think that what passes for humanity on this mere speck of a planet, amidst the billions upon billions of planets that are certainly extant, is the only intelligent species out there... is the ultimate in hubris.
 
And, worth a separate post: all those beautiful images from Hubble and Chandra that illustrate that the universe is billions of years old. Does AvalonXQ imagine that astronomers are part of some vast conspiracy that spends all their time making this stuff up for perverse kicks or something?
No no no no no. The universe just LOOKS like it's billions of years old. God is messing with us, just like with the dinosaurs.
Bill Hicks said:
Get this, I actually asked one of these guys, OK, Dinosaurs fossils - how does that fit into you scheme of life? Let me sit down and strap in. He said, "Dinosaur fossils? God put those there to test our faith." Thank God I'm strapped in right now here man. I think God put you here to test my faith, Dude. You believe that? "uh huh." Does that trouble anyone here? The idea that God.. might be.. ****in' with our heads? I have trouble sleeping with that knowledge. Some prankster God running around: "Hu hu ho. We will see who believes in me now, ha ha." [mimes God burying fossils] "I am God, I am a prankster." "I am killing Me." You know, You die and go to St. Peter... "Did you believe in dinosaurs?" "Well, yeah. There was fossils everywhere" Thuh [trapdoor opens] "Aaaaaaarhhh!" "You ****in idiot." "Flying lizards, you're a moron. God was ****in' with you!" "It seemed so plausible, ahhhh!" "Enjoy the lake of fire, ****er!"
 
And, worth a separate post: all those beautiful images from Hubble and Chandra that illustrate that the universe is billions of years old. Does AvalonXQ imagine that astronomers are part of some vast conspiracy that spends all their time making this stuff up for perverse kicks or something?

To be a YEC is to deny a substantial portion of reality, and is also a failure to appreciate that unspeakable beauty can occur naturally. To think that what passes for humanity on this mere speck of a planet, amidst the billions upon billions of planets that are certainly extant, is the only intelligent species out there... is the ultimate in hubris.

Gawd did it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom