YEC's and Evolution

I don't think the word "disinterested" means what you think it does.

It's not a synonym for "uninterested."

I think it is. Sometimes.

usage Disinterested and uninterested have a tangled history. Uninterested originally meant impartial, but this sense fell into disuse during the 18th century. About the same time the original sense of disinterested also disappeared, with uninterested developing a new sense—the present meaning—to take its place. The original sense of uninterested is still out of use, but the original sense of disinterested revived in the early 20th century. The revival has since been under frequent attack as an illiteracy and a blurring or loss of a useful distinction. Actual usage shows otherwise. Sense 2 of disinterested is still its most frequent sense, especially in edited prose; it shows no sign of vanishing. A careful writer may choose sense 1a of disinterested in preference to uninterested for emphasis <teaching the letters of the alphabet to her wiggling and supremely disinterested little daughter — C. L. Sulzberger>. Further, disinterested has developed a sense (1b), perhaps influenced by sense 1 of the prefix dis-, that contrasts with uninterested <when I grow tired or disinterested in anything, I experience a disgust — Jack London (letter, 1914)>. Still, use of senses 1a and 1b will incur the disapproval of some who may not fully appreciate the history of this word or the subtleties of its present use.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disinterested
 
1) I haven't seen persuasive evidence that this is an accurate account of life on Earth.
2) In the absence of persuasive evidence, I accept the teachings of the Bible, which contradict the theory.

I don't know if anyone mentioned this to you in this thread or not yet, but depending on how one chooses to subjectively "interpret" the Bible, the theory of evolution doesn't necessarily conflict with anything. "Catholics" tend to embrace the theory of evolution.

FYI, your definition of the theory looked pretty good to me.
 
16 vs 1 isn't a debate, it's a dogpile. I noted four posters whose tone was deliberately nasty, and many more posters who were very helpful in tone. The difference is blatantly obvious to a disinterested observer.

DR

I fail to see how the number of posters has any bearing on anything. I would be happy to be the only person of reason having a discussion with 100s of YECs at the same time. All that matters is the evidence, not the number or posters.

It's near impossible to get him or her to discuss the actual evidence at hand or anything other than the thread itself (as opposed to the topic), which is the cause of the complaints. If someone was genuine, they would ignore all of the post that aren't about the topic (like this one) and focus on the evidence. Instead of doing the opposite as Avalon is doing. If this wasn't the case we wouldn't be having these discussions about the thread itself. But with an almost complete lack of discussion on the actual topic, there is little else to cover.
 
Hello world - awaking an old thread...

AvalonXQ:

I think it might be wise to concentrate on one issue at a time. As it seems that the latest stumbling block was the perceived difference between so called "Micro" and "Macro" Evolution, let's start there. I will attempt to explain why the two are the same thing, the only difference is that of magnitude - time, or the number of generations.

There was a question about dogs turning into cows. This is theoretically possible, but extremely unlikely.

Evolution doesn't have a direction, it picks the road to take semi-randomly at each junction - in every generation. Usually this changes the direction only slightly, almost unnoticeably, but these small changes in direction accumulate over time. Usually evolution from two slightly different roads merges again to form a yet new direction (different dog breeds can have offspring). Sometimes it splits and goes to two different directions, in other words branches (i guess the difference between some dog breeds is so big that they couldn't have offspring, at least without artifical semination, so they could actually be called different species).

Natural selection works like the width of the road - some of these randomly chosen roads are wide and good to travel on, sometimes they are narrow or come to a dead end, extinction. It "guides" the evolution, as in making it likely to take better roads, but it doesn't guide it to any specific direction.

If you think about the common ancestor of dogs and cows, that branch of evolution split to separate roads tens of millions of years ago. There have been millions of generations, millions of small changes of direction. The roads have lead to two rather different locations, "dog" and "cow".

The evolution of "dogs" and "cows" has not stopped: they still go on, getting to a junction every generation. As the evolution does not have a predetermined direction or a reverse gear, it is extremely unlikely that "dog" will ever end up taking the *exact* right one way good roads and end up to the *exact* location called "cow".

It is likely though, that if the "dog" survives millions of generations, the resulting species, none of which is any longer "dog", will be as different as today's actual dogs and cows are. Same goes with "cows" - in millions of generations, assuming no extinction, "cows" will evolve to multiple new species, which can be as different as today's cows and dogs are.

Another thing to consider is the difference between dog breeds - as you know, it's quite big, yet it's accumulated over a very short period of time, just a few thousand years at best. Now, multiply that variation by a million, and think how big the difference would be?
 
Last edited:
Hello world - awaking an old thread...

AvalonXQ:

I think it might be wise to concentrate on one issue at a time. As it seems that the latest stumbling block was the perceived difference between so called "Micro" and "Macro" Evolution, let's start there. I will attempt to explain why the two are the same thing, the only difference is that of magnitude - time, or the number of generations.

There was a question about dogs turning into cows. This is theoretically possible, but extremely unlikely.

Evolution doesn't have a direction, it picks the road to take semi-randomly at each junction - in every generation. Usually this changes the direction only slightly, almost unnoticeably, but these small changes in direction accumulate over time. Usually evolution from two slightly different roads merges again to form a yet new direction (different dog breeds can have offspring). Sometimes it splits and goes to two different directions, in other words branches (i guess the difference between some dog breeds is so big that they couldn't have offspring, at least without artifical semination, so they could actually be called different species).

Natural selection works like the width of the road - some of these randomly chosen roads are wide and good to travel on, sometimes they are narrow or come to a dead end, extinction. It "guides" the evolution, as in making it likely to take better roads, but it doesn't guide it to any specific direction.

If you think about the common ancestor of dogs and cows, that branch of evolution split to separate roads tens of millions of years ago. There have been millions of generations, millions of small changes of direction. The roads have lead to two rather different locations, "dog" and "cow".

The evolution of "dogs" and "cows" has not stopped: they still go on, getting to a junction every generation. As the evolution does not have a predetermined direction or a reverse gear, it is extremely unlikely that "dog" will ever end up taking the *exact* right one way good roads and end up to the *exact* location called "cow".

It is likely though, that if the "dog" survives millions of generations, the resulting species, none of which is any longer "dog", will be as different as today's actual dogs and cows are. Same goes with "cows" - in millions of generations, assuming no extinction, "cows" will evolve to multiple new species, which can be as different as today's cows and dogs are.

Another thing to consider is the difference between dog breeds - as you know, it's quite big, yet it's accumulated over a very short period of time, just a few thousand years at best. Now, multiply that variation by a million, and think how big the difference would be?
Very good.
 
When I try to explain evolution and when I am asked question as to why apes still exist and haven't evolved into humans I use the term "genetic dice" that is DNA seldom if ever follows the same path. However Halsu explained it better than I ever could.
 
Thanks dude -

I'll continue the same metaphor with the evidence for evolution...

If we have a theory that evolution works like the roads i described earlier, we can make some predictions about dogs and cows:

A) The individual members of pre "dog" and "cow" species have died along the journey, and we should find their bones along the roads.
B) Both species should have some common stuff on them, as well as gathered some differing stuff along the way.
C) There should be species that are different, but similar to dogs and cows, as the results of other forks in the road that did not lead to "cow" or to "dog".

How well these predictions are met?

The answer to A) is obvious: the fossil record. I do not know how good the real record is for actual dogs and cows, but i'm pretty sure there are examples of both some common ancestors (maybe far earlier along the road, ages before the two lines split), as well as some examples further down the road (intermediates between the common ancestor and dogs, as well as intermediates between the common ancestor and cows). Note however, that there are not, and are not supposed to be intermediates between dogs and cows. Those do not exist, those shouldn't exist: that's empty space between the forked roads.

As far as B) goes, you probably guessed that i refer to the DNA. Again, the findings suit the prediction: there is some common DNA (stuff that the common ancestor was made of) as well as DNA that was gathered along the separate ways to doghood and cowhood (dust from the desert "cow" road crossed, mud from the swamp along the road to "dog").

Let's look at C): This is equally obvious: both dogs and cows have relative species, of varying distances from dog and cow, depending on how far along the road the lines forked. Their fossil trail and DNA differences match the forking roads theory's predictions perfectly.
 
Last edited:
When I try to explain evolution and when I am asked question as to why apes still exist and haven't evolved into humans I use the term "genetic dice" that is DNA seldom if ever follows the same path. However Halsu explained it better than I ever could.
When you are born, why do your cousins still exist and not evolve into you or die out?
 
When I try to explain evolution and when I am asked question as to why apes still exist and haven't evolved into humans I use the term "genetic dice" that is DNA seldom if ever follows the same path. However Halsu explained it better than I ever could.

Apes have not evolved into humans for the simple reason humans didn't evolve from apes. Humans evolved from a common ancestor with apes.
 
Hello world - awaking an old thread...
AvalonXQ:
I think it might be wise to concentrate on one issue at a time. As it seems that the latest stumbling block was the perceived difference between so called "Micro" and "Macro" Evolution, let's start there. I will attempt to explain why the two are the same thing, the only difference is that of magnitude - time, or the number of generations.
There was a question about dogs turning into cows. This is theoretically possible, but extremely unlikely.
Evolution doesn't have a direction, it picks the road to take semi-randomly at each junction - in every generation. Usually this changes the direction only slightly, almost unnoticeably, but these small changes in direction accumulate over time. Usually evolution from two slightly different roads merges again to form a yet new direction (different dog breeds can have offspring). Sometimes it splits and goes to two different directions, in other words branches (i guess the difference between some dog breeds is so big that they couldn't have offspring, at least without artifical semination, so they could actually be called different species).
Natural selection works like the width of the road - some of these randomly chosen roads are wide and good to travel on, sometimes they are narrow or come to a dead end, extinction. It "guides" the evolution, as in making it likely to take better roads, but it doesn't guide it to any specific direction.
If you think about the common ancestor of dogs and cows, that branch of evolution split to separate roads tens of millions of years ago. There have been millions of generations, millions of small changes of direction. The roads have lead to two rather different locations, "dog" and "cow".
The evolution of "dogs" and "cows" has not stopped: they still go on, getting to a junction every generation. As the evolution does not have a predetermined direction or a reverse gear, it is extremely unlikely that "dog" will ever end up taking the *exact* right one way good roads and end up to the *exact* location called "cow".
It is likely though, that if the "dog" survives millions of generations, the resulting species, none of which is any longer "dog", will be as different as today's actual dogs and cows are. Same goes with "cows" - in millions of generations, assuming no extinction, "cows" will evolve to multiple new species, which can be as different as today's cows and dogs are.
Another thing to consider is the difference between dog breeds - as you know, it's quite big, yet it's accumulated over a very short period of time, just a few thousand years at best. Now, multiply that variation by a million, and think how big the difference would be?


I would also like to point out, as I did in the other threads, that many, many, many genes are common between dogs and cows.
There are differences between the specific sequences and some of the genes are, in fact, unique but the vast majority of them are, in fact, common between the two species...
 
Does that mean humans evolved from apes?
This question often comes up, and it's just a silly semantics question. Yes, humans evolved from apes; not the apes alive today, but certainly an animal that would be unequivocally classified as an ape. And, since we are ourselves classified as a species of ape, the question becomes even more pointless.

Also, as a former lurker on this thread, I'd like to know if AvalonXQ has read his literature already, and whether (s)he still thinks the earth is less than 10000 years old.
And if so, what was wrong with the papers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom