YEC's and Evolution

No no no no no. The universe just LOOKS like it's billions of years old. God is messing with us, just like with the dinosaurs.

Of course, Sledge has to screw it all up for everyone. Now, I can just imagine god asking:

Did you believe in dinosaurs?" "Well, yeah. There was fossils everywhere" Thuh [trapdoor opens] "Aaaaaaarhhh!" "You ****in idiot."
and me saying "Well, no, I heard from our creation scientists you were just messing with us, planting bones to test our faith!".

God: Oh, so you were believing sciency facts, not on pure faith, eh! [THUH, trap door opens]
 
This is correct - mentioning our extinct cousins reminded me of a logical trap i (and many others) often fall into, when discussing the now gone common ancestor:

I think it's misleading to say that our common ancestor is now extinct. It's obviously not, as we're still here.

More correct way is to say the common ancestor has evolved to us and other apes, and none of it's current descendants are classified as the same species it once was.

The common ancestor is no more, but it's not extinct.

Since most Creationists I deal with have a hard enough understanding the concept of common ancestry this wasn't an issue that's come up for me before. I like the poetry of how your phrase it, but I wonder if it might leave some wiggle room for our opponents. Maybe we could add a parenthetical (the CA species might be, but it's decendant species are not).

Hmmm, it's such a shame we have to worry about sematics so much when dealing with Creationists.
 
Since most Creationists I deal with have a hard enough understanding the concept of common ancestry this wasn't an issue that's come up for me before. I like the poetry of how your phrase it, but I wonder if it might leave some wiggle room for our opponents. Maybe we could add a parenthetical (the CA species might be, but it's decendant species are not).

Hmmm, it's such a shame we have to worry about sematics so much when dealing with Creationists.

I'm not the first one to think about it, it seems - i found the below link when i did a bit of Google-aided research ;-)

Our ancestors never faced an extinction event, they're pseudoextinct rather than extinct:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudoextinction
 
I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.


Excellent, keep us posted, I'm sure many reasonable posters / lurkers are interested in your progress.

And nevermind the other stuff, it's internet, **** happens. Just concentrate on the evidence and what you think about it.
 
Excellent, keep us posted, I'm sure many reasonable posters / lurkers are interested in your progress.

And nevermind the other stuff, it's internet, **** happens. Just concentrate on the evidence and what you think about it.

Ah, but there's 'prior art' with this one. All he needs to do is read something like Dawkins' Greatest Show on Earth or Jerry Coyne's Why Evolution Is True, which is actually even more accessible. This has been suggested to him on other threads. Heck, even if he agreed to read up a bit on radiometric dating, that would get him over the YE part of the YEC.

But... he won't. Slap me in the face with a wet mackerel if I'm wrong.
 
...All he needs to do is read something like Dawkins' Greatest Show on Earth or Jerry Coyne's Why Evolution Is True, which is actually even more accessible. This has been suggested to him on other threads. Heck, even if he agreed to read up a bit on radiometric dating, that would get him over the YE part of the YEC.

But... he won't. Slap me in the face with a wet mackerel if I'm wrong.


I will :)
 
Specific question: have their been any blinded tests of isochron dating?
Example:
1) Geologist A selects samples, judged to be uncontaminated, from various rock strata from the Grand Canyon. The samples are carefully recorded and randomly labeled. Geologist A records an estimate of how old each sample should be.
2) Geologist B, without direct communication with Geologist A and no information other than the random labels, dates the sample set.
3) ???
4) Profit
Has this ever happened? I've done a bit of Googling but having found anything.
 
Last edited:
Specific question: have their been any blinded tests of isochron dating?
Example:
1) Geologist A selects samples, judged to be uncontaminated, from various rock strata from the Grand Canyon. The samples are carefully recorded and randomly labeled. Geologist A records an estimate of how old each sample should be.
2) Geologist B, without direct communication with Geologist A and no information other than the random labels, dates the sample set.
3) ???
4) Profit
Has this ever happened? I've done a bit of Googling but having found anything.

It *might* have been done, but double blind tests are usually needed in area's where there is a specific worry about confirmation bias about subjective results (are you feeling 'better'?)
Whereas there is no profit to be made from radio-dating anything, so its unlikely that people would generate false data, and the data are generated using machines and numbers which won't subjectively alter their data.
Furthermore, the data are presented in papers, where anyone can study them and decide wether they agree with the contamination in the rock and the way the raw data is manipulated, so if anyone disagree's they can take their own sample and re-analyze it.

This is actually happening, there have been several papers recently that adjusted the age of the earth based on new findings. But these were alterations of several millions of years, which is nothing on the several billion consitently found.

The only way to reconcile YEC with radio dating is either assuming that the natural laws changed dramatically to allow decay to happen infinetely faster or different up until recently, or that the earth was created to *look* billions of years old, or assume that there is a massive world-wide conspiracy to lie about the age of the earth.
 
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.
I was curious as to whether a blind test had been done to demonstrate the ability of radiometric dating standing on its own.

Oh, and correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the "double" in double-blind usually refers to the patient and the treating physician, and so the term really doesn't fit this situation since the "patient" is an inanimate object. Maybe the "double" refers to something else in this case that I'm not seeing.
 
Last edited:
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.
I was curious as to whether a blind test had been done to demonstrate the ability of radiometric dating standing on its own.

It looks like the fundamentals of the dating have nothing to do with basing it on ages of other rocks, see the Wikipedia page.

And, anyway, if the dates aren't adjusted so far as to compress the entire time-span of dating to after 6000 years ago, so what?

Perhaps the YEC's should update the Wikipedia page on radiometric dating. I didn't see anything there about adjustments.
 
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.
I was curious as to whether a blind test had been done to demonstrate the ability of radiometric dating standing on its own.

It looks like the fundamentals of the dating have nothing to do with basing it on ages of other rocks, see the Wikipedia page.
AvalonXQ, I think you're misunderstanding what I believe the YECs are really arguing. Radiometric dating isn't circular, and I doubt that many would argue that it is. Radiometric dating is limited, however, as it can only be applied to igneous rocks -- rocks which resulted from volcanic activity, usually. The "melting of the rock" allows the daughter elements to escape, and starts the clock on the decay of the radioactive parent elements.

The problem is that most fossils are not found in igneous rock, but in sedimentary rock. Radiometric dating usually can't be used to date sedimentary rock directly, because the "age" obtained would be the age of the grains of sand and sediment that went into forming the rock, when what one wants is the age at which the layer of sediment was formed. I say "usually" can't be used, because Carbon 14 dating is one type of radiometric dating which can be used for relatively recent fossils in sedimentary rock. I'll ignore Carbon 14 dating for the remainder of this post.

The so-called "circularity" comes in when dating the sedimentary rocks, which contain the majority of the fossils. If the fossils in a certain location were buried by a volcanic eruption, the igneous rocks laid down by the eruption can be dated with radiometric methods. Since "rock on top" is younger than "rock underneath" in this situation, this allows scientists to say that the sedimentary rock containing the fossils of interest is older than the radiometrically-dated rock above it. If there have been several volcanic events, it may be possible to bracket the age of sedimentary rock, because it will be younger than the rock below it, but older than the rock above it.

Because volcanoes don't erupt all over the world simultaneously, it may be that the fossils in one location have been bracketed by volcanic dates, while fossils of the same organisms in another location were not. The circularity would come in because scientists might assume that the organisms in the second location probably lived at the same time period as the organisms in the first location. The age of those fossils might then be used to bracket the age of fossils at the second location which were found in other strata.

This correlation of strata (fossil) ages around the world is what is known as the "geologic column". It is not really circular, because the age of fossils in location 2 would not then be used to assign an age to the lava flows in location 1. When YECs say "circular", they generally mean the type of fossils is used to assign an age to a strata of rock, and the age of the strata is used to say how old the fossils are. That isn't really what's happening.

What's really happening is that the age of the strata at location 1 (determined by radiometric methods) is used to assign an age to the fossils at location 1. The age of those fossils can then be used to assign a (less certain) age to the strata in which similar fossils were found at location 2. If you considered only location 2, it might seem circular -- the age of the strata is determined by the type of fossils, and the age of the fossils is determined by the age of the strata -- but people who say it's circular are usually either misunderstanding (as I assume you are) or dishonest.

ETA: There is a kind of "circularity" for igneous rocks as well -- certain radiometric techniques are only valid for rocks of a certain range of ages, and using techniques which are not matched to the general age of the rocks in question can give erroneous results. Think of those maddening blog entries, which give only a month/date and a time -- "August 28, 4:30 PM". For the next few months, that timestamp can be used to accurately date the text to which it's correlated, but ten years from now, going just by the timestamp, it will be anybody's guess when that entry was written. At that point, though, the fact that it was formatted for PHPBB may still permit one to say it was not written before 1990, etc.

YECs have made much of "inaccurate" dates obtained using the wrong tool for a given job. That's dishonest too.
 
Last edited:
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.

And the of course are wrong because they have no idea about radiometric dating. Not only that but GPS shows beyond any doubt whatsoever that the continents are drifting apart at a rate of approximately 10 cm per year. If the Earth were young you could stand on the coast at Atlantic City and see Europe since it wouldn't even be a mile away. YECs are both history and science deniers and to paraphrase Jerry Coyne they are perverted.
 
And the of course are wrong because they have no idea about radiometric dating.
I don't think that's why they're wrong, and I'm certain that some of them know more about radiometric dating than you do.

Not only that but GPS shows beyond any doubt whatsoever that the continents are drifting apart at a rate of approximately 10 cm per year. If the Earth were young you could stand on the coast at Atlantic City and see Europe since it wouldn't even be a mile away.
If you assume that Atlantic City and Europe were connected 6000 years ago when the YECs believe the Earth was created, that would be true. I'm not sure how convincing this argument would be to a YEC, though, since I don't think many of them would make that assumption. They'd probably assume that Atlantic City and Europe were about as far apart 6000 years ago as they are now (and they'd be right). From their perspective, you're committing the fallacy of "begging the question".

But then, you're not trying to convince anyone, are you? You just want to
YECs are [...] perverted.

say that. Again.
 
I don't think that's why they're wrong, and I'm certain that some of them know more about radiometric dating than you do.

Well, generally, if I'd invested my life into the fact that I will go to a magical place after deaths based off my ignorance of science, I'd do pretty damn well to keep ignoring science. It's not hard once you start.
 
Well, generally, if I'd invested my life into the fact that I will go to a magical place after deaths based off my ignorance of science, I'd do pretty damn well to keep ignoring science. It's not hard once you start.
Is that why YECs don't go to doctors, don't drive cars or use computers, and prefer foot messengers to cell phones? Don't wash their hands before they eat, or brush their teeth after? Don't fertilize or water their lawns?

I think it would be pretty hard to ignore science. It might be pretty easy to ignore radiometric dating, and those who do might be wrong because they don't know anything about it.

Those who don't are probably wrong for other reasons.
 
Is that why YECs don't go to doctors, don't drive cars or use computers, and prefer foot messengers to cell phones? Don't wash their hands before they eat, or brush their teeth after? Don't fertilize or water their lawns?

I think it would be pretty hard to ignore science. It might be pretty easy to ignore radiometric dating, and those who do might be wrong because they don't know anything about it.

Those who don't are probably wrong for other reasons.

Don't be silly. They only ignore the science that poses difficult questions.
 
There's a difference between ignoring something and refusing to use things that come from it. I find internal combustion engines useful, but ignore most of the details of how they work, for example.
 
Don't be silly. They only ignore the science that poses difficult questions.

Funny how they ignore general relativity which makes the GPS confirmation of continental drift yet they gladly use GPS units in their cars. Just that the GPS in their car doesn't contradict a young Earth so it's ok.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom