Radiometric Dating II
radiometric dating is, at it's core, based upon the idea that radioactive decay of isotopes is a constant. Even this, fairly well established concept is open for debate in the scientific arena. Indeed, a recent group has challenged this assumption to some quite interesting responses. ...
See the discussion of this topic in another JREF thread:
Group measures radioactive decay rates changing with seasons - blames sun, and especially
ben_m's post #7 in that thread.
Yes, they are talking about a variation in the decay rate of ~0.002%
Radiometric dates are linear with respect to the decay rate. That means if the decay rate is uncertain at a level of ~0.002%, then so will the derived date be uncertain at a level of 0.002%. That won't get you from 4,500,000,000 years to 10,000 years. To that extent, variable decay rates are already known.
7Be decays by electron capture and it has been shown that deforming the quantum wave function of the innermost electron, by trapping the
7Be nucleus in a
C60 "Buckyball" can accelerate the decay rate by ~1% (
Ohtsuki, et al., 2004). The same group can also see decay rate changes ~1.5% for
7Be in dense environments when the temperature is dropped to ~5 Kelvins (
Ohtsuki, et al., 2007).
Now, while Beryllium is of no use in radiometric dating, the K/Ar method depends on the electron capture decay of potassium into argon. But the in the much larger K atom, the innermost electron is well shielded by the outer electrons, not the case for beryllium, so one would expect a much smaller effect, if any, to be present in K/Ar dating. And since the old ages are linear with respect to decay rate, you can still get only about 1% reduction in 4,500,000,000 years, still far short of the 10,000 year mark. I have seen no specific study to determine the constancy of the K/Ar decay rate as a consequence of the results obtained on
7Be, but I suspect that's because nobody thinks it is worth doing.
The key lesson to take home from all this is that the radiometric ages are linear with respect to the decay rate, so if you want to get 4,500,000,000 years down to 10,000 years, then you have to speed up the decay rate by a factor of 450,000 not 0.01. And the cases shown above, only highly contrived and artificial conditions lead to the effect. How many of the atoms in a geological setting will ever experience 5 Kelvin temperatures? Or get stuck in fullerene balls? It clearly makes no sense at all to push the point that the assumption of constant decay rates is somehow not a good assumption, in order to bring credence to the idea that radiometric dating could be that far off.