YEC's and Evolution

Don't be silly. They only ignore the science that poses difficult questions.
How do they know which science poses difficult questions if they're ignoring it?

Funny how they ignore general relativity which makes the GPS confirmation of continental drift yet they gladly use GPS units in their cars. Just that the GPS in their car doesn't contradict a young Earth so it's ok.
I'm not following you. What is it about general relativity that proves the Earth is more than 6000 years old?
 
Are you serious? They start ignoring it when they notice it asks difficult questions.
So, kind of like noreligion and "How does general relativity threaten YEC"? If the question is too difficult, just ignore it.

Maybe he's a YEC.
 
So, kind of like noreligion and "How does general relativity threaten YEC"? If the question is too difficult, just ignore it.

Maybe he's a YEC.

Sticking your head in the sand isn't a behaviour unique to YEC:s.

I could've adressed the question, but...
1. I suck at relativity
2. I don't even remember which part general and special deal with
3. It's 8 AM and I haven't slept for 18-something hours.
 
Sticking your head in the sand isn't a behaviour unique to YEC:s.

I could've adressed the question, but...
1. I suck at relativity
2. I don't even remember which part general and special deal with
3. It's 8 AM and I haven't slept for 18-something hours.
Well, after you've had a good night's sleep -- or a good day's sleep -- or a restful nap, maybe you could take a stab at it. General relativity is the one about gravity and space-time, and while it may indeed contradict a young Earth (plenty does), I'm serious when I say I don't see how it would. I'm inclined to think noreligion is mistaken when he implies YECs ignore GR because it contradicts a young Earth, but maybe he knows (or you know) something I don't.
 
Uuuh... Might he be referring to cosmic redshift that's used to measure the distance of stars? Basically, the light from stars is dragged out as space-time expands, and with a bit of spectrum analysis one can determine the distance from them. That definitely contradicts the idea of a young universe, although I wouldn't say it's fool-proof evidence against YEC.
 
Uuuh... Might he be referring to cosmic redshift that's used to measure the distance of stars? Basically, the light from stars is dragged out as space-time expands, and with a bit of spectrum analysis one can determine the distance from them. That definitely contradicts the idea of a young universe, although I wouldn't say it's fool-proof evidence against YEC.
The cosmic redshift, which helps us determine that some galaxies are billions of light years away, implying that the light from them has been traveling for billions of years, does contradict a young universe and thus a young Earth.

I don't think cosmic red shift depends on general relativity, but like you, I confess that GR is not my strong suit. Maybe it does, and maybe that's exactly what noreligion had in mind when he claimed that YECs ignore GR.

I'd say it's more likely that YECs ignore the implications of cosmic red shift than that they ignore GR, but it's certainly possible that they ignore both.
 
Yeah, I think CRS depends on Maxwell's equations rather than GR.


Oh, I think noreligion might be thinking about the Conservapedia nutjobs. They're convinced that general/special relativity = moral relativism.
 
I think noreligion might be thinking about the Conservapedia nutjobs. They're convinced that general/special relativity = moral relativism.
Possible, I suppose, but "relativity = moral relativism" doesn't seem especially incompatible with a young Earth either.

I think the most likely explanation is that he made a claim which he is unable to defend, and has borrowed a page from the "ignore it and maybe it will go away" playbook. As you have observed, the tactic isn't only used by YECs. Sometimes it's even used by people who sneer at YECs because they "ignore difficult questions."
 
Radiometric Dating

Specific question: have their been any blinded tests of isochron dating? Example:
1) Geologist A selects samples, judged to be uncontaminated, from various rock strata from the Grand Canyon. The samples are carefully recorded and randomly labeled. Geologist A records an estimate of how old each sample should be.
2) Geologist B, without direct communication with Geologist A and no information other than the random labels, dates the sample set. ...
As far as I know, that in fact is how it is always done. Of course, this has nothing to do with the science & technology of radiometric dating, but is intended only to remove observer bias.
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.
That is dead wrong, scientists never do that. Usually the older rocks are on the bottom and the younger rocks are on top, which provides a sequence of relative ages. If the sequence of absolute radiometric ages does not match the sequence of relative ages, this is a warning: either the radiometric ages are wrong or the anticipated sequence of relative ages is wrong. That leads the scientists to go back and examine the geological environment of the samples, while the technicians have to review their process to make sure no mistakes were made.

I have never seen any creationist raise a reasonable argument against radiometric dating. I recommend the book Radiogenic Isotope Geology by Alan P. Dickin (Cambridge University Press, 1995 & 1997; there may be a more recent edition, but this is the one I have). The science of radiometric dating is well described in detail here. You can also try my online Radiometric Dating Resource List, though I suspect it could use an update that I have been too lazy to do.
 
YEC's argue that radiometric dating is circular, as scientists adjust their dates based on how old they already think the rock should be based on what's in it.
I was curious as to whether a blind test had been done to demonstrate the ability of radiometric dating standing on its own.
This is simply false.
radiometric dating is, at it's core, based upon the idea that radioactive decay of isotopes is a constant.

Even this, fairly well established concept is open for debate in the scientific arena. Indeed, a recent group has challenged this assumption to some quite interesting responses.
http://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/08/27/follow-up-on-the-solar-neutrinos-radioactive-decay-story/

The claim is that solar nuetrinos effect the observed decay rate. This has resulted in a rather interesting response (which is quite astute)
1.) Such responses have never been seen before
2.) Neutrinos are known to be non-interactive
3.) Neutrinos do not actually generate with the solar flares

SO the effect of this non-constant behavior is quite intriguing.

Now, to what degree are they talking about?
How about a normalized change in observed decay counts which vary 1.00005 to 0.99985
http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/0808/0808.3156.pdf

Yes, they are talking about a variation in the decay rate of ~0.002%


So not only are the assumptions continually challenged in science, the level of detail to which they are willing to challenge them are well beyond the level of criticism possible from YEC'ers.
 
I thought neutrinos, in very rare events, could react and change neutrons into protons and electrons?
 
Radiometric Dating II

radiometric dating is, at it's core, based upon the idea that radioactive decay of isotopes is a constant. Even this, fairly well established concept is open for debate in the scientific arena. Indeed, a recent group has challenged this assumption to some quite interesting responses. ...
See the discussion of this topic in another JREF thread: Group measures radioactive decay rates changing with seasons - blames sun, and especially ben_m's post #7 in that thread.

Yes, they are talking about a variation in the decay rate of ~0.002%
Radiometric dates are linear with respect to the decay rate. That means if the decay rate is uncertain at a level of ~0.002%, then so will the derived date be uncertain at a level of 0.002%. That won't get you from 4,500,000,000 years to 10,000 years. To that extent, variable decay rates are already known. 7Be decays by electron capture and it has been shown that deforming the quantum wave function of the innermost electron, by trapping the 7Be nucleus in a C60 "Buckyball" can accelerate the decay rate by ~1% (Ohtsuki, et al., 2004). The same group can also see decay rate changes ~1.5% for 7Be in dense environments when the temperature is dropped to ~5 Kelvins (Ohtsuki, et al., 2007).

Now, while Beryllium is of no use in radiometric dating, the K/Ar method depends on the electron capture decay of potassium into argon. But the in the much larger K atom, the innermost electron is well shielded by the outer electrons, not the case for beryllium, so one would expect a much smaller effect, if any, to be present in K/Ar dating. And since the old ages are linear with respect to decay rate, you can still get only about 1% reduction in 4,500,000,000 years, still far short of the 10,000 year mark. I have seen no specific study to determine the constancy of the K/Ar decay rate as a consequence of the results obtained on 7Be, but I suspect that's because nobody thinks it is worth doing.

The key lesson to take home from all this is that the radiometric ages are linear with respect to the decay rate, so if you want to get 4,500,000,000 years down to 10,000 years, then you have to speed up the decay rate by a factor of 450,000 not 0.01. And the cases shown above, only highly contrived and artificial conditions lead to the effect. How many of the atoms in a geological setting will ever experience 5 Kelvin temperatures? Or get stuck in fullerene balls? It clearly makes no sense at all to push the point that the assumption of constant decay rates is somehow not a good assumption, in order to bring credence to the idea that radiometric dating could be that far off.
 
It clearly makes no sense at all to push the point that the assumption of constant decay rates is somehow not a good assumption, in order to bring credence to the idea that radiometric dating could be that far off.
I thought that point was obvious from my post, but thank you for explaining it further.
 
AvalonXQ said:
I'm dealing with a lack of convincing evidence of the factual claims associated with common ancestry, which can only really be rectified by further study on my part.

Excellent, keep us posted, I'm sure many reasonable posters / lurkers are interested in your progress.

And nevermind the other stuff, it's internet, **** happens. Just concentrate on the evidence and what you think about it.


How's it going Avalon?
 
How's it going Avalon?

As I've mentioned in another thread, the more I read the less convinced I am that any moderate amount of study is going to result in an educated conclusion. It's going to take a massive amount of effort for me to get to a point where I can understand what the evidence is and how to evaluate it properly.
So, in practice, I'm simply moving my position to agnostic about the whole thing. It will likely stay there for the near future.
 
Avalon, Debunking Christianity just mentioned a book "Why Evolution Is True" that a review on Amazon said was a great, short or at least not long intro to the evidence for evolution, bringing in many different fields. I have it on order from my library, maybe it will be a quick read for you, too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom