Except he has provided proof: the percentiles that the APFT is based on. They didn't pick the times and reps out of thin air, they are based on evaluations of performance during the design and implementation of the standards. His proof is the APFT, a point you seem to continue to miss. Now it's your turn for that proof stuff. I already showed you how easy it would be to support your position.
That is the
claim; it is not the
proof. I am asking to see those "evaluations of performance."
It is like saying that tables of homeopathic remedies are their own proof because obviously homeopaths did the research to create them.
excaza said:
A position you have yet to provide evidence for, other than your assertion.
Until I have evidence to counter--as opposed to a claim--it is not incumbent upon me to provide such evidence. But have no fear. See the end of this post.
excaza said:
A point nobody disagrees with you on, so why continue to bring it up?
Perhaps because this is a thread on the draft, and this topic is the sub-topic of women's fitness for the draft based on their fitness for combat. If women's lesser APFT performance was not brought up in that context, why was it brought up?
I wouldn't normally do this, because it really is not incumbent on me to bring up evidence to counter a claim without evidence, but here you go:
The Army Physical Fitness Test (APFT): Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers is a study conducted in 1944 by the US Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine in Natick, Massachusetts.
If there are better, more recent studies, I could not find them with the limited effort I was willing to put into my research.
There are eight sets of standards for both males and females, broken out by age. I analyzed only the youngest four age groups both because I was tired and because the
n for females drops precipitously for the four higher age groups, so it is possible the numbers are different for the older ages.
My analysis was simple:
1. I ignored data for sit-ups since sarge's claim does not apply to that exercise.
2. For push-ups and the two-mile run I compared percentiles of bottom-performing males with the percentiles of women who exceeded that performance.
3. For bottom-performing males, the percentile I chose was the lowest percentile that still achieved the minimum passing score (60 points).
4. I have no hard numbers for sarge's claim except for the one mention of 10% and 10%, so my null hypothesis was that no more than 10% of women would exceed the bottom (but still passing) 10% of men.
Note: Given that the percentiles were based on actual performances and were rounded to 5 and 10 percentile groups, the raw scores don't always match exactly, so the analysis below includes some mild rounding.
Here is what I found:
Push-ups
Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males
Ages 22-26: 50% of females beat the bottom 10% of males
Ages 27-31: 15% of females beat the bottom 10% of males
Ages 32-36: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males
2 Mile Run
Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males
Ages 22-26: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males
Ages 27-31: 30% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males
Ages 32-36: 20% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males
Conclusion: In no instance is the comparative performance as poor as 10% to 10% in the overlap.