Woman and the Military Draft

My hope is for something different. That the test were to be gender neutral and that standards applied to specialties.

You want to stay a treadhead? You need to do x on the test.

You want to stay a grunt? You need to do y (slightly different from x) on the test.

You want to stay an Intel weenie? You only need to do z, which is still greater than failing because everybody's got to be able to do at least the minimum fighting stuff.

And I agree with this completely. There should be gender neutral standards that are job specific. If females want to do combat arms, that's fine. But they should have to be able to perform physically to the same standard that the males have to achieve.
 
Frankly, you just proved my point. Females are less fit than males using the Army's current standard for fitness. Females are not only less fit than males in general, the method used to derive the standards for the test show that the most fit females are just about as fit as the least fit males.
No.

1. You are using success on the APFT as your measure of fitness, ignoring completely that even the army no longer says that.

2. Even if you were correct, it would only be a measure of fitness for being in the army, not a measure of fitness otherwise. But you're not correct.

3. I see you're still not showing the research.


sarge said:
If the Army changes the definition of "fitness", and makes the physical activities that women are less far behind in more important, then females will be closer to even with men.
And you are proving how arbitrary your standard is. You're not discussing actual fitness; you're discussing measurements, regardless if it actually measures fitness.


sarge said:
Right now, however, it is conclusive - the most fit female Soldiers are at best on a par with the least fit male Soldiers that meet at least the minimum standard. That has been my only contention, and I am correct.
No. See my list above.

And see the continued absence of the research you claim.
 
And I agree with this completely. There should be gender neutral standards that are job specific. If females want to do combat arms, that's fine. But they should have to be able to perform physically to the same standard that the males have to achieve.

I've no problem with that.

I would expect a big difference between the females that volunteer for general military enlistment, and the females that would be attracted to volunteer for combat arms careers.
 
No.

1. You are using success on the APFT as your measure of fitness, ignoring completely that even the army no longer says that.

I am using the APFT as the measure of "fitness" because the Army uses the APFT as the measure of fitness. There is no other meaningful measure of fitness for combat than the only test of fitness that currently exists.

Again, if you choose to use a different measure of "fitness" than the Army uses, fine. List your test, and we'll see if I agree with your notion that the overlap between the "fitness" of women and men actually occupies a fairly large band of performance.

Using the measures of muscular endurance, muscular strength, and cardiovascular endurance, women fall well short of men.

2. Even if you were correct, it would only be a measure of fitness for being in the army, not a measure of fitness otherwise. But you're not correct.

About the method the Army uses to derive APFT standards, I am absolutely correct - I participated in developing them. About whether or not the APFT is the measure of fitness in the Army, I am absolutely correct. About whether or not women are significantly inferior to men on the components of fitness measured by this test, I am also absolutely correct.

3. I see you're still not showing the research.

Can't. Don't own it, probably can't find it in a google search. I am retired (but still work for the Army). However, that doesn't change that I have already demonstrated that women are inferior to men in all but one of the Army's measures of fitness.


And you are proving how arbitrary your standard is.

It isn't my standard. It is the Army's standard - and it isn't arbitrary at all. There must be a measure of fitness, and that measure must be some form of physical test. The Army will always use a unit administerable test, and it is certain that women will always be inferior to men on that fitness test.

You're not discussing actual fitness; you're discussing measurements, regardless if it actually measures fitness.

Not true.

Unless you re-define "fitness" to mean "able to perform as close to maximum potential as physical training will allow", fitness must be measured against an absolute standard.

So, either women can be "fit" when they are getting the most out of their bodies as it is possible to do so, or women are "fit" when they meet a certain standard. If a women has the potential to bench press 200 lbs and the ability to bench press 120 lbs, then trains to the abilty to bench press 190 lbs, she is very "fit" in comparison to her potential. She is still inferior to a man that has the potential to bench press 350 lbs and the ability to bench press 200 lbs.

Women are physically inferior to men in most every way that combat would place a premium on. That doesn't mean that women are unfit for combat - but it also does not mean that the fitness tests are arbitrary.


You are arguing the wrong point (badly).

Here are the facts:

1. The Army APFT is a poor test of general fitness, and is an even poorer test of fitness for any specific MOS requirement. Irrelevent, really - as any test of the components of fitness will demonstrate women's inferiority to men.

2. Women are physically inferior to men in most regards. That, while unequivocally true, is almost irrelevent to the suitability of women for combat. Combat has not recently required great strength or stamina, nor does possessing either greatly improve one's chances in combat.
 
I am using the APFT as the measure of "fitness" because the Army uses the APFT as the measure of fitness. There is no other meaningful measure of fitness for combat than the only test of fitness that currently exists.

Again, if you choose to use a different measure of "fitness" than the Army uses, fine. List your test, and we'll see if I agree with your notion that the overlap between the "fitness" of women and men actually occupies a fairly large band of performance.

Using the measures of muscular endurance, muscular strength, and cardiovascular endurance, women fall well short of men.



About the method the Army uses to derive APFT standards, I am absolutely correct - I participated in developing them. About whether or not the APFT is the measure of fitness in the Army, I am absolutely correct. About whether or not women are significantly inferior to men on the components of fitness measured by this test, I am also absolutely correct.



Can't. Don't own it, probably can't find it in a google search. I am retired (but still work for the Army). However, that doesn't change that I have already demonstrated that women are inferior to men in all but one of the Army's measures of fitness.




It isn't my standard. It is the Army's standard - and it isn't arbitrary at all. There must be a measure of fitness, and that measure must be some form of physical test. The Army will always use a unit administerable test, and it is certain that women will always be inferior to men on that fitness test.



Not true.

Unless you re-define "fitness" to mean "able to perform as close to maximum potential as physical training will allow", fitness must be measured against an absolute standard.

So, either women can be "fit" when they are getting the most out of their bodies as it is possible to do so, or women are "fit" when they meet a certain standard. If a women has the potential to bench press 200 lbs and the ability to bench press 120 lbs, then trains to the abilty to bench press 190 lbs, she is very "fit" in comparison to her potential. She is still inferior to a man that has the potential to bench press 350 lbs and the ability to bench press 200 lbs.

Women are physically inferior to men in most every way that combat would place a premium on. That doesn't mean that women are unfit for combat - but it also does not mean that the fitness tests are arbitrary.


You are arguing the wrong point (badly).

Here are the facts:

1. The Army APFT is a poor test of general fitness, and is an even poorer test of fitness for any specific MOS requirement. Irrelevent, really - as any test of the components of fitness will demonstrate women's inferiority to men.

2. Women are physically inferior to men in most regards. That, while unequivocally true, is almost irrelevent to the suitability of women for combat. Combat has not recently required great strength or stamina, nor does possessing either greatly improve one's chances in combat.
You are missing what I said and modifying your own position without acknowledging it.

My point has never been that women don't, on average, perform to a lower standard than men on physical tests. My point, and it still stands as you cannot present any evidence to support your claim, is that the overlap is more than just the very lowest performing men and the very highest performing women.

Regarding the APFT itself, I do not deny that the intent is to measure fitness. I deny that it actually measures fitness, and that it never has. The Army, as I have shown, agrees.

Regarding the highlighted portion above, please compare it to what you said in an earlier post:

sarge said:
The APFT does not test muscular strength at all.
 
You are missing what I said and modifying your own position without acknowledging it.

Incorrect on both counts.

My point has never been that women don't, on average, perform to a lower standard than men on physical tests. My point, and it still stands as you cannot present any evidence to support your claim, is that the overlap is more than just the very lowest performing men and the very highest performing women.

I have presented evidence to support my claim. The APFT is evidence, even if it is not a good indicator of fitness for combat.

"Fitness" consists of (depending on who does the defining) 5-7 components. Two of these are measured by the APFT.

Regarding the APFT itself, I do not deny that the intent is to measure fitness. I deny that it actually measures fitness, and that it never has. The Army, as I have shown, agrees.

The Army does not agree that the APFT does not measure fitness. The Army believes that there are better meausres of fitness than the current APFT, and more importantly that the APFT does not effectively measure fitness for service. In fact, the Army is re-instating several events that were part of the previous version of the APFT.

The APFT does measure two of the components of fitness.

It appears that you are confusing some other argument with mine.

Regarding the highlighted portion above, please compare it to what you said in an earlier post:

There is no incongruity in the two points. That the APFT does not measure muscular strength has nothing to do with the absoulte that women are inferior to men when muscular strength is measured. Frankly, I find it hard to believe that you would argue that women share a significant overlap with men when muscular strength is measured. Of course, I've already allowed that possing great muscular strength is not an important component of fitness for combat.

So - let's recap:

My sole argument is that the most fit women Soldiers are only as fit (less fit, actually) than their male counterparts that actually meet fitness standards. My measure of fitness is the same as the Army's - the APFT.

I further declare that women are less fit than men, by a significant margin, when all of the components of fitness are measured. Muscular Strength, Muscular Endurance, Cardiovascular Endurance, and Body Composition all favor men by a wide margin. Flexibility favors women.

At no point have I argued that women are unfit for combat - although I have argued that it may be inappropriate to open combat MOSs soley to accomodate the very small pool of women that would marginally meet the real fitness requirements.
 
The Soviet experience in WWII shows that women can be placed in certain combat positions and excel. (Snipers, tankers, field artillery.) They would certainly be able to handle most of the rear-eschalon stuff.

The remfs can't run away as efficiently? More motivation to stand your ground.

My concern is that we have a lot more rifle muzzles pointed at anybody who dares to invade us and a lot fewer people standing on active duty just to have them there, costing enormous amounts of money that we can no longer afford.

Works for the Swiss.
 
I also probably wouldn't be adverse to the idea of sending everyone straight out of high school into 6-8 weeks of basic training.

Everyone? Not possible, too many who are physically or mentally unqualified to participate in any kind of boot camp. Why waste so much money on training people when most of them will never put that training to any practical use? Better we train the volunteers instead.

Ranb
 
I love how Progressives break apart comments into partial sentences and attack their detractors on an almost word-by-word level. It tells me two things. First of all, they lack the capacity to have a complete idea. Secondly, they lack the capacity to understand some elses complete idea. Thirdly, they ... just kidding. But, on the other hand, I could probably sneek that past you and you would not catch it to prove my point. When you argue someone's sentences and not their paragraphs, you are not arguing their ideas at all. You are only taking them out of context. You are inventing an argument to attack that is not really there. You are not out to be correct. You are only interested in domination. You are rejecting reality and substituting your own, more comfortable, one.

The military is not all about invading another country. It is what is called upon to restore order in many situations. The aftermath of natural disasters is often followed by starving people who resort to animal instincts for survival. The military is called upon to provide aid and security in such situations.

Living without a military is like living without both a police force as well as a Fire Fighting force.

Now, for the registation for the draft, I might add this. Things exist in the real world without the intention of making direct use of them. Nuclear weapons is one example. The gold in Fort Knox is another. And having registration for a draft s another.

I did not name any names. So let's see who assumes I am talking about them. Let's see who cannot tell fact from supposition.
 
Last edited:
My point, and it still stands as you cannot present any evidence to support your claim, is that the overlap is more than just the very lowest performing men and the very highest performing women.

You have yet to support you position either, instead resorting to "I know what I'm talking about." it's trivial to support your position: provide statistics on the percentage of women scoring 100% (or better) on their fitness test, and compare it to men who are barely passing. That is your overlap, so show us that it does what you insist.
 
Everyone? Not possible, too many who are physically or mentally unqualified to participate in any kind of boot camp. Why waste so much money on training people when most of them will never put that training to any practical use? Better we train the volunteers instead.

Ranb
This is why I advocate alternative services under a draft. Put the sub-par in support positions in public safety, social services, just filling in in crucial infrastructural positions while the physically fit are off repelling invaders or putting down insurrection or snadbagging rivers or whatever.
 
If you are against the existance of the Draft and registering for it, demanding that girls must be required to registerd by law just as boys are, might serve a goal of getting rid of it. If one assumes that women do not have to register because of some barbaic instinct to protect women from harm, this would use that instinct towards abolishing the draft.
 
Last edited:
Everyone? Not possible, too many who are physically or mentally unqualified to participate in any kind of boot camp. Why waste so much money on training people when most of them will never put that training to any practical use? Better we train the volunteers instead.

Ranb

If you read on you'd see that I was specifically talking about using the "Boot camp" to weed out the unfit. I realize that many would never make it past the physical entrance examination phase. Yet another reason to require it actually. In a time of need you don't have to waste valuable time and resources just to tell someone "No, we can't use you." and instead focus on the ones that are able to do the job.

That's why I pretty much said that I would have the training stop at a basic training level and then cut them loose. The main reason I'm not adverse to the idea wasn't to have a huge standing army (or even a reserve army) but to know who was pre-screened and available and have them know and be able to perform the absolute basics of military life with no specific job or even a branch in mind.
 
This is why I advocate alternative services under a draft. Put the sub-par in support positions in public safety, social services, just filling in in crucial infrastructural positions while the physically fit are off repelling invaders or putting down insurrection or snadbagging rivers or whatever.

Getting closer everyday!!

That is one of the reasons I prefer the more general moniker "National Service" rather than manditory conscription.
 
Oh no, I'm perfectly fine with the US going to war with other countries if it's justified in doing so, and it was in WWII. I don't disagree with war, I disagree with the draft.

You do not make any sense. Maybe you have not studied History. Having someone else fight your war is a luxury a country cannot afford when victory is not certain.

Maybe you do not take this subject seriously and you are not making comments you would really stand behind or expect anyone else to take seriously. So why do you bother?

How exactly would you expect to go to war without an army to do the job?

Luck? Do you take for granted a class of people will exist to do it?

Without a Draft, the United States would have lost World War II. I think I understand Passifist Liberalism. It relies heavily on Magic.
 
Last edited:
You have yet to support you position either, instead resorting to "I know what I'm talking about." it's trivial to support your position: provide statistics on the percentage of women scoring 100% (or better) on their fitness test, and compare it to men who are barely passing. That is your overlap, so show us that it does what you insist.
Actually, sarge and I started out equal on the "I know what I'm talking about scale." I backed off on my claim to greater authority when he told me his credentials.

More importantly, my claim is to dispute sarge's claim, which he admits he can and/or will provide no information for, so I don't think I'll lose much sleep over your misplaced idea of burden of proof.
 
Sarge,

Since I really am not trying to argue for argument's sake and certainly not to score debating points, I'll stick with responding primarily to your recap.

Sarge, I will address just the recap you provided in post 107:

sarge said:
My sole argument is that the most fit women Soldiers are only as fit (less fit, actually) than their male counterparts that actually meet fitness standards. My measure of fitness is the same as the Army's - the APFT.
Stated in this manner, I have far less disagreement than before, though I could still argue about the meaning of “most” and what the actual numbers say as opposed to what the APFT card declares as standard.


sarge said:
I further declare that women are less fit than men, by a significant margin, when all of the components of fitness are measured. Muscular Strength, Muscular Endurance, Cardiovascular Endurance, and Body Composition all favor men by a wide margin. Flexibility favors women.
And this, I think, may be one of the major sticking points for me. Regarding your first three categories, I have no problem admitting what I have already admitted: on average, men perform better than woman. What I take exception to comprises two things: (1) The use of the word "fit" to describe that performance. "Fit" assumes there is something it is meant to fit with; in this case, it is combat ability. As I have said before, I doubt the current APFT's relevance in measuring that fitness. (2) The Body Composition component mystifies me. Unlike the other categories it is not a measurement of performance.


sarge said:
At no point have I argued that women are unfit for combat
It is hard to take this (from post #94) in any other fashion:
sarge said:
The number of women Soldiers that can successfully perform the full range of duties of Infantry/Artillery/Tank Crewman duties without compromising standards is too small to warrant risking the disruption and expense that integrating these MOSs would entail.


sarge said:
- although I have argued that it may be inappropriate to open combat MOSs soley to accomodate the very small pool of women that would marginally meet the real fitness requirements.
The comment from post #94 certainly says that, but it also says women are unfit for combat (in different words).


So I’ll recap my own position:

1. Regardless if the current APFT is a weak, strong, or non- indicator of fitness for combat, I hold that the overlap (of top female performers with bottom male performers) is larger than you imply. You haven't quantified it, but you have indicated it is only the fringe of each. At one point I think you said it is 10% and 10%.

2. The current APFT is not in actuality a reliable measure of combat readiness.
 
Actually, sarge and I started out equal on the "I know what I'm talking about scale." I backed off on my claim to greater authority when he told me his credentials.

More importantly, my claim is to dispute sarge's claim, which he admits he can and/or will provide no information for, so I don't think I'll lose much sleep over your misplaced idea of burden of proof.

Except he has provided proof: the percentiles that the APFT is based on. They didn't pick the times and reps out of thin air, they are based on evaluations of performance during the design and implementation of the standards. His proof is the APFT, a point you seem to continue to miss. Now it's your turn for that proof stuff. I already showed you how easy it would be to support your position.

1. Regardless if the current APFT is a weak, strong, or non- indicator of fitness for combat, I hold that the overlap (of top female performers with bottom male performers) is larger than you imply. You haven't quantified it, but you have indicated it is only the fringe of each. At one point I think you said it is 10% and 10%.
A position you have yet to provide evidence for, other than your assertion.

2. The current APFT is not in actuality a reliable measure of combat readiness.
A point nobody disagrees with you on, so why continue to bring it up?
 
Last edited:
Except he has provided proof: the percentiles that the APFT is based on. They didn't pick the times and reps out of thin air, they are based on evaluations of performance during the design and implementation of the standards. His proof is the APFT, a point you seem to continue to miss. Now it's your turn for that proof stuff. I already showed you how easy it would be to support your position.
That is the claim; it is not the proof. I am asking to see those "evaluations of performance."

It is like saying that tables of homeopathic remedies are their own proof because obviously homeopaths did the research to create them.


excaza said:
A position you have yet to provide evidence for, other than your assertion.
Until I have evidence to counter--as opposed to a claim--it is not incumbent upon me to provide such evidence. But have no fear. See the end of this post.


excaza said:
A point nobody disagrees with you on, so why continue to bring it up?
Perhaps because this is a thread on the draft, and this topic is the sub-topic of women's fitness for the draft based on their fitness for combat. If women's lesser APFT performance was not brought up in that context, why was it brought up?


I wouldn't normally do this, because it really is not incumbent on me to bring up evidence to counter a claim without evidence, but here you go:

The Army Physical Fitness Test (APFT): Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers is a study conducted in 1944 by the US Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine in Natick, Massachusetts.

If there are better, more recent studies, I could not find them with the limited effort I was willing to put into my research.

There are eight sets of standards for both males and females, broken out by age. I analyzed only the youngest four age groups both because I was tired and because the n for females drops precipitously for the four higher age groups, so it is possible the numbers are different for the older ages.

My analysis was simple:

1. I ignored data for sit-ups since sarge's claim does not apply to that exercise.

2. For push-ups and the two-mile run I compared percentiles of bottom-performing males with the percentiles of women who exceeded that performance.

3. For bottom-performing males, the percentile I chose was the lowest percentile that still achieved the minimum passing score (60 points).

4. I have no hard numbers for sarge's claim except for the one mention of 10% and 10%, so my null hypothesis was that no more than 10% of women would exceed the bottom (but still passing) 10% of men.

Note: Given that the percentiles were based on actual performances and were rounded to 5 and 10 percentile groups, the raw scores don't always match exactly, so the analysis below includes some mild rounding.

Here is what I found:

Push-ups

Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males

Ages 22-26: 50% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 27-31: 15% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 32-36: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males


2 Mile Run

Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males

Ages 22-26: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 27-31: 30% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males

Ages 32-36: 20% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males


Conclusion: In no instance is the comparative performance as poor as 10% to 10% in the overlap.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom