Woman and the Military Draft

I am being rhetorical.

Is the draft archaic or is something else?

It kind of sucks that women are not required to register for the draft while men are. Don't you think? I think the USA culture stinks. I only live here because me kid does not want to move.

I had a great gig in the center of Washington state where I made a few friends. I wanted to give a couple of the friends I had made a hug the day my contract was over. The guy wouldn't because he did not want me to think he was gay... or whatever. The girl would not because it would be harassment. She even hinted at it. I thought that the USA is odd. Most other countries do not have such hang ups.

The fact women are not required to register for the draft makes the hang-ups official.

In Brazil I felt like people behaved as human beings are supposed to. And what is wierd is that the USA thinks Brazilians are perverts!

I think service in the military is mandatory in Israel, for bother genders, by the way.

Which makes me think of something else. In US English, Americans say "sex" when they mean "gender". They are the perverts, I think.
 
Last edited:
No, but I don't understand why.

Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men. They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military. Women have never been subject to conscription the United States. The only country where I've ever heard of conscription for women is Israel.

I think there's more of an argument for getting rid of Selective Service registration than for requiring women to register. At the time, it was kept as a "just in case" thing for those who were worried that we couldn't have an army without conscription, but subsequent history has shown that an all-volunteer army works just fine, and in fact, when there is a national crisis like 9/11, the military has all the volunteers it needs.

So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.
 
I am being rhetorical.

Is the draft archaic or is something else?

It kind of sucks that women are not required to register for the draft while men are. Don't you think? I think the USA culture stinks. I only live here because me kid does not want to move.

I had a great gig in the center of Washington state where I made a few friends. I wanted to give a couple of the friends I had made a hug the day my contract was over. The guy wouldn't because he did not want me to think he was gay... or whatever. The girl would not because it would be harassment. She even hinted at it. I thought that the USA is odd. Most other countries do not have such hang ups.

The fact women are not required to register for the draft makes the hang-ups official.

In Brazil I felt like people behaved as human beings are supposed to. And what is wierd is that the USA thinks Brazilians are perverts!

I think service in the military is mandatory in Israel, for bother genders, by the way.

Which makes me think of something else. In US English, Americans say "sex" when they mean "gender". They are the perverts, I think.

Some people just aren't into hugging. I don't see what that has to do with the draft. :confused:
 
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men. They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military. Women have never been subject to conscription the United States. The only country where I've ever heard of conscription for women is Israel.

I think there's more of an argument for getting rid of Selective Service registration than for requiring women to register. At the time, it was kept as a "just in case" thing for those who were worried that we couldn't have an army without conscription, but subsequent history has shown that an all-volunteer army works just fine, and in fact, when there is a national crisis like 9/11, the military has all the volunteers it needs.

So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.

This is not true in the modern hi-tech military. I would have to disagree with everything you have said. My example of Israel proves you wrong. I saw women in jumpsuits armed with machine guns patroling the streets in Haifa. They were just as tough if not tougher than men.
 
Last edited:
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men. They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military. Women have never been subject to conscription the United States. The only country where I've ever heard of conscription for women is Israel.

And the what 90% of soldiers who are non combat personnel need to be men because of why?
 
Some people just aren't into hugging. I don't see what that has to do with the draft. :confused:

Again, I think you are wrong. It is a cultural thing and the American culture is ********** up. All men who are close like brothers hug in Brazil. And it is not a gay thing and I did not know any dude there who was "not into it".

Edited by LashL: 
Edited to properly mask profanity. See Rule 10 re: the auto-censor.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.

Uh huh. Is this a Liberal thing were you are instinctly against the military? Your feeling that we do not need a registration for the draft is a luxury that the men and women who volunteer have provided to you. If not for them there would be a few more 9-11's and you would be demanding all young people are obligated to serve as they do in Greece and Israel.
 
Uh huh. Is this a Liberal thing were you are instinctly against the military? Your feeling that we do not need a registration for the draft is a luxury that the men and women who volunteer have provided to you. If not for them there would be a few more 9-11's and you would be demanding all young people are obligated to serve as they do in Greece and Israel.

:rolleyes:

I served in the Navy for six years.
 
:rolleyes:

I served in the Navy for six years.

And I am eating a peanut butter sandwich while typing this. This fact is unrelated to what we are talking about. On what tangable FACTS do you base your idea that we do not need people registered for a draft in the USA? Is it an idea of yours that human beings are good by nature and are not out to bring down the USA? That fantasy left me on 9-11-2001.
 
Last edited:
This fact is unrelated to what we are talking about.

Let me see if I can help you understand what you wrote.
You wrote:
Is this a Liberal thing were you are instinctly against the military? Your feeling that we do not need a registration for the draft is a luxury that the men and women who volunteer have provided to you.
So the fact is exactly related to what you just accused me of.

A fact that is unrelated to what we are talking about is your experience of people who didn't want to hug. What does whether Americans like to hug or not have to do with the draft?

This is not true in the modern hi-tech military.
If you think that "the modern hi-tech military" is not physically demanding, you are sorely mistaken. Soldiers have to carry a hundred or more pounds of gear and be able to hump it 20 miles a day or more.

And the what 90% of soldiers who are non combat personnel need to be men because of why?
They don't. This is about whether women should have to register for a draft. Not whether they can volunteer.
 
Last edited:
I imagine in China women have the same obligations as men do regarding service in the military. But I might be wrong.

That was one option when I was interviewing for before I got the job I currently have. I did phone interviews with Microsoft in Beijing. I was ready to leave the USA forever. My grandfather came to the USA from Greece. I figure we gave it a shot. Now it is time to move on.

Am I debating someone regarding American culture who is submerged in defending it out of national pride? Kind of like arguing Islam with a Muslim. Don't you think?
 
If you think that "the modern hi-tech military" is not physically demanding, you are sorely mistaken. Soldiers have to carry a hundred or more pounds of gear and be able to hump it 20 miles a day or more.

.

Removed image as it was a breach of Rule 10.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL


Your logic is messed up. Life is not fair. Nor is the military. No, your generalization is not accurate. "Soldiers" do not "have to" carry a hundred or more pounds of gear and be able to hump it 20 miles a day or more. You are grasping at straws out of some sort of misguided national pride. I do not know if you are talking about the Army or the Marines, but women I served with in the Navy did not have such demands on them.

And if you read my post, you would see that I cited Israel as an example where women serve in combat situations with no problems.

Seriously, what about the women who currently serve in the US military? Are you saying they are required to lug 100 pounds as you describe? If someone was to tell you that your being rational and accurate has taken a back seat to your defending of your country, would you think that that person would have a point?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men.
In some aspects, yes, but in others they are equal or superior. Some of those aspects are applicable to combat (though there is no one combat scenario, even if we are pretending there is).


puppycow said:
They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military.
They cannot be assigned to the combat arms, but they have served in combat, some with distinction. Others have been regularly placed in roles in which combat is expected (think Military Police in Afghanistan).


puppycow said:
So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.
I'd be okay with that.
 
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men.
I don't want to follow this tangent very far, but the distribution of relevant physical attributes of men and women are overlapping curves. Even if the mean of the women's curve is lower than that of men, most of the area overlaps. Some men deemed fit for combat service are physically inferior to some women. So thinking in general is simply prejudiced when applied to individuals, isn't it?



They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military.
While they can't legally, my understanding is that they have in reality been doing so for some time.



So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.

I remember reading a Phyllis Schlafly column once against allowing women into combat service (or maybe she was even in favor of a broader prohibition of women in the military). She said that being a soldier is the business of killing, and women shouldn't be in the business of killing.

And men should?
 
No, but I don't understand why. The whole process is archaic, at this point.

Indeed. A Cold War relic. However I think the issue isn't why women are not subjected to the Selective Service System but rather why men still are. In my opinion, there is never going to be another military draft because the government doesn't really want people to be over concerned with what wars we are engaged in.

I ask my high school seniors what effect the U.S.'s wars have on them, an unless they have a relative in Iraq or Afghanistan the answer is always, "none". Then I ask them how they would feel if they knew at 18 they would be spending two years in Bagdad or Kabul, well then the comments and criticism starts flying.

Why would anyone want to subject women to the same stupidity that men have been subjected to since 1981?
 
I imagine in China women have the same obligations as men do regarding service in the military. But I might be wrong.

That was one option when I was interviewing for before I got the job I currently have. I did phone interviews with Microsoft in Beijing. I was ready to leave the USA forever. My grandfather came to the USA from Greece. I figure we gave it a shot. Now it is time to move on.

Am I debating someone regarding American culture who is submerged in defending it out of national pride? Kind of like arguing Islam with a Muslim. Don't you think?

None of this is relevant to the point you and Puppycow are debating.

The last part in particular is strictly an ad hominem fallacy. (It's fallacious in that his motives for arguing are completely irrelevant to the arguments he's made.)
 
Last edited:
No one has to register for the draft in the United States as the United States does not have a draft.

Even though we haven't had a draft since the Vietnam era, registration for the draft was re-instituted in about 1979 or '80.

At this point, all 18 year old males are required to register. It's primarily being enforced with the Solomon Amendment that would deny federal financial aid to non registrants (and I think requires proof of compliance with draft registration as part of the application).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom