Woman and the Military Draft

Sarge,
Stated in this manner, I have far less disagreement than before, though I could still argue about the meaning of “most” and what the actual numbers say as opposed to what the APFT card declares as standard.

"Most" as in "the most fit" rather than "most" as in "most women". In other words, the women that score the highest on any fitness test the Army is likely to devise will score at or below the level of the lowest scoring males that pass the same test.


And this, I think, may be one of the major sticking points for me. Regarding your first three categories, I have no problem admitting what I have already admitted: on average, men perform better than woman.

"On average", while accurate, is completely misleading. All but a handful of trained men will outperform all women on any test that measures the first three components of fitness.

What I take exception to comprises two things: (1) The use of the word "fit" to describe that performance. "Fit" assumes there is something it is meant to fit with; in this case, it is combat ability.

Not at all. There is a generally accepted definition for "physical fitness" that incorporates an ability to perform to some standard on a series of tests that measures between 5-7 components of "fitness". In my posts, "fitness" and "suitability" are not synonymous.

As I have said before, I doubt the current APFT's relevance in measuring that fitness.

The APFT is sufficient to measure the two components of fitness that we've already discussed. I may agree that the APFT is a poor measure of MOS specific physical suitability - indeed I made that argument many times during my career.

It is true however that the APFT is not entirely worthless as a predictor of suitability for some activities. Generally, someone that can only do 20 pushups (male or female) is less likely to perform successfully as a loader on an M1A2 than someone that can perform 100 pushups.

(2) The Body Composition component mystifies me. Unlike the other categories it is not a measurement of performance.

It is a predictor of performance. Very fit women have a higher body fat percentage than very fit men do, and high body fat percentages make cardioendurance events more difficult. This (and a 25% less efficient CV system) is the primary reaon that men significantly outperform women in running events. Indeed, body fat contents that reasonably fit men easily attain may be unhealthy for women to maintain. A 5% BFC for a fit male is fine, while a fit female may need to devote twice as much of her mass to fat.


It is hard to take this (from post #94) in any other fashion:



The comment from post #94 certainly says that, but it also says women are unfit for combat (in different words).

Only if you believe combat excludes all but Infantry/Armor/Artillery units.

Fewer than 3% of all female Soldiers possess the physical abilities to perform the full range of duties required of Infantrymen. I don't know the results of the Armor Branch tests. Ft Sill declined to participate. Integrating Infantry units to accomodate a handful of females (that we have no pressing need for) would be a social experiment rather than a force improvement initiative.

Women are undeniably suitable for combat duty, and they are undeniably fit enough for some combat MOSs. I am not expert on much more than IET and Infantry/Airborne matters, but I can see women performing all MP/Engineer/Aviation duties, and many Armor/Artillery jobs.


So I’ll recap my own position:

1. Regardless if the current APFT is a weak, strong, or non- indicator of fitness for combat, I hold that the overlap (of top female performers with bottom male performers) is larger than you imply. You haven't quantified it, but you have indicated it is only the fringe of each. At one point I think you said it is 10% and 10%.

The overlap of male/female performance on tests that measure muscular endurance, muscular strength, cardiovascular endurance. These are real components of fitness, and have nothing to do specifically with the APFT, nor do they necessarily have anything to do with suitability for any specific task or job.

The overlap for the other components of fitness is much wider, and in one component females are more "fit" than males - flexibility.

2. The current APFT is not in actuality a reliable measure of combat readiness.

The APFT is not a complete test of anything except the ability to perform pushups, situps, and run two miles nekkid.
 
Last edited:
If you are against the existance of the Draft and registering for it, demanding that girls must be required to registerd by law just as boys are, might serve a goal of getting rid of it.

One could do that, but it would be dishonest. I prefer to argue for what I think is right, rather than arguing for what I think is wrong in order to manipulate people into doing what I think is right.
 
Girls are not required by law to register for the draft as boys are because of a clerical oversight that should be fixed.

If society has changed and there are no longer any prejudicial restrictions or differences between males and females taking up arms to defend the country, then women should be required to register for the draft.
 
One could do that, but it would be dishonest. I prefer to argue for what I think is right, rather than arguing for what I think is wrong in order to manipulate people into doing what I think is right.

Making war as ugly as possible whilst exposing it as it is should be a requirement for walking on earth as a human being. It is not a matter of what one could or could not do.

Ending the draft will not end war. Limiting the military will not limit war. It is a backwards approach to ending war. It is like dragging a war on as long as possible instead of getting the ugly job done and overwith as soon as possible. Dragging a war on as long as possible by sending as few troops as you can is the approach that JFK and BHO have done. They are wrong and the carnage that does not get reported by the US media is worsened and extended.

This is why I think Liberals do not have working brains. Everyone is against war -- or at least I would like to hope so. By protesting war you are saying that the Neocons are too evil and stupid to know that war is bad.

Like I said, girls are not required by law to register for the draft as boys are because of a clerical oversight that should be fixed.

If society has changed and there are no longer any prejudicial restrictions or differences between males and females taking up arms to defend the country, then women should be required to register for the draft. If you are for a better and more peaceful world, you should be for extending the draft, not limiting it.

Now, are you going to slice this post up into sentences because you do not want to believe what I am saying?
 
Last edited:
Making war as ugly as possible whilst exposing it as it is should be a requirement for walking on earth as a human being. It is not a matter of what one could or could not do.
You have a habit of confusing the draft with war. You really shouldn't, as they are utterly different things. Many drafts have been held without war, and many wars have been held without a draft.

This is why I think Liberals do not have working brains. Everyone is against war -- or at least I would like to hope so.
I'm not against war. I've supported several of them. War is certainly not a thing to be engaged in lightly, but there are times when having a war is a preferable option to not having a war. However, as I have said, a person's attitude to war is nothing to do with their attitude to the draft. In my view the draft is immoral, pure and simple. This remains true if there is a war, or no war, and no matter whom it is applied to.

Like I said, girls are not required by law to register for the draft as boys are because of a clerical oversight that should be fixed.
Yes, it should be fixed - by abolishing the draft completely.

Now, are you going to slice this post up into sentences because you do not want to believe what I am saying?
No, but I am going to divide it up so that I can address the points you made one at a time.
 
You have a habit of confusing the draft with war.

No I don't. You have the habit of ignoring the purpose of things. That is like confusing nuclear arms with nuclear war. I don't confuse either of those as well.

We might not have a military one day if we do not have registration for a draft. Then no one will be around to fight in a war.

But this one comment was just a part of my larger argument and point. Too bad you have the habit of missing those. My comment, my post and my point is derailed. In your mind, you think you have responded to what I have said. You have not.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it should be fixed - by abolishing the draft completely.

What would you suggest we do if no one volunteers for the military one day and we have the need for an army?

What do you suggest we do if your volunteer army gets wiped out in a series of suprise attacks?
 
The Army Physical Fitness Test (APFT): Normative Data on 6022 Soldiers is a study conducted in 1944 by the US Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine in Natick, Massachusetts.

If there are better, more recent studies, I could not find them with the limited effort I was willing to put into my research.

There are eight sets of standards for both males and females, broken out by age. I analyzed only the youngest four age groups both because I was tired and because the n for females drops precipitously for the four higher age groups, so it is possible the numbers are different for the older ages.

My analysis was simple:

1. I ignored data for sit-ups since sarge's claim does not apply to that exercise.

2. For push-ups and the two-mile run I compared percentiles of bottom-performing males with the percentiles of women who exceeded that performance.

3. For bottom-performing males, the percentile I chose was the lowest percentile that still achieved the minimum passing score (60 points).

4. I have no hard numbers for sarge's claim except for the one mention of 10% and 10%, so my null hypothesis was that no more than 10% of women would exceed the bottom (but still passing) 10% of men.

Note: Given that the percentiles were based on actual performances and were rounded to 5 and 10 percentile groups, the raw scores don't always match exactly, so the analysis below includes some mild rounding.

Here is what I found:

Push-ups

Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males

Ages 22-26: 50% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 27-31: 15% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 32-36: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males


2 Mile Run

Ages 17-21: 10% of females beat the bottom 20% of males

Ages 22-26: 20% of females beat the bottom 10% of males

Ages 27-31: 30% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males

Ages 32-36: 20% of females equaled the bottom 10% of males


Conclusion: In no instance is the comparative performance as poor as 10% to 10% in the overlap.
I just saw that I misstated the date of the study. It is 1994, not 1944.
 
No I don't. You have the habit of ignoring the purpose of things. That is like confusing nuclear arms with nuclear war. I don't confuse either of those as well.
You certainly seem to. For example you assumed after my first post that because I was against the draft that I was a pacifist who opposed all war.

We might not have a military one day if we do not have registration for a draft. Then no one will be around to fight in a war.
If a country cannot raise a military from its own free citizens then it has no business attempting to fight a war.

But this one comment was just a part of my larger argument and point. Too bad you have the habit of missing those. My comment, my post and my point is derailed. In your mind, you think you have responded to what I have said. You have not.
I responded to the part that I wanted to contribute a thought on. That's how this works; you get to express whatever points you want however you want, and I get to respond to them in my own way. If you don't like my responses then you have the option to ignore them; you don't have the option to control my responses.

This is interesting. Name the ones you have "supported" and tell us how you have supported them and why.
Well I won't go through a list of every war in history, but a few examples would include the American war of independence, World War II, the Falklands war, the first Gulf war. I supported the second Gulf war at the time, but changed my mind about that one later on.

As to how, some of them happened before I was born so I'm limited to moral support. For the later ones my support was moral with some financial support.

What would you suggest we do if no one volunteers for the military one day and we have the need for an army?
I think that the situation you describe is a contradiction in terms. A country is it's people - a country cannot "need" anything that it's people do not want it to have. If the people want an army, they will volunteer and form an army. If they don't, then the country has no need of an army.

If the population of the country are unwilling to volunteer for the military then we do not have need of an army for we have nothing that the people believe is worth fighting for. If my country is invaded by oppressors and the people decline to fight for their freedom, then their freedom is unimportant to them and they deserve to be conquered.

What do you suggest we do if your volunteer army gets wiped out in a series of suprise attacks?
I would suggest that we ask for volunteers to replace it. And if we don't get them, see above.
 
You certainly seem to. For example you assumed after my first post that because I was against the draft that I was a pacifist who opposed all war.

That does not answer my question. How do you suppose to fight a war if your volunteer military cannot handle it for one reason or another?

I assumed you were opposed to war because I overestimated your capacity to have thought this through. If you are not opposed to war, and since you say you supported some war, how can you be opposed to the registration for the draft?
 
Last edited:
If a country cannot raise a military from its own free citizens then it has no business attempting to fight a war.

That does not make any sense! How do you define the "country"? Do you mean the people or the government? We are supposed to be a country by and for the people.

Are you against the government of a free society demanding of its citizens to take of arms and defend its freedom?
 
Last edited:
Well I won't go through a list of every war in history, but a few examples would include the American war of independence, World War II, the Falklands war, the first Gulf war. I supported the second Gulf war at the time, but changed my mind about that one later on.

Great. Beautiful. Let's start with the so-called "American war of indepencence". Why are you for this war? Were the American Colonists justified in not paying the British Tax? Let me guess, you are going to back out of this argument and eventually say that you do not know enough to support these wars. Let me guess also that you will say that you don't know any more about these wars than what you have been taught in school or were told on television. Am I right?
 
Last edited:
I would suggest that we ask for volunteers to replace it. And if we don't get them, see above.

What do you think about the slogan "freedom is not free"?

There is strength in numbers. No one is going to volunteer if they think they are the only ones and they are just going off to die. With a draft, on the other hand, everyone will be confident that they might come out alive. I think you believe in a fantasy.
 
One could do that, but it would be dishonest. I prefer to argue for what I think is right, rather than arguing for what I think is wrong in order to manipulate people into doing what I think is right.

Speaking of "right", albeit a different definition: Do you think it is a right or a privilege to live in a free society? What do you think of the expression, "Freedom is not Free"?
 
That does not answer my question. How do you suppose to fight a war if your volunteer military cannot handle it for one reason or another?
I don't seem to be making myself clear. Let me try again.

If you can't raise a volunteer army to fight a war, then you don't fight the war.

I assumed you were opposed to war because I overestimated your capacity to have thought this through. If you are not opposed to war, and since you say you supported some war, how can you be opposed to the registration for the draft?
It's really easy.

That does not make any sense! How do you define the "country"? Do you mean the people or the government? We are supposed to be a country by and for the people.
Sure it makes sense. The fact that the government derives its authority from the people is the whole point. If the people refuse to support a war by volunteering for it in sufficient numbers, then the government has no authority to fight it and must accept the consequences instead.

Are you against the government of a free society demanding of its citizens to take of arms and defend its freedom?
Yes, absolutely.

Great. Beautiful. Let's start with the so-called "American war of indepencence". Why are you for this war? Were the American Colonists justified in not paying the British Tax? Let me guess, you are going to back out of this argument and eventually say that you do not know enough to support these wars. Let me guess also that you will say that you don't know any more about these wars than what you have been taught in school or were told on television. Am I right?
I certainly don't claim any great mastery of history, if that's what you are trying to sledgehammer. I support the American war of independence because it was, in the very broadest sense, in the cause of increasing personal freedom. And yes, I know enough to know that it's highly simplistic to say that the war was fought over the idea of personal liberty and equality for all. But it's my view that it was foolish, in the long term, for Britain to expect to exert political control of the colonies directly. They were distant enough that they were always going to break off and go their own way in time. This to me seems a good thing, even if a system that favoured the rich landowners in a distant land was being exchanged for a system that favoured the rich landowners in America.

What do you think about the slogan "freedom is not free"?
I think it's a fine slogan, and very true. And I think that saying "you must fight for your freedom whether you like it or not" is an absurd and self contradictory statement, because if you are compelled to fight then you have already lost your freedom.

There is strength in numbers. No one is going to volunteer if they think they are the only ones and they are just going off to die. With a draft, on the other hand, everyone will be confident that they might come out alive.
I don't care. You seem to have trouble comprehending this, so let me say it once more very clearly : I would rather see every man woman and child in a country slaughtered to the last than see a draft imposed on them. It really is that simple. A people who won't volunteer to fight for their overseas interests don't deserve to have overseas interests. A people who won't volunteer to fight for their freedom don't deserve to have freedom. A people who won't volunteer to fight for their life don't deserve to have life.

There is strength in numbers? Sure, and if the cause is important enough that the people will fight for it, then there will be enough volunteers.

Speaking of "right", albeit a different definition: Do you think it is a right or a privilege to live in a free society? What do you think of the expression, "Freedom is not Free"?
I'm still in favour of the "Freedom is not Free" slogan. It's precisely because I'm for freedom that I think the government should not be able to take it away from the people by forcing them to enlist in the army if they don't choose to.
 
Bottom line - in this thread -you don't need to possess knowledge of anything other than one's own "feelings" to have an opinion.

Seis - You're entitled to your feelings, but you're completely wrong.
 
I don't seem to be making myself clear. Let me try again.

If you can't raise a volunteer army to fight a war, then you don't fight the war.

Here you go. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7371677#post7371677 Make your case there. See YA !!

You believe in magic more than psychology. Human beings are not willing to do what they should do because, mostly, human beings are stupid. That is why pure Deomcracies fail. That is why California is broke. People vote for benefits and then vote against paying for it. This reminds me very much of you.
 
Last edited:
Are you against the government of a free society demanding of its citizens to take of arms and defend its freedom?

Yes, absolutely.

Uh Huh. Are you against taxes too?

By the way, BStrong is not a sock puppet. I mean, I did not just create an account and log on with a different identity. There ARE some people in this world who do not disaree with me. But there are few because the humans species is not an intelligent one.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom