sarge
Penultimate Amazing
Sarge,
Stated in this manner, I have far less disagreement than before, though I could still argue about the meaning of “most” and what the actual numbers say as opposed to what the APFT card declares as standard.
"Most" as in "the most fit" rather than "most" as in "most women". In other words, the women that score the highest on any fitness test the Army is likely to devise will score at or below the level of the lowest scoring males that pass the same test.
And this, I think, may be one of the major sticking points for me. Regarding your first three categories, I have no problem admitting what I have already admitted: on average, men perform better than woman.
"On average", while accurate, is completely misleading. All but a handful of trained men will outperform all women on any test that measures the first three components of fitness.
What I take exception to comprises two things: (1) The use of the word "fit" to describe that performance. "Fit" assumes there is something it is meant to fit with; in this case, it is combat ability.
Not at all. There is a generally accepted definition for "physical fitness" that incorporates an ability to perform to some standard on a series of tests that measures between 5-7 components of "fitness". In my posts, "fitness" and "suitability" are not synonymous.
As I have said before, I doubt the current APFT's relevance in measuring that fitness.
The APFT is sufficient to measure the two components of fitness that we've already discussed. I may agree that the APFT is a poor measure of MOS specific physical suitability - indeed I made that argument many times during my career.
It is true however that the APFT is not entirely worthless as a predictor of suitability for some activities. Generally, someone that can only do 20 pushups (male or female) is less likely to perform successfully as a loader on an M1A2 than someone that can perform 100 pushups.
(2) The Body Composition component mystifies me. Unlike the other categories it is not a measurement of performance.
It is a predictor of performance. Very fit women have a higher body fat percentage than very fit men do, and high body fat percentages make cardioendurance events more difficult. This (and a 25% less efficient CV system) is the primary reaon that men significantly outperform women in running events. Indeed, body fat contents that reasonably fit men easily attain may be unhealthy for women to maintain. A 5% BFC for a fit male is fine, while a fit female may need to devote twice as much of her mass to fat.
It is hard to take this (from post #94) in any other fashion:
The comment from post #94 certainly says that, but it also says women are unfit for combat (in different words).
Only if you believe combat excludes all but Infantry/Armor/Artillery units.
Fewer than 3% of all female Soldiers possess the physical abilities to perform the full range of duties required of Infantrymen. I don't know the results of the Armor Branch tests. Ft Sill declined to participate. Integrating Infantry units to accomodate a handful of females (that we have no pressing need for) would be a social experiment rather than a force improvement initiative.
Women are undeniably suitable for combat duty, and they are undeniably fit enough for some combat MOSs. I am not expert on much more than IET and Infantry/Airborne matters, but I can see women performing all MP/Engineer/Aviation duties, and many Armor/Artillery jobs.
So I’ll recap my own position:
1. Regardless if the current APFT is a weak, strong, or non- indicator of fitness for combat, I hold that the overlap (of top female performers with bottom male performers) is larger than you imply. You haven't quantified it, but you have indicated it is only the fringe of each. At one point I think you said it is 10% and 10%.
The overlap of male/female performance on tests that measure muscular endurance, muscular strength, cardiovascular endurance. These are real components of fitness, and have nothing to do specifically with the APFT, nor do they necessarily have anything to do with suitability for any specific task or job.
The overlap for the other components of fitness is much wider, and in one component females are more "fit" than males - flexibility.
2. The current APFT is not in actuality a reliable measure of combat readiness.
The APFT is not a complete test of anything except the ability to perform pushups, situps, and run two miles nekkid.
Last edited: