Not in my experience, which is extensive.
Frankly, if you contest the notion that the most fit female Soldiers are less fit than the least fit Male Soldiers that meet the minimum standards, you do not have extensive experience on this subject.
Not that it should matter, but I am an expert at this. I was a career Army NCO. I was a Drill Sergeant, a basic training First Sergeant, a Training Battalion Sergeant Major, a graduate of (Ben Harrison version) and instructor at (Benning version) the MFTC.
Again, not in my experience. Can you point me to any of that research?
If you have any experience with combat-specific fitness and how the standards are developed for the tests measuring that fitness, you'd know how to find the actual research.
Rather than do the search and subsequent reading, take the simpler approach of looking at the basic APFT. The APFT standards are derived by testing thousands of Soldiers.
Compare the standards for a male to the standards for a female. A male Soldier makes the minimum possible passing score on the push-up event by completing 41 reps. A female Soldier of the same age scores the maximum possible score for exactly the same number of reps.
A female that completes a 2 mile run in 15:36 scores a maximum for this event. A male that completes the run in the same time just squeaks in to a passing score by a whopping 17 seconds.
So - the Army says right now that the most basic measure of fitness is performance on the APFT, and the Army conducted extensive research to determine what males and females are capable of scoring on the events that make up the APFT, and that research concluded that the most fit females are roughly on a par with the least fit males that actually meet the minimum standards. So - you will find a small percentage of females that can meet the standards, but most females are much less physically capable than their male counterparts.
Frankly, it is as nearly self-evident as something can be.
The Army is finally coming around to admitting that it's measure of combat-specific fitness is not only inadequate but misguided--an idea that has been rather obvious to most for a couple of decades at least.
The Army will change it's test and the events that the test is composed of. The Army will not make the test gender neutral - something I've long been a proponent of. The reason the Army will not do so is because making the test gender neutral will make female Soldiers uncompetative, period.
[quote[You are mixing terms, even if your concept is correct. Less strong does not equal less fit; it also does not equal less-capable.[/QUOTE]
I'm mixing nothing. You are confusing several components of fitness and assuming I am talking about physical strength. I am not. The APFT does not test muscular strength at all. It tests the muscular endurance of the shoulder girdle and abdomen and cardio-vascular endurance. Females are inferior in these areas.
Of course, male superiority in physical strength is even greater, but that is only important in a few specific instances. For that reason, muscular strength is not mesured in any official test.