Woman and the Military Draft

The bad part is that anybody, anywhere has to register for the draft. IMO there are no circumstances in which a draft is ever justified.

If the alternative is genocide, and in some current instances that is a real concern, your opinion may not withstand reality.
 
Crossbow, what exactly is your point? Are you saying that there is no draft or are you saying that it is OK that women are not required to register for the draft? Do you have a point?

Just because no one is being drafted does not mean there is no draft. Nuclear weapons have not gone off in war time for a long time either. But we have them standing by. The registration for the draft is a deteriant as well.

So do you think it is OK that women don't have to register for the draft? If registration for the draft is a meaningless gesture, then why not have then do it as men are required by law to do it?
 
Last edited:
Seismosaurus, do you mean now or do you mean ever?

Was the draft in WWII a bad thing? Going to war with Japan was bad, IYO? A japanese officer who was there (when the treaty was signed) later told the emperior that McAuthor said that in time Japan and the USA would be friends. the officer and the emperior agreed that it was a good thing that the USA had won the war because the Japanese would have wanted to enslave us. That was the story I was told.

The bad part is that anybody, anywhere has to register for the draft. IMO there are no circumstances in which a draft is ever justified.

Even if the volunteer force gets wiped out and a horde of Somali pirates are on their way to rape and kill our kids? If that is not bad enough, I think I can imagine worse if you give me time.

You see, you are, in fact, violently forcing your passificism on others. Isn't that much more barbaic than a draft?
 
Last edited:
Ideally, our standing army should consist only of a command and logistics structure with a reasonably large training cadre of professionals, a quick reaction force of a few thousand and massive reserve units which can be mobilized within a day. The original intent from the time the Constitution was ratified was that every citizen had an obligation to answer thehue and cry to repel invasion or suppress insurrection. THe old sheriff's posse was based on the same Anglo-Saxon tradition.

What I would like to see is a mandatory training requirement for every citizen and resident allien on graduation from high school, but expand it to service in public safety in general. Assign each person to a unit and require that they fall in for reserve unit training each year. When an emergency is declared, the standing forces would be the first on the ground, to be relieved or augmented by the reserve units, which shall be de-mobilized when the emergency is over. Each person would recieve active duty pay for the time they are on training or deployed.

This would also make available a trained force to deal with massive disasters like floods, wildfires earth quakes and floods and hurricanes.

As a penalty, those who refuse military or public safety service would not be eleigible to posess a driver's license, to vote or to own a firearm of any description. (The 2nd Ammendment is about the need for an armed militia, after all.)

Sure would cut the defense budget, wouldn't it?

A bit more focussed and limited than what I was talking about, but close enough to contribute to the discussion of a manditory National Service concept.
 
I don't want to follow this tangent very far, but the distribution of relevant physical attributes of men and women are overlapping curves. Even if the mean of the women's curve is lower than that of men, most of the area overlaps. Some men deemed fit for combat service are physically inferior to some women. So thinking in general is simply prejudiced when applied to individuals, isn't it?




While they can't legally, my understanding is that they have in reality been doing so for some time.





I remember reading a Phyllis Schlafly column once against allowing women into combat service (or maybe she was even in favor of a broader prohibition of women in the military). She said that being a soldier is the business of killing, and women shouldn't be in the business of killing.

And men should?

Women have been, at times, proven capable of being quite lethal. Even more so than men. Sugar and spice can be over hyped. Read about female poisoners, that will curl your hair.
 
Seismosaurus, do you mean now or do you mean ever?
I mean ever.

Was the draft in WWII a bad thing?
Yes it was, in my opinion. Otherwise I would have said "there are no circumstances in which a draft is ever justified... except for when it is."

Going to war with Japan was bad, IYO?
Oh no, I'm perfectly fine with the US going to war with other countries if it's justified in doing so, and it was in WWII. I don't disagree with war, I disagree with the draft.

I have no problem with governments using force to defend themselves, and I have no real problem with a government using force to protect its vital interests. I even have no real problem with a government using force for what it considers moral reasons - to stop a dictator mistreating his own people, say.

What I have a very great issue with is a government telling its own people that they consider ANY issue so overwhelmingly important that the people must support it or be punished. A draft is slavery, pure and simple, and as Robert Heinlein put it : "If a country can't save itself through the volunteer service of its own free people, then I say : Let the damned thing go down the drain!"

Even if the volunteer force gets wiped out and a horde of Somali pirates are on their way to rape and kill our kids?
Yes, even then.

If that is not bad enough, I think I can imagine worse if you give me time.
Go ahead.

You see, you are, in fact, violently forcing your passificism on others. Isn't that much more barbaic than a draft?
Um, I am not a pacificst in any way, shape or form. So no.
 
Last edited:
If the alternative is genocide, and in some current instances that is a real concern, your opinion may not withstand reality.
If the people of your or my country are so unconcerned with genocide that they won't volunteer to stop it, then so be it.
 
Sarge was making a generalization, which is true. Of course not ALL males are better then ALL females. But the majority of males are indeed stronger physically then [sic] females.

Except that he specifically said "not just in average". Again, that means no overlap in the curves. It doesn't mean a fast 400 m by a male is faster than all females; it means the slowest male 400m time is faster than all females.

Since not ALL males are physically superior to ALL females, the military's prohibition against women in combat has to be a bias that works against some females. That is, there are some females physically superior to males in combat who are excluded.

Except, as noted, it doesn't really happen that way in real life, which is even worse. It's strictly then a barrier to advancement for women's military careers.
 
No - it is correct. While there is overlap, it occurs in the top end of females and the bottom end of males among the physically fit.
Not in my experience, which is extensive.


sarge said:
Among Soldiers that meet the APFT standards, the most fit females are not quite as fit as the least fit males, and this is supported by dozens of years of actual research.
Again, not in my experience. Can you point me to any of that research?


sarge said:
The Army's conducted numerous long-term studies, and the reuslt is always the same: using the Army's version of events that measure combat-specific fitness, the most fit female Soldiers are less fit than the least fit male Soldiers that still meet minimum standards. The lone exception is in abdominal and hip flexor endurance (measured by the bent leg situp).
The Army is finally coming around to admitting that it's measure of combat-specific fitness is not only inadequate but misguided--an idea that has been rather obvious to most for a couple of decades at least.


sarge said:
You can certainly find exceptional females that meet minimum standards for males, but the normal female of above average fitness is still less fit than the normal male at the bottom end of the fitness scale.
You are mixing terms, even if your concept is correct. Less strong does not equal less fit; it also does not equal less-capable.
 
Even if the volunteer force gets wiped out and a horde of Somali pirates are on their way to rape and kill our kids? If that is not bad enough, I think I can imagine worse if you give me time.

In terms of ridiculous fantasies I've read here, this one is pretty up there.

Yes, Somali pirates in dinghies are crossing oceans to land an amphibious assault on America, defeat the most overfunded military in the world, and nothing is in between them and literally raping every woman and child. This truly is a realistic scenario.

Next up: Greenland invades China.
 
Last edited:
Not in my experience, which is extensive.


Again, not in my experience. Can you point me to any of that research?


The Army is finally coming around to admitting that it's measure of combat-specific fitness is not only inadequate but misguided--an idea that has been rather obvious to most for a couple of decades at least.


You are mixing terms, even if your concept is correct. Less strong does not equal less fit; it also does not equal less-capable.

May I ask what your experience is exactly? Are you suggesting that it is actually WOMEN who are superior to men? Or do you think they are on the same level as men? In my 5 years experience in the Army, I have seen and worked with literally thousands of soldiers who have taken the Army PT test, both men and women. In my experience, I have seen a total of two women who could max their PT test. If their score was applied to the male scale, they would have failed the PT test miserably.

Hell, track and field is the basics of physical performance. Running, throwing, jumping, etc. Go to any high school track meet or college track meet, and look at the differences in times and distances between females and males. If the males were put against the females, the females would basically look like children in comparison to the males. This is fact, and it is indisputable. Like I said before, I ran faster then any woman in the history of planet earth when I was simply a junior in high school. So what exactly is your position?
 
Except that he specifically said "not just in average". Again, that means no overlap in the curves. It doesn't mean a fast 400 m by a male is faster than all females; it means the slowest male 400m time is faster than all females.

You are either mistaking what "not just in the average means" or you failed to read my subsequent clarifying posts.

There is overlap in the range of fitness for male and female Soldiers, but that overlap occurs well south of the middle of the pack for fit male Soldiers. The most fit female Soldiers are most often not quite as fit as the least fit of the male Soldiers that meet the minimum APFT standards, except for the event that specifically measures abdominal/hip flexor endurance.

Since not ALL males are physically superior to ALL females, the military's prohibition against women in combat has to be a bias that works against some females. That is, there are some females physically superior to males in combat who are excluded.

The military is not a platform for social change, and nor should it be unless the change is incidental to some gain in military efficiency. The number of women Soldiers that can successfully perform the full range of duties of Infantry/Artillery/Tank Crewman duties without compromising standards is too small to warrant risking the disruption and expense that integrating these MOSs would entail.

So - discriminatory, yes. Necessarily so.

Except, as noted, it doesn't really happen that way in real life, which is even worse. It's strictly then a barrier to advancement for women's military careers.


Here in the real world, female Soldiers are actually inferior to male Soldiers. Not sure what "real life" you are talking about.

The services practice discrimination. Age, gender, and body composition are all barriers to service. These barriers are performance based, and contribute to a more efficient force. That is all the justification necessary to exclude all women from some jobs even though a very small population of women might meet the minimum standards for these jobs.
 
Not in my experience, which is extensive.

Frankly, if you contest the notion that the most fit female Soldiers are less fit than the least fit Male Soldiers that meet the minimum standards, you do not have extensive experience on this subject.

Not that it should matter, but I am an expert at this. I was a career Army NCO. I was a Drill Sergeant, a basic training First Sergeant, a Training Battalion Sergeant Major, a graduate of (Ben Harrison version) and instructor at (Benning version) the MFTC.


Again, not in my experience. Can you point me to any of that research?

If you have any experience with combat-specific fitness and how the standards are developed for the tests measuring that fitness, you'd know how to find the actual research.

Rather than do the search and subsequent reading, take the simpler approach of looking at the basic APFT. The APFT standards are derived by testing thousands of Soldiers.

Compare the standards for a male to the standards for a female. A male Soldier makes the minimum possible passing score on the push-up event by completing 41 reps. A female Soldier of the same age scores the maximum possible score for exactly the same number of reps.

A female that completes a 2 mile run in 15:36 scores a maximum for this event. A male that completes the run in the same time just squeaks in to a passing score by a whopping 17 seconds.

So - the Army says right now that the most basic measure of fitness is performance on the APFT, and the Army conducted extensive research to determine what males and females are capable of scoring on the events that make up the APFT, and that research concluded that the most fit females are roughly on a par with the least fit males that actually meet the minimum standards. So - you will find a small percentage of females that can meet the standards, but most females are much less physically capable than their male counterparts.

Frankly, it is as nearly self-evident as something can be.


The Army is finally coming around to admitting that it's measure of combat-specific fitness is not only inadequate but misguided--an idea that has been rather obvious to most for a couple of decades at least.

The Army will change it's test and the events that the test is composed of. The Army will not make the test gender neutral - something I've long been a proponent of. The reason the Army will not do so is because making the test gender neutral will make female Soldiers uncompetative, period.


[quote[You are mixing terms, even if your concept is correct. Less strong does not equal less fit; it also does not equal less-capable.[/QUOTE]

I'm mixing nothing. You are confusing several components of fitness and assuming I am talking about physical strength. I am not. The APFT does not test muscular strength at all. It tests the muscular endurance of the shoulder girdle and abdomen and cardio-vascular endurance. Females are inferior in these areas.

Of course, male superiority in physical strength is even greater, but that is only important in a few specific instances. For that reason, muscular strength is not mesured in any official test.
 
May I ask what your experience is exactly?
9 years active duty as an officer in the Army. 18 years since then as an officer in the Reserves, including deployments.

Quad4_72 said:
Are you suggesting that it is actually WOMEN who are superior to men? Or do you think they are on the same level as men?
Neither. The subject of my objections was quite clear: Sarge's claim that "the overlap" is only at the lower margins of male fitness and the upper margins of female fitness. I expanded my objection to include his mixing of the terms "fitness" and "strength."


Quad4_72 said:
In my 5 years experience in the Army, I have seen and worked with literally thousands of soldiers who have taken the Army PT test, both men and women. In my experience, I have seen a total of two women who could max their PT test. If their score was applied to the male scale, they would have failed the PT test miserably.
I don't know if I've observed "literally thousands," but I've observed a lot. I've observed far more than two females who maxed the PT test. And, yes, if the female scores were moved to the male standards, the female scores would be lower. That wasn't the claim, nor my point.


Quad4_72 said:
Hell, track and field is the basics of physical performance. Running, throwing, jumping, etc. Go to any high school track meet or college track meet, and look at the differences in times and distances between females and males. If the males were put against the females, the females would basically look like children in comparison to the males. This is fact, and it is indisputable.
Your hyperbole isn't fact (they would not look like children in comparison), but I don't disagree with your point. Your point, however, is irrelevant to mine and to Sarge's.

You are comparing athletic women to athletic men. I agree that for the most part women will come out on the low end.

What I don't agree with is Sarge's claim that the overlap of fitness encompasses only the lower end of males and the higher end of females.


Quad4_72 said:
Like I said before, I ran faster then any woman in the history of planet earth when I was simply a junior in high school.
Marvelous.


Quad4_72 said:
So what exactly is your position?
There are two, both in relation to Sarge's claim.

1. Strength does not equal fitness

2. That part of the Venn Diagram which includes women who are more fit than men (and those men) includes more than just the very lowest performing men and more than just the very highest performing women.
 
The Army will change it's test and the events that the test is composed of. The Army will not make the test gender neutral - something I've long been a proponent of. The reason the Army will not do so is because making the test gender neutral will make female Soldiers uncompetative, period.

See, I heard that the Army was thinking about making the test gender neutral. That means one of two things. It means that either it will be REALLY easy for males to pass, making the Army less efficient, or it will be EXTREMELY difficult for females to pass, leading to an overall more efficient Army.
 
/
Frankly, if you contest the notion that the most fit female Soldiers are less fit than the least fit Male Soldiers that meet the minimum standards, you do not have extensive experience on this subject.
Ah. The old If you disagree you don't have the chops to be in the debate gambit. I have used it once on this forum as I recall. I still regret it. It is so obvious a fallacy as to make using it shameful.


sarge said:
Not that it should matter, but I am an expert at this. I was a career Army NCO. I was a Drill Sergeant, a basic training First Sergeant, a Training Battalion Sergeant Major, a graduate of (Ben Harrison version) and instructor at (Benning version) the MFTC.
I stipulate that you have more direct experience than I do in Army Fitness training and testing.


sarge said:
If you have any experience with combat-specific fitness and how the standards are developed for the tests measuring that fitness, you'd know how to find the actual research.
I've done so (looked up the research) in the long ago past. As I am not the one making the claim here, I don't feel inclined to do your work for you.


sarge said:
Rather than do the search and subsequent reading, take the simpler approach of looking at the basic APFT. The APFT standards are derived by testing thousands of Soldiers.
Looking at it? I have taken it and administered it hundreds of times. My latest was back in April.


Sarge said:
Compare the standards for a male to the standards for a female. A male Soldier makes the minimum possible passing score on the push-up event by completing 41 reps. A female Soldier of the same age scores the maximum possible score for exactly the same number of reps.

A female that completes a 2 mile run in 15:36 scores a maximum for this event. A male that completes the run in the same time just squeaks in to a passing score by a whopping 17 seconds.
Ah, yes. Females have lower standards for the 2 mile run and the push-ups. So do older males like me. There is no question I am no longer able to compete with the top young males (or females for that matter) on how fast I run, and if my scores were transcribed to the toughest age group standards I would likely fail at least one event. Even so, without even maxing out my own PT standards I still beat more than a few of the younger males on every event. And I can still out-ruckmarch most of the young males who are faster than I am.

Just like the overlap for females and males, the overlap for older and younger males encompasses more than just the fringes.


Sarge said:
So - the Army says right now that the most basic measure of fitness is performance on the APFT,
No. Right now they say they've been wrong, which is something that many people have been saying for a long term.

From this link:
Today's PT test does not adequately measure components of strength, endurance, or mobility. The events have a low correlation to the performance of warrior tasks and battle drills and are not strong predictors of successful physical performance on the battlefield or in full spectrum operations," said Lt. Gen. Mark P. Hertling, TRADOC's deputy commanding general for Initial Military Training, who holds a master's degree in exercise physiology.
I knew LTG Hertling when he was BG Hertling at the 1AD in Iraq. Good man, and smart. Helped me out a bit when I needed it.



Sarge said:
and the Army conducted extensive research to determine what males and females are capable of scoring on the events that make up the APFT,
Yes. Scores on the APFT. Not actual fitness, despite the name. I can still do more push-ups than most of my far more muscular friends. Does that mean I have more upper body strength? I can guarantee it did not.


Sarge said:
and that research concluded that the most fit females are roughly on a par with the least fit males that actually meet the minimum standards.
And it is this research I am asking you to show me.


Sarge said:
So - you will find a small percentage of females that can meet the standards, but most females are much less physically capable than their male counterparts.

Frankly, it is as nearly self-evident as something can be.
That women will perform more poorly on average than men on events designed to maximize male physiology? No doubt.

But I thought we were talking about fitness, not an ability to pass an Army test.


Sarge said:
The Army will change it's test and the events that the test is composed of. The Army will not make the test gender neutral - something I've long been a proponent of. The reason the Army will not do so is because making the test gender neutral will make female Soldiers uncompetative, period.
Possibly. I've no doubt that on average women will still perform to a lower standard than men on at least the push-up event and probably the 1.5 mile run.


Sarge said:
Garrette said:
You are mixing terms, even if your concept is correct. Less strong does not equal less fit; it also does not equal less-capable.

I'm mixing nothing. You are confusing several components of fitness and assuming I am talking about physical strength. I am not. The APFT does not test muscular strength at all. It tests the muscular endurance of the shoulder girdle and abdomen and cardio-vascular endurance. Females are inferior in these areas.
I will concede this point and admit I misspoke.

Please see my response to Quad4_72 above.
 
Last edited:
See, I heard that the Army was thinking about making the test gender neutral. That means one of two things. It means that either it will be REALLY easy for males to pass, making the Army less efficient, or it will be EXTREMELY difficult for females to pass, leading to an overall more efficient Army.
My hope is for something different. That the test were to be gender neutral and that standards applied to specialties.

You want to stay a treadhead? You need to do x on the test.

You want to stay a grunt? You need to do y (slightly different from x) on the test.

You want to stay an Intel weenie? You only need to do z, which is still greater than failing because everybody's got to be able to do at least the minimum fighting stuff.
 
Ah, yes. Females have lower standards for the 2 mile run and the push-ups. So do older males like me. There is no question I am no longer able to compete with the top young males (or females for that matter) on how fast I run, and if my scores were transcribed to the toughest age group standards I would likely fail at least one event. Even so, without even maxing out my own PT standards I still beat more than a few of the younger males on every event. And I can still out-ruckmarch most of the young males who are faster than I am.

Just like the overlap for females and males, the overlap for older and younger males encompasses more than just the fringes.

Frankly, you just proved my point. Females are less fit than males using the Army's current standard for fitness. Females are not only less fit than males in general, the method used to derive the standards for the test show that the most fit females are just about as fit as the least fit males.

If the Army changes the definition of "fitness", and makes the physical activities that women are less far behind in more important, then females will be closer to even with men. Right now, however, it is conclusive - the most fit female Soldiers are at best on a par with the least fit male Soldiers that meet at least the minimum standard. That has been my only contention, and I am correct.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom