Woman and the Military Draft

So we should eliminate public education and manditory attendance?
No, I think it's reasonable for education to be mandatory up until age 16. Beyond that, no. Children are generally not the best judges of how they should spend their time and talents. Paternalism has a place: In the raising of children, not in the control of adults.



Expect,...no. Advocate for and support, sure.
That's your right. I shall advocate against it. If it were to become law I would resist it and advocate for its repeal.
 
Do I need to elaborate? I was thinking of just asking some politicians of what they thought. I could not see myself doing it but somehow I can see Moore doing a project like that.
 
Democracy Succeed by not wasting time on unimportant issues.

Uh huh.

To each his own. I had close friends die in training exercises that were too war-like to women to be in. I say we share the cost across the board.

Are women too valuable because they have a womb? Are we really a notch below Neanderthals?
 
This is not true in the modern hi-tech military. I would have to disagree with everything you have said. My example of Israel proves you wrong. I saw women in jumpsuits armed with machine guns patroling the streets in Haifa. They were just as tough if not tougher than men.

This statement is not based on fact. It is a fact that women are not as physically strong as men. Just because you saw a woman patrolling a street does not make her "Tough if not tougher" then anyone. You just made that up. Let's see this woman hump that machine gun along with 85 more lbs of gear up a mountain in Afghanistan.
 
Uh huh.

To each his own. I had close friends die in training exercises that were too war-like to women to be in. I say we share the cost across the board.

Are women too valuable because they have a womb? Are we really a notch below Neanderthals?

You are talking about women serving in combat positions. That is a totally separate issue from registering for Selective Service. Goalpost movement noted.
 
Random interjections of fact and opinion:

1. Women are physically inferior to men in most all ways that matter, if the test is ground dismounted combat, and not just in the average. The most fit 10% of American female Soldiers are physically inferior to the least fit 10% of American male Soldiers. Toss in mechanically aided combat, and there is no physical impediment to women serving in combat. Tanks, HMMWVs, Planes, Helicopters - women can operate (and fight) these as well as men.

2. There is no need for a draft, and in the absence of need for a draft, a draft causes more problems than it solves.

3. Sending every recently graduated American to some form of mandatory Basic Training would be disruptive for the Armed Services, hugely expensive for no real gain, and an unjustifiable intrusion on the right to persue happiness.
 
So we should eliminate public education and manditory attendance?
No, I think it's reasonable for education to be mandatory up until age 16. Beyond that, no. Children are generally not the best judges of how they should spend their time and talents. Paternalism has a place: In the raising of children, not in the control of adults.

Largely agreed, our primary difference is in what we consider mature adults and what we consider to be children. For instance, frontal lobe development is not complete (on average) until the late twenties, and one of its primarily responsibilities is for judgement in decision making. In many ways, what I propose is nothing more than a form of manditory Preparatory Schooling for being an independent, self-sufficient and responsible adult citizen in our nation. More schooling and skills training than Boot Camp (though as most who have experienced boot camp acknowledge, that is all that boot camp is as well, the emphasis is just on military schooling and skills training).

That's your right. I shall advocate against it. If it were to become law I would resist it and advocate for its repeal.

I would expect no less, though I suspect that after the patella twitching reflex fades, and the issues are more fully expanded, that many of the objections would become much less strident.

Along these lines, for those that have commented to the effect that manditory conscription would be a large burden, of little benefit, to the military, I'd like to put forth a response in connection to my manditory National Service proposal.

First, and perhaps foremost, though there would be military feedback into the process, I wouldn't expect there to be much, if any, direct military involvement in this 2 year National Service period I am proposing, and even for those who elect to enter the military training option during their National Service commitment, it would be more accurate to view this as a preliminary preparation for later potential military service, than as a actual military service. So this proposal would not place any additional burdens on the military, but would provide them with a source of prequalified and preprocessed recruits predisposed and much better prepared to enter military service careers after they have completed their National Service obligations.
 
Random interjections of fact and opinion:

1. Women are physically inferior to men in most all ways that matter, if the test is ground dismounted combat, and not just in the average. The most fit 10% of American female Soldiers are physically inferior to the least fit 10% of American male Soldiers. Toss in mechanically aided combat, and there is no physical impediment to women serving in combat. Tanks, HMMWVs, Planes, Helicopters - women can operate (and fight) these as well as men.

I agree with you with all except the highlighted part. Tanks actually require a great deal of strength to man. For example, uploading 30+ rounds of ammo into the semi ready and ready racks can be quite taxing. Not to mention PROFICIENT continuous loading of the rounds in combat takes a great deal of upper body strength. Then throw in having to change a road wheel or break track in a combat situation (All require a great deal of upper body strength) I would not lump tanks in with the other vehicles you mentioned. Not to mention if you ever had to pull an injured 200lb man out of the drivers hole or the gunners station that is an EXTREMELY difficult task, even for strong males. And that is probably the main reason why I would not want a female on my tank. Just a little friendly knowledge you can throw in the brain vault :)
 
I'm certainly no defender of most of what Bill Thompson says, but this is silly.

The only point of Selective Service registration is to be ready in case the draft is re-instituted. As such, it is perfectly proper to refer to it as "draft registration", and that is certainly conventional usage.

I am not trying to be obtuse or obstinate, instead I am just trying to be precise.

Therefore, I suggest that you check out what 'Selective Service Registration' is yourself, and here is an excellent starting point:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_Service_System

The Selective Service System is a means by which the United States government maintains information on those potentially subject to military conscription. Most male U.S. citizens and male immigrant non-citizens between the ages of 18 to 25 are required by law to have registered within 30 days of their 18th birthday. As of the end of 2008, the names and addresses of over 14 million men are on file.

Registration for Selective Service is also required for various federal programs and benefits, including student loans, job training, federal employment, and naturalization.

The Selective Service System provides the names of all registrants to the Joint Advertising Marketing Research & Studies (JAMRS) program for inclusion in the JAMRS Consolidated Recruitment Database. The names are distributed to the Services for recruiting purposes on a quarterly basis.

...

Note the terms "those potentially subject to conscription", as opposed to terms such as "those subject to conscription". In other words, there has to be some sort of additional legislation passed in order institute conscription.

And sorry, but that is a mighty big step.

Therefore, I really do not think that it is accurate to refer to 'Selective Service Registration' as 'Draft Registration' since the draft ended about 40 years ago and it is not likely to be reinstated anytime in the foreseeable furture.

Now it is true that back when there was a draft, most people referred to 'Selective Service Registration' as 'Registering for the Draft', but that was then and this is now.
 
Random interjections of fact and opinion:

1. Women are physically inferior to men in most all ways that matter, if the test is ground dismounted combat, and not just in the average.

This is false. What you're saying is that there is no overlap, and there most certainly is. This is the same as saying every woman is physically superior to every man. (Picture two bell curves where the right tail of the women's curve lies wholly to the left of the left tail of the men's curve.)

I can prove it is false, therefore, by showing just one single example of a woman that is not physically inferior to a man. Linky.

Here is that example: in a recent local triathlon, the top female finished second overall. That is, she beat all the elite male athletes except for one.
 
@crossbow:

If the government selects persons for service who have registered for selective service, how is that not a draft?

Here is what I think. I think you found out you messed up and you are using word games to save face. Am I right?

No you are not right.

However, you have never let a minor thing like being wrong in the past prevent you from being wrong in the future.
 
I am not trying to be obtuse or obstinate, instead I am just trying to be precise.
No. It is an abuse of the conventions of language to say that "Selective Service registration" is not "draft registration".

And, for purposes of this discussion, it's ridiculous to argue the point, because when someone uses the term "draft registration" in the U.S., we all know exactly what it means. (Again, the conventions of language.)

Read the mission statement of the Selective Service System. Its only purpose is to be prepared for the re-institution of a draft. There is no other purpose for its existence or for the registration.

ETA: As evidence that this is conventionally accepted usage, I will list a few links to mainstream news media headlines using the term "draft registration" (or variants) in headlines:

http://news.google.com/newspapers?i...1137&dq=draft+registration+requirements&hl=en

http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/bostonh...+falls+short+in+Mass.+and+nation&pqatl=google

http://www2.wsav.com/news/2011/jul/11/today-in-history-ar-1352061/
 
Last edited:
This is false. What you're saying is that there is no overlap, and there most certainly is. This is the same as saying every woman is physically superior to every man. (Picture two bell curves where the right tail of the women's curve lies wholly to the left of the left tail of the men's curve.)

I can prove it is false, therefore, by showing just one single example of a woman that is not physically inferior to a man. Linky.

Here is that example: in a recent local triathlon, the top female finished second overall. That is, she beat all the elite male athletes except for one.

Sarge was making a generalization, which is true. Of course not ALL males are better then ALL females. But the majority of males are indeed stronger physically then females. Since you want to use racing as an example, let me give you one as well. When I was in high school, as a junior I ran my 800m in 1:51.79 and my 400m in 47.18. That means I had ran faster then any woman in the history of planet Earth as a junior in high school. Women and men simply don't compare physically. This is a fact of life. Deal with it.
 
This is false. What you're saying is that there is no overlap, and there most certainly is. This is the same as saying every woman is physically superior to every man. (Picture two bell curves where the right tail of the women's curve lies wholly to the left of the left tail of the men's curve.)

I can prove it is false, therefore, by showing just one single example of a woman that is not physically inferior to a man. Linky.

Here is that example: in a recent local triathlon, the top female finished second overall. That is, she beat all the elite male athletes except for one.


No - it is correct. While there is overlap, it occurs in the top end of females and the bottom end of males among the physically fit.

Among Soldiers that meet the APFT standards, the most fit females are not quite as fit as the least fit males, and this is supported by dozens of years of actual research. The Army's conducted numerous long-term studies, and the reuslt is always the same: using the Army's version of events that measure combat-specific fitness, the most fit female Soldiers are less fit than the least fit male Soldiers that still meet minimum standards. The lone exception is in abdominal and hip flexor endurance (measured by the bent leg situp).

You can certainly find exceptional females that meet minimum standards for males, but the normal female of above average fitness is still less fit than the normal male at the bottom end of the fitness scale.
 
No. It is an abuse of the conventions of language to say that "Selective Service registration" is not "draft registration".

And, for purposes of this discussion, it's ridiculous to argue the point, because when someone uses the term "draft registration" in the U.S., we all know exactly what it means. (Again, the conventions of language.)

Read the mission statement of the Selective Service System. Its only purpose is to be prepared for the re-institution of a draft. There is no other purpose for its existence or for the registration.

ETA: As evidence that this is conventionally accepted usage, I will list a few links to mainstream news media headlines using the term "draft registration" (or variants) in headlines:

http://news.google.com/newspapers?i...1137&dq=draft+registration+requirements&hl=en

http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/bostonh...+falls+short+in+Mass.+and+nation&pqatl=google

http://www2.wsav.com/news/2011/jul/11/today-in-history-ar-1352061/

Wow! I do not why this is so hard to understand, so let me put it this way ...

If one wishes (such as you are doing) to say that in the venacular that the terms 'Selective Service Registration' and 'Registration for the Draft' are the same terms, then one can indeed make a good case for doing so.

Indeed, I have no problem with that either provided that it is clear to everyone concerned that vernacular terminology is being used.

However, if one wishes (such as I have been doing all along) to use the actual meaning of the terms 'Selective Service Registration' and 'Registration for the Draft', then one must conclude that these are two different things.

After all, one cannot register for something that does not exist. And specifically in this case, since the draft does not exist, therefore one is not registering for the draft; rather one is being registered in a system that just may, possibly, but is very unlikely, to be used in a draft (which ended in 1973).

Furthermore, when you tell me (or anyone else) to "Read the mission statement of the Selective Service System" (which I have done by the way) then in order to accurately understand such text, then one must drop the venacular terminology and use the actual terminology (which is just waht I have been doing all along).

Whew! I hope that is clear now.
 
If one wishes (such as you are doing) to say that in the venacular that the terms 'Selective Service Registration' and 'Registration for the Draft' are the same terms, then one can indeed make a good case for doing so.

Indeed, I have no problem with that either provided that it is clear to everyone concerned that vernacular terminology is being used.

It most certainly is clear how it's being used in this thread.

And you most certainly did object to it:
You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft. Instead, men are required to register for 'Selective Service' which is not a draft.

However, if one wishes (such as I have been doing all along) to use the actual meaning of the terms 'Selective Service Registration' and 'Registration for the Draft', then one must conclude that these are two different things.
Nonsense. If the draft were reinstated, the Selective Service System would not be disbanded and all its registration information tossed out and a completely new registration system initiated. Registering with Selective Service is logically and by convention (which is how language works) legitimately referred to as "draft registration".

After all, one cannot register for something that does not exist.
Why not?

That is exactly the purpose of the Selective Service System: to be prepared in case the draft is reinstated.

Seriously, it's a silly point. There was no confusion.

I turned 18 exactly in 1979 when draft registration was re-started, and it has conventionally been referred to that way or as registration with the Selective Service since.
 
Ideally, our standing army should consist only of a command and logistics structure with a reasonably large training cadre of professionals, a quick reaction force of a few thousand and massive reserve units which can be mobilized within a day. The original intent from the time the Constitution was ratified was that every citizen had an obligation to answer thehue and cry to repel invasion or suppress insurrection. THe old sheriff's posse was based on the same Anglo-Saxon tradition.

What I would like to see is a mandatory training requirement for every citizen and resident allien on graduation from high school, but expand it to service in public safety in general. Assign each person to a unit and require that they fall in for reserve unit training each year. When an emergency is declared, the standing forces would be the first on the ground, to be relieved or augmented by the reserve units, which shall be de-mobilized when the emergency is over. Each person would recieve active duty pay for the time they are on training or deployed.

This would also make available a trained force to deal with massive disasters like floods, wildfires earth quakes and floods and hurricanes.

As a penalty, those who refuse military or public safety service would not be eleigible to posess a driver's license, to vote or to own a firearm of any description. (The 2nd Ammendment is about the need for an armed militia, after all.)

Sure would cut the defense budget, wouldn't it?
 
Ideally, our standing army should consist only of a command and logistics structure with a reasonably large training cadre of professionals, a quick reaction force of a few thousand and massive reserve units which can be mobilized within a day. The original intent from the time the Constitution was ratified was that every citizen had an obligation to answer thehue and cry to repel invasion or suppress insurrection. THe old sheriff's posse was based on the same Anglo-Saxon tradition.

What I would like to see is a mandatory training requirement for every citizen and resident allien on graduation from high school, but expand it to service in public safety in general. Assign each person to a unit and require that they fall in for reserve unit training each year. When an emergency is declared, the standing forces would be the first on the ground, to be relieved or augmented by the reserve units, which shall be de-mobilized when the emergency is over. Each person would recieve active duty pay for the time they are on training or deployed.

This would also make available a trained force to deal with massive disasters like floods, wildfires earth quakes and floods and hurricanes.

As a penalty, those who refuse military or public safety service would not be eleigible to posess a driver's license, to vote or to own a firearm of any description. (The 2nd Ammendment is about the need for an armed militia, after all.)

Sure would cut the defense budget, wouldn't it?

I agree with everything you posted, except I and the SC disagree with the bolded portion.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/07-290.ZS.html

Held:

1. The Second Amendment protects an individual right to possess a firearm unconnected with service in a militia, and to use that arm for traditionally lawful purposes, such as self-defense within the home. Pp. 2–53.

(a) The Amendment’s prefatory clause announces a purpose, but does not limit or expand the scope of the second part, the operative clause. The operative clause’s text and history demonstrate that it connotes an individual right to keep and bear arms. Pp. 2–22.

(b) The prefatory clause comports with the Court’s interpretation of the operative clause. The “militia” comprised all males physically capable of acting in concert for the common defense. The Antifederalists feared that the Federal Government would disarm the people in order to disable this citizens’ militia, enabling a politicized standing army or a select militia to rule. The response was to deny Congress power to abridge the ancient right of individuals to keep and bear arms, so that the ideal of a citizens’ militia would be preserved. Pp. 22–28.

(c) The Court’s interpretation is confirmed by analogous arms-bearing rights in state constitutions that preceded and immediately followed the Second Amendment . Pp. 28–30.

(d) The Second Amendment ’s drafting history, while of dubious interpretive worth, reveals three state Second Amendment proposals that unequivocally referred to an individual right to bear arms. Pp. 30–32.

(e) Interpretation of the Second Amendment by scholars, courts and legislators, from immediately after its ratification through the late 19th century also supports the Court’s conclusion. Pp. 32–47.

(f) None of the Court’s precedents forecloses the Court’s interpretation. Neither United States v. Cruikshank, 92 U. S. 542 , nor Presser v. Illinois, 116 U. S. 252 , refutes the individual-rights interpretation. United States v. Miller, 307 U. S. 174 , does not limit the right to keep and bear arms to militia purposes, but rather limits the type of weapon to which the right applies to those used by the militia, i.e., those in common use for lawful purposes. Pp. 47–54.

2. Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is not unlimited. It is not a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose: For example, concealed weapons prohibitions have been upheld under the Amendment or state analogues. The Court’s opinion should not be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms. Miller’s holding that the sorts of weapons protected are those “in common use at the time” finds support in the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of dangerous and unusual weapons. Pp. 54–56.

3. The handgun ban and the trigger-lock requirement (as applied to self-defense) violate the Second Amendment . The District’s total ban on handgun possession in the home amounts to a prohibition on an entire class of “arms” that Americans overwhelmingly choose for the lawful purpose of self-defense. Under any of the standards of scrutiny the Court has applied to enumerated constitutional rights, this prohibition—in the place where the importance of the lawful defense of self, family, and property is most acute—would fail constitutional muster. Similarly, the requirement that any lawful firearm in the home be disassembled or bound by a trigger lock makes it impossible for citizens to use arms for the core lawful purpose of self-defense and is hence unconstitutional. Because Heller conceded at oral argument that the D. C. licensing law is permissible if it is not enforced arbitrarily and capriciously, the Court assumes that a license will satisfy his prayer for relief and does not address the licensing requirement. Assuming he is not disqualified from exercising Second Amendment rights, the District must permit Heller to register his handgun and must issue him a license to carry it in the home. Pp. 56–64.


See also Mcdonald v. Chicago

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald_v._Chicago
 
The bad part is that anybody, anywhere has to register for the draft. IMO there are no circumstances in which a draft is ever justified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom