Woman and the Military Draft

How can you be for taxes and yet against registering for the draft? Explain. Explain in more than just one or two words. Draft registration holds the country together. Taxes just pays for odds and ends. If you do not care for your country, why support it at all?
Draft registration doesn't hold the country together. All it does is make the population less free. Taxes do serve useful purposes, including supporting the military which I am all in favour of.

I do not think you are serious at all.
Imagine my concern. Make sure you imagine something really small.

Registering for the draft does not cost anything at all. So why would you be support the government taking your money when you are not for them asking something that is free?
Because Freedom should be defended. The draft is slavery, and I am against slavery.
 
Me and my other ex-service friends find it interesting how women have demanded the right to serve in the military. Yet, somehow, they seem to be absent from many harms way scenarios. And they have not demanded to be included in the draft. It is suspicious.

Also making the military co-ed has actually hurt the military. But no one will admit it. Instead, they state only facts that make the situation sound like a success, like, for example, how MANY women there are and the percentages. They do not mention all the motherless kids and sometimes, now, parentless kids left behind or the burden on the military for all the unwanted and unplanned pregnancies.

But, regardless, if women are except from registering for the draft, there are no equal rights.
 
Draft registration doesn't hold the country together. All it does is make the population less free. Taxes do serve useful purposes, including supporting the military which I am all in favour of.


Imagine my concern. Make sure you imagine something really small.


Because Freedom should be defended. The draft is slavery, and I am against slavery.

You are against reality too. Since you are posting your argument in the wrong forum, you prove you are out of touch. Here is my response to your post:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7403930&postcount=32
 
Me and my other ex-service friends find it interesting how women have demanded the right to serve in the military.

How old are you and your friends? I served more than a quarter-century, have been retired for an additional 7 years, and women have served for my entire experience with the military. Women haven't "demanded the right to serve" in 60 years or more, and have served in fully integrated units for more than 30 years.

withYet, somehow, they seem to be absent from many harms way scenarios. And they have not demanded to be included in the draft. It is suspicious.

Women in uniform are not absent from "many" harms way scenarios. They are absent from very few - and the absences are not based on some attempt by women to avoid hazardous duty. Women fly aircraft into combat, perform as paratroopers, and (very soon) serve on every type of ship.

So far as I know, no significant minority of Americans has demanded to be included in the draft - possibly because we don't have a draft, of course.

Also making the military co-ed has actually hurt the military.

What are your credentials for making this judgment? I don't share this opinion, and I believe I actually have relevent experience that makes my opinion an informed one.

For that matter, in what way has making the military co-ed hurt the military? Be specific.

But no one will admit it. Instead, they state only facts that make the situation sound like a success, like, for example, how MANY women there are and the percentages. They do not mention all the motherless kids and sometimes, now, parentless kids left behind or the burden on the military for all the unwanted and unplanned pregnancies.

I think it probable that the folks with an actual informed opinion on the matter simply disagree with your assessment, and will not admit to something they believe to be false.

But, regardless, if women are except from registering for the draft, there are no equal rights.

Really? None? The absence of a requirment for a segment of the population to register for a draft means that there is no parity of rights across the whole of our society?

I am completely comfortable with women not being required to register for the Selective Service. I can't think of a single period during our history when the presence of a list of draft-aged women would have measurably lessened any risk to our security, and I can't foresee any future circumstance when having a list would be critical to preserving our security. As forceably inducted into military service is a really big imposition on personal freedom, I'd like the practice limited to the smallest pool of folks possible.
 
How old are you and your friends? I served more than a quarter-century, have been retired for an additional 7 years, and women have served for my entire experience with the military. Women haven't "demanded the right to serve" in 60 years or more, and have served in fully integrated units for more than 30 years.

what is your point?

do you have one?

What is your point, Sarge? Is your post a rhetorical stroll down memory lane?
 
Last edited:
This woman was not drafted, nor was she required to sign up for "selective service." Nor is she, by all the rules of the military, allowed into an MOS where she will be expected to serve as a front-line combatant.

So instead she's a medic.

In this picture, she's "providing perimeter security" while the other medics go into a facility.

She's a soldier, with a rifle, standing guard outside of an objective. That's front-line combat in the 21st century.

The military doesn't want a draft, because instead of being filled with people who volunteered (want to be there) the military will be filled with people who DON"T want to be there.

Women signing or not signing for selective service is utterly moot on two fronts.

"don't have to be there" is just because we are lucky to have the volunteers. That is not a given. That is not to be taken for granted. That is not granted.
 
Me and my other ex-service friends find it interesting how women have demanded the right to serve in the military. Yet, somehow, they seem to be absent from many harms way scenarios. And they have not demanded to be included in the draft. It is suspicious.

Also making the military co-ed has actually hurt the military. But no one will admit it. Instead, they state only facts that make the situation sound like a success, like, for example, how MANY women there are and the percentages. They do not mention all the motherless kids and sometimes, now, parentless kids left behind or the burden on the military for all the unwanted and unplanned pregnancies.

But, regardless, if women are except from registering for the draft, there are no equal rights.

I asked earlier, maybe you missed it, what was your mos?
 
what is your point?

do you have one?

What is your point, Sarge? Is your post a rhetorical stroll down memory lane?

You said: "Me and my other ex-service friends find it interesting how women have demanded the right to serve in the military."

I said (in direct response): "How old are you and your friends? I served more than a quarter-century, have been retired for an additional 7 years, and women have served for my entire experience with the military. Women haven't "demanded the right to serve" in 60 years or more, and have served in fully integrated units for more than 30 years."

My point should be clear - I have some experience with women in the military, and in my experience women have not recently demanded the right to serve in the military. I asked how old you and your ex-service friends are. If you are older than I, it is possible you experienced women "demanding the right to serve". If you are of an age with me, you have not.
 
Also making the military co-ed has actually hurt the military. But no one will admit it. Instead, they state only facts that make the situation sound like a success, like, for example, how MANY women there are and the percentages. They do not mention all the motherless kids and sometimes, now, parentless kids left behind or the burden on the military for all the unwanted and unplanned pregnancies.

If that's what you believe, why on earth would you be for drafting women?

What would you do about women who get pregnant in the military BTW?

When women are volunteers, you can reasonably tell them that you can be a soldier or you can be pregnant, but you can't be both. Conscripting would make all the current problems with pregnancies much worse. The government would waste a lot of resources training women only to have many of them get pregnant the day they leave boot camp.
 
Last edited:
You said: "Me and my other ex-service friends find it interesting how women have demanded the right to serve in the military."

I said (in direct response): "How old are you and your friends? I served more than a quarter-century, have been retired for an additional 7 years, and women have served for my entire experience with the military. Women haven't "demanded the right to serve" in 60 years or more, and have served in fully integrated units for more than 30 years."

My point should be clear - I have some experience with women in the military, and in my experience women have not recently demanded the right to serve in the military. I asked how old you and your ex-service friends are. If you are older than I, it is possible you experienced women "demanding the right to serve". If you are of an age with me, you have not.
So? It does not matter. Are you just making conversation? THey have demanded the right to serve. They serve. If they demand to serve they should be in 100% and that includes being part of the draft registration.

Your point is to stroll down memory lane or discuss history for the fun of it. This is off topic.
 
If that's what you believe, why on earth would you be for drafting women?

What would you do about women who get pregnant in the military BTW?

When women are volunteers, you can reasonably tell them that you can be a soldier or you can be pregnant, but you can't be both. Conscripting would make all the current problems with pregnancies much worse. The government would waste a lot of resources training women only to have many of them get pregnant the day they leave boot camp.

Why do libs talk about things in terms of "belief" as if reality is a choice? If the truth does not fit the narrative, then just switch your belief. This must be why hallucinogenic drug abuse and Liberalism go hand in hand.

Drafting women does not demand that woman serve side by side with men in combat.

They do not sleep side by side in boot camp. At least they didn't in the 80's. I doubt they do now.

When I was in the Navy, women did not serve alongside men on warships. They had their seperate ships. The same could be true in the Draft. In fact, it could be better and more structured instead of less, like you assume.
 
Last edited:

Thank you.

I hate to be impolite, but I have a hard time accepting that a Naval Intelligence billet in the 1980's is much qualification or justification for a valid opinion wrt women, or as far as it goes, anything regarding service in combat, and the aftereffects involved.
 
So? It does not matter.

Of course it matters. You claimed that women were demanding to serve - something that has not been true in half a century.

Are you just making conversation?

Are you under the impression that belicosity is an acceptable substitute for correctness?

THey have demanded the right to serve. They serve. If they demand to serve they should be in 100% and that includes being part of the draft registration.

Nonsense.


Your sole argument (to the extent that you have presented one) is that it is unfair that women are not required to register for the draft. The military descriminates against the margins all the time, with good reason. So long as there is no reasonable expectation that we will need an immediate pool of women servicemembers in the near future, there is no reason to extend selective service registration.

The military to a large extent is, and should remain, exempt from forced distribution personnel actions designed soley to engineer an outcome. We don't promote by quota, we don't induct by quota, and we don't retain by quota. We discriminate based on age, gender, obesity, and (to a lesser extent) physical disability.

Your point is to stroll down memory lane or discuss history for the fun of it. This is off topic.

I directly addressed your contention. Exposing your errors does not make it off topic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom