Woman and the Military Draft

I certainly don't claim any great mastery of history, if that's what you are trying to sledgehammer. I support the American war of independence because it was, in the very broadest sense, in the cause of increasing personal freedom.

Not really. Do you have strong opinions about anything that you really know something about? You statement suggest that Canadians are not free or have any personal freedom. The Americans went to war to get out of paying the British back for the French Indian war. That is what the high taxes were all about.

Would you think that looters are people who are just increasing their personal freedom?

Did you answer the question about the comment of Freedom not being Free. Why not do that in the other discussion thread I started. This discussion thread is about women and the draft. It assumes you have gotten beyond the draft issue itself.
 
Last edited:
I think it's a fine slogan, and very true. And I think that saying "you must fight for your freedom whether you like it or not" is an absurd and self contradictory statement, because if you are compelled to fight then you have already lost your freedom.

Why should anyone contradict you when you cntradict yourself? How is it a fine slogan that is very true then?

let me get this straight. Are you saying that living in a free society is a right or a privledge? You live with freedoms others have fought and died for but they are not worth fighting or dying for to you, perhaps? So you are basically like a kid who snuck into the Willy Wonka factory without a golden ticket. Right?

I know Libs are all about beliving in something because they think it is the ethical thing to belive in (aminal rights, anti-war, anti-military, anti-capitol punishment etc). But how is what you believe in ethical? How is it, when you get down to brass tacks, that what you believe in just basically being a thief?

No, dude, if you are not willing to be drafted to defend a free society, you should not live in that society at all. My best friends died for this country. I would trade most people I have met in the USA to have them back, if it were possible. It is not a right to be free. It is a privledge. Countries that have not fought for that right do not have it. You are like the proverbial college drop-out sponging off of his parents and thinking he is entitled.
 
"On average", while accurate, is completely misleading. All but a handful of trained men will outperform all women on any test that measures the first three components of fitness.

Do you have evidence to support this claim?

(You're not comparing "trained men" to untrained women here, are you? That's not at all appropriate. I thought we were talking about basic physical attributes, and not something that is the result of training.)

At any rate, as I said before, the fact that the distribution curves of whatever this physical trait is we're talking about between males and females overlaps, that means certainly some women who are denied official combat assignments are physically superior to some men who are not denied them.

As such, the policy is prejudice of the worst sort. It denies individuals important career advancement opportunities based on their membership in a group and not on their individual qualifications.
 
Uh Huh. Are you against taxes too?
Nope.

Not really. Do you have strong opinions about anything that you really know something about? You statement suggest that Canadians are not free or have any personal freedom. The Americans went to war to get out of paying the British back for the French Indian war. That is what the high taxes were all about.
You know, if you're just going to invent views that you think I hold and then argue against the view that you invented, then there's really no need for me to reply and no point in doing so.

I will respond when you challenge my views. I really can't be bothered responding to what you assume are my views based on your own shaky extrapolations of what I said..

Would you think that looters are people who are just increasing their personal freedom?
No, I wouldn't think that they are "just" that.

Did you answer the question about the comment of Freedom not being Free. Why not do that in the other discussion thread I started.
I answered it at least twice that I recall.

This discussion thread is about women and the draft. It assumes you have gotten beyond the draft issue itself.
Well you are certainly entitled to your assumptions. But your assumptions do not in any way bind me or my responses.

Why should anyone contradict you when you cntradict yourself?
I'm of the opinion that people shouldn't contradict me, but I admit to bias. :) If I contradict myself, I've yet to see how. Certainly you've not shown any contradictions.

How is it a fine slogan that is very true then?
I believe it is a fine in that it summarises an important and often overlooked point in a clear, very concise manner. It's true in that freedom actually isn't free.

You live with freedoms others have fought and died for but they are not worth fighting or dying for to you, perhaps? So you are basically like a kid who snuck into the Willy Wonka factory without a golden ticket. Right?
Wrong. You seem to have reverted back to the thought that I'm some sort of pacifist who opposes war and fighting. I'm not - that's simply another view you have invented and attributed to me.

I'm all for having freedom. I'm all for fighting for freedom, if necessary. I would do so, if the circumstances were right, and I would urge others to do so. What I would not do is force others to do so.

I know Libs are all about beliving in something because they think it is the ethical thing to belive in (aminal rights, anti-war, anti-military, anti-capitol punishment etc). But how is what you believe in ethical? How is it, when you get down to brass tacks, that what you believe in just basically being a thief?
I don't. That's simply another invention of yours.

No, dude, if you are not willing to be drafted to defend a free society, you should not live in that society at all.
If you have a draft then you do not live in a free society.

My best friends died for this country. I would trade most people I have met in the USA to have them back, if it were possible. It is not a right to be free. It is a privledge.
I agree. I only wish you were in favour of people having and exercising that priviledge, as I am.
 
"Most" as in "the most fit" rather than "most" as in "most women". In other words, the women that score the highest on any fitness test the Army is likely to devise will score at or below the level of the lowest scoring males that pass the same test.
I disagree. And made up evidence is no evidence at all.

I have provided evidence of my position: that the physical abilities in question of men and women overlap significantly enough that banning women from combat assignments (officially) is ill-advised prejudiced.

I keep putting that "officially" in there since we know women have indeed served in combat and several have distinguished themselves. So the policy is even worse in that it is primarily a glass ceiling and does not de facto keep women out of combat.
 
It is true however that the APFT is not entirely worthless as a predictor of suitability for some activities. Generally, someone that can only do 20 pushups (male or female) is less likely to perform successfully as a loader on an M1A2 than someone that can perform 100 pushups.

And I guarantee with 100% certainty that there are some women who can do more pushups than some men.

That fact in itself is enough to show that the policy officially prohibiting women from combat assignments results in harmful prejudice.
 
Making war uglier and more horrible and more hellish than it already is, is a good thing. It is a good thing we have had nuclear weapons. A nuclear exchange would be horrible -- a horror almost impossible to imagine. So it did not happen. We have nuclear weapons to thank for making The Cold War not become The Hot War.

Having women forced to register for the draft under law would be a step in the right direction.

I do not like any possible reason why they do not have to register. One reason is that people do now want war to look uglier. That is wrong.

We will have the possibility of having ALL or our children -- boys and girls -- marching off to die to thank in preventing a war.

We will have the possibility of killing young girls in the minds of radical islamists to thank for preventing more terrorist attacks against The West.
 

How can you be for taxes and yet against registering for the draft? Explain. Explain in more than just one or two words. Draft registration holds the country together. Taxes just pays for odds and ends. If you do not care for your country, why support it at all?

I do not think you are serious at all. Why waste your time commenting online?

Registering for the draft does not cost anything at all. So why would you be support the government taking your money when you are not for them asking something that is free?
 
Bill,

How would like to find yourself fighting in a war and surviving it only to come home to your wife who is now a chain-smoking alcoholic that has nightmares every night about the three guys she killed at Anzio?

It's bad enough that we go - I don't want women drafted or in the combat mos.
 
BStrong,

How is that any different that the men who suffer from Post Tramatic Syndrome or whatever it is called?

Also, don't you prove the point I make in the post just above yours or a few posts above yours? Let's make war the biggest freaking nightmare possible !!

Thirdly, women serve in Greece and Israel by obligation with no problems. It works in better cultures than in the American culture. The USA needs to step up and better itself.

And lastly, we now allow gays -- or we soon will -- so it is now only fair that herosexuals suffer the same sort of drama that you illustrate that homosexuals will.
 
Last edited:
BStrong,

How is that any different that the men who suffer from Post Tramatic Syndrome or whatever it is called?

Also, don't you prove the point I make in the post just above yours or a few posts above yours? Let's make war the biggest freaking nightmare possible !!

It already is.

I'm a volunteer with Swords to Plowshares, and women are already exposed to combat and are suffering the after effects. It's hard enough for males to deal with combat related Post Traumatic Stress, it's a whole new layer of complexity trying to help women trying to deal with it - I can talk to a whole bunch of men from earlier conflicts and the current ones, and relate to their experiences.

Women coming out of Iraq and Afghanistan today that have seen actual combat - and there are more than a few - have no such support system in place,

And imo, making war "worse" isn't going to deter politicians in the least - unless you define "worse" as drafting politicians to serve exclusivly in the enlisted combat mos.
 
It already is.

Let's make it worse together.

If we had the draft after 9-11, both wars would have been long over and done with instead of dragging on for 10 years. The idea of overwhelming your enemy with numbers and getting the job done is somehow too real for Progressives.

And you DO realise more people have died because of cell phone texting in the USA then have died in combat in Iraq during the same time, right? When I was in the military, people died in accidents in the military when there was no battle. But that was less than the number of people in accidents in the civilian world. The Iraq war casualities was less than what the military sometimes experienced in peacetime due to accidents. If there was a draft, the war would be over sooner and there would be even less. And one might argue that lives would have been saved that would have otherwise ended to to cell phone texting.
 
Last edited:
It already is.

I'm a volunteer with Swords to Plowshares, and women are already exposed to combat and are suffering the after effects. It's hard enough for males to deal with combat related Post Traumatic Stress, it's a whole new layer of complexity trying to help women trying to deal with it - I can talk to a whole bunch of men from earlier conflicts and the current ones, and relate to their experiences.

Women coming out of Iraq and Afghanistan today that have seen actual combat - and there are more than a few - have no such support system in place,

your logic has holes. One could argue convincingly that mates who share the same experience can support each other compared to a wife who cannot understand why her husband cannot handle her nagging about minutia.

There are countless stories of tragic events that are caused by civilian wives not understanding their war ravaged husbands when they come home from war.
And imo, making war "worse" isn't going to deter politicians in the least - unless you define "worse" as drafting politicians to serve exclusivly in the enlisted combat mos.
of course, if there is a draft, the rich will have to give up their sons and daughters. All the more reason to support it.
 
Last edited:
Saying this segment or that segment of the population should go to war whilst another one is excluded is wrong. That is the bottom line.

You can argue all you want. But let's focus on the truth.

You can make an argument to support anything. You can even make an argument that ONLY women should go to war (and for some series of listed reasons and facts and half-truths, men should stay at home). But let's focus on the truth.

It is not fair that women are excluded from the draft.

If women can protest equal rights, so can men.
 
Let's make it worse together.

If we had the draft after 9-11, both wars would have been long over and done with instead of dragging on for 10 years. The idea of overwhelming your enemy with numbers and getting the job done is somehow too real for Progressives.


And you DO realise more people have died because of cell phone texting in the USA then have died in combat in Iraq during the same time, right? When I was in the military, people died in accidents in the military when there was no battle. But that was less than the number of people in accidents in the civilian world. The Iraq war casualities was less than what the military sometimes experienced in peacetime due to accidents. If there was a draft, the war would be over sooner and there would be even less. And one might argue that lives would have been saved that would have otherwise ended to to cell phone texting.

You're assuming facts not in evidence.

The Sovs. went through Afghanistan without scruples or restraint, and they left under fire.

We could have drafted every man in captivity, put 'em all in the Infantry, and shipped 'em all to the 'Stan - and with the constraints of the roe, it would not have had any positive effect in stopping the insurgency -and my opinion from having been there in '04 as a contractor, the work we have been doing is about as good as it gets in coin given the terrain and culture we're dealing with.

I won't even address your second paragraph.
 
If we had the draft after 9-11, both wars would have been long over and done with instead of dragging on for 10 years.

Rubbish. Especially at the beginning of these two wars, we had recruits already in the military that were not deployed. Why do you think having a draft in place would have made sending more troops in more popular (and swayed the political will)?

In fact, a stronger argument can be made for the opposite. With a draft in place, more people may have objected to Bush's elective wars.

ETA: And we don't have to conjecture. We actually lost the Vietnam War despite having a draft.
 
Last edited:
Let's make it worse together.

If we had the draft after 9-11, both wars would have been long over and done with instead of dragging on for 10 years. The idea of overwhelming your enemy with numbers and getting the job done is somehow too real for Progressives.

This is non-sense. Having had a draft in September 2011 would not have had an impact on the outcome of the war in either Iraq or Afghanistan. A surplus of inexperienced warm bodies would have been counter-productive, at least initially.

And you DO realise more people have died because of cell phone texting in the USA then have died in combat in Iraq during the same time, right? When I was in the military, people died in accidents in the military when there was no battle. But that was less than the number of people in accidents in the civilian world. The Iraq war casualities was less than what the military sometimes experienced in peacetime due to accidents.

When? In what year in the past few decades has the US Military lost more people to accidents than we lost in Iraq?

If there was a draft, the war would be over sooner and there would be even less. And one might argue that lives would have been saved that would have otherwise ended to to cell phone texting.

One might argue that - but it would be an empty argument. The presence of a draft would not have had a positive effect (from an American perspective) on the conduct of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom