Woman and the Military Draft

Homosexuals make up, at most, ten percent of the population. That is according to supposition from homosexuals and their community. This ten percent idea seems to have just started as a rumor and has caught on as being the accepted fact. I have read from more scientific studies that is is more like two percent. But, regardless (10 percent or 2 percent), I find it interesting that there has been such a demand that they are allowed to serve openly in the military while 50% of humanity is exempt from the draft.

While all of malekind (if there even is such a term) is being discriminated against, we have been focusing on a small minority.
 
Last edited:
Homosexuals make up, at most, ten percent of the population. That is according to supposition from homosexuals and their community. This ten percent idea seems to have just started as a rumor and has caught on as being the accepted fact. I have read from more scientific studies that is is more like two percent. But, regardless (10 percent or 2 percent), I find it interesting that there has been such a demand that they are allowed to serve openly in the military while 50% of humanity is exempt from the draft.

What draft? There is no draft.

What does one have to do with the other anyway?

The troll is very strong with this one.
 
This is non-sense. Having had a draft in September 2011 would not have had an impact on the outcome of the war in either Iraq or Afghanistan. A surplus of inexperienced warm bodies would have been counter-productive, at least initially.



When? In what year in the past few decades has the US Military lost more people to accidents than we lost in Iraq?


One might argue that - but it would be an empty argument. The presence of a draft would not have had a positive effect (from an American perspective) on the conduct of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
I am actually mostly in agreement with you, but one needs only go back to 1991 to start seeing years in which accidental deaths exceed the highest year of deaths-due-to-combat-action (Iraq and Afghanistan combined).

For the years 2001-2008, accidental deaths exceeded combat action deaths for the years 2001, 2002, 2003, and 2008.

Source. See page 8, Table 5.
 
Last edited:
What draft? There is no draft.

What does one have to do with the other anyway?

Fill in gaps with your cryptic post, please.
What does one what have to do wth the other what?
By law boys in the USA have to register for a possible draft in case they are needed.
 
Last edited:
This is non-sense. Having had a draft in September 2011 would not have had an impact on the outcome of the war in either Iraq or Afghanistan. A surplus of inexperienced warm bodies would have been counter-productive, at least initially.

This is not 1946.
We don't send kids into battle with bayonettes anymore.
I feel sorry for you, man.
 
Fill in gaps with your cryptic post, please.
What does one what have to do wth the other what?
By law boys in the USA have to register for a possible draft in case they are needed.

You made like registration was the same as draft. (When you said 50% of humanity--as long as by "humanity" you mean U.S. humans-- is exempt from the draft.) It's not.

At any rate, if you view registration is a wrong perpetrated against males, wouldn't the obvious solution be to eliminate it rather than to wrong others as well?

Two wrongs do not make a right.
 
Last edited:
This is not 1946.
We don't send kids into battle with bayonettes anymore.
I feel sorry for you, man.

You seem to be shooting yourself in the foot here. (A traditional draft dodge, BTW!) So if we don't need lots of cannon fodder to win modern wars, what makes you think having a draft would have resulted in swift victories in Iraq and Afghanistan? In fact, most of the continuing problems there are related to nation-building issues (counter insurgency, attempting to build or rebuild institutions, etc.).
 
You seem to be shooting yourself in the foot here. (A traditional draft dodge, BTW!) So if we don't need lots of cannon fodder to win modern wars, what makes you think having a draft would have resulted in swift victories in Iraq and Afghanistan? In fact, most of the continuing problems there are related to nation-building issues (counter insurgency, attempting to build or rebuild institutions, etc.).


UGH. Look it up for yourself. You think I am here to talk to you about how strenght in numbers still applies to modern warfare?

But what the hell is your point? If we don't need a draft, and yet boys are required by law to register for the draft, have the damn women register for the damn draft.
 
Last edited:
You think I am here to talk to you about how strenght in numbers still applies to modern warfare?
Apparently you are, but you're arguing against yourself.

Also, you never replied to my early challenges. Why would you think a draft would have meant more troops would have been sent to those countries? It isn't strictly the availability of personnel that makes that determination.

We had a draft during Vietnam, and it didn't give us a swift victory (or a victory at all).

So again, there's a huge hole in your reasoning that if we had the draft we could have had swift ends to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

But what the hell is your point? If we don't need a draft, and yet boys are required by law to register for the draft, have the damn women register for the damn draft.
Why not stop having boys register? If it's wrong, it would be wrong for both. Two wrongs don't make a right.

If draft registration is a good thing (which you sort of seem to be arguing some of the time) then any discrimination would be victimizing females, not males as you earlier claimed.
 
Fill in gaps with your cryptic post, please.
What does one what have to do wth the other what?
By law boys in the USA have to register for a possible draft in case they are needed.

What does allowing gays, or any other group for that matter, to openly serve in the military have to do with who has to register with selective service?

And since you've gone over to full troll, it's ignore from here on out. I know you won't miss me, I won't miss you.
 
What does allowing gays, or any other group for that matter, to openly serve in the military have to do with who has to register with selective service?

And since you've gone over to full troll, it's ignore from here on out. I know you won't miss me, I won't miss you.

Best I can tell, he was saying that we stopped discriminating against gay people voluntarily serving openly in the military, and since registering for the draft is really bad (that is, it is discrimination against "malekind") we shouldn't stop it, but should extend it to females.

It's pretty tortured logic no matter how you look at it.
 
Best I can tell, he was saying that we stopped discriminating against gay people voluntarily serving openly in the military, and since registering for the draft is really bad (that is, it is discrimination against "malekind") we shouldn't stop it, but should extend it to females.

It's pretty tortured logic no matter how you look at it.

No it's just plain ole trolling.
 
I am actually mostly in agreement with you, but one needs only go back to 1991 to start seeing years in which accidental deaths exceed the highest year of deaths-due-to-combat-action (Iraq and Afghanistan combined).

For the years 2001-2008, accidental deaths exceeded combat action deaths for the years 2001, 2002, 2003, and 2008.

Source. See page 8, Table 5.

Yes, if you include all fatal accidents involving servicemembers. Perhaps I misunderstood his claim. I assumed, since he was comparing accidental deaths of Servicemen to combat deaths of Servicemen, that he was talking about service-connected accidental deaths. Those numbers seem to include all deaths of Servicemen, not just accidental line-of-duty deaths. Otherwise, his comparison is silly. I can demonstrate, by the same method, that being an American is far more dangerous than being a Soldier in Iraq.
 
This is not 1946.
We don't send kids into battle with bayonettes anymore.


Sure we do. I carried a bayonette in both Iraq and Afghanistan.

I'm not sure what your point is, however. Draft's are adequate at producing targeted numbers of inductees. Draft's are not particularly effective at producing large numbers of well trained professional Soldiers, however.

A draft in place on 911 would not have changed the equation in Iraq at all. We delivered and supplied just about all the trained ground forces we could have as it was. having a large pool of relatively untrained draftees wouldn't have made a difference.

I feel sorry for you, man.

Goody.
 
I'm not sure what your point is, however. Draft's [sic] are adequate at producing targeted numbers of inductees. Draft's [sic] are not particularly effective at producing large numbers of well trained professional Soldiers, however.

A draft in place on 911 would not have changed the equation in Iraq at all. We delivered and supplied just about all the trained ground forces we could have as it was. having a large pool of relatively untrained draftees wouldn't have made a difference.

Yes, and also the point I've been making. There was (and always is) resistance to sending in unlimited numbers of troops to "get the job done" (even if that were possible). A draft would probably increase and not decrease that resistance and the net result is that the additional conscripts probably wouldn't mean any higher numbers deployed.

The best argument is that it would mean fewer individuals would have to go back again and again, but then you run into Sarge's argument that part of the reason for sending vets back is that they're ready already.

And that wouldn't have resulted in a quicker finishing of the job in Iraq and Afghanistan.
 
How about we just make military/national service mandatory for every one for two years regardless of gender. 18-20 everyone does two years. You can choose military or civil projects, but for two years everyone gets to give back to their nation.

Any form of national service would mean government indoctrination in the form of multiculturalism, antiracism, and other unhealthy propaganda.
 
rebecca-buck.jpg

This woman was not drafted, nor was she required to sign up for "selective service." Nor is she, by all the rules of the military, allowed into an MOS where she will be expected to serve as a front-line combatant.

So instead she's a medic.

In this picture, she's "providing perimeter security" while the other medics go into a facility.

She's a soldier, with a rifle, standing guard outside of an objective. That's front-line combat in the 21st century.

The military doesn't want a draft, because instead of being filled with people who volunteered (want to be there) the military will be filled with people who DON"T want to be there.

Women signing or not signing for selective service is utterly moot on two fronts.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom