Woman and the Military Draft

Wow! You sure do raise a few points that I would like to address:

First of all, I did not call you a liar. While it is true that I have a low opinion about you, however I did not call you a liar.

Did I say you called me a liar? Aren't you, in fact, telling a lie now?
Why do you have a low opinion of me? (This comment lets us peer into your mental stability. Don't you agree?) I mean, you do not know me at all.

What difference does it mean that poeple use handles instead of their real name? How does this have any influence on anything? Are you saying that you DID research the military draft registration before you posted. Why is it absurd for me to think that you are not putting your name on the line and so you can post guesses, assumptions, whims and delusions? It does not matter if most everyone else uses handles. You seem to have an reason for using one.
Third of all, you still do not understand the difference between a "Draft" and "Selective Service". Those two things are hardly the same, therefore I suggest that you stop using the terms interchangably.
What is your criteria for belief? Do you believe something that sounds good ? Maybe even you do not believe what you are saying. How do you define a military draft? Does not the government select people for service?

Tell me, what do you see the difference between selective service and the draft? I look forward to your response with glee and delight. I know this will be entertaining.
 
Last edited:
Well, maybe so, but then maybe not. After all, it was quite some time ago when the Pilgrims came over and there have been many, many, many other influences besides them.

What is it with you and the Pilgrims? They were not the only one and most of them were escaping religious situations and looking for religious freedoms.

What other influences are you talking about? Please use real facts and not whims or supposition or fantasies.

Most industrial countries are secular. The United states is unique in being modern and not being secular. It is because of its beginnings.
 
Last edited:
You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft. Instead, men are required to register for 'Selective Service' which is not a draft.

I'm certainly no defender of most of what Bill Thompson says, but this is silly.

The only point of Selective Service registration is to be ready in case the draft is re-instituted. As such, it is perfectly proper to refer to it as "draft registration", and that is certainly conventional usage.
 
@crossbow:

If the government selects persons for service who have registered for selective service, how is that not a draft?

Here is what I think. I think you found out you messed up and you are using word games to save face. Am I right?
 
Are you saying that countries that have a conscription army are similar to North Korea? You are aware that quite a few European countries do that, right?
No, but it is a step in that direction.
I think that you've watched waaaay too many Hollywood movies about what happens in boot camp without actually having gone there yourself. I've done it and no, it wasn't terribly pleasant nor was it meant to be. It also wasn't anywhere near as bad as I thought it would be (you see, I've seen those movies too).
Actually, as I mentioned earlier in the thread, I spent six years in the Navy, which means I went through boot camp. Perhaps you've forgotten, but where you are and what you do is controlled 24 hours a day from the moment you arrive until the day you leave (except for one day of semi-controlled liberty near the end IIRC). The whole point of the exercise is to establish that they are in charge, and you must obey without question.

How so? If they could opt out with the full awareness that there would be consequences (this is what the Swiss do) and they decide to do so then wouldn't they themselves have decided that they wanted to take on that status?

No. If I say that you must worship the Spaghetti Monster or suffer consequences, and you refuse, have you "decided that you wanted to take on that status"? No, the person refusing didn't want to be a second class citizen, the person who made the rules decided that.

I never said it would be free but it wouldn't cost as much as you think it would either. The facilities are already there and if more need to be built it's not like the government doesn't already own vast tracts of land. They wouldn't be building the Wynn after all.

Again, no clue. The instructors are already being paid right now (and they pay taxes out of their wages too!!!, imagine that). They are already in the military as a career choice and are in their CONUS (or shore duty) rotation. A lot of those jobs are really nothing more than make-work to give them time with their families.

There would need to be more facilities and more instructors. The facilities and instructors we have now are just enough for our present needs, not for putting every citizen through boot camp. And every trainee would have to be paid too.
And yet you think that it would be more efficient to scramble to gather up a military, screen and train them at the drop of a hat. Put down the bong. What makes you think that they would "Soon forget" what they learned? Why don't you go ask some other people who've been through it if they've forgotten the basic skills that they learned from it. Might they get a bit rusty? Sure, but refresher training takes a heck of a lot less time than starting from fresh.

So lets review:
Universally recognized right of all sovereign nations
Waste is subjective
"You never know" is why every nation has a military in the first place, including the ones that haven't been to war for a very, very long time.

Do you have insurance? Car, home, fire? Why? Why pay those premiums and waste all of that money? The odds are slim that your home will burn down as long as you maintain it and don't do anything stupid. If you're a safe driver you should never get in an accident. Keep your doors and windows locked and a burglar won't come in. So you're all good right?

That is what your argument boils down to.I get it. You don't like the military in general and think that we should all just get along. That's a nice sentiment and all but for those of us who live in the real world know better than to hold childlike fantasies.

The US already has the most powerful military in the world and spends ten times what any other country spends on their military. I think that we're plenty safe already. We are better prepared for war than most other countries. I'm not saying we don't need to prepare for war, I'm saying that your idea is not the right way to do it. I am not a pacifist. I have no "childlike" illusions that "we can all just get along."
 
PuppyCow, love that handle by the way, I do not think it is Progress to do away with a draft. It has to do with history, not politics. We can entertain the idea of doing away with the draft because we have not used it for a long time and so we have the fantasy to believe that mankind had evolved beyond the necessity of one.

If the USA was attacked more often and even occupied, doing away with the draft would be regarded as absurd.

Service is required for all young men and women in Greece (last time I was there). In fact it is required for all children of parents born in Greece and grandkids of Greeks (I was told).

If you told them that it was not necessary and that a volunteer military is all that is required, I am sure they would think you live in a dreamworld and have no idea of history.
 
Last edited:
So American culture stinks because we don't hug and we don't force our youth to serve in the armed forces despite the fact that we have enough volunteers?

BTW: Don't move to China, they don't hug there either.
 
Call it whatever you want. Men are required by law to register for service while women are not in the USA. This stinks and is undefendable.
 
Last edited:
...I would be against that. There is no national security need to have such a program,...

What makes you feel that manditory national service (civil or military) is only a good thing when there are national security needs that can't be met in other ways?

I personally think it is a good, if not the best, means of preparing individuals to transition into becoming an adult, fully privileged and responsible citizen of our nation.

and hence it would merely be some kind of government-imposed social engineering.

Please explain.

I'm for maximizing freedom whenever it is reasonable to do so, and if you want to restrict people's freedom, you better have a damn good reason for it besides "it builds character."

What I'm proposing would enhance freedoms and opportunities, not restrict or reduce them.

I would want to see some strong evidence that society would be significantly improved in tangible ways before starting such a program.

If such couldn't be demonstrated I wouldn't expect such a system to be adopted, yet alone maintained.
 
Call it whatever you want. Men are required by law to register for service while women are not in the USA. This stinks and is undefendable.
Do I think women should register as well? Yes. Do I think any of my elected representatives should put any effort into making it happen? Not really. There are a lot more important things than worrying about who has to register for a draft that will probably not occur in my lifetime.

So something that is pretty inconsequential in the big picture of things is what really bothers you about America? Between that and the hugging it just sounds like you are looking for things not to like. To expect any country to be perfect according to your personal definition of perfection is just not possible. It's too bad you don't have any appreciation or tolerance for a foreign culture. If you substitute any other country for the USA in your complaints, you'd sound like the stereotypical 'ugly American'.
 
Do I think women should register as well? Yes. Do I think any of my elected representatives....

I was just thinking the same sort of thing. Democracy Fail !!

Fathers will not go for it especially if their daughters are princesses.

But isn't the "ew" factor the reason why parents were against gay marriage? They just wanted grandkids and somehow this translated to an instinct of being against their sons marrying other dudes. It does not make sense, I know, and I am not defending it. So I am also not defending parents who would be against their daughters having to register for the draft.
 
Actually, as I mentioned earlier in the thread, I spent six years in the Navy, which means I went through boot camp. Perhaps you've forgotten, but where you are and what you do is controlled 24 hours a day from the moment you arrive until the day you leave (except for one day of semi-controlled liberty near the end IIRC). The whole point of the exercise is to establish that they are in charge, and you must obey without question.

That is not the whole point of the exercise. Perhaps you've forgotten. I went to Great Lakes back in the early 80's and pretty much from day one the CC's made it quite clear to all of us that what they expected from us was attention to detail and teamwork. Everything that they did was geared towards that goal. Did they have a lot of control over our schedules? Sure they did, without a doubt. They had their own schedules to meet too. Some kid picking his nose or scratching his balls instead of getting to the task on hand so that everybody (teamwork) could get to where they needed to be on time (so that everyone else that followed that day wouldn't be delayed) isn't unreasonable. Making sure that your skivvies were properly stenciled (attention to detail) makes sure that you get your laundry back. Hoo boy, how unreasonable was that, huh?

Your complaint seems to be about personal discipline. You couldn't do what you wanted to do when you wanted to do it for eight weeks and apparently it was so hard on you that you think that it was hard on other people. And to top it off they didn't explain to you personally why they wanted you where they wanted you right when they wanted you there. Get a grip, that's life in the adult world. Go to work 9-5, pay your taxes, pay your bills, get a drivers license etc etc. People tell you what to do everyday in life.

There would need to be more facilities and more instructors. The facilities and instructors we have now are just enough for our present needs, not for putting every citizen through boot camp. And every trainee would have to be paid too.

As far as facilities goes I'm sure that some more would probably need to be constructed but as I recall from my experience at least half of the barracks in Great Lakes were unoccupied. Each division building was designed to hold about 80 guys per floor wing (4 wings per floor) and they were 3 floors high. That's close to 1,000 people passing through every 10 weeks or so (giving the CC's a few weeks off between companies) and there were at least ten of those buildings (probably more as we never marched past our own building and I know that we weren't all the way back on the property).

The CC's did at least 90% of our instruction (2 per company) so that's 24 instructors per building which would make it about 240 people (plus support staff so call it 300 just to round it off) to do most of the work to train 10,000 every 10 weeks. Five cycles per year makes it 300 people to train 50,000. It takes more people to push paperwork and do the medical than it ever will to do the actual training.

Which was my point from the start, to get the process going and get people screened and sorted to send them on their merry way with a little bit of preparation for what may be expected from them should the need arise will take as long or longer than the training itself will. Hell, even sending them through the first part of the process where you get poked and prodded before they send you off to boot camp is better than what we have now and would cost a lot less too.

CSB time; I live across the street from a high school football field and every year they hold their graduation ceremony there to accommodate all of the family members who want to attend. This means that I get to see and hear the preparations for the event from start to finish. Every year over a two day period they rehearse the part where the students stand up one row at a time and walk up to get their diplomas and then sit back down and every year they have to try it at least four times before they get it right. Let me say that again. They had to practice standing up and getting in line in an orderly fashion FOUR TIMES to get it right. Now this isn't some school filled with miscreants and whatnot, it's the best school in the district and probably one of the best ones on the state. The kids (as a group) lacked enough discipline and focus to stand up and get in line and at least half of them were old enough to have to sign up for the selective service. Now granted that's anecdotal at best but it has happened every year for the last ten years that I've been watching it go on which tells me that it probably isn't a one off occurrence.
 
PuppyCow, love that handle by the way,
Glad to hear that you approve, Bill. Your handle is nice too.
I do not think it is Progress to do away with a draft. It has to do with history, not politics. We can entertain the idea of doing away with the draft because we have not used it for a long time and so we have the fantasy to believe that mankind had evolved beyond the necessity of one.

If the USA was attacked more often and even occupied, doing away with the draft would be regarded as absurd.

Service is required for all young men and women in Greece (last time I was there). In fact it is required for all children of parents born in Greece and grandkids of Greeks (I was told).

If you told them that it was not necessary and that a volunteer military is all that is required, I am sure they would think you live in a dreamworld and have no idea of history.
You are entitled to your opinion, but the USA is not Greece, and in fact, I'll bet that Greece in 2011 could get along just fine without conscription, whatever people might think. For one thing, Greece is a member of NATO. As far as the USA is concerned, we are the world's largest military superpower, without conscription.

In fact, I believe that most military scholars believe that a volunteer army is generally better than a conscript army. Here is one such argument.
 
What makes you feel that manditory national service (civil or military) is only a good thing when there are national security needs that can't be met in other ways?

I personally think it is a good, if not the best, means of preparing individuals to transition into becoming an adult, fully privileged and responsible citizen of our nation.
Because I believe in freedom, and that usually individual people know what is the best use of their own time and talents. A one-size fits all top-down imposed mandate is grossly inefficient.



Please explain.
Social Engineering
Social engineering is a discipline in political science that refers to efforts to influence popular attitudes and social behaviors on a large scale, whether by governments or private groups.

. . .

While social engineering can be carried out by any organization. whether large or small, public or private, the most comprehensive (and often the most effective) campaigns of social engineering are those initiated by powerful central governments.

Extremely intensive social engineering campaigns occurred in countries with authoritarian governments. In the 1920s, the government of the Soviet Union embarked on a campaign to fundamentally alter the behavior and ideals of Soviet citizens, to replace the old social frameworks of Tsarist Russia with a new Soviet culture, to create the New Soviet man. The Soviets used newspapers, books, film, mass relocations, and even architectural design tactics to serve as "social condenser" and change personal values and private relationships. Similar examples are the Chinese "Great Leap Forward" and "Cultural Revolution" program and the Khmer Rouge's plan of deurbanization of Cambodia.

Beyond that, I think that I've explained my position adequately in this thread. See my other posts if you need clarification.



What I'm proposing would enhance freedoms and opportunities, not restrict or reduce them.
No, I don't think so. Mandating what people do with their time and talents does not "enhance freedom and opportunities."



If such couldn't be demonstrated I wouldn't expect such a system to be adopted, yet alone maintained.
On this point we can agree. BTW, do you expect the system which you propose to be adopted in the United States?
 
I was just thinking the same sort of thing. Democracy Fail !!
Democracy Succeed by not wasting time on unimportant issues.

Fathers will not go for it especially if their daughters are princesses.
Have you asked them? I have two daughters, I really could care less if they had to register with Selective Service.

But isn't the "ew" factor the reason why parents were against gay marriage? They just wanted grandkids and somehow this translated to an instinct of being against their sons marrying other dudes. It does not make sense, I know, and I am not defending it. So I am also not defending parents who would be against their daughters having to register for the draft.

The 'ew' factor? No wonder why you don't like American culture, you have no comprehension of it.
 
You are wrong about everything.

You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft. Instead, men are required to register for 'Selective Service' which is not a draft.

You are wrong to think that somehow the people from the Mayflower define what the USA is now. After all, that was just one event that happened hunderds of years ago, and there has been a considerable amount of change since then.

SS is the agency that gathers the records in case the govt wants to implement a draft. It is de facto registering for the draft, albeit a 'potential' draft.

While you might be technically correct, the OP is pragmatically correct.

As far as the past shaping today .... Yes, because if events from hundreds of years ago shaped today, why ... then we would be having discussions on the status of the Christianity of the founding fathers :-)
 
No, I don't think so. Mandating what people do with their time and talents does not "enhance freedom and opportunities."

So we should eliminate public education and manditory attendance?

On this point we can agree. BTW, do you expect the system which you propose to be adopted in the United States?

Expect,...no. Advocate for and support, sure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom