Actually, as I mentioned earlier in the thread, I spent six years in the Navy, which means I went through boot camp. Perhaps you've forgotten, but where you are and what you do is controlled 24 hours a day from the moment you arrive until the day you leave (except for one day of semi-controlled liberty near the end IIRC). The whole point of the exercise is to establish that they are in charge, and you must obey without question.
That is not the whole point of the exercise. Perhaps you've forgotten. I went to Great Lakes back in the early 80's and pretty much from day one the CC's made it quite clear to all of us that what they expected from us was attention to detail and teamwork. Everything that they did was geared towards that goal. Did they have a lot of control over our schedules? Sure they did, without a doubt. They had their own schedules to meet too. Some kid picking his nose or scratching his balls instead of getting to the task on hand so that everybody (teamwork) could get to where they needed to be on time (so that everyone else that followed that day wouldn't be delayed) isn't unreasonable. Making sure that your skivvies were properly stenciled (attention to detail) makes sure that you get your laundry back. Hoo boy, how unreasonable was that, huh?
Your complaint seems to be about personal discipline. You couldn't do what you wanted to do when you wanted to do it for eight weeks and apparently it was so hard on you that you think that it was hard on other people. And to top it off they didn't explain to you personally why they wanted you where they wanted you right when they wanted you there. Get a grip, that's life in the adult world. Go to work 9-5, pay your taxes, pay your bills, get a drivers license etc etc. People tell you what to do everyday in life.
There would need to be more facilities and more instructors. The facilities and instructors we have now are just enough for our present needs, not for putting every citizen through boot camp. And every trainee would have to be paid too.
As far as facilities goes I'm sure that some more would probably need to be constructed but as I recall from my experience at least half of the barracks in Great Lakes were unoccupied. Each division building was designed to hold about 80 guys per floor wing (4 wings per floor) and they were 3 floors high. That's close to 1,000 people passing through every 10 weeks or so (giving the CC's a few weeks off between companies) and there were at least ten of those buildings (probably more as we never marched past our own building and I know that we weren't all the way back on the property).
The CC's did at least 90% of our instruction (2 per company) so that's 24 instructors per building which would make it about 240 people (plus support staff so call it 300 just to round it off) to do most of the work to train 10,000 every 10 weeks. Five cycles per year makes it 300 people to train 50,000. It takes more people to push paperwork and do the medical than it ever will to do the actual training.
Which was my point from the start, to get the process going and get people screened and sorted to send them on their merry way with a little bit of preparation for what may be expected from them should the need arise will take as long or longer than the training itself will. Hell, even sending them through the first part of the process where you get poked and prodded before they send you off to boot camp is better than what we have now and would cost a lot less too.
CSB time; I live across the street from a high school football field and every year they hold their graduation ceremony there to accommodate all of the family members who want to attend. This means that I get to see and hear the preparations for the event from start to finish. Every year over a two day period they rehearse the part where the students stand up one row at a time and walk up to get their diplomas and then sit back down and
every year they have to try it
at least four times before they get it right. Let me say that again. They had to practice standing up and getting in line in an orderly fashion
FOUR TIMES to get it right. Now this isn't some school filled with miscreants and whatnot, it's the best school in the district and probably one of the best ones on the state. The kids (as a group) lacked enough discipline and focus to stand up and get in line and
at least half of them were old enough to have to sign up for the selective service. Now granted that's anecdotal at best but it has happened every year for the last ten years that I've been watching it go on which tells me that it probably isn't a one off occurrence.