Woman and the Military Draft

In my opinion, there is never going to be another military draft because the government doesn't really want people to be over concerned with what wars we are engaged in.
I don't understand how this argument distinguishes draftees from voluntary enlistees.

I agree that there won't be a draft in the foreseeable future, but that's primarily because most military people prefer "volunteers", and it's been adequate for our needs.

Also, I don't think there's any kind of foreseeable use of the military that will have a huge demand for relatively unskilled cannon fodder.
 
Here is my theory. Tell me where I am wrong. As I heard a business analyst once say, "how something starts is how something is". The United States is a country whose culture is akin to that of Puritans with radical, break-away Christian (abiet unique and firmly heald) ideas of codes of behavior that do not make logical sense but makes sense within their own ideas of right and wrong and ethics. War, in a biblical sense, is necessary. Rules of how to conduct war in the USA is based on the culture that they originated from. Forcing women to serve breaks their nonsensical rules.
 
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men. They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military. Women have never been subject to conscription the United States. The only country where I've ever heard of conscription for women is Israel.

I think there's more of an argument for getting rid of Selective Service registration than for requiring women to register. At the time, it was kept as a "just in case" thing for those who were worried that we couldn't have an army without conscription, but subsequent history has shown that an all-volunteer army works just fine, and in fact, when there is a national crisis like 9/11, the military has all the volunteers it needs.

So let's just get rid of the whole thing altogether rather than asking women to do it too.

How about we just make military/national service mandatory for every one for two years regardless of gender. 18-20 everyone does two years. You can choose military or civil projects, but for two years everyone gets to give back to their nation.
 
Because women (in general) are not physically equal to men. They still cannot serve in combat roles in the military. Women have never been subject to conscription the United States. The only country where I've ever heard of conscription for women is Israel.

Technically, women in Norway have to serve in the military service - the constitution says every citizen has to serve. However, at the time the constitution was written, women weren't considered citizens.

Now, women have to register for the draft, but can opt out of military service. Most do.
 
I think it's important that for gender equality to exist both men and women should have to serve their country during a draft. Regardless I'm not fond of drafts at all.
 
I think it's important that for gender equality to exist both men and women should have to serve their country during a draft. Regardless I'm not fond of drafts at all.

A popular position in Norway is that either both genders serve, as per the constitution, or we abolish it all together.

Strangely enough, equality in this case has not been something feminist groups have fought for.. :)

As a side note, I have served with many women, from grunts to Majors, and even had female Lt. as my closest superior in Bosnia, in an infantry unit that would see combat if anything happened. I know we also have women in our infantry units in Afghanistan.

In my experience, they were just as capable as any other man.
 
A lot of people have focused on my statement that "women (in general) are not physically equal to men." I mentioned this only as a historical reason for why things are the way they are. It was not actually my intention to endorse the status quo.

Here's my position: Conscription is no longer necessary for the United States. Neither is the Selective Service system. Getting rid of it might save a little money too.

I'm in favor of allowing women the opportunity to serve in the military in any role in which they can perform at the required level. For example, the requirements to become a Navy Seal are much more physically demanding than those to become an airframe mechanic. If a woman wants to become a Navy Seal, I think she should be allowed, if she can pass all the same physical tests that a male Navy Seal candidate must pass (and the vast majority of men cannot pass these tests).

How about we just make military/national service mandatory for every one for two years regardless of gender. 18-20 everyone does two years. You can choose military or civil projects, but for two years everyone gets to give back to their nation.

I would be against that. There is no national security need to have such a program, and hence it would merely be some kind of government-imposed social engineering. I'm for maximizing freedom whenever it is reasonable to do so, and if you want to restrict people's freedom, you better have a damn good reason for it besides "it builds character." I would want to see some strong evidence that society would be significantly improved in tangible ways before starting such a program.
 
I'm all for having women register with the selective service if for no other reason than they could free up eligible men for combat duty and widen the pool of possibilities. Equal rights also means equal responsibilities and there's no good reason for excluding them other than sexism.

I also probably wouldn't be adverse to the idea of sending everyone straight out of high school into 6-8 weeks of basic training. The hardest part of using the selective service for a rapid mobilization would be processing them into the system and training them in the ways of the military. I'm not talking about training them to do specific tasks related to a field but more along the lines of general knowledge that everyone in uniform should be familiar with and some physical training. You could easily cut six months off of the time needed to form new units (battalion sized) just by doing that.
 
I also probably wouldn't be adverse to the idea of sending everyone straight out of high school into 6-8 weeks of basic training.

Good grief, no. What gives you the right to impose this on people against their will? What would be the penalty for refusal?

The hardest part of using the selective service for a rapid mobilization would be processing them into the system and training them in the ways of the military. I'm not talking about training them to do specific tasks related to a field but more along the lines of general knowledge that everyone in uniform should be familiar with and some physical training. You could easily cut six months off of the time needed to form new units (battalion sized) just by doing that.

You sort assumed that there is some sort of need for this. Are you saying that our current all-volunteer army is not sufficient for our security needs?
 
Good grief, no. What gives you the right to impose this on people against their will? What would be the penalty for refusal?

6-8 weeks out of a teenagers life to learn something that they can carry with them for the rest of their lives? Oh the horror! Most kids at that age (myself included back in the day) need to learn most of the skills that are taught in boot camp anyway. Teamwork and the ability to understand and follow basic instructions are but two of many.

As far as a penalty I'd guess that the inability to be able to qualify for a government related job (including working for anyone who takes on contract work) would be enough. Maybe a reduced student loan rate or maybe something else similar to that. Maybe take on the Swiss model of increased taxes until the age of 30. I'm just spitballing on that though. I wouldn't make jail time or a criminal record a part of it though.

You sort assumed that there is some sort of need for this. Are you saying that our current all-volunteer army is not sufficient for our security needs?

You are assuming that we will never need more people than what we currently get through an all volunteer force. I'm saying that we always seem to be preparing for the last war that we were in instead of the next one. Neither you nor I know what that might be or when so I don't see a problem with being ahead of the curve. Do your six weeks or whatever and go on your merry way. The point wouldn't be to have a large standing army it would be to streamline the entry process should we ever need to. It takes time just to do all of the medical stuff alone not to mention teaching some of the basic skills. Shaving some time off of the front of that process would most likely save lives if the need ever arose because lets face it, if we ever restarted the draft there would have to be a very good reason for doing so and it would probably be time critical.
 
I'm all for having women register with the selective service if for no other reason than they could free up eligible men for combat duty and widen the pool of possibilities. Equal rights also means equal responsibilities and there's no good reason for excluding them other than sexism.

Would that be "equal responsibilities"? I'd wager that the persons who end up in combat duty have a much higher chance of getting killed or severely maimed.
 
6-8 weeks out of a teenagers life to learn something that they can carry with them for the rest of their lives? Oh the horror! Most kids at that age (myself included back in the day) need to learn most of the skills that are taught in boot camp anyway. Teamwork and the ability to understand and follow basic instructions are but two of many.
Ugh. Where to start? First off, you didn't answer the question: What gives you the right? What gives you the right to order people to spend six weeks learning what you think they need to learn. This is a step in the direction of North Korea, where everyone is required to participate in militaristic nonsense. One step often leads to another, and then another.

Hey, I think that everyone should be forced to learn ballet! Yeah! And the ballet instructer should have near-dictatorial powers over the students 24-hours a day and they should have all their movements controlled and regimented. They need to be broken down and taught who's boss. They must learn to respect my authoriTAY!

Actually, I think that the "skills" they teach you in boot camp such as how to shine a boot or march have very little utility in real life. Lots of people get through life just fine without ever going to boot camp, so these skills are either unnecessary or can be learned in other ways.

So, what gives you the right?

As far as a penalty I'd guess that the inability to be able to qualify for a government related job (including working for anyone who takes on contract work) would be enough. Maybe a reduced student loan rate or maybe something else similar to that. Maybe take on the Swiss model of increased taxes until the age of 30. I'm just spitballing on that though. I wouldn't make jail time or a criminal record a part of it though.

This is a very significant penalty as it essentially relegates anyone who refuses to submit to this nonsense to the status of second-class citizen.

Furthermore, this boodoggle of yours would cost real money. Facilities would have to be built. Instructors and students would have to be paid, instead of potentially paying taxes if they are in the private sector. At a time when we are looking for ways to cut the government so as to save money, this would be one more money pit. Furthermore, by reducing the pool of people that the government can hire or do business with, it makes it harder for the government to get the best value for its money (taxpayer's money).


You are assuming that we will never need more people than what we currently get through an all volunteer force. I'm saying that we always seem to be preparing for the last war that we were in instead of the next one. Neither you nor I know what that might be or when so I don't see a problem with being ahead of the curve. Do your six weeks or whatever and go on your merry way. The point wouldn't be to have a large standing army it would be to streamline the entry process should we ever need to. It takes time just to do all of the medical stuff alone not to mention teaching some of the basic skills. Shaving some time off of the front of that process would most likely save lives if the need ever arose because lets face it, if we ever restarted the draft there would have to be a very good reason for doing so and it would probably be time critical.

This would be a grossly inefficient way of creating a pool of potential reserves, most of whom would soon forget whatever it is they learned.

So let's review:
North Korea
Waste of money
No demonstrable improvement of national security. "You never know" is not a demonstrable improvement.
 
Here is my theory. Tell me where I am wrong. As I heard a business analyst once say, "how something starts is how something is". The United States is a country whose culture is akin to that of Puritans with radical, break-away Christian (abiet unique and firmly heald) ideas of codes of behavior that do not make logical sense but makes sense within their own ideas of right and wrong and ethics. War, in a biblical sense, is necessary. Rules of how to conduct war in the USA is based on the culture that they originated from. Forcing women to serve breaks their nonsensical rules.

You are wrong about everything.

You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft. Instead, men are required to register for 'Selective Service' which is not a draft.

You are wrong to think that somehow the people from the Mayflower define what the USA is now. After all, that was just one event that happened hunderds of years ago, and there has been a considerable amount of change since then.
 
You are wrong about everything.

You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft.

That does not make any sense. What does registering for the draft have to do with an actual draft? Just because no one is being drafted does not mean they might need it later, "Crossbow" (if that is your real name). You should look up your facts. But you are hiding behind a pseudoname. So you can post whims and supposition.

Men ARE required to register for the draft in the USA when they become old enough by law:
http://www.google.com/#sclient=psy&...gc.r_pw.&fp=c488823cce0a6f39&biw=1384&bih=854

All U.S. male citizens and male aliens are currently required to sign up for the Selective Service within 30 days of their 18th birthday.

This is why I don't understand why people make web posts on internet forums under fake names. They can be wrong and accuse people of lying and hide behind a fake name.

You are wrong to think that somehow the people from the Mayflower define what the USA is now. After all, that was just one event that happened hunderds of years ago, and there has been a considerable amount of change since then.

If not for the mindset of these earlier americans, modern evangelists and modern mormons would not exist.

Let's try this again.

Here is my theory. Tell me where I am wrong. As I heard a business analyst once say, "how something starts is how something is". The United States is a country whose culture is akin to that of Puritans with radical, break-away Christian (abiet unique and firmly heald) ideas of codes of behavior that do not make logical sense but makes sense within their own ideas of right and wrong and ethics. War, in a biblical sense, is necessary. Rules of how to conduct war in the USA is based on the culture that they originated from. Forcing women to serve breaks their nonsensical rules.
 
Last edited:
Here is my theory. Tell me where I am wrong. As I heard a business analyst once say, "how something starts is how something is".

If I may make some inferences from your posting history: you are an educated, traveled, worldly, observant, insightful person. Therefore why would you put any credence whatsoever in the absurd assertion that the way a country starts determines how it will be decades or centuries later?


The United States is a country whose culture is akin to that of Puritans with radical, break-away Christian (abiet unique and firmly heald) ideas of codes of behavior that

You do realize that the Puritans represented a very small fraction of Colonial America. There were many different types of people present at the founding of the United States.
DISCLAIMER I am not a defend-America-at-all-costs kind of person. Although I was born and raised here, I have lived in a foreign country and understand that every country has its pluses and minuses.​
 
Last edited:
Ugh. Where to start? First off, you didn't answer the question: What gives you the right? What gives you the right to order people to spend six weeks learning what you think they need to learn. This is a step in the direction of North Korea, where everyone is required to participate in militaristic nonsense. One step often leads to another, and then another.

I don't have the right however it is a sovereign right that every nation has that is recognized by every other nation so get off of your high horse.

Hey, I think that everyone should be forced to learn ballet! Yeah! And the ballet instructer should have near-dictatorial powers over the students 24-hours a day and they should have all their movements controlled and regimented. They need to be broken down and taught who's boss. They must learn to respect my authoriTAY!

Actually, I think that the "skills" they teach you in boot camp such as how to shine a boot or march have very little utility in real life. Lots of people get through life just fine without ever going to boot camp, so these skills are either unnecessary or can be learned in other ways.

So, what gives you the right?
I think that you've watched waaaay too many Hollywood movies about what happens in boot camp without actually having gone there yourself. I've done it and no, it wasn't terribly pleasant nor was it meant to be. It also wasn't anywhere near as bad as I thought it would be (you see, I've seen those movies too).

The skills learned are geared towards teamwork and attention to detail, something that's pretty rare in your average high schooler. Sure, many will eventually learn it in other ways and I don't recall saying otherwise. That doesn't mean that they won't benefit from learning it sooner rather than later.

This is a very significant penalty as it essentially relegates anyone who refuses to submit to this nonsense to the status of second-class citizen.
How so? If they could opt out with the full awareness that there would be consequences (this is what the Swiss do) and they decide to do so then wouldn't they themselves have decided that they wanted to take on that status?

Furthermore, this boodoggle of yours would cost real money. Facilities would have to be built. Instructors and students would have to be paid, instead of potentially paying taxes if they are in the private sector. At a time when we are looking for ways to cut the government so as to save money, this would be one more money pit.
I never said it would be free but it wouldn't cost as much as you think it would either. The facilities are already there and if more need to be built it's not like the government doesn't already own vast tracts of land. They wouldn't be building the Wynn after all.

Again, no clue. The instructors are already being paid right now (and they pay taxes out of their wages too!!!, imagine that). They are already in the military as a career choice and are in their CONUS (or shore duty) rotation. A lot of those jobs are really nothing more than make-work to give them time with their families.

Furthermore, by reducing the pool of people that the government can hire or do business with, it makes it harder for the government to get the best value for its money (taxpayer's money).
This is the first thing that you've said that I can agree with. It probably would reduce the potential civilian employee pool and put some limits on government contractors. If their skills are so critical that nobody else can do them then that's what waivers are for. Then again I can't really think of any skill that is so critical that there is only one person in the whole world that can do it.

This would be a grossly inefficient way of creating a pool of potential reserves, most of whom would soon forget whatever it is they learned.
And yet you think that it would be more efficient to scramble to gather up a military, screen and train them at the drop of a hat. Put down the bong. What makes you think that they would "Soon forget" what they learned? Why don't you go ask some other people who've been through it if they've forgotten the basic skills that they learned from it. Might they get a bit rusty? Sure, but refresher training takes a heck of a lot less time than starting from fresh.

So let's review:
North Korea
Waste of money
No demonstrable improvement of national security. "You never know" is not a demonstrable improvement.
So lets review:
Universally recognized right of all sovereign nations
Waste is subjective
"You never know" is why every nation has a military in the first place, including the ones that haven't been to war for a very, very long time.

Do you have insurance? Car, home, fire? Why? Why pay those premiums and waste all of that money? The odds are slim that your home will burn down as long as you maintain it and don't do anything stupid. If you're a safe driver you should never get in an accident. Keep your doors and windows locked and a burglar won't come in. So you're all good right?

That is what your argument boils down to.I get it. You don't like the military in general and think that we should all just get along. That's a nice sentiment and all but for those of us who live in the real world know better than to hold childlike fantasies.
 
Last edited:
That does not make any sense. What does registering for the draft have to do with an actual draft? Just because no one is being drafted does not mean they might need it later, "Crossbow" (if that is your real name). You should look up your facts. But you are hiding behind a pseudoname. So you can post whims and supposition.

Men ARE required to register for the draft in the USA when they become old enough by law:
http://www.google.com/#sclient=psy&...gc.r_pw.&fp=c488823cce0a6f39&biw=1384&bih=854

All U.S. male citizens and male aliens are currently required to sign up for the Selective Service within 30 days of their 18th birthday.

This is why I don't understand why people make web posts on internet forums under fake names. They can be wrong and accuse people of lying and hide behind a fake name.

Wow! You sure do raise a few points that I would like to address:

First of all, I did not call you a liar. While it is true that I have a low opinion about you, however I did not call you a liar.

Second of all, to answer your question, 'Crossbow' is not my real name. Just in case you have not figured it by now, but just about everyone at JREF uses handles as opposed to their real name, therefore I suggest that you keep this fact in mind in the future.

Third of all, you still do not understand the difference between a "Draft" and "Selective Service". Those two things are hardly the same, therefore I suggest that you stop using the terms interchangably.

Fourth of all, I did post that Selective Service registration was required. In fact, I said:

Crossbow said:
You are wrong about men and women registering for the draft because there is no draft. Instead, men are required to register for 'Selective Service' which is not a draft.

Therefore, I suggest in the future you read everything that the person has written as opposed to simply reacting to the one bit that makes you mad.

If not for the mindset of these earlier americans, modern evangelists and modern mormons would not exist.

Well, maybe so, but then maybe not. After all, it was quite some time ago when the Pilgrims came over and there have been many, many, many other influences besides them.

And in any event, there is no way to proove your statement so at best an unsubstantiated statement. Therefore, I would have to say that you are rather over-stating a very complex thing.

Let's try this again.

Here is my theory. Tell me where I am wrong. As I heard a business analyst once say, "how something starts is how something is". The United States is a country whose culture is akin to that of Puritans with radical, break-away Christian (abiet unique and firmly heald) ideas of codes of behavior that do not make logical sense but makes sense within their own ideas of right and wrong and ethics. War, in a biblical sense, is necessary. Rules of how to conduct war in the USA is based on the culture that they originated from. Forcing women to serve breaks their nonsensical rules.

Sure! Go ahead and try it again, and I will tell you where you are wrong again.

Applying a couple of things from a group of a few hundred settlers from a few hundred years ago to what is going on now makes little to no sense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom