Ugh. Where to start? First off, you didn't answer the question: What gives you the right? What gives you the right to order people to spend six weeks learning what you think they need to learn. This is a step in the direction of North Korea, where everyone is required to participate in militaristic nonsense. One step often leads to another, and then another.
I don't have the right however it is a sovereign right that every nation has that is recognized by every other nation so get off of your high horse.
Hey, I think that everyone should be forced to learn ballet! Yeah! And the ballet instructer should have near-dictatorial powers over the students 24-hours a day and they should have all their movements controlled and regimented. They need to be broken down and taught who's boss. They must learn to respect my authoriTAY!
Actually, I think that the "skills" they teach you in boot camp such as how to shine a boot or march have very little utility in real life. Lots of people get through life just fine without ever going to boot camp, so these skills are either unnecessary or can be learned in other ways.
So, what gives you the right?
I think that you've watched waaaay too many Hollywood movies about what happens in boot camp without actually having gone there yourself. I've done it and no, it wasn't terribly pleasant nor was it meant to be. It also wasn't anywhere near as bad as I thought it would be (you see, I've seen those movies too).
The skills learned are geared towards teamwork and attention to detail, something that's pretty rare in your average high schooler. Sure, many will eventually learn it in other ways and I don't recall saying otherwise. That doesn't mean that they won't benefit from learning it sooner rather than later.
This is a very significant penalty as it essentially relegates anyone who refuses to submit to this nonsense to the status of second-class citizen.
How so? If they could opt out with the full awareness that there would be consequences (this is what the Swiss do) and they decide to do so then wouldn't they themselves have decided that they wanted to take on that status?
Furthermore, this boodoggle of yours would cost real money. Facilities would have to be built. Instructors and students would have to be paid, instead of potentially paying taxes if they are in the private sector. At a time when we are looking for ways to cut the government so as to save money, this would be one more money pit.
I never said it would be free but it wouldn't cost as much as you think it would either. The facilities are already there and if more need to be built it's not like the government doesn't already own vast tracts of land. They wouldn't be building the Wynn after all.
Again, no clue. The instructors are already being paid
right now (and they pay taxes out of their wages too!!!, imagine that). They are already in the military as a career choice and are in their CONUS (or shore duty) rotation. A lot of those jobs are really nothing more than make-work to give them time with their families.
Furthermore, by reducing the pool of people that the government can hire or do business with, it makes it harder for the government to get the best value for its money (taxpayer's money).
This is the first thing that you've said that I can agree with. It probably would reduce the potential civilian employee pool and put some limits on government contractors. If their skills are so critical that nobody else can do them then that's what waivers are for. Then again I can't really think of any skill that is so critical that there is only one person in the whole world that can do it.
This would be a grossly inefficient way of creating a pool of potential reserves, most of whom would soon forget whatever it is they learned.
And yet you think that it would be more efficient to scramble to gather up a military, screen and train them at the drop of a hat. Put down the bong. What makes you think that they would "Soon forget" what they learned? Why don't you go ask some other people who've been through it if they've forgotten the basic skills that they learned from it. Might they get a bit rusty? Sure, but refresher training takes a heck of a lot less time than starting from fresh.
So let's review:
North Korea
Waste of money
No demonstrable improvement of national security. "You never know" is not a demonstrable improvement.
So lets review:
Universally recognized right of all sovereign nations
Waste is subjective
"You never know" is why every nation has a military in the first place, including the ones that haven't been to war for a very, very long time.
Do you have insurance? Car, home, fire? Why? Why pay those premiums and waste all of that money? The odds are slim that your home will burn down as long as you maintain it and don't do anything stupid. If you're a safe driver you should never get in an accident. Keep your doors and windows locked and a burglar won't come in. So you're all good right?
That is what your argument boils down to.I get it. You don't like the military in general and think that we should all just get along. That's a nice sentiment and all but for those of us who live in the real world know better than to hold childlike fantasies.