Torture memo...OMG

Nonsense. I didn't say that.
I meant it seriously as I feel it accurately represents what you said. Since you say it does not, please clarify for me what you actually meant and how it is different from the UN/Darfur situation.
 
That's a completely unfair comparison. We impeached Nixon.

After he did what he did. So much for checks and balances.

Remember "It isn't illegal if the President does it" - or however it went? I really think Nixon believed that, and he sure was one who knew how the US works.
 
I meant it seriously as I feel it accurately represents what you said. Since you say it does not, please clarify for me what you actually meant and how it is different from the UN/Darfur situation.

There's a hell of a difference between undesirable and illegal.
 
There's a hell of a difference between undesirable and illegal.
Point 1: Genocide isn't illegal?

Point 2: So your issue is one of definitions and not of efficacy?

Point 3: So you have no problem if I amend my analogy to all Danish laws needing to be abolished because crimes still occur? Or I can at least insist Danish laws not be held up as a good example of a legal system?
 
Point 1: Genocide isn't illegal?

Point 2: So your issue is one of definitions and not of efficacy?

Point 3: So you have no problem if I amend my analogy to all Danish laws needing to be abolished because crimes still occur? Or I can at least insist Danish laws not be held up as a good example of a legal system?

I have absolutely no idea what you are getting at.

You introduced "undesirable". The 'splainin' is all yours.
 
After he did what he did. So much for checks and balances.

Remember "It isn't illegal if the President does it" - or however it went? I really think Nixon believed that, and he sure was one who knew how the US works.

Check circuts. Humour detection routines have failed.
 
I have absolutely no idea what you are getting at.

You introduced "undesirable". The 'splainin' is all yours.
Yes, I did. But you did NOT introduce "illegal" in the post to which I was responding. So if you want to split hairs, keep it to the hair we're looking at.
 
Wow, go away for less than a day, and blam....2 plus pages of posting to read.

I kind of figured it would become a hot topic....

Alot of excellent points on both sides of the argument. The arguments at times, as expected, tangented (a word??) into torture dos and dont and even occasionally way off into Iraq war issues...oh well.

My 2 cents:

Torture tends to be very nebulous. To help us with it's wide scope, we have, in part, the Geneva conventions

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geneva_Conventions

We also have our own societal "moral compass".

In times of peace, in times of fearlessness, the limits to such things are quite clear. War and fear however, tend to provide a dense fog, a cloud cover so to speak, making our ability to navigate the issue much harder.

The closer the personal connection, also the denser the fog...

For instance, if you were a 50 year old mother, whose son was detained by Chinese Police after a protest, and whom they were "interrogating" to obtain information on the leader of the protest, a man wanted a great deal by them, would you accept the "near drowning" ,face slapping, and other methods we discuss here? If not, what would be tolerable for you to allow them to do to your son?

If 20 white americans were captured by the government of an Arab Nation, and were to be "Interrogated" for allegedly participating in collection of "state secrets", what would you consider tolerable? What if the captured were arabs and the interrogators white americans?

If your father was found to have connections to a man that murdered 20 American FBI agents in an act of terrorism, because they shot and killed his entire family, what would you allow them to do to get the info out of your father?

Finally, If your entire family was allegedly killed by a group of women terrorists, what would you allow the authorities to do to get info out of them, or to get confessions from them?

This issue, torture, and what is acceptable and not, is far, far from an easy one. It is a moral dilemma that is too emotion provoking to be made by an individual at all connected to a particular event. As well, it brings into it the issues of war, fear, race, and religion. As a result, i think that we should abide by those laws made by intelligent, and circumstantially DISTANT individuals who set forth the guidelines of Geneva.

TAM:)
 
The closer the personal connection, also the denser the fog...

For instance, if you were a 50 year old mother, whose son was detained by Chinese Police after a protest, and whom they were "interrogating" to obtain information on the leader of the protest, a man wanted a great deal by them, would you accept the "near drowning" ,face slapping, and other methods we discuss here? If not, what would be tolerable for you to allow them to do to your son?

If 20 white americans were captured by the government of an Arab Nation, and were to be "Interrogated" for allegedly participating in collection of "state secrets", what would you consider tolerable? What if the captured were arabs and the interrogators white americans?

If your father was found to have connections to a man that murdered 20 American FBI agents in an act of terrorism, because they shot and killed his entire family, what would you allow them to do to get the info out of your father?

Finally, If your entire family was allegedly killed by a group of women terrorists, what would you allow the authorities to do to get info out of them, or to get confessions from them?
Which gets to what I have said several times on this board.

Torture is admissible if and only if the person administering it is willing to suffer the personal legal consequences regardless if the torture does or does not accomplish what is intended. It is easy for me to say I will sacrifice my prisoner in order to save five million people from the hypothetical nuclear bomb or to save my family from the hypothetical terrorists. It is another thing entirely to say that I will sacrifice myself for those reasons. The only instance under which I will consider giving a torturer a moral pass (not a legal one) is when that torturer, after all is said and done, surrenders himself voluntarily to the authorites and confesses to the crime and says "I did it because I felt the ends justified not only hurting my prisoner but sacrificing my freedom." Failing that, it's mach posturing without moral value.
 
First, I didn't say there was a political system that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. That isn't the question here. The question is, is Bush "rogue"? As in out-of-control?

Secondly, if Bush is rogue, then it is clear that the "checks and balances" are not sufficient to keep him in check. What good is it to bring him up on charges later, when the damage is done?

One constructive idea: Stop bragging about "checks and balances", when they clearly don't stop someone like Bush from doing what he wants when he is president.

It sure didn't stop Nixon.

Perhaps this is news for you since you are so busy killing people that you see on a plane with a gun, but the legal system is supposed to be reactive.

A person is cited for speeding after he was caught speeding.
A person is arrested for robbery after he committed the robbery.
President Nixon resigned after his role in the Watergate cover-up became clear.

Just like legal actions cannot be instituted against a person before they commit a crime, legal proceedings against a president cannot be instituted before that president actually commits a crime.
 
Just like legal actions cannot be instituted against a person before they commit a crime, legal proceedings against a president cannot be instituted before that president actually commits a crime.
That's... cute?
 
Is this memo out yet? Yet another "debate the ethics of torture" thread is tiresome retread material.
 
Is this memo out yet? Yet another "debate the ethics of torture" thread is tiresome retread material.
To be fair, that's not what the topic started out as.

To be snarky, not everyone participates in every "debate the ethics of torture" thread. There are enough people on this board who post at enough varying times with enough varying interests to support many such retreads. You are not obligated to participate.
 
First, I didn't say there was a political system that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. That isn't the question here. The question is, is Bush "rogue"? As in out-of-control?

Your statement was:
If you do have a rogue President, then clearly your system isn't strong enough to prevent such a thing.

How does that turn into "Is he really out of control?" Clearly your English needs some work.

I do believe he is dangerously out of control. His party used to be able to control him to a moderate extent. Now, he has alienated just about everyone and he sees no reason to stop these avenues of alienation.

Secondly, if Bush is rogue, then it is clear that the "checks and balances" are not sufficient to keep him in check. What good is it to bring him up on charges later, when the damage is done?

You can't prosecute anyone before the crime is committed. Maybe in your country, drivers find speeding tickets under their windshield wipers for an infraction the police know will occur later on but that's not our custom here. One day, we will all have developed sufficient psychic abilities to arrest all those criminal fetus while they're still in the womb. How I long for those days to arrive! :boggled:

One constructive idea: Stop bragging about "checks and balances", when they clearly don't stop someone like Bush from doing what he wants when he is president.

That's a constructive idea? I always tell myself "consider the source". In that light, I thank you for your tremendous contribution to the field of political science.

Who was bragging about checks and balances? You can't preempt someone from doing something that they can do. You can only prosecute him/her later. Is there a system you know of that prevents a cashier from stealing money instantaneously? How about stopping a jaywalker? Can I prevent you from posting nonsense on this Forum? (Darat can but only once he's got good reason to. Oh, how I long for those days to arrive!)

It sure didn't stop Nixon.

Your knowledge of history is tantamount to my knowledge of hang-gliding. That is, not at all. The only reason Nixon resigned was because (1) the Judicial Branch ordered him to release the evidence that (2) the Legislative Branch was going to use to convict him. Just how old are you?
 
Last edited:
Check circuts. Humour detection routines have failed.

Call it sarcasm or even irony, and I'm with'ya.

Yes, I did. But you did NOT introduce "illegal" in the post to which I was responding. So if you want to split hairs, keep it to the hair we're looking at.

I'm not splitting hairs. What did you mean by "undesirable"? Elder Bush thinks atheists are undesirable in the US. Is that what you meant?

Perhaps this is news for you since you are so busy killing people that you see on a plane with a gun,

Way to poison the well.

but the legal system is supposed to be reactive.

A person is cited for speeding after he was caught speeding.
A person is arrested for robbery after he committed the robbery.
President Nixon resigned after his role in the Watergate cover-up became clear.

Just like legal actions cannot be instituted against a person before they commit a crime, legal proceedings against a president cannot be instituted before that president actually commits a crime.

Yeah. But when it comes to someone who has his finger on the red button - not just so to speak - it might be a good idea to have a system that prevents that someone from going nuts.

We are not talking about the President drunk driving. M'kay?
 
I'm not splitting hairs.
Then we shouldn't have a problem.


What did you mean by "undesirable"?
Actions analogous to whatever would prompt you to say we shouldn't "brag" about checks and balances. When you define those things better, I will define "undesirable" better.


Elder Bush thinks atheists are undesirable in the US. Is that what you meant?
Nope.


There. I have answered your questions. Please answer mine. I'll restate them for you (worded differently, perhaps):

1. Why did you introduce "illegal" in comparison to my "undesirable" when "illegal" wasn't in the post to which I was responding?

2. Is genocide illegal?

3. Is your issue one of definitions and not of efficacy?

4. Would you have a problem if I amend my analogy to all Danish laws needing to be abolished because crimes still occur? Can I insist Danish laws not be held up as a good example of a legal system?
 
Yeah. But when it comes to someone who has his finger on the red button - not just so to speak - it might be a good idea to have a system that prevents that someone from going nuts.
Start with a blank slate. What would a hypothetical system that accomplishes that look like?
 
You can't prosecute anyone before the crime is committed. Maybe in your country, drivers find speeding tickets under their windshield wipers for an infraction the police know will occur later on but that's not our custom here. One day, we will all have developed sufficient psychic abilities to arrest all those criminal fetus while they're still in the womb. How I long for those days to arrive! :boggled:
Unless they can win the Million Dollar Challenge, they are not True Psychics.
Who was bragging about checks and balances?
A character from the film Wizard of Oz who wished he had a brain.
You can't preempt someone from doing something that they can do. You can only prosecute him/her later.
Nitpick: you can try to deter through policies of consequences for bad actions.
Is there a system you know of that prevents a cashier from stealing money instantaneously?
Fear of getting caught. Hmm, not much of a system.
How about stopping a jaywalker?
If they are on a plane, and yet to jaywalk, there are alleged to be some Danish enforcers available. Not sure about the billable hour rate.
Can I prevent you from posting nonsense on this Forum? (Darat can but only once he's got good reason to. Oh, how I long for those days to arrive!)
Spilled my soda, I did, you slimething you! :D
Your knowledge of history is tantamount to my knowledge of hang-gliding. That is, not at all. The only reason Nixon resigned was because (1) the Judicial Branch ordered him to release the evidence that (2) the Legislative Branch was going to use to convict him. Just how old are you?
I thought he resigned because he was "not a crook." ;) Learn something new every day. :cool:

DR
 
This issue, torture, and what is acceptable and not, is far, far from an easy one. It is a moral dilemma that is too emotion provoking to be made by an individual at all connected to a particular event. As well, it brings into it the issues of war, fear, race, and religion. As a result, i think that we should abide by those laws made by intelligent, and circumstantially DISTANT individuals who set forth the guidelines of Geneva.

TAM:)

I disagree.
Mistreatment of prisoners is not acceptable. Ever.
Simple.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom