Torture memo...OMG

Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?
 
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?

What part of America do you hate most? The rule of law, or our freedoms?
 
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?
The problem there is that once you start adopting tactics which are little better than those of your enemy, you lose any claims of moral superiority.
 
The problem there is that once you start adopting tactics which are little better than those of your enemy, you lose any claims of moral superiority.

So it's not about winning, it's about being "morally superior"? What is the practical value of being "morally superior" but dead?
 
So it's not about winning, it's about being "morally superior"? What is the practical value of being "morally superior" but dead?
Are you going to pretend that torturing people saves lives? It is, after all, "against our laws, and against our values."
 
Morality is an evolutionary adaptation that allows us to cooperate with potential allies. Cooperation makes us stronger so that we can vanquish those who would do us harm.
 
Morality is an evolutionary adaptation that allows us to cooperate with potential allies. Cooperation makes us stronger so that we can vanquish those who would do us harm.

Two questions:

1) are you, have you ever been, or do you plan to be a member of the armed forces?

2) do you play Dungeons & Dragons? "Vanquish those who would do us harm"?!?! Who talks like that?
 
I scanned the article, is there a direct link to this memo?

No, the White House is refusing to release that memo. I also heard there's a second secret memo that Congress wants.

Opinion: If it isn't obvious to everyone that we have a rogue President right now, I would be astounded. Some people like rogues. I don't, at lest not in elected positions. This is what happens when we placate the Moral Majority.
 
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?

Given that KSM has confessed to so many crimes, I find it hard to believe he committed all of them. The crime against Daniel Pearl was disgraceful, but forcing someone to confess doesn't necessarily mean they did it.
 
So, are you saying that you don't mind if American troops are tortured?

I do mind. But I don't think they needed this as a pretext. The bad guys were already many orders of moral magnitude worse than this to begin with. They would torture US troops anyway, IMHO.
 
Yes, there is.

To those of us who follow the real news instead of just watching the mainstream news, none of this is new news. I am, however, glad to see it all over the mainstream news today.

skeptigirl, that's not the memo mentioned in the article although it's probably very close. You posted a link to a memo that was discovered and then publicly repudiated by the White House. In 2005, upon the installment of Speedy Gonzales* as Attorney General, the DoJ issued two secret memos un-repudiating the 2002 memo and, apparently, re-authorizing torture of suspected terrorists.

If it wasn't so twisted and disgusting, it would be comical. Kinda like triple super-secret probation for the omegas.

* I never in my entire life expected to know of anyone who would make me say that maybe Ashcroft wasn't so bad. This guy proved me wrong.
 
I do mind. But I don't think they needed this as a pretext. The bad guys were already many orders of moral magnitude worse than this to begin with. They would torture US troops anyway, IMHO.

That's not my point. My point is this: do you find the practice of torture to be wrong, or is it only wrong when you don't get to pick the victims?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom