Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)
The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results.
WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up
claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?
The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable.
Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in.
The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.
Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!
And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.
Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?