Torture memo...OMG

I'll back down and say I don't advocate torture of anyone who hasn't been convicted of crime against humanity.
Torture as revenge, then, as opposed to a means of acquiring information?


I'm just saying I would be happy if people like Denis Rader or the people who killed Daniel Pearl or the guy who shot John Lennon were really made to pay for their crimes.
I would shed no tears, but it would not bring me joy.


This seems logical to me.
It seems purely emotional to me.


You don't administer the same punishment for armed robbery as for shoplifting, so why administer the same punishment to Denis Rader as you do to a garden variety murderer?
Because we have agreed there are limits to what actions are appropriate even in the face of someone else violating those limits. Granted that the limits are not starkly drawn lines, but I for one agree with them and favor erring on the side of stopping too short as opposed to stepping too far.
 
Last edited:
If you do have a rogue President, then clearly your system isn't strong enough to prevent such a thing.

All that talk about "checks and balances" is just that: Talk.

The first statement is banal; the second, incorrect.

First, I know of no political system ever deviced that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. Do you?

Secondly, the checks and balances built into the Constitution have been tested and have been shown to work many, many times. Our present problem is that everyone in the USA is entitled to due process. Bringing Bush up on charges toward eventual impeachment would probably take as long as the time he has remaining in his term. It's a practical, not an ideological, distinction.

If you have any constructive ideas, let's hear them.
 
And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?
That's the key question, and a critical question on the nature of adopting such a policy. One can get into discussions between "what is torture" and "what is reasonable if hard treatment" of a confinee, but not taking the time to establish such a policy in a lawful manner is a matter that Congress, and the people are justifiably upset about. The two faced nature of how this has been pursued is a stain on the executive branch that chose this path.

DR
 
The US is ripping out fingernails? :confused:

Who can say that we aren't?

That's one of the problems with the duplicity of the Bush administration: once you've eroded the trust levels to this point, no one can honestly and rationally say "no, the U.S. is absolutely not doing X", because Bush's White House has already been caught lying about whether or not they were doing A-W.
 
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)

The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?

The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable. :rolleyes:

Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in. :rolleyes:

The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.

Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!

And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.

Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?


Thank you! So glad you're here.


I don't want to torture anyone, but I also don't want myself or other innocent people to be tortured or killed.

So, you're only in favour of torturing those people who have been tried and found guilty? Anyone not haveing been tried and found guilty being, by the standards of US justice, Innocent.
 
As Puppy Cow demonstrates, you judge a man's character by how he treats whom he doesn't have to treat well.

Puppy Cow, consider yourself judged.

ETA: Oh holy cow (:D), this thread is longer than I thought it was. My post is now obselete.
 
Last edited:
I'll back down and say I don't advocate torture of anyone who hasn't been convicted of crime against humanity. See my reasoning actually has nothing to do with the "War on Terror" and would have made just as much sense pre-9/11 as post-9/11.

I'm just saying I would be happy if people like Denis Rader or the people who killed Daniel Pearl or the guy who shot John Lennon were really made to pay for their crimes. This seems logical to me. You don't administer the same punishment for armed robbery as for shoplifting, so why administer the same punishment to Denis Rader as you do to a garden variety murderer?

Thanks much for the retraction!

However, now it sounds as if you want to use torture as a tool of legal punishment as opposed to having torture used as a form of legal interrogation.

If this is the case, then I suggest that you familiarize yourself with the Constitution of the United States of America, and Article 8 in particular which states:

Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.

Therefore, in order to give torture a legal sanction will require, at the very least, a serious re-write of the Constitution.

Are you sure that you want to go down that road?

I most certainly do not, since it leads to hell.
 
The US is ripping out fingernails? :confused:

For that, the USA out-sources. Guess why the Rendition program exists?

Of course, there was Abu Ghraib, in case you forgot. But the exposure of Abu Ghraib made a fair few higher-up's nervous, even though it was only bottom and middling ranks who got punished for that (IOW, only those following the orders got punished, none of those who actually gave the orders or put the pressure on to start suchlike were punished).
 
This is the chickens*#t argument. On Sept 11, we lost 3000 people - out of 300 million. We lose 10 times as many each year in car wrecks. We as individuals are in very little danger of becoming dead.

In response, we have invaded 2 countries, killed hundreds of thousands of civilians, lost almost 4000 of our soldiers, spent more than half a trillion dollars, and failed to catch those responsible for the attack.

This is clearly not about winning. No matter how hard all this is spun, it still does not look like winning. We are bankrupting our economy, our military, and our ethics while losing our liberties and freedoms in the process. And accomplishing jack diddly squat.

You might want to reconsider the value of a little moral superiority.

Nominated. Not because I think it'll win, truth in politics is inherently divisive, but because more people should read it.
 
What I have always wondered with regards to this issue is simply this...if torture as a means of getting information is effective, why not employ these same methods for use in domestic criminal investigations. Afterall, if water-boarding isn't "torture" then surely it must not be "cruel and unusual" either.
 
Maybe that was what you intended, but that's not the way it came off.
I think if you read it again you'll find it's not so much the statement itself but rather the context of the prior post which may have made it come across differently. In any case, yes, it is the general point which is the issue I was getting at.
 
Were you one those people who expected Iraqis to greet us as liberators while providing flowers and candy?
We needn't derail a thread about the Administration's apparent endorsement of torture with a rewrite of history.

They did greet us with flowers anyway, if not candy; I received more than one flower in April of 2003. The fact that we screwed it up since does not change the nature of the initial welcome.
 
The first statement is banal; the second, incorrect.

First, I know of no political system ever deviced that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. Do you?

Secondly, the checks and balances built into the Constitution have been tested and have been shown to work many, many times. Our present problem is that everyone in the USA is entitled to due process. Bringing Bush up on charges toward eventual impeachment would probably take as long as the time he has remaining in his term. It's a practical, not an ideological, distinction.

If you have any constructive ideas, let's hear them.

First, I didn't say there was a political system that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. That isn't the question here. The question is, is Bush "rogue"? As in out-of-control?

Secondly, if Bush is rogue, then it is clear that the "checks and balances" are not sufficient to keep him in check. What good is it to bring him up on charges later, when the damage is done?

One constructive idea: Stop bragging about "checks and balances", when they clearly don't stop someone like Bush from doing what he wants when he is president.

It sure didn't stop Nixon.
 
First, I didn't say there was a political system that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. That isn't the question here. The question is, is Bush "rogue"? As in out-of-control?

Secondly, if Bush is rogue, then it is clear that the "checks and balances" are not sufficient to keep him in check. What good is it to bring him up on charges later, when the damage is done?

One constructive idea: Stop bragging about "checks and balances", when they clearly don't stop someone like Bush from doing what he wants when he is president.

It sure didn't stop Nixon.

That's a completely unfair comparison. We impeached Nixon.
 
First, I didn't say there was a political system that completely excludes self-righteous, ignorant and arrogant people. That isn't the question here. The question is, is Bush "rogue"? As in out-of-control?

Secondly, if Bush is rogue, then it is clear that the "checks and balances" are not sufficient to keep him in check. What good is it to bring him up on charges later, when the damage is done?

One constructive idea: Stop bragging about "checks and balances", when they clearly don't stop someone like Bush from doing what he wants when he is president.

It sure didn't stop Nixon.
I see. So anytime anything undesirable occurs it means there is no value (anything worth "bragging about") in any system intended to prevent it or curb it.

Dismantle the UN immediately. Darfur is still Darfur.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom