Darth Rotor
Salted Sith Cynic
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2006
- Messages
- 38,527
How is mistreatment different from torture? Can you please be specific?I disagree.
Mistreatment of prisoners is not acceptable. Ever.
Simple.
DR
How is mistreatment different from torture? Can you please be specific?I disagree.
Mistreatment of prisoners is not acceptable. Ever.
Simple.
Straw man fallacy. I am in favor of basic human decency.
I think decent humans should be treated well.
Most, if not all, of those being tortured aren't given fair trial to determine if they are "decent" humans or not. In otherwords, we could very well be torturing innocent people just because they have brown skin and talk funny.
But you won't let that bother you, right?
Bringing up other US faults is a red herring. There is no shortage of other US faults. The point of my comment had nothing to do with good and evil. Throughout the wars this country has fought, where the threats were as great (greater IMO) than the threat of terrorist attacks today, we didn't feel the need to officially sanction torture of POWs as a means of getting information from them.Well, there was the Japanese Internment in WW II. That wasn't torture but it was still shameful. And that's the larger point. We are all people. People get scared. People do stupid and sometimes mean things when scared. If scared enough, people will abandon what they've believed all their lives. Only to regret it to the bone later on. Torture if one of those things that you would not be able to look your kids in the eye and admit you were in favor of it because you were afraid.
This is a bad mistake. We can avoid it and should.
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)
The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?
The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable.
Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in.
The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.
Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!
And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.
Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?
fishbob said:This is the chickens*#t argument. On Sept 11, we lost 3000 people - out of 300 million. We lose 10 times as many each year in car wrecks. We as individuals are in very little danger of becoming dead.
In response, we have invaded 2 countries, killed hundreds of thousands of civilians, lost almost 4000 of our soldiers, spent more than half a trillion dollars, and failed to catch those responsible for the attack.
This is clearly not about winning. No matter how hard all this is spun, it still does not look like winning. We are bankrupting our economy, our military, and our ethics while losing our liberties and freedoms in the process. And accomplishing jack diddly squat.
You might want to reconsider the value of a little moral superiority.

I disagree.
Mistreatment of prisoners is not acceptable. Ever.
Simple.
Excellent point.When Americans fight and die in wars its ostensibly to defend morals, principles, justice, ways of life, etc. That is an example of morals trumping self-preservation. If you truly believed that self-preservation is most important you would believe in never fighting in any wars and submitting to the will of other governments to avoid possible attacks, thats the safety trading for liberty flaw that Franklin complained about some having.
Because half the country who votes, voted for a leader with a very warped sense of power and really poor morals of his own....Why might America be doing this?...
True enough, though you do realize that at Gitmo, the status of POW is still a matter of some considerable dispute. Likewise, the detainees who, in the first year in Iraq, ended up in the overcrowded Abu Ghraib prison were often other than POW, though that alone is no excuse to apply other than standard jail/disciplinary barracks rules right out of the Army FM. (Note: At a DB, torture is no more correct a policy than in a regular jail.)Bringing up other US faults is a red herring. There is no shortage of other US faults. The point of my comment had nothing to do with good and evil. Throughout the wars this country has fought, where the threats were as great (greater IMO) than the threat of terrorist attacks today, we didn't feel the need to officially sanction torture of POWs as a means of getting information from them.
I repeat what I said earlier in this thread, this is not new information. There is overwhelming evidence the US has indeed been torturing prisoners, 2 of them were mistakenly arrested and were tortured for months. And if you want to quibble we sent one of the two to be tortured by someone else, Gonzales has said publicly as has Bush and Cheney, that they are defining torture as anything worse than the measures they've chosen to approve of. Even this week the new spokesliar for Bush, Dana Perino, said it was her understanding each country could interpret the Geneva conventions for themselves. In other words, if you don't suffer massive organ failure you weren't tortured.We've been fooled by overblown memo stories in the past. Withholding judgement unless it actually surfaces...
I think most of the "complexity" is bogus, and covers for psychological defects in some people.This is your pov, based on your "moral compass" it is no more (or less) right than anyone elses really, but it is yours, and you are entitled. I think the issue is more complex for many people.
TAM![]()
Joe, TAM is a doctor, and a person of considerable empathy. I cannot fathom why you would want to throw rocks at him like that. He's been a fellow traveller in the anti CT crowd, and a voice of reason. FWIW, he deserves better than that.I think most of the "complexity" is bogus, and covers for psychological defects in some people.
Are you seriously asking if I realize the US is arresting and detaining without charges people from many countries including a couple of US citizens, getting around habeas corpus by making up the fake category of enemy combatant?True enough, though you do realize that at Gitmo, the status of POW is still a matter of some considerable dispute. Likewise, the detainees who, in the first year in Iraq, ended up in the overcrowded Abu Ghraib prison were often other than POW, though that alone is no excuse to apply other than standard jail/disciplinary barracks rules right out of the Army FM. (Note: At a DB, torture is no more correct a policy than in a regular jail.)
The rendition issue is a related matter that is not confined to the current war on terror era.
DR
Bringing up other US faults is a red herring. There is no shortage of other US faults. The point of my comment had nothing to do with good and evil. Throughout the wars this country has fought, where the threats were as great (greater IMO) than the threat of terrorist attacks today, we didn't feel the need to officially sanction torture of POWs as a means of getting information from them.

You left out if he hadn't mentioned bringing democracy to Iraq as well since we only want Democracy if they elect the leaders we approve of.....If he [Bush] had only emphasized winning at any cost and never mentioned anything to do with morality, then that would be different.
....
Joe, TAM is a doctor, and a person of considerable empathy. I cannot fathom why you would want to throw rocks at him like that. He's been a fellow traveller in the anti CT crowd, and a voice of reason. FWIW, he deserves better than that.
DR
You left out if he hadn't mentioned bringing democracy to Iraq as well since we only want Democracy if they elect the leaders we approve of.
And we bomb infants and children and call it collateral damage. Your comment is nothing but a red herring.Currently, they get beheaded.
Of course not, that leaves evidence showing.The US is ripping out fingernails?![]()
Of course not. They out-source the real torture.