Torture memo...OMG

I do mind. But I don't think they needed this as a pretext. The bad guys were already many orders of moral magnitude worse than this to begin with. They would torture US troops anyway, IMHO.

You make a very good pragmatic point, Puppycow, and I pretty much agree with you with regard to people we are certain know secrets that would kill many others. The problem is how to know them. Osama was well known by the US armed forces before he became the most hated man in the world. So, how would you know whom to torture? Also, as we've seen, we can't trust many of the people making the big decisions as far as we can throw them so how would we citizens ensure that they would stop where we wanted them to?

From my perspective, torture under any circumstances is so against my concept of what the USA stands for that I would vote against it. Yes, I would rather be one of those bodies falling from a high building than see the ideal of democracy fail because some lunatics learned how to use explosives. That's what you fought for, isn't it?
 
Given that KSM has confessed to so many crimes, I find it hard to believe he committed all of them. The crime against Daniel Pearl was disgraceful, but forcing someone to confess doesn't necessarily mean they did it.

Last I hear Gonzales was photoshopping KSM's image onto the grassy knoll just as JFK's motorcade passed by. ;)
 
That's not my point. My point is this: do you find the practice of torture to be wrong, or is it only wrong when you don't get to pick the victims?

The latter. Let me ask you: Is there no historical person (Hitler for example) who you wouldn't be at least secretly happy if they were tortured?
 
The latter. Let me ask you: Is there no historical person (Hitler for example) who you wouldn't be at least secretly happy if they were tortured?

I'm not interesting in playing hypothetical games, especially not when the real issue is so serious, and you are admitting to being against basic human decency.
 
From my perspective, torture under any circumstances is so against my concept of what the USA stands for that I would vote against it. Yes, I would rather be one of those bodies falling from a high building than see the ideal of democracy fail because some lunatics learned how to use explosives. That's what you fought for, isn't it?
I just don't understand how people can simply reject basic values like the rule of law and even their own humanity, based on cowardice. Of course, not being a coward myself, of course I have a hard time with it. I will never get it... why do these people hold democracy in so little regard?
 
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)

The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?

The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable. :rolleyes:

Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in. :rolleyes:

The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.

Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!

And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.

Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?
 
The latter. Let me ask you: Is there no historical person (Hitler for example) who you wouldn't be at least secretly happy if they were tortured?
  1. Favorable emotions are associated with X.
  2. Therefore, X is true.
Wait, wait, I know this one!
 
The latter. Let me ask you: Is there no historical person (Hitler for example) who you wouldn't be at least secretly happy if they were tortured?

Kind of sad that someone's needless suffering could somehow bring you happiness.

Plus, tortue is generally used to get information, not just to physically assault someone for the purpose of physical assault. And usually the information derived through tortue is useless, most people will just make up useless information or agree with where the questioning is going simply to stop the pain. How many finger nails of yours being ripped out would it take before you sold out your mother?
 
You make a very good pragmatic point, Puppycow, and I pretty much agree with you with regard to people we are certain know secrets that would kill many others. The problem is how to know them. Osama was well known by the US armed forces before he became the most hated man in the world. So, how would you know whom to torture? Also, as we've seen, we can't trust many of the people making the big decisions as far as we can throw them so how would we citizens ensure that they would stop where we wanted them to?
Those are difficult questions. Electing more trustworthy people would be a start, but all people are human beings so nobody can be fully trusted. We may need some sort of new system to handle terrorists that balances different concerns.

From my perspective, torture under any circumstances is so against my concept of what the USA stands for that I would vote against it. Yes, I would rather be one of those bodies falling from a high building than see the ideal of democracy fail because some lunatics learned how to use explosives. That's what you fought for, isn't it?
Um... So you're saying for you that moral superiority trumps self-preservation?
I don't think that's quite what I was "fighting for."
I believe in justice ("believe" isn't really the right word: I wish there was more justice). I would like cruel people who deliberately cause pain and suffering to themselves experience an equal amount of pain and suffering. But I have a problem because I don't think that there's a God who is going to adminster justice in some afterlife. I wish I could, because then I wouldn't be worried about evil people, and I would find it very easy to "turn the other cheek."
I don't want to torture anyone, but I also don't want myself or other innocent people to be tortured or killed.
 
This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.

Well, there was the Japanese Internment in WW II. That wasn't torture but it was still shameful. And that's the larger point. We are all people. People get scared. People do stupid and sometimes mean things when scared. If scared enough, people will abandon what they've believed all their lives. Only to regret it to the bone later on. Torture if one of those things that you would not be able to look your kids in the eye and admit you were in favor of it because you were afraid.

This is a bad mistake. We can avoid it and should.
 
I'm not interesting in playing hypothetical games, especially not when the real issue is so serious, and you are admitting to being against basic human decency.

Straw man fallacy. I am in favor of basic human decency.

I think decent humans should be treated well.
 
I just don't understand how people can simply reject basic values like the rule of law and even their own humanity, based on cowardice. Of course, not being a coward myself, of course I have a hard time with it. I will never get it... why do these people hold democracy in so little regard?

Ad Hominem fallacy: People who don't agree with me are cowards.
 
When Americans fight and die in wars its ostensibly to defend morals, principles, justice, ways of life, etc. That is an example of morals trumping self-preservation. If you truly believed that self-preservation is most important you would believe in never fighting in any wars and submitting to the will of other governments to avoid possible attacks, thats the safety trading for liberty flaw that Franklin complained about some having.

Currently Americans and the American government are doing the most cowardly thing that any Americans have ever done, which is to voluntarily choose to change the government into one with less liberty not because of enemies that might conquer and force us to change but because of enemies which merely scare us and pose no other threat to our freedom or political system. At least the French tried to stave off the Germans and didn't out of fear cowardly change into another kind of government before the Germans even showed that they had the ability to conquer France.

Why might America be doing this? I don't know but maybe its because of a winner's complex that the generations after WW2 and the Cold War have, like the winner's complex some boxers get like Joe Louis before he fought Max Schmeling. Americans have been safe, rich, superpowerful and completely democratic and free for 60 years so now we're in a fat, doped up elvis stage of development that precedes a rapid downfall.
 
Those are difficult questions. Electing more trustworthy people would be a start, but all people are human beings so nobody can be fully trusted. We may need some sort of new system to handle terrorists that balances different concerns.

Really, I hate to be this mean but I believe that extracting information out of people like terrorists who, by definition, have pretty much already lost touch with reality would not be difficult for a fairly gifted psychologist. I'm not saying torture but, maybe, treatment. Make them get back in touch for reality, even for five minutes. Then make them see what they've done. That would cause anyone such searing psychological pain that it would dwarf all the headslapping and waterboarding you could do to them in a year. Probably just a pipe dream.

Um... So you're saying for you that moral superiority trumps self-preservation?

For the individual, no. For Democracy, yes. That is what Democracy is all about. Maybe not "superiority" as that merely means that you can puff out your chest and judge others. But, simple morality or ethics is what Democracy stands on. Otherwise, the democracies of the world would become the Balkans, the Iraq (:D), maybe even the USSR in not too long a time.

What has really happened? Would you have even considered advocating torture on 9/10/2001? So, our security forces dropped their guard and some psychopaths got lucky and killed thousands the next day. In the grand scheme of things, what should we do? Learn to keep our defenses up or lash out and torture people guilty of only making us believe they know something we want to know? My opinion is, let's not let our guard down again. Let's live well and watch these idiots die of ulcers due to the hate they have for us while we laugh and party. But let's not leave the door open to them again. Many, many people and system failed that tragic day. If we could all learn to do what we are supposed to do and not blame the crazies for taking advantage of our dereliction, we would all be safe again.

I don't think that's quite what I was "fighting for."

Puppycow, I don't feel I can lecture to you. You've been in the armed forces but I haven't so I don't know your service life but I'm sure it was a hard one. I am indebted to you for being there, war or no. Just being there makes a heck of a difference. And, yes, perhaps you would wield a scalpel of justice with absolute fairness and wisdom. I think someone like you might. I wouldn't trust myself though. I've lived long enough to know that I'm not the man I wanted to be. I've disappointed too many people to trust myself with that type of power or responsibility.

I believe in justice ("believe" isn't really the right word: I wish there was more justice). I would like cruel people who deliberately cause pain and suffering to themselves experience an equal amount of pain and suffering. But I have a problem because I don't think that there's a God who is going to administer justice in some afterlife. I wish I could, because then I wouldn't be worried about evil people, and I would find it very easy to "turn the other cheek."
I don't want to torture anyone, but I also don't want myself or other innocent people to be tortured or killed.

Well stated. Word up.
 
We've been fooled by overblown memo stories in the past. Withholding judgement unless it actually surfaces...
 
The problem there is that once you start adopting tactics which are little better than those of your enemy, you lose any claims of moral superiority.

You think being harsh to prisoners is only a little better than what Al Qaeda does to prisoners? You've lost all perspective then. Regardless of whether or not you think we've sunk below the standards we should maintain, we aren't even close to our enemy. Not even on our worst days.
 
Kind of sad that someone's needless suffering could somehow bring you happiness.
I think if you take a good look at the world and history that you'll find plenty of sadder stuff than that.

Plus, tortue is generally used to get information, not just to physically assault someone for the purpose of physical assault. And usually the information derived through tortue is useless, most people will just make up useless information or agree with where the questioning is going simply to stop the pain. How many finger nails of yours being ripped out would it take before you sold out your mother?

I'm not claiming it gets good information.
 
So it's not about winning, it's about being "morally superior"? What is the practical value of being "morally superior" but dead?

For me, it is about winning. I can't stand Bush precisely because we have lost this war.

I think we lost it precisely because of the insane arrogance that drove the administration to think that they were above the law, and that the prohibitions against torture only applied to the bad guys. The world really does hate us now, and the most extreme among our enemies really do want to kill us, and there are a lot more of those people, who want to kill us, than there were back when the war started.

If you were to search the archives for posts, you would find I started writing back in 2004, and was still cautiously optimistic that democracy would win the day in Iraq. As time went on, I grew less and less hopeful. One thing, though, remained constant. Whether in 2004, 2005, 2006, or 2007, I said that whatever happens, Bush gets the credit, or the blame. I say the same thing now, but it will be blame. The war is over. We lost. Iraq is in civil war and whatever rises from the ashes there, it won't be democracy. The only question is how many more of our soldiers will die before the government admits it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom