Torture memo...OMG

I'm with LoneWolf, why do you not condone torture, Ziggy? Give us a "good" argument against torture.
 
One of the problems with looking at historical uses of torture is that it's often not done for purposes we'd be interested in using it for, if we were to do it. <snip> These are different goals than getting reliable information, and if the torture techniques which were used for these goals don't work well for getting reliable information, that's not surprising, nor is it very indicative of its potential.
This point is well taken; but it leads to another that is an important political consideration. Due to the use of such techniques for such purposes, they have acquired a stigma, one that is obvious in the responses you are getting here. From this point of view, it is immaterial whether they work or not. These political considerations, and this stigma, lead many to state that they will not be associated with advocating such methods, and that if such methods are the only means of guaranteeing their safety, they prefer to be unsafe. I am among these people, but that doesn't mean I can't dispassionately evaluate the actual effectiveness of these methods aside from the moral implications.

There is, however, in my opinion something that has been missed in your argument. If the point of interrogation is to gain actionable intelligence, then the mere fact that the subject will say whatever they perceive the interrogator wants to hear in many cases means that it is unlikely that torture will be effective because there is no clear motivation to tell the truth. It is arguable that a person in extreme pain is incapable of considering whether further pain might result in some indefinite future if what they say is not true; they will say whatever makes the pain stop now, without consideration of future consequences.

As a result, independent verification of what they have said is an absolute requirement; no semi-objective evaluation of the quality of the intelligence is possible based on their demeanor or reactions, because that demeanor and those reactions are irrevocably altered by the experience. For this reason, psychological interrogation techniques are more effective, and faster in the long run, because judgment of the subject's truthfulness from demeanor and reactions is possible. While this will never be 100% effective, it is nearly 0% effective when torture is used, and psychological interrogation is therefore the superior method in this respect.

Furthermore, because of the strong social prohibitions against it, the use of torture promotes a perception of moral superiority in the ideologically committed subject, which contributes to their ability to resist or evade surrendering usable intelligence. Once torture has been used, the most effective methods of psychological manipulation have been sacrificed. The subject who considers hirself superior to the interrogator can never be motivated to seek approval from that interrogator, and this is the basis of effective psychological interrogation.

Let's sum these points up.
1. Interrogation by torture has moral and political associations that make its use prohibitive in most peoples' estimation, no matter the justification.
2. Interrogation by torture does not permit evaluation of the information gained prior to independent verification, and is in this way inferior to psychological interrogation.
3. Interrogation by torture both strengthens the resolve of the ideologically committed subject, and renders the most effective types of psychological interrogation unusable.
Conclusion: Torture is therefore the last resort; and it is arguable that it is needed only if psychological methods fail, and further arguable that they will only fail if the interrogator is incompetent. Given the first point, torture can be seen as violation of moral standards due to incompetence. I don't think I need to characterize that last statement any further.
 
But "cost of torture is too high" is a completely subjective phrase, like the cost of anything else being "too high." It all depends on how much you have to spend.

On an individual basis, there is *never* a cost to high to use even the worst techniques on someone, and if they claim otherwise I say they have never really cared about another human being -- if someone kidnaps your spouse or child and is raping them hourly, and you find an accomplice, you *will* do whatever it takes to find out where (your family) they are so you can save them. It is that simple. Anyone who wouldn't is even less humane..
My initial approach would be intimidation, and my methods might well be extreme. Whether I could actually bring myself to torture someone in cold blood, I do not know. Whether once I began I would be able to stop short of killing them, I also do not know; it would take an extreme state of anger for me to overcome my ethics sufficiently to begin, and once begun, I am not sure I would have the self control to stop.

For a variety of obvious reasons, both ethical, and practical given my above self-evaluation, I would leave it to professionals given the choice. In the absence of that choice? I simply cannot say if I would have the self-control to do it successfully, and that's assuming that I was capable of overcoming my ethics, which is also doubtful. And if I did, I am certain I would never be free of the guilt of it, nor of the memories.

On a collective basis, however, the suffering of individuals like that might not be worth accepting nasty interrogation techniques, because while the suffering of a single victim we don't know doesn't do much damage to the average jane and joe, the knowledge that our country tortures prisoners surely does. So its a complex issue at that level.

For a country like the USA, I would say the cost of using such techniques in overall much greater than the cost of a few thousand extra citizens dying from terrorist attacks, because our ideals and ethics are very high and knowing that is a great source of pride and comfort to the average American.
This is a strong argument against it. This is part of our national cohesiveness, and damage to it is damage to our national identity, and our ability to overcome adversity.

Of course, I wouldn't say that if whoever dies (or has died) is someone I know -- in that case I would favor very rough methods indeed -- but that is the whole point of a collective approach. It keeps the few who are directly involved from deciding for the rest of us.
Precisely. It is nearly impossible to overcome the emotional imperatives and act rationally in the manner most likely to gain one's objective in such a case.
 
1. Interrogation by torture has moral and political associations that make its use prohibitive in most peoples' estimation, no matter the justification.

True.

2. Interrogation by torture does not permit evaluation of the information gained prior to independent verification, and is in this way inferior to psychological interrogation.

Not true. Such an evaluation is not trivial for any technique, and might be more difficult for in information gained from torture, but it can be evaluated without direct verification. See, for example, my comments regarding "truth serum" above.

3. Interrogation by torture both strengthens the resolve of the ideologically committed subject, and renders the most effective types of psychological interrogation unusable.

Probably true in many cases.

Conclusion: Torture is therefore the last resort; and it is arguable that it is needed only if psychological methods fail,

I can accept that.

and further arguable that they will only fail if the interrogator is incompetent.

I don't see how we can conclude this. Maybe the frequency of cases which cannot be solved by competent psychological interrogation techniques is very small (and if it's small enough then the benefits will not outweigh the costs), but there's really no reason to think it's zero.

We are, of course, still ignoring one of the most important applications for torture: luring foolish young Jedi into traps so we can freeze them in carbonite. :jedi:
 
Not true. Such an evaluation is not trivial for any technique, and might be more difficult for in information gained from torture, but it can be evaluated without direct verification. See, for example, my comments regarding "truth serum" above.
Mmmmm- in an absolute sense, you're probably right, I was overly assertive, but certainly it will be far more difficult in the case of a tortured subject than in the case of a psychologically coerced one. Equally certainly, there will be far more cases in which such an evaluation will be impossible when the subject is tortured than when s/he is not.

I don't see how we can conclude this. Maybe the frequency of cases which cannot be solved by competent psychological interrogation techniques is very small (and if it's small enough then the benefits will not outweigh the costs), but there's really no reason to think it's zero.
From material I have seen, both statements by interrogators and statements in interrogation manuals, I believe that, the odd psychopath of one sort or another aside, there will be almost no cases in which torture will be more effective than psychological coercion. Those cases where psychological methods fail will likely not be solvable by torture. I am nearly certain that the social costs will far outweigh any possible benefits. Of course, I admit to bias, but I am trying to be as dispassionate in my analysis as I reasonably can.

We are, of course, still ignoring one of the most important applications for torture: luring foolish young Jedi into traps so we can freeze them in carbonite. :jedi:
Troo dat.
 
One of the problems with looking at historical uses of torture is that it's often not done for purposes we'd be interested in using it for, if we were to do it.

Neither of us knows the details of all the evidence available.

Your original point was that there was little data. I think there has been ample opportunity to gather relevant data. And the experts would, in my opinion, be very unprofessional to be making the comments they do if they cannot base it on relevant data.

So, yes, I agree with your above point to the extent that there can be other aims to torture. But interrogation is commonly one of the aims. And I think it likely that a systematic record would list the aims along with other details.
 
Last edited:
I only have a couple of observations about the article...

1) The techniques used by the CIA, IMHO, barely constitute torture of any serious degree, and people describing them as horrifically inhumane and such things need to A) Harden up (and) B) do some research into REAL torture to get a handle on just how soft these techniques are.

2) Having said that, torture, even soft torture, doesn't work very well. It tends to harden the subject's resolve, or alternatively they'll start confessing to everything under the sun. Other techniques work just as effectively or moreso.

3) In the west we hold ourselves to a higher moral standard. We aim for the betterment of mankind. As such, even soft torture techniques have been outlawed, and we have a moral obligation to eliminate their use. Our enemy may bring on our soldiers the most horrific tortures and brutal punishment imaginable. Our correct response is to treat their prisoners with dignity and humanity, and to bomb the living snot out of any of them that haven't been captured yet.

4) The primary subject of this thread - the US Administration's manipulation and disrespect for the Judiciary - is absolutely shocking, and violates the fundamental principals of the rules of law. I disagree with many of the criticism laid against the Bush Administration, not because I support them, but because I seem them being blamed for many things that are not their fault, but they are blamed simply because they're hated and despised, so they're a convenient scapegoat. However, this is not one of those things. Failing to respect and honour the independence of the Judiciary is surely an impeachable offense?

-Gumboot
 
First, I agree with the other things you said in this thread. It's too easy to disagree with one point and leave the impression you disagree with them all.
I disagree with many of the criticism laid against the Bush Administration, not because I support them, but because I seem them being blamed for many things that are not their fault, but they are blamed simply because they're hated and despised, so they're a convenient scapegoat.
I can't speak for others, but a great deal of my disdain for them is due to three factors:
1. They're generally incompetent, and often they are incompetent because they're more interested in ideological crap or simple greed or taking care of some sycophant's greed than in the business of the country. If you're supposed to be running the country, RUN THE COUNTRY. That's why corruption is illegal.
2. When they've screwed something up badly, because they were paying attention to greed or ideology instead of to what they were supposed to be doing, they do a cover-up, and if lying won't do it, they'll do anything, as far as I've been able to tell no matter how illegal, heinous, immoral, or destructive to the country, to keep the cover-up going. That's why cover-ups are illegal.
3. AFTER screwing something up because they were greedy, and AFTER lying, cheating, and screwing up the country with the cover-up more than they did with the initial screwup, THEN they have the stones to try to convince people they did the right thing and you're not a patriot if you don't support them.

Now, there's plenty else I could talk about; but these three things are topical, because they are why people are being tortured. There is a clear reason Franklin said that those who would sacrifice freedom for safety deserve neither; it's because people who promise safety in exchange for freedom are doing it to distract people from what they're stealing.
 
There is a clear reason Franklin said that those who would sacrifice freedom for safety deserve neither;.

Actually, it's not clear who said it, and the full quote is: "Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." (bolding mine).
http://www.futureofthebook.com/stories/storyReader$605
 
So, your basic philosophy is that if the other nation doesn't play be the rules, we shouldn't either? Is that all you see them as, rules? I personally think torture is vile, disgusting, inhumane and most of all, unreliable. If you could simply show me scientific evidence that torture has a good success rate for producing reliable information, I might entertain your philosophical arguments as to when we should disregard humanity and use it. Until then, your arguments are just piss in the wind.

Also, since the time the Geneva conventions were authored, what's changed that has made torture acceptable to you?

Sorry for what I miss. I'm traveling, but this one is as good as any of the others saying essentially the same thing, to respond to.

I keep reading various arguments against "torture", depending on the moment.

First is the general one of what is interrogation and what is torture. When it comes down to the basics, I read that anything that causes discomfort is torture. We all agree that scalpels and pliers are demeaning torture, but I don't agree that coercive measures are. The concept that the recipient will always remember an unpleasant memory is not torture to me.

The second is that we have to be morally pure or our lives are not worth defending. I disagree. We are not morally pure and we can do unpleasant things, like kill people, if we need to. The question is whether we are better than another. Some people seem to think that we become just like the worst if we defend ourselves aggressively.

The third is the legal issue. The Geneva Conventions keep coming up as if they are the Ten Commandments to a fundamentalist. They are not. They are a mutually agreed standard of behavior that is mutually beneficial to signatories if they observe them, period.

The fourth is that others will behave better towards our own if we are seen as behaving nicely towards theirs. That is what the GC is supposed to be for, but it is irrelevant and even counter productive in the case of dealing with fanatics who see such behavior only as weakness.

The fifth is that others (not our enemies) will like us better or help us more if we are seen as gentle folk. I think not. The world is not that simple.

The sixth is that "torture" (we agree no scalpels, remember) doesn't work, as in "the sun will come up tomorrow", or that information amounts to "confession". We can all agree that there can be pointless efforts at interrogation, examples which have been offered. So what? I don't think all interrogators are stupid people (also I don't know what you have on the brain with the brown skin comment - stupid).

Then there is the one about making a mistake and how does one say sorry? One says sorry about the same way one says sorry to the family of anyone who is killed or maimed from being in the wrong place at the wrong time in a war. Most of the ones I have heard claiming torture, sound like they have more than a simple personal agenda, but they all have 10 fingers. It's standard procedure to claim torture if ever held by the US, so I don't agonize over every report like some. I suspect there are very few real reasons to say sorry to anyone out there, but it's possible and it's also possible there could be some who would understand that there was good reason to suspect them even if innocent.

Oh, yes, then there is the one about crushing a baby's skull to save thousands of others, as posted here. That's a silly example and a classic morality question that is usually posed to see if people have normal emotions. It's irrelevant to the torture issue since the comparisons are not equivalent, but most people would, given time, logically say that a baby could be sacrificed to save thousands of others. In truth that happens all the time in health care when considering limits to resources, although not as simplistically posed.

What have I missed?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom