Torture memo...OMG

So it's not about winning, it's about being "morally superior"? What is the practical value of being "morally superior" but dead?
Considering that President Bush has repeatedly made speeches which emphasized the moral part of the struggle against terrorism, this would tend to make the ethics and morality involved in said struggle a primary element.

If he had only emphasized winning at any cost and never mentioned anything to do with morality, then that would be different.

You think being harsh to prisoners is only a little better than what Al Qaeda does to prisoners?
It was more of a general point rather than a statement of specific comparisons.

I would say that how much the U.S. is living up to its own established laws, ethics, and codes of behaviour is also an important element to consider, especially if the struggle is going to be given some kind of moral grounding.
 
Last edited:
You think being harsh to prisoners is only a little better than what Al Qaeda does to prisoners? You've lost all perspective then. Regardless of whether or not you think we've sunk below the standards we should maintain, we aren't even close to our enemy. Not even on our worst days.

Second place? We oughta try harder.
 
Second place? We oughta try harder.

And we need to find more words that substitute for the "T" word.....as more and more stuff comes out we need more and viable alternatives to use as only the badies are allowed to have the "T" word used to describe thier actions.
 
So it's not about winning, it's about being "morally superior"? What is the practical value of being "morally superior" but dead?

This is the chickens*#t argument. On Sept 11, we lost 3000 people - out of 300 million. We lose 10 times as many each year in car wrecks. We as individuals are in very little danger of becoming dead.

In response, we have invaded 2 countries, killed hundreds of thousands of civilians, lost almost 4000 of our soldiers, spent more than half a trillion dollars, and failed to catch those responsible for the attack.

This is clearly not about winning. No matter how hard all this is spun, it still does not look like winning. We are bankrupting our economy, our military, and our ethics while losing our liberties and freedoms in the process. And accomplishing jack diddly squat.

You might want to reconsider the value of a little moral superiority.
 
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)

The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?

The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable. :rolleyes:

Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in. :rolleyes:

The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.

Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!

And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.

Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?

well said
 
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)

That is not what it is, that is an ad hom /poisoning the well fallacy.
It's always better to convince people, not turn them off because you insult them.

The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence. Bill O'Reilly tried to puff this up claiming Brian Ross reported high ranking military claimed torture got results at Gitmo. Ross called O'Reilly on the distortion and said in reality the military official Ross interviewed said the majority of information they got from torture at Gitmo was false and wasted the military's time hunting down those false leads. I posted on this entire affair already. I'll have to hunt up the links since they are old and not readily available on the ABC news site. Maybe someone who recalls the thread and will kindly find it for us?

Okay, this is not in question, really. (well, some posters, not naming names, do not understand this..)

The supposed results touted by the Bush officials mainly consists of stuff you expect from the bad guys, lots of confessions. Oh like those are reliable. :rolleyes:

Of course we have the idiotic scenario constantly touted again and again including asking Hilary Clinton in one of the debates, "would you torture someone if they knew where an armed nuclear bomb was to stop it"? Yeah, like that's the real scenario these guys are torturing folks in. :rolleyes:

Er. That's a POSSIBLE scenario, and is often used to demonstrate an interesting principle - would you sacrifice one life for millions? Intersting question.

The evidence: Benefit: Little to none, it doesn't yield much useful information.

Risk: It takes every bit of moral authority away from us, it creates more terrorists, the world sees less and less reason to be on our side. In short, what "good guy" image? Torturers don't have one. We have become the country my parents warned me against!

And as has been well documented, we have caused at a minimum 2 innocent men to be tortured for months, all based on stupid mistakes. What kind of country is this that we think that's OK because years ago one terrorist attack killed 3,000 people? This country did not resort to this kind of thing in WWI or WWII at least not as an officially sanctioned policy.

Because.. uh... YOU COULD DIE TOMMOROW IN A TERRORIST ATTACK.... or something. Seriously, though, when people are afraid, reason and morality tends to go out the window - not everyone has strong moral fiber

Why does anyone think this is OK? IT IS NOT OK! And if it was OK, why does Bush feel the need to OK it in secret and pretend in public we aren't doing it?

Because he's a Christian man. :rolleyes: Seriously, though, because most people will say it's wrong. And by most standards of morality it is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Opinion: If it isn't obvious to everyone that we have a rogue President right now, I would be astounded.

If you do have a rogue President, then clearly your system isn't strong enough to prevent such a thing.

All that talk about "checks and balances" is just that: Talk.
 
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?

Seeing as KSM was so bad, would you torture his children to get to him?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/06/08/wterror108.xml

"We have families who have not seen their loved ones for years. They've literally disappeared," Miss Mariner said. [of HRW]

Among the cases detailed in the report is the detention in September 2002 of two children, then aged seven and nine, of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the admitted Sept 11 mastermind, who is now held at Guantanamo Bay. "According to eyewitnesses, the two were held in an adult detention centre for at least four months while US agents questioned the children about their father's whereabouts."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khalid_Shaikh_Mohammed#Report_interrogators_abused_his_children

"The Pakistani guards told my son that the boys were kept in a separate area upstairs, and were denied food and water by other guards. They were also mentally tortured by having ants or other creatures put on their legs to scare them and get them to say where their father was hiding."

Who knows if it's true.
But would you support it?

After all, it's not about morals to you. It's about survival.
 
Evidence you skeptics with NeoCon tainted brains, look to the evidence not your macho man gut reactions. (Don't go getting your drawers in a bunch, this subject warrants calling it like it is.)

The scientific evidence indicates torture does not get results. WA Post report on the scientific evidence.

Interesting article.

WashingtonPost said:
In it, experts find that popular culture and ad hoc experimentation have fueled the use of aggressive and sometimes physical interrogation techniques to get those captured on the battlefields to talk, even if there is no evidence to support the tactics’ effectiveness.

24 rides again.
CSMonitor did a summary:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0212/p99s01-duts.html

last November Mr. Surnow and the story's [24's] creative staff were visited by a brigadier general and three top military and FBI interrogators, as well as human rights groups, who told them that the show's graphic depictions of the torture of suspects was "hurting efforts to train recruits in effective interrogation techniques and is damaging the image of the US around the world."

[...] In their view, the show promoted unethical and illegal behavior and had adversely affected the training and performance of real American soldiers. "I'd like them to stop," Finnegan said of the show's producers. "They should do a show where torture backfires."

Hey, but what would the experts know? They don't realise that the techniques are a big sell at home.
 
Hi, fishbob,
In response, we have invaded 2 countries, killed hundreds of thousands of civilians, lost almost 4000 of our soldiers, spent more than half a trillion dollars, and failed to catch those responsible for the attack.

That's just down to bad planning.

Invading the wrong country, and knowing that it was the wrong country, and knowing that bin Laden would be more likely to be found at home than schmoozing a daft dictator who would probably shoot him, all indicate a big "F" in the planning department.

Luckily, the Bush family happened to have all the right investments made beforehand.
 
I do mind. But I don't think they needed this as a pretext. The bad guys were already many orders of moral magnitude worse than this to begin with. They would torture US troops anyway, IMHO.

Sorry, but I think that you do not quite understand what you are advocating.

If the USA engages in torture,
Then the USA is esentially permitting others to torture US troops and it will be very difficult (if not impossible) to prosecute anyone who does torture.
 
Puppycow, I don't feel I can lecture to you. You've been in the armed forces but I haven't so I don't know your service life but I'm sure it was a hard one. I am indebted to you for being there, war or no. Just being there makes a heck of a difference.
I despise this sentiment. I have over ten years active duty service and over thirteen more in the reserves. I am an officer in the army, and I have been to Iraq. I have endured hardships elsewhere, too, and much of my motivation has been a desire to serve a country I love.

None of that places me above criticism. None of it in any veteran anywhere places them above criticism. There are asses and losers and idiots and would-be despots in the military. Most servicemembers are fine people, but even the fine people make mistakes and have regrettable biases and blind spots. Criticize them for it. Criticize me.

My government has given me kevlar to protect me from literal bullets. I do not want and will always reject protection from logical bullets.
 
It was more of a general point rather than a statement of specific comparisons.

Maybe that was what you intended, but that's not the way it came off.

I would say that how much the U.S. is living up to its own established laws, ethics, and codes of behaviour is also an important element to consider, especially if the struggle is going to be given some kind of moral grounding.

Then that's the point you should be making. No need to compare us to our enemy to make that point.
 
Kind of sad that someone's needless suffering could somehow bring you happiness.

Plus, tortue is generally used to get information, not just to physically assault someone for the purpose of physical assault. And usually the information derived through tortue is useless, most people will just make up useless information or agree with where the questioning is going simply to stop the pain. How many finger nails of yours being ripped out would it take before you sold out your mother?

The US is ripping out fingernails? :confused:
 
I despise this sentiment. I have over ten years active duty service and over thirteen more in the reserves. I am an officer in the army, and I have been to Iraq. I have endured hardships elsewhere, too, and much of my motivation has been a desire to serve a country I love.

I wasn't saying that I couldn't criticize or ask questions. I feel I lack the experience and general ken that a soldier has so I can't lecture soldiers about the realities of that kind of life. Puppycow seems bitter over the dangers that servicepeople face without much thought given by the politicos so I was acknowledging that I don't have any practical knowledge there.

And I wanted Puppycow to know that his hardships were appreciated because, most times, troops don't hear that.

Thank you.
 
Sorry, but I think that you do not quite understand what you are advocating.

If the USA engages in torture,
Then the USA is esentially permitting others to torture US troops and it will be very difficult (if not impossible) to prosecute anyone who does torture.

I'll back down and say I don't advocate torture of anyone who hasn't been convicted of crime against humanity. See my reasoning actually has nothing to do with the "War on Terror" and would have made just as much sense pre-9/11 as post-9/11.

I'm just saying I would be happy if people like Denis Rader or the people who killed Daniel Pearl or the guy who shot John Lennon were really made to pay for their crimes. This seems logical to me. You don't administer the same punishment for armed robbery as for shoplifting, so why administer the same punishment to Denis Rader as you do to a garden variety murderer?
 
After accusing me of "hating America" and being a "coward," Joe Ellison felt he also had to send me a catty PM saying I'm on his ignore list. :)
 
I wasn't saying that I couldn't criticize or ask questions. I feel I lack the experience and general ken that a soldier has so I can't lecture soldiers about the realities of that kind of life. Puppycow seems bitter over the dangers that servicepeople face without much thought given by the politicos so I was acknowledging that I don't have any practical knowledge there.
I gathered it was something like this, but I still don't like the sentiment because it is carried too far, I think, and encouraged to be carried too far by some servicemembers and by some overly zealous supporters of the military.

I analogize it with academics, particularly those with Doctoral Degrees. I don't have one. I will never get one. My wife is working on hers now so I have a very close perspective on the hardships and rigor and pain required to obtain one. Not to mention the significant leap in technical knowledge (particularly regarding statistics) required to move from a Graduate Degree to a PhD. I respect the effort and knowledge immensely, but I feel no need to preface my criticisms of Gary Schwartz with a repitition of that respect.


And I wanted Puppycow to know that his hardships were appreciated because, most times, troops don't hear that.
I appreciate this sentiment and do not want to sound ungrateful, but unlike the Vietnam era, the amount and degree of overtly expressed gratitude is large.

I'm not criticizing you, Slimething. I'm emphasizing the fact that members of the military are not sacrosanct and their experiences do not afford them de facto expert status.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom