I didn't throw rocks at him, or anyone here specifically. I apologize to him and everyone else here for the confusion. I do think that the "complexity" claimed by some people is cover for a fundamental flaw in their empathy. Some people really are just looking for an excuse to hurt other people, and the reasons are less important than the satisfaction of some need they feel to see other people suffer.
DR:
Thanks for the stand up, but I didn't take offense to what he said...
Joe:
If you look a the different examples I used earlier, I was trying to show that depending on the circumstances, the view one has towards what is acceptable can change.
Look at these two examples:
(A) A father has captured a member of a team of terrorists that holds his son captive. This man knows the location of his son, and the "codeword" that if spoken to the head of the team, will allow the release of his son. His son will be killed in 3 hours if the codeword is not given.
As the father, what lengths would you go to get the code word, if getting it was your only option to save your son? Is waterboarding permissible? other methods? are any methods unacceptable in this case, from your perspective as the father?
(B) a CIA agent is captured by Arab Officials. He is being held for obtaining and passing on, state secrets of that Arab Country. The officials know there is another mole within, and want to find out who. What lengths should the be allowed to go to, to get this info?
Two very different scenarios, with different stakes emotionally and tactically. My point, using these two cases, is that the decision to use certain methods of "heavy-handedness" or torture, is not as simple as always or never, and the decision can be heavily influenced by how close the decision maker is to the participants and circumstances.
For that reason, I suggest the complexities make it paramount that such decisions, in terms of what is acceptable, should be made by emotionally detached persons, and done in a situation that does not require the immediate application of such rules and governances, as such circumstance might apply undue, and influencing pressures on the arbitors of such.
TAM