Torture memo...OMG

This topic a'sploded.

I'd make a comment, throw up some links, or at least make some effort to debate the point over torture if it hadn't been thoroughly destroyed.

Elind, do you have any hard data or figures demonstrating that information taken out of tortured individuals are the least bit reliable? Because it seems like actual examples in the real world outdo your hypothetical "maybes".

The feeling I get is that he's really not concerned with getting information, so much as intimidating "the enemy", and not looking "weak"... whatever those things mean, and whatever he thinks they mean. :rolleyes:
 
I'd take being a girly man Human Rights advocate over being a tough guy Spartan that loves to torture people to look buffed up.
 
I'd take being a girly man Human Rights advocate over being a tough guy Spartan that loves to torture people to look buffed up.

The reality is that it takes real bravery to stand up and support human rights and the rule of law, and not give in to the fear and weakness that drives the urge to commit torture.
 
It's not irrelevant because you say we lose our morality if we fight to win in certain ways (and that includes aall actions taken), while you simultaneously seem to think it is possible to fight war the way police deal with criminals in a civilian society.
I suppose perhaps we had better define what is meant exactly by war.

Obviously we don't do certain things that our enemy does, I presume you agree with that, but I don't think torture is what some would call unpleasant or frightening in such circumstances and I think that if one is not prepared to do some things that one wouldn't do outside of war, then I don't think one has the will to win, and probably won't.
So then you would have been in favour of the Western Allies using Gestapo- or SS-like methods on German prisoners? Your statement would seem to point in that direction.

It's a rhetorical question to me.
The question goes straight to the heart of the matter. It's very simple. Would you be comfortable with those techniques being used on American prisoners, yes or no? Why are you reluctant to respond?

We all know that they do much worse.
What others do is irrelevant to what we choose to do or not do. On another forum someone had a sig which I think summed it up: "The moral failings of others do not excuse our own."

Our military people are trained to deal with interrogation and it is expected, if not worse, although in this war there is little advantage the enemy can gain from that, whereas we can potentially gain much more. What they do, kill and maim, or maim and kill, is not comparable to what we do and what we do certainly has no effect on reciprocity from them, as it might have had in the case of wars between nations.
Perhaps it is worth remembering that some of those undergoing these techniques may not in fact be guilty of anything - they're only suspected of being involved. Mistakes happen. What do you say to the person who was wrongly accused and was subject to this treatment?

Sorry, the worst we did then was try to destroy the people who worked in the factories, as their homes were easier to find than the factories.
Such actions, I would argue, can be fully justified logically and rationally, and were defendable morally. I've argued in support of the Strategic Bomber Offensive on several occasions on other message boards.

You seem to think doing anything that isn't nice is a formula for turning into Nazis. I disagree.
No. It is simply about being true to one's own morals, values, and established rules of law.

One is actually fighting to win, so that one can actually be in a position to uphold something.
If it's only about winning, then stamping out Islamic extremism is easy: there are no Muslim extremists if there are no Muslims. Wipe them out. Kill everyone who even dares to think about supporting extremists. Erase entire towns if even one terrorist hails from there. The Mongols under Genghis Khan were quite effective at eliminating resistance; they'd just slaughter everyone in the city should even one resist. After a few such eradications, folks elsewhere got the message and resistance ceased.

So, if it's mainly about winning, are you in favour of the above mentioned solution? That would certainly achieve victory, albeit with a high body count. And if you are not in favour, then why not? How far then are you prepared to go in terms of doing what is necessary to achieve victory?
 
So you think you wouldn't talk if you didn't feel like it. Good for you toughie. The point is that taken to excess interrogation will generate fictitious information, not that it won't generate any. If you seriously think most people won't start talking under harsh circumstance you must be from another planet.

So you are admitting that you don't have any scientific evidence to support your claims. Thank you.
 
I didn't say it doesn't work, I said it doesn't work when done for the the wrong motives or objectives, and I said more too; but what the hell.

Because motives are an intrinsic part of reality, and have the ability to change the outcome in cause and effect relationships.

If your motives are pure, then you can move mountains. And homeopathy will work for you, too.
 
Thank you. :) Just a little video drop before i embrace orpheus. Robert Bear comments on torture and KSMs "confession" (listen carefully TAM) in a three minute interview yesterday with Keith Olberman:


I watch "countdown" just about every night I can, and was fortunate enough to already see that interview.

There is no doubt that some of what KSM said was fictional (Daniel Pearl beheading for starters). Alot of what he confessed to wrt 9/11 however, is corroberated by so much collateral evidence, that it rings true.

As much as I like Keith O, and feel he is an Oasis in a desert, I also feel he, like Michael Moore, tends to pull a little to far the other side of the middle...just My Opinion though.

TAM:)
 
So what you are saying, TAM, is that the information KSM gave which was true was stuff we already knew.
 
So what you are saying, TAM, is that the information KSM gave which was true was stuff we already knew.

Not quite. Of the information we learned, some could be confirmed to be true, but some was confirmed to be false. Unfortunately, you can't tell the difference without external verification. That doesn't help much, because if we have to get the information from another, reliable source, then we don't need his help. A source who gives information that needs external verification is not very useful. For starters, what to make of the unverified information? Some could be true, some could be false. You don't know.
 
I do mind. But I don't think they needed this as a pretext. The bad guys were already many orders of moral magnitude worse than this to begin with. They would torture US troops anyway, IMHO.

Why? Tortureing those who would do you harm seems to be what you are advocating, so as americans would do them harm, torture would seem to be justified.
 
The latter. Let me ask you: Is there no historical person (Hitler for example) who you wouldn't be at least secretly happy if they were tortured?

Oh goody we are playing hypotheticals. Hypotheticaly what was so wrong with 9/11 given the history of america destroying cities(say like Tokyo) durring its recent history?
 
I suppose perhaps we had better define what is meant exactly by war.

If you want to pretend to be a law student, please don't waste my time.

So then you would have been in favour of the Western Allies using Gestapo- or SS-like methods on German prisoners? Your statement would seem to point in that direction.
I'd be surprised if it never happened, but the difference, which I repeat again to you who can't get it, is that the Gestapo were genetically goons conditioned to do so with or without reason; whereas I maintain we were not.

The question goes straight to the heart of the matter. It's very simple. Would you be comfortable with those techniques being used on American prisoners, yes or no? Why are you reluctant to respond?
I did respond. You are too dense to understand what I said.

What others do is irrelevant to what we choose to do or not do. On another forum someone had a sig which I think summed it up: "The moral failings of others do not excuse our own."
Then why is it that you are continually bringing up examples of ages past as an excuse for failures of the present? I never said other's moral failing excuse our own, but I did say that our failure to fight for our own (perhaps not yours) is a moral failure in itself, worse than that of giving up for an abstract fear of being compared with one's enemy.

Perhaps it is worth remembering that some of those undergoing these techniques may not in fact be guilty of anything - they're only suspected of being involved. Mistakes happen. What do you say to the person who was wrongly accused and was subject to this treatment?
I'd say the same as I would to anyone who died in a war. Sorry; that's life and I might be tempted to add that perhaps if you had worked harder to keep your own society more civil, then you wouldn't have had to die or suffer in this way.

Such actions, I would argue, can be fully justified logically and rationally, and were defendable morally. I've argued in support of the Strategic Bomber Offensive on several occasions on other message boards.
Good for you. Kill em when you can't see em, but don't harm them when you can. Sounds like the ultimate cop out.

No. It is simply about being true to one's own morals, values, and established rules of law.
My law says that if you don't win, then your laws aren't worth spittle.

If it's only about winning, then stamping out Islamic extremism is easy: there are no Muslim extremists if there are no Muslims. Wipe them out. Kill everyone who even dares to think about supporting extremists. Erase entire towns if even one terrorist hails from there. The Mongols under Genghis Khan were quite effective at eliminating resistance; they'd just slaughter everyone in the city should even one resist. After a few such eradications, folks elsewhere got the message and resistance ceased.
Be careful. When god is at work, **** happens.


So, if it's mainly about winning, are you in favour of the above mentioned solution? That would certainly achieve victory, albeit with a high body count. And if you are not in favour, then why not? How far then are you prepared to go in terms of doing what is necessary to achieve victory?
If all Muslims decide that it's their way or death, like some real life examples today, then that may be what will happen. A sociopathic society that worships death will not be converted by nice people like you, except by your conversion to theirs.

You brought up the End of Times scenario, not me (Christians can come up with this crap too you know), but I do note that you propose no alternatives, except for the abstract of providing an "example" of niceness that you seem to think can convert those out to kill you in the name of a god.
 
Last edited:
.... please don't waste my time.
Don't put on such airs.

...the Gestapo were genetically goons conditioned...
As usual from you, this is both incoherent and rabidly unscientific. Pure woo. Make up your mind. Genetics? Puh-leeeze.
You are too dense to understand what I said.
Oh puh-leeeze. Who are you to criticise?
but I did say that our failure to fight for our own (perhaps not yours) is a moral failure in itself,
How much actual fighting have you done? Just another Keyboard Kampaign member, are you? WE have not failed to fight for our own; maybe we don't fight for YOUR goals, but that looks like not being bad at all.
:)

Now: back to your pretending that all Moslems or Arabs are somehow the same. You're wrong. Get over it.
 
Grow up child. There are more intelligent discussions on the issue right here.

There is nothing more relevant to the discussion than scientific evidence to support your claim that torture actually works to produce reliable information. If you can't prove that torture even has a chance to produce important information reliably, then every single argument of yours is pointless. Simply put, if torture doesn't work, there is no point in discussing the morality of when it should be used or not, because if it doesn't work, it is immoral to use EVER.
 
More like fitting pieces of a puzzle, which we had put partially together.

TAM:)
Other than Bush claiming to have gotten useful information from KSM, do we really know if that is just propaganda or an actual fact? And isn't this one of the guys we held and threatened his kids as a tactic? Perhaps that was another case.
 
Grow up child. There are more intelligent discussions on the issue right here.
Elind, don't expect to convince anyone of your position without evidence. What else do you have to offer besides your opinion and why on Earth should that alone be convincing?
 
Elind said:
Then why is it that you are continually bringing up examples of ages past as an excuse for failures of the present? I never said other's moral failing excuse our own, but I did say that our failure to fight for our own (perhaps not yours) is a moral failure in itself, worse than that of giving up for an abstract fear of being compared with one's enemy.

Ah, yes, because we don't want to subject people to torture to get dubious information that, scientifically speaking, is just as likely to be inaccurate as it is to be accurate, we "don't want to fight for our own".

:rolleyes:

I bet you laughed at the Geneva Convention, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom