Don't give up now, Elind. Read my last reply.
I didn't give up, on you.
I think you make strong and eloquent arguments that I can't counter with any fundamentals, except perhaps that you make no allowance for human limitations. I think "our" limitations are less than some others, but I am prepared to live with the fact that we have them and have to win nevertheless. Our laws are made by us for specific circumstances. I am not convinced that they apply, or should be made to apply, for all circumstances, like war.
Your comment as to my aggressive stance should be seen in the light of what I perceive as either blatant politicking for points (partisan rubbish) or simple naivety as to the human condition or history, so to speak.
The issues of incompetence are real, but I also feel that the whole issue of "torture" is a main stream media favorite that I take little credence in for the most part, which is not to mean I dismiss it. Every single detainee, other than a few early ones, has had stories of torture which seem on analysis to be similar to complaints of poor food, but are hardly reported as such.
There is another war going on here that used to be well recognized a generation or two ago, but seems to be over the heads of many today. It is called propaganda, and it is only applied it seems to some, unethically, by their own government.
We have all these discussions about torture and it becomes to seem that that is all WE do.
Sorry, but I have come to believe that little can be taken at face value, particularly what is reported by the likes of AP or Reuters or the BBC when they regularly quote unverifiable sources from our obvious enemies, and the NYT discloses whatever "secrets" may be available because they support the other political side. (I'm still pissed at outing OBL and his satellite phones, for example, and there are other examples).
Peace.
