Torture memo...OMG

The people supporting the policy are mostly acting out of fear, even the "interrogators" themselves might think they are doing the right thing, but the architects of it know exactly what they are doing. They are everything but stupid and they know history.
And those architects may or may not be who they are commonly perceived to be.

History can be seen as the catalog of ways of getting things done. If someone's already figured it out, why re-invent the wheel? On the other hand, that can be a trap, too, when one is faced with novel circumstances, particularly if those circumstances have been engineered by an enemy.
 
Hey, you agree with wsws and me. They certainly don't get a free pass but i would say that the average democrat falls more into the fear-driven category. Some people at the top of the democrats are certainly not opposed to the straussian ideas of mass control and as guilty as the architects of that mess.

Just because we may not see eye to eye on "9/11 truth" does not mean I am a neo-con or Bush Apologist...far from it. I dislike a lot of what I see coming out of the USG right now...I just wonder how different, if at all, things would be if a DEM was in power at the time of 9/11.

TAM:)
 
@Schneibster: Oh, it's late here. That's to confusing and i don't want to derail this thread, in which you, skeptigirl and others are doing important work, with my opinions. CU!

@TAM: No need to explain yourself. :)
 
I just wonder how different, if at all, things would be if a DEM was in power at the time of 9/11.
I think hugely different, because the neo-cons had the gameplan already in place before 9-11.... but it doesn't much matter, because Bush was the one who was president on 9-11.
 
We can agree to disagree on this one. I absolutely agree the "playbook" the REPs had was much different than that the DEMs were reading. However, 9/11 was such a transforming event, I am not sure the DEMS could have had a drastically different response than that the Neocons had.

Where I think the difference would be, would be most everything AFTER the invasion of Afghanistan...

TAM:)
 
Yeah, when a gang flies airplanes into the two largest buildings in your country, and you know where they came from, your options tend to be a bit limited. I will say that I think the economy would have been in much better shape at that time, without the banks thieving from the stock market and no Big West Coast Energy ripoff.
 
That's the one. I'd forgotten "drivel." Shin Bet said it's "useless." The transcript's not on line yet or I'd have posted a link to it.
 
Don't give up now, Elind. Read my last reply.

I didn't give up, on you.

I think you make strong and eloquent arguments that I can't counter with any fundamentals, except perhaps that you make no allowance for human limitations. I think "our" limitations are less than some others, but I am prepared to live with the fact that we have them and have to win nevertheless. Our laws are made by us for specific circumstances. I am not convinced that they apply, or should be made to apply, for all circumstances, like war.

Your comment as to my aggressive stance should be seen in the light of what I perceive as either blatant politicking for points (partisan rubbish) or simple naivety as to the human condition or history, so to speak.

The issues of incompetence are real, but I also feel that the whole issue of "torture" is a main stream media favorite that I take little credence in for the most part, which is not to mean I dismiss it. Every single detainee, other than a few early ones, has had stories of torture which seem on analysis to be similar to complaints of poor food, but are hardly reported as such.

There is another war going on here that used to be well recognized a generation or two ago, but seems to be over the heads of many today. It is called propaganda, and it is only applied it seems to some, unethically, by their own government.

We have all these discussions about torture and it becomes to seem that that is all WE do.

Sorry, but I have come to believe that little can be taken at face value, particularly what is reported by the likes of AP or Reuters or the BBC when they regularly quote unverifiable sources from our obvious enemies, and the NYT discloses whatever "secrets" may be available because they support the other political side. (I'm still pissed at outing OBL and his satellite phones, for example, and there are other examples).

Peace.:boxedin:
 
congratulations on the use of "being harsh", you win the award for the latest limp substitute for that "T" word that you are unable to face.

What are you doing, ganging up with Joe E. to compete for inane responses?

I've tried to engage you with some actual issues for a couple of months now, without success. Normally I wouldn't bother except that you've been around a long time and used to have more bite. What's wrong; bad health lately? I'm sorry to hear it if so, but otherwise sharpen up, please.
 
Your first mistake is assuming the biggest guns always win and that winning over the population doesn't matter.

I don't think I said that. Sorry if it seemed so, but one of the best ways to win over a population is to protect them and impress them. Obviously Bush & Co. didn't think that far.

We had big guns in Vietnam. The NeoCon revisionists have fantasized that constraints on the military prevented winning the war. They have forgotten that in order to kill an enemy you have to know who the enemy is. We couldn't kill the enemy in Vietnam because we couldn't tell the good guys from the bad guys and the way we went about killing just turned more and more 'good guys' into 'bad guys'.
Actually I think the true answer is that we were not prepared to do what was necessary in Vietnam, which was defeat the North. Whether we should have bothered is another issue, but that is what it comes down to. Perhaps the question is whether we would have had to go to war with our Wallmart suppliers in China, but in any case the bottom line is that we didn't fight to win.

Russia could not win in Afghanistan and neither will we if we don't do something to make us more attractive to the people there than the Taliban and al Qaeda. We aren't doing that and the consequences are revealing.
And we can't win in Iraq by simply being the biggest guy on the block. Humans are adaptive little critters. If you have a bigger gun, I'll plant a roadside bomb when you aren't looking.
We can win if the local get tired of getting blown up in the process and kill them for us. That will probably happen eventually, as people tend to get tired of death, but the question is whether we have the desire to win.


Your second mistake is assuming the supposed rough treatment isn't torture in this case, because the evidence says it is and Bush et al is downplaying it.
Your evidence isn't my evidence, nor interpretation, nor importance. What can I say?

Your third mistake is assuming we are getting all this useful information by torturing people. Very few military experts agree (see my links above and/or do your own search for evidence). I cited quite a few experts from the military, Elind, not those armchair soldier draft dodgers which are currently running the show and their right wing draft dodging counterparts in the media who are cheering them on.
I don't cherry pick my evidence. I've had a more intelligent discussion here with someone else on this, if you are interested in my opinion. As to yours, based on prior posts, I think you are a political junkie with an ax to grind.
 
Well, we disagree on the role of the media, and I'd encourage you to put up a thread about it. I know that there are some people here who have strong views on free speech that might have some interesting views on that. It is, however, off-topic. The propaganda angle is yet another thread, although I think a great many more accusations of propagandizing happen than instances of it.

Peace to you as well.
 
Just because we may not see eye to eye on "9/11 truth" does not mean I am a neo-con or Bush Apologist...far from it. I dislike a lot of what I see coming out of the USG right now...I just wonder how different, if at all, things would be if a DEM was in power at the time of 9/11.

TAM:)
You're asking the wrong question. It isn't whether or not it was a Democrat or a Republican, you should be asking whether or not it would be different if we had a competent administration vs the incompetent one we have now.

The current administration used the 9/11 attack for their personal agenda of invading Iraq which had nothing to do with 9/11 other than Iraq was a Middle East country. And the Bushco botched the war with one ignorant mistake after another on top of all the foreign contractor cronyism added to the mess. That isn't because they were Republicans.
 
Last edited:
@Schneibster: Oh, it's late here. That's to confusing and i don't want to derail this thread, in which you, skeptigirl and others are doing important work, with my opinions. CU!

@TAM: No need to explain yourself. :)
Thank you. I really appreciate compliments, especially in the politics forum where I am usually fighting uphill battles.
 
Well, we disagree on the role of the media, and I'd encourage you to put up a thread about it. I know that there are some people here who have strong views on free speech that might have some interesting views on that. It is, however, off-topic. The propaganda angle is yet another thread, although I think a great many more accusations of propagandizing happen than instances of it.

Peace to you as well.

Here I think we have a more serious disagreement. Surely you believe, from what I read, that the Bush administration, let alone every one that has ever been, can be accused of propaganda? Having said that, would you not agree that propaganda that serves you is better than that which serves your enemy?

As to free speech, I presume you mean whether or not our own press should print matters that serves our enemies well, and ourselves not? Granted that can sometimes be a gray area and well suited to partisan bickering, but in the example given I don't see how the NYT could justify telling OBL that he was being listened to, in the name of free speech. Can you? Perhaps I misunderstood; perhaps they only reported some other traitor after he was outed?

As to dismissing propagnada, surely you have noticed that there has hardly been an incidence of bombing anywhere that does not have a quote from a Mohammed (picture of a guy with a beard, sometimes) saying only civilians were killed, or that it was an innocent party at 2am. Just some tracers shooting for fun? AP loves that kind of stuff that they call reporting.

Did you pay attention to the war with Hezbullah and Israel? Notice the barrage of faked photos, from dead babies to wailing grandmothers, to bombed ambulances that were all proven fakes? 600 some photos reluctantly expunged from AP archives after they were found coming from a Hezbullah paid "stringer" (most AP so called reporters are paid locals with connections, and biases). Please tell me you are not as naive as that.:confused:

Coming back to basics, perhaps all this will become somewhat moot within our lifetime if what I read of current research on "mind reading" pans out, and I have no doubt it's under plenty of scrutiny as we speak. Put a helmet connected to a computer on someone and tell 99% for sure if he is lying or not based on brainwaves. Who needs torture if you can just use intelligent questions with yes no answers?

Do you recognize this picture? OK, thanks; you do. Next question....
 
I don't think I said that. Sorry if it seemed so, but one of the best ways to win over a population is to protect them and impress them. Obviously Bush & Co. didn't think that far.
Protect them? By ignoring collateral damage as we drop our bombs? By invading their homes at night? By letting rapists and murderers in our army and in Blackwater's go home and get wrist slaps?

Why do you suppose that after a couple of years we have seen so little progress? So you really think it is because we started with our military wrists tied? Because we aren't tough enough?

You are simply ignoring the real mistakes which had nothing to do with not being tough enough. We protected oil fields over precious artifacts in their museums and the rest of the infrastructure. We hired Bush and Cheney cronies to rebuild the country while thousands of Iraqis went unemployed. We fired interpreters who were gay to please Bush's "base" back home. We sent Brenner and a bunch of 20 something Evangelicals from the Young Republicans to rewrite the laws and policies of the country from their safe place in the Green Zone. We outlawed labor unions while we wrote a law giving the vast majority of the oil profits to foreign corporations who were not required to invest one dime back in the Iraq economy from the profits, all the while claiming we were promoting democracy.

Those are but a few of the reasons this war is not over. Restraints on the military have very little if anything to do with the failure.
And while you brush off what I have to say because I happen to be an information junkie (not a political junkie as you stupidly believe) you are missing the chance to actually look at the facts, the evidence and assess the situation for yourself. Instead, you look through your tunnel vision and see only a sliver of what is really involved in this complex but not difficult to understand war.

Actually I think the true answer is that we were not prepared to do what was necessary in Vietnam, which was defeat the North. Whether we should have bothered is another issue, but that is what it comes down to. Perhaps the question is whether we would have had to go to war with our Wallmart suppliers in China, but in any case the bottom line is that we didn't fight to win.
This reinforces my conclusion that you have a very narrow field of view from which you see the world. This conclusion is naive.

We can win if the local get tired of getting blown up in the process and kill them for us. That will probably happen eventually, as people tend to get tired of death, but the question is whether we have the desire to win.
You make the false assumption the locals you believe need to get tired of the violence view the US as the good guys.

Your evidence isn't my evidence, nor interpretation, nor importance. What can I say?

I don't cherry pick my evidence. I've had a more intelligent discussion here with someone else on this, if you are interested in my opinion. As to yours, based on prior posts, I think you are a political junkie with an ax to grind.
I would be more interested in your opinion if you presented some evidence and showed you had the capacity to look at evidence presented by others which contradicts your world view.
 
Last edited:
Protect them? By ignoring collateral damage as we drop our bombs? By invading their homes at night? By letting rapists and murderers in our army and in Blackwater's go home and get wrist slaps?

Blackwater is there because the Iraqis are whooses who can't accomplish anything on their own. We didn't ignore collateral damage, we minimized it, which is not to say zeroed. What planet are you from?

Our army is not composed of rapists and murderers, but there likely are a few in there somewhere as any rational person might conclude, without having a little priss like you accuse them all of the same.

Why do you suppose that after a couple of years we have seen so little progress? So you really think it is because we started with our military wrists tied? Because we aren't tough enough?

You come from the instant gratification generation. I make no excuses for the Bush administration's incompetence, but progress is a relative term, and it is also something never achieved by the likes of you.

It's late. You piss me off with your Daily Kos crap, and I suggest we cross the road when we meet again. You one side, me the other.
 
Naturally you'd look at the fact we've made no progress training the Iraqi army and blame it on them being whooses. These people had no problem functioning as a society before we got there. Gee look, they even have roads and buildings. Who'd of thought such a "primitive" culture could have actually built a power plant and a highway?

I don't care if you ignore me. (BTW, I rarely read the Daily Kos because I have little time for blogs.) But I do suggest you take the time to learn a little more for yourself about why we are not making any progress in Iraq. Don't form your world view on so little information and your quickly formed stereotyped version of the facts. You do no one any favors, especially yourself when you rally behind ideas, leaders and policies based on nothing more than your gut reaction. Take the time to inform yourself.

I never think I have enough information. I will form opinions based on what I currently know, but I do it knowing that if there is a hint of information I may be wrong, or if there is something which comes up that I wasn't aware of, I want to find out about it. The best opinions, the best decisions are made from a position of knowledge, not from a position of certainty.
 
This topic a'sploded.

I'd make a comment, throw up some links, or at least make some effort to debate the point over torture if it hadn't been thoroughly destroyed.

Elind, do you have any hard data or figures demonstrating that information taken out of tortured individuals are the least bit reliable? Because it seems like actual examples in the real world outdo your hypothetical "maybes".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom