Torture memo...OMG

Give me a break. You are now in the camp that thinks if we act nice and roll over we make friends? Where do you get this crap that people hate us (not just us either, in case you haven't paid attention) because we are not nice enough?

I said nothing, ever, any time, at all about rolling over and acting nice. As I recall, nobody on this forum has ever said anything about rolling over and acting nice. Rolling over and acting nice is not generally recognized as an effective tactic.

Pay attention - I said specifically that abuse of prisoners is wrong. I said that treatment of prisoners and fighting are two separate issues, and all my comments in this thread have been directed toward treatment of prisoners and none of my comments had anything at all to do with fighting.

"This crap" that you are complaining about is entirely in your own mind. I understand that there may be a sale this week on home brain enema kits at your neighborhood Walmart pharmacy. Stock up.
 
My attitude is that same, rational, humane human beings have limits on their behavior. Not because of public opinion, not to "be nice", not for any other reason than it hurts us, it corrupts us to behave in certain ways.

Sane, humane people don't torture animals. We don't say "well, we don't torture the good animals, but the neighbor's dog barks all night and got loose and bit my leg, so it is cool if I rip out that dog's eyes with a pair of pliers." It doesn't matter what the dog did or didn't do: decent people just don't torture animals. If an animal is wild and dangerous, we can put it down humanely... we don't allow people to torture animals to death.

If we don't torture animals, why would we torture fellow human beings? It doesn't matter how evil they might be; if we torture them, we are also evil. If someone is tried and convicted of a capital offense, we execute them in the quickest, most painless way possible.

Wrong behavior is wrong no matter who it targets. I wouldn't torture the worst person in the world... not because they don't deserve it, but because it is a violation of basic human values to do so.
 
Amazing repetition here, but perhaps one day I'll get it closer to understandable.

/snip/

We have this mantra repeated ad nauseam that if you twist someone's arm it's torture, and all terrorist murderers are noble people that would rather die than rat on their fellow scum.

Amazing repetition?

The only person in this thread that has ever mentioned anything about "terrorist murderers being noble people" is Elind. Numerous times he has attributed this notion to the people he disagrees with, while arguing vehemently against his own attribution. All together now: S t r a w m a n.
 
Last edited:
Sleep deprivation.. maybe. However, if it's done to the point where symptoms of insanity begin, I'd call that torture for sure.
If you do it to the point of insanity, you have failed, I would think, due to your subject now being a more unreliable source of information than previously. At that point, yes indeed, it becomes abuse for the sake of abuse, and of no value other than, as I see it, to screw with someone. I don't think that is how it is used.
Waterboarding is torture. Just because these methods were used as "training" doesn't make it morally more correct.
I didn't say it was, so what? It is recoverable from in a relatively short time frame. Having your arm broken by "interrogators" in the Hanoi Hilton takes a bit longer to get over. Having a thumb cut off, see Jack Ensch, F-4 RIO, quite another.

ETA 2: From Captain Richard Stratton's recollection:

Still, no one is immune to torture.

"Torture is a different thing for different people," Stratton said. "For some, it meant kneeling on a broomstick for three days. Guys would land with a broken arm and they would just twist the arm."
Stratton spend a long time in the Hanoi Hilton.
Is pepper spraying prisoners for information torture? I've seen marine combat training involve sparring with pepper spray in their face. I would say yes, it's still torture.
Is it done every day? All the time? Now and again? Pepper spray is also a temporary effect, though again, if you get pepper spray in the face every hour on the hour, I'd guess two things: you'll say anything to get them to knock that crap off,

or,

you'll adapt to it and go to a place I've never been, mentally, where you beg them to bring it on.
Training our soldiers to be more resilient to certain forms of torture doesn't justify using those same methods on others.
I never said it was. The loose usage of the term "torture" fails to make the distinction between permanent physical damage and temporary suckage. The point on the problems of vacating a moral high ground stands on its own.

The further points made by people like McCain, Stockdale, and for that matter, the oft quoted CIA report in the early sixties, are enough of an argument for not using torture as a matter of practice, particularly against "true believers," to prefer other methods of interrogation for those who are to be interrogated. (I'll see if I can dig up anything on the recent topic by Eugene "Red" McDaniel, another one time guest at the Hanoi Hilton. ETA if I can.

ETA: Looks like Red didn't get anything out recently, last ADI briefing was in 1998 that I can find. http://www.ojc.org/adi/captain.htm )

I read many essays by James Stockdale on how he dealt with, and resisted, real torture, physical abuse that left permanent damage. His stoic approach is likely the same frame of mind that the True Believer of an Islamist sort has recourse to, to include the three guys who suicided in Gitmo a couple of years ago.

http://koranteng.blogspot.com/2005/07/erustication-and-italian-job.html

ETA: This gentleman points out that the rendition policy began in the 1990's, but I note an eerie silence on that point by some of our more vitriolic pundits here. Why was it not stopped then? Why was it condoned?

If it's wrong, and let's take that position, it's wrong, then both parties, both houses of Congress, and both Baby Boomer administrations have blood on their knuckles. An interesting note in that blog article, the threat of rendition to Israel and the Mossad was apparently enough to get one nabbed terrorist (operative??) to become very cooperative.

That's a version of good cop, bad cop.

DR
 
Last edited:
So, Darth Rotor, do you think that if electrocuting a man's gonads had no permanent effect, then it would be a perfectly viable method of extracting information?

Do you also assume that that information will necessarily be reliable?
 
So, Darth Rotor, do you think that if electrocuting a man's gonads had no permanent effect, then it would be a perfectly viable method of extracting information?
Where do you get the idea that has no permanent effect?

Why are you playing the idiot hypothetical game?

ETA: While I am at it, I am not aware that electric shock to the nuts is in the Field Manual. As I recall, some soldiers in Abu Ghraib got hammered for pulling that crap, even the image of it as a threat. Did you not know that there were people court martialed for that, Lonewulf, or did you selectively forget that in your desire to play a silly game?
also assume that that information will necessarily be reliable?
What the hell are you talking about? Go back and read a bit more, and try again. For that matter, I suggest you read this, rather that playing silly games.

http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/showthread.php?t=109066

I referenced it early in the thread. It is the piece in the Atlantic Monthly that described how team of interrogators used other than extreme methods to coax actionable intelligence out of someone to get targeting info on Zarqawi.

The price paid for this is time. A key problem with the people in Bush's team is that they are, and were, impatient. They want it now. Some things you don't get "now" and beating someone, or as you suggest, zapping their nuts, gets you something now, but as noted elsewhere, is it actionable intelligence? The experiences on that vary. Stockdale and his chums, and their experience, show that any amount of useless info, like what the Hawaiian good luck sign is, is admitted.

DR
 
Last edited:
Where do you get the idea that has no permanent effect?

Why are you playing the idiot hypothetical game?

Because I find it interesting that there's this insinuation that torture is fine, only as long as the pain is temporary.

Of course, I'm sure you only mean the physical pain. ;)

ETA: While I am at it, I am not aware that electric shock to the nuts is in the Field Manual. As I recall, some soldiers in Abu Ghraib got hammered for pulling that crap, even the image of it as a threat. Did you not know that there were people court martialed for that, Lonewulf, or did you selectively forget that in your desire to play a silly game?

I think that it's a silly game to write down off one form of torture while embracing another.
 
Because I find it interesting that there's this insinuation that torture is fine, only as long as the pain is temporary.

Of course, I'm sure you only mean the physical pain. ;)

I think that it's a silly game to write down off one form of torture while embracing another.
Did you read this thread sober, or whilst swilling good German beer? :confused:

DR
 
This gentleman points out that the rendition policy began in the 1990's, but I note an eerie silence on that point by some of our more vitriolic pundits here. Why was it not stopped then? Why was it condoned?

YOU TALKING TO ME? YOU TALKING TO ME?

Just for the record, I have never been called vitriolic before.

Government moves slowly, and news leaks out over time. I was not aware of the rendition policy until after the invasion of Afghanistan. As I learned about it, I developed an opinion. I wouldn't consider this to be an eerie scenario, but to each his own.

By the way, given that this creeps you out and that Halloween is on the way, if I don't say anything to you do I get candy?
 
I have to sort of side with Ken on this one -- I would like to see actual evidence that torture is more reliable than other, less offensive, techniques. My hunch is that it might not be, and has only persisted because of some desire to hurt the enemy.
 
........and I thought this was going to boil down to “Why is it harder to teach your kids to not hit people later in life if you spank them as a form of punishment?” on page 3.......

At what page number does this thread become torture? I'm sure we all agree there will be an exact page number that this occurs and isn't a matter of opinion?

Obviously we all can see the difference between:
A: Saying "Tell me everything." repeatedly for hours on end and
B: Saying "Tell me everything." once with a big stick

Don't forget carrot/stick can be financial as well as moral. It needs to be said that violence (torture) is way cheaper than rewards (putting someone up for life in exchange for co-operation).

Bring down the price of carrots!!

Should we now compare seperating finance from morals to seperating religion from government?
 
It hasn't been established by any science that torture works. Until you then, the burden is upon you to prove that it does.

You realize the problem with this, don't you? You're basically saying that we should do scientifically controlled studies using torture to test its efficacy - after all, how else to prove that it doesn't work?

Since it's not known to work reliably, then it is definitely immoral to use to garner information.

Have any interrogation techniques been tested scientifically? Do any of them work reliably? For the first question, I doubt many, and for the second question, probably none - certainly no evidence to that effect has been produced by opponents of torture.

If torture can be shown or made to be effective, would you still have any argument against it? If so, then why not rely upon that argument now?
 
You realize the problem with this, don't you? You're basically saying that we should do scientifically controlled studies using torture to test its efficacy - after all, how else to prove that it doesn't work?

Since it has been around for so long, and still is in all forms, I don't see why this would be a problem. I would buy this argument if it was "we don't know for sure that torture works, so we are going to assume it doesn't because learning otherwise is too costly," rather than "we don't know if it works, and studying it is too costly, but what the hell lets pull his fingernails out!"

If torture can be shown or made to be effective, would you still have any argument against it? If so, then why not rely upon that argument now?

No. But then I wouldn't call it torture anymore. The term "torture" seems to imply (at least for me) some degree of punishment, because throughout history torture has been used more often for punishment and sadism than interrogation purposes (or at least the extreme versions have). If the same technique was used *only* to get information, then I would just call it aggressive interrogation, and would have no problem with it.

That being said, I think the cases where such techniques are used should be restricted to those when we *absolutely know* a subject contains the information we wish to extract.

Doing anything even remotely psychologically damaging to an innocent person is inexcusable and in my opinion even a single instance of that would invalidate years of otherwise productive sessions with the real bad guys. Kind of like that old "its better to let ten criminals go free than jail one innocent" thing.
 
You realize the problem with this, don't you? You're basically saying that we should do scientifically controlled studies using torture to test its efficacy - after all, how else to prove that it doesn't work?

Scientific analysis of the data already available.

From an earlier article:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/15/AR2007011501204.html?nav=rss_world

Kleinman wrote that intelligence gathered with coercion is sometimes inaccurate or false, noting that isolation, a tactic U.S. officials have used regularly, causes "profound emotional, psychological, and physical discomfort" and can "significantly and negatively impact the ability of the source to recall information accurately."

So we already have data.
The only way your argument works is when a new form of physical discomfort is suggested. We know X, Y and Z don't work. Maybe if we play heavy metal really loud for days and days? What if we half-drown people? Like a new fad diet when the old one doesn't help us loose weight.


I suggest we go with the experts who say that popular culture has it wrong:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0212/p99s01-duts.html

In fact, Finnegan and the others had come to voice their concern that the show's central political premise – that the letter of American law must be sacrificed for the country's security – was having a toxic effect. In their view, the show promoted unethical and illegal behavior and had adversely affected the training and performance of real American soldiers. "I'd like them to stop," Finnegan said of the show's producers. "They should do a show where torture backfires."

If torture can be shown or made to be effective, would you still have any argument against it? If so, then why not rely upon that argument now?

There are other arguments against torture. From Joe Navarro:
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/02/19/070219fa_fact_mayer?currentPage=4

Joe Navarro, one of the F.B.I.’s top experts in questioning techniques, attended the meeting; he told me, “Only a psychopath can torture and be unaffected. You don’t want people like that in your organization. They are untrustworthy, and tend to have grotesque other problems.”

Why not rely on that argument now?
Because those proposing torture have not shown that it works -- the foundation of most of their arguments, so their first task is to back up their claim. Especially given the expert opinions against. What evidence there is suggests that torture doesn't work.
 
Last edited:
YOU TALKING TO ME? YOU TALKING TO ME?
No, but as that was a sloppy casting, it may have put the hook into the wrong fish.
Just for the record, I have never been called vitriolic before.
I don't find your posts to trend that way.
Government moves slowly, and news leaks out over time. I was not aware of the rendition policy until after the invasion of Afghanistan. As I learned about it, I developed an opinion. I wouldn't consider this to be an eerie scenario, but to each his own.
Well put. This still raises the question of why this policy did not see the light of day until it did. Congressional oversight, security, or the magnitude of the matter not obvious until Gitmo (an attempt at loophole exploitation) raised a series of issues to the level of "where the heck is this headed?"
By the way, given that this creeps you out and that Halloween is on the way, if I don't say anything to you do I get candy?
Say what you like, you aren't part of the problem, so you get candy, if I were the sort who gave candy at Halloween.

We opted out of that a couple of years ago, and my life has been slightly better for it.

I can offer you a beer, however, and it is Friday. :)

DR
 
Scientific analysis of the data already available.

What data? Data on torture? I'm not aware any such scientific evidence exists. And your link doesn't reference any. In fact, your link seems to indicate that there's a lack of scientific evidence regarding the efficacy of pretty much all our interrogation techniques.

I suggest we go with the experts who say that popular culture has it wrong:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0212/p99s01-duts.html

I'm sure it does. The problem is that one cannot conclude that because Jack Bauer's form of torture is likely ineffective (but note that the primary objection to it in the article is that it encourages illegal and uncontrolled behavior, not that it doesn't work) that this means torture is categorically ineffective.

There are other arguments against torture.

I'm sure there are, and I have not denied them. My point is that relying upon the idea (which hasn't been proven) that torture is ineffective creates a situation in which opposition to torture becomes difficult if it can be shown or made to be effective. If that were to happen, would your opposition to it vanish? I suspect not. Which indicates to me that you should be using those other arguments to begin with. Furthermore, as your own link points out, there are people who may be performing interrogations who seem to be coming to the conclusion (rightly or wrongly) that it does work. Arguments against its efficacy aren't convincing them. If you want them to refrain from torturing interrogation subjects, you're going to need to provide them with other reasons not to.

Why not rely on that argument now?
Because those proposing torture have not shown that it works

And the only way to show that it works is to try it. Is that what you want advocates to be doing? Again, I suspect not.

The real world isn't an Oxford debating club. When some interrogator is faced with a situation in which he feels the need to get critical information out of a subject, is he going to be convinced not to torture by the fact that it hasn't been proven effective? No, because the fact of the matter is it hasn't been proven ineffective either. You need a different argument. If I'm not mistaken, your opposition to torture is not founded on an evaluation of its efficacy, don't expect that to be the deciding factor for people placed in the position of actually doing it.
 
Since it has been around for so long, and still is in all forms, I don't see why this would be a problem.

Killing people has been around since the dawn of time too. And there are even circumstances under which it is a legal imperative. But I wouldn't want to go around performing scientific studies which required killing people - I would indeed consider that a problem.

I would buy this argument if it was "we don't know for sure that torture works, so we are going to assume it doesn't because learning otherwise is too costly,"

The heart of this argument is that the cost of torture is too high. That cost exists regardless of any benefit. If there is to be an argument against torture which does not depend upon denying any benefit, it must focus upon the cost, which is what I've been trying to say.
 
What data? Data on torture? I'm not aware any such scientific evidence exists. And your link doesn't reference any.

It quotes one guy saying that isolation can "significantly and negatively impact the ability of the source to recall information accurately."

That indicates to me that the data on interrogation techniques and the quality of the results they get is available.

In fact, your link seems to indicate that there's a lack of scientific evidence regarding the efficacy of pretty much all our interrogation techniques.

Except that isolation is one of the techniques used by the US.

There is no evidence to show that the new fads in coercion work. There is evidence that other forms of torture were not helpful to the interrogator. The article gives an example of one -- isolation.

Do we have to test every possible form of coercion?


I'm sure it does. The problem is that one cannot conclude that because Jack Bauer's form of torture is likely ineffective (but note that the primary objection to it in the article is that it encourages illegal and uncontrolled behavior, not that it doesn't work) that this means torture is categorically ineffective.

The article says that the show 24 was "hurting efforts to train recruits in effective interrogation techniques..."

And: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A2302-2005Jan11.html

An up-to-date illustration of the colonel's point appeared in recently released FBI documents from the naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. These show, among other things, that some military intelligence officers wanted to use harsher interrogation methods than the FBI did. As a result, complained one inspector, "every time the FBI established a rapport with a detainee, the military would step in and the detainee would stop being cooperative."

So the FBI claimed detainees would stop being cooperative. They got less from them after torture than before.

This may not be conclusive to you. You may say there are other techniques to try. I say enough of this kind of thing has been tried already.

My point is that relying upon the idea (which hasn't been proven) that torture is ineffective creates a situation in which opposition to torture becomes difficult if it can be shown or made to be effective. If that were to happen, would your opposition to it vanish? I suspect not.

I've strongly implied not. I'll say it plainly: I still would not support torture.

Which indicates to me that you should be using those other arguments to begin with. Furthermore, as your own link points out, there are people who may be performing interrogations who seem to be coming to the conclusion (rightly or wrongly) that it does work.

What objective data do they have to back them up? Where we have data, it says torture does not work.

And the only way to show that it works is to try it. Is that what you want advocates to be doing? Again, I suspect not.

My point is, we have data. We don't have to try every form of coercion. There comes a point where you have to draw a line and reach a conclusion.

The real world isn't an Oxford debating club. When some interrogator is faced with a situation in which he feels the need to get critical information out of a subject, is he going to be convinced not to torture by the fact that it hasn't been proven effective? No, because the fact of the matter is it hasn't been proven ineffective either.

Are you saying that people in the real world aren't convinced by argument? I've given another argument, I've quoted the experts on my side of the debate. Perhaps you can find experts for the other side. How many of them hold high positions in intelligence agencies?

You want me to debate ethics, too?
The argument doesn't warrant that. We'll end up in the ticking-bomb scenario and debating the most effective interrogation technique -- again. Because the pro-torture side doesn't have another tune. They only sing "torture works."

Imagine the mindset of the people involved in this kind of thing. Can they really switch it off when they get off work? You want your life in their hands?
 
Last edited:
Killing people has been around since the dawn of time too. And there are even circumstances under which it is a legal imperative.

Right. So my point is that since people are killed all the time, it woudn't be a big deal to simply collect data on it. You don't HAVE to commission a study -- just keep track of the statistics that already exist. Same goes for torture. People have been and are gonna be tortured for a long time, regardless of what we do, so someone might as well at least log the results when it happens.

The heart of this argument is that the cost of torture is too high. That cost exists regardless of any benefit. If there is to be an argument against torture which does not depend upon denying any benefit, it must focus upon the cost, which is what I've been trying to say.

But "cost of torture is too high" is a completely subjective phrase, like the cost of anything else being "too high." It all depends on how much you have to spend.

On an individual basis, there is *never* a cost to high to use even the worst techniques on someone, and if they claim otherwise I say they have never really cared about another human being -- if someone kidnaps your spouse or child and is raping them hourly, and you find an accomplice, you *will* do whatever it takes to find out where (your family) they are so you can save them. It is that simple. Anyone who wouldn't is even less humane..

On a collective basis, however, the suffering of individuals like that might not be worth accepting nasty interrogation techniques, because while the suffering of a single victim we don't know doesn't do much damage to the average jane and joe, the knowledge that our country tortures prisoners surely does. So its a complex issue at that level.

For a country like the USA, I would say the cost of using such techniques in overall much greater than the cost of a few thousand extra citizens dying from terrorist attacks, because our ideals and ethics are very high and knowing that is a great source of pride and comfort to the average American. Of course, I wouldn't say that if whoever dies (or has died) is someone I know -- in that case I would favor very rough methods indeed -- but that is the whole point of a collective approach. It keeps the few who are directly involved from deciding for the rest of us.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom