Sleep deprivation.. maybe. However, if it's done to the point where symptoms of insanity begin, I'd call that torture for sure.
If you do it to the point of insanity, you have failed, I would think, due to your subject now being a more unreliable source of information than previously. At that point, yes indeed, it becomes abuse for the sake of abuse, and of no value other than, as I see it, to screw with someone. I don't think that is how it is used.
Waterboarding is torture. Just because these methods were used as "training" doesn't make it morally more correct.
I didn't say it was, so what? It is recoverable from in a relatively short time frame. Having your arm broken by "interrogators" in the Hanoi Hilton takes a bit longer to get over. Having a thumb cut off, see Jack Ensch, F-4 RIO, quite another.
ETA 2: From Captain Richard Stratton's recollection:
Still, no one is immune to torture.
"Torture is a different thing for different people," Stratton said. "For some, it meant kneeling on a broomstick for three days. Guys would land with a broken arm and they would just twist the arm."
Stratton spend a long time in the Hanoi Hilton.
Is pepper spraying prisoners for information torture? I've seen marine combat training involve sparring with pepper spray in their face. I would say yes, it's still torture.
Is it done every day? All the time? Now and again? Pepper spray is also a temporary effect, though again, if you get pepper spray in the face every hour on the hour, I'd guess two things: you'll say anything to get them to knock that crap off,
or,
you'll adapt to it and go to a place I've never been, mentally, where you beg them to bring it on.
Training our soldiers to be more resilient to certain forms of torture doesn't justify using those same methods on others.
I never said it was. The loose usage of the term "torture" fails to make the distinction between permanent physical damage and temporary suckage. The point on the problems of vacating a moral high ground stands on its own.
The further points made by people like McCain, Stockdale, and for that matter, the oft quoted CIA report in the early sixties, are enough of an argument for not using torture as a matter of practice, particularly against "true believers," to prefer other methods of interrogation for those who are to be interrogated. (I'll see if I can dig up anything on the recent topic by Eugene "Red" McDaniel, another one time guest at the Hanoi Hilton. ETA if I can.
ETA: Looks like Red didn't get anything out recently, last ADI briefing was in 1998 that I can find.
http://www.ojc.org/adi/captain.htm )
I read many essays by James Stockdale on how he dealt with, and resisted, real torture, physical abuse that left permanent damage. His stoic approach is likely the same frame of mind that the True Believer of an Islamist sort has recourse to, to include the three guys who suicided in Gitmo a couple of years ago.
http://koranteng.blogspot.com/2005/07/erustication-and-italian-job.html
ETA: This gentleman points out that the rendition policy began in the 1990's, but I note an eerie silence on that point by some of our more vitriolic pundits here. Why was it not stopped then? Why was it condoned?
If it's wrong, and let's take that position, it's wrong, then both parties, both houses of Congress, and both Baby Boomer administrations have blood on their knuckles. An interesting note in that blog article, the threat of rendition to Israel and the Mossad was apparently enough to get one nabbed terrorist (operative??) to become very cooperative.
That's a version of good cop, bad cop.
DR