Torture memo...OMG

It makes your point just about as clear as the first time you made it, and obviously my point came across as clear as mud.

First ask yourself if nation 2 was being vile while not in a state of war. Then ask if nation 1 was also. Then ask if you see no moral difference between the two, culturally and politically speaking.

As to when they go to war, if they are not the same then they will not behave, within individual human limitations, in the same way because they don't think the same way; but war is not civil and it must be fought to win, and it can be fought to win without becoming like the other.

We won WWII by being much more brutal than how we fight today, but it did not corrupt everything about us. The truth is that civil society is more robust than you give it credit for.

As to all those who claim to fear too much toughness will corrupt our entire morality, I also see much of that posturing as simple partisan politics. Hypocritical in other words, when it is not simple naivety.
You just aren't in touch with reality here. WWI and WWII were completely different wars. They were wars with tanks and planes against tanks and planes. The aggressors were trying to take and hold land which the inhabitants did not want to be taken and held. We did just fine kicking Iraq out of Kuwait. We didn't have any trouble marching on Baghdad with our military superiority. If all we needed to do was have bigger guns we would have been done with this war by now. Obviously that wasn't the only thing we needed.
 
First, I'm sorry but I don't take the Washington Post as an authority on anything except partisan politics anymore.

There's an expert for everything and every opinion and there is no doubt that individual humans without external rules can make up their own rules and can do so for the hell of it rather than any other reason, but that doesn't mean it makes sense to try to sanitize reality.

...[snip]...

One thing that is appreciated, and felt, by most humans is fear. There would be far less need for "torture" (as I don't call it) if captives were afraid from the first moment they were captured, rightly or wrongly. However thanks to many people they know they have little to fear. When I lived in Arab countries many years ago, I always thought it amusing how criminals (before OBL times) that one read about being arrested always immediately took the police to their accomplices or their loot. Fear is a powerful tool when properly used.
The WA Post summarizes other experts, even the opinion pieces on this subject cite experts. And you have yet to find us any that support your position. Though there are a few, they are in the minority.

As far as all we need is for them to be afraid of us...I'd hate to be your kid. :rolleyes: What a power fantasy. It doesn't work that way. There are people on both sides willing to die, what makes you think the prisoners in question simply need to be afraid?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by skeptigirl
This administration learned from Nixon's mistakes and I believe that is part of the problem why we are not seeing the public outraged and screaming "Impeach them". This administration is controlling information in a much tighter way. The truth comes out but they are very good at stopping it from snowballing.

However, that only goes so far. Everything is falling apart for these guys now. There isn't enough lipstick to put on all the pigs that they've made. But since the Democrats expect to win the Presidency in 2008 and probably expand their lead in the Senate and Congress, I think a number of them are afraid (they shouldn't be but they are) that if they undertake a harsher attack against Bush it could backfire.


That still doesn't solve the problem of too much power in one person.
Are you claiming our system of government which has survived for 230 years is now so distorted it is broken?

I suggest you read more US history. The pendulum has swung further than this in the past and it still swung back.
 
Indeed. Even more ironic - and tragically absurd - is to point out that the values "the west" can be really proud of, and fought for in centuries of bloody history, are exactly the same values people want to throw over board now to fight "them". It could be seen as frightening, but fear seems to be THE driving force behind this madness so i decide to not be frightened but only disgusted.

That's exactly it. The whole "we have to be tough on terrorists, even if it means ignoring our laws" is a basically cowardly position. Reasoned, logical thinkers accept the clear fact that torture doesn't work on any level. It doesn't get results, and it turns people against us. There is no rational reason for it.

The irrational, fear-based viewpoint advocates torture for reasons besides interrogation results. The "reason" for hurting prisoners has little to do with gathering information, and just about everything to do with alleviating the uncontrollable fear that drives every cowardly decision.

What I wonder, though, is how much actual hatred for our values these people have, as opposed to just forgetting those values because of fear. They certainly jump on any excuse, no matter how feeble, to betray those values every chance they get.
 
So you think you wouldn't talk if you didn't feel like it. Good for you toughie. The point is that taken to excess interrogation will generate fictitious information, not that it won't generate any. If you seriously think most people won't start talking under harsh circumstance you must be from another planet.
There you go fighting more straw men. No one is arguing this. People who are tortured talk and say whatever they think the torturer wants them to say, mostly false information.
 
We are talking of how our enemy is treated in general. With few exceptions our prisoners now are treated better than those we have in maximum security prisons at home.

.....
Ignoring the torture aspect for the moment, if I gave you a choice of being in a prison in the tropics, with tolerable food and conditions but you had no charges brought against you in a court which you could defend yourself, you had no sentence so no idea how long you'd be there, no visits or even contact with your friends or family, would you really think that you were better off than if you were in a prison with worse conditions but you were there after due process, you knew the length of your sentence and you had contact including visits with friends and family? Which would you choose?
 
There you go fighting more straw men. No one is arguing this. People who are tortured talk and say whatever they think the torturer wants them to say, mostly false information.

I think what Elind is saying is that he wants people in other countries, and probably Muslims specifically, to live in fear of America, the way he lives in fear of the rest of the world?
 
...

btw, the innocently kidnapped and tortured German skeptigirl was talking about earlier is NOW dangerous to himself and society - a broken man:
This is even more disgusting and sad. We not only kept this guy a few extra months because Conde and Bush were embarrassed, but we also we denied him any compensation and psychological treatment which we know many torture victims need again, because Bush and Conde didn't want to be embarrassed by the publicity. They blocked lawsuits by both the German and the Canadian, claiming a trial would reveal national secrets (like that would have stopped an out of court settlement, we know it was our terrible mistake), and Bush and Conde wouldn't even apologize to these two people.
 
Another embarrassment to the country, I can't wait until that idiot is out of office. Who is in charge of the torture program anyway? Still using pliers and water boarding, is this the 20th century?The best way to get information out of a person is through the use of psychoactive drugs. I'm sure the military could find something better but cocaine would probably work. Make a person high enough and they will start to tell you everything you could want to know.
 
I agree. The distinction however is between "torture" (the definition being debatable)
Not really. http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/cat.htm says torture is "...any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity." That's according to international law. Specifically, the United Nations Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, which we signed in 1988 and ratified in 1994, making it part of the US Code. Any US citizen (and that includes all government officials and soldiers) violating this law anywhere in the world is guilty of a felony.

to gain confession and "torture" to gain information, not to mention how smart the interrogators are. My personal opinion is that it is tolerable when information may be new and actionable. After a time it is probably pointless.
Pragmatically, it is incompetent, and therefore inexcusable. Ethically, it is inexcusable. It's morally reprehensible and abhorrent, just as Ashcroft said it is. There is no possible justification, precisely because it does not work. It has no place in the repertoire of a modern society; simply because it is ethically inexcusable and pragmatically ineffective. It's also a felony, and a violent criminal offense.

Bungles galore this administration has made, but that alone doesn't address the issue.
The longer I watch, the more convinced I become that incompetence is the root of the bulk of the problems; and the ones that aren't direct results of incompetence are results of cover-ups of incompetence, and advantage being taken by unscrupulous individuals of those cover-ups.

See, you haven't been listening to me, although I may not have been terribly clear. I don't believe in inflicting pain, as in nerve pain, either. Emotional pain, nervous pain, hunger pain perhaps, disorientation pain, fear of pain; but no rack, no scalpels no drills no needles.

My issue in these arguments is that putting someone in a blindfold is considered torture by some. Perhaps not you?
See above. I think calling a blindfold torture is hyperbole. Calling waterboarding torture is not. Have you ever nearly drowned? I have. That's torture.

I take what you said above, snipped, at face value. You will note that I have always tried to talk of harsh or( devious) INTERROGATION, not inflicting pain as described. Some techniques might be borderline in that area, but my position is that you don't throw out all options in a time of war because some could be seen as such, and you certainly don't do so because of the naive opinion that this "would make us as bad as them".
The line is drawn above. If a reasonable person would conclude that an act would violate the law above, then it should not be undertaken. Judicial oversight should be sought if there is any question, and a suitable court for seeking that oversight has been provided. Matters brought before this court are national secrets, and protected under law as such.

I have no problem with coercive interrogation. It's reasonable to expect it, and it's used in civil law enforcement in this country. I have serious problems with torture, and it's my expectation that my employees (I, among others, after all do pay for their salaries) will respect the law. They are not. I have no hesitation in stating that people who do not respect and obey the law should be prosecuted, and if I had the doing of it, I'd be proceeding now.

I'd draw the line at any physical act, other than ordinary restraint. No slapping, no waterboarding, no electric shocks, no uncomfortable positions, no starvation, no cold, no loud noises, no drugs. No super high-tech pain beams. A highly coercive, even "harsh," interrogation can be conducted without these measures, and is every day. There is no law against deceit; and no law against intimidation. A good working knowledge of psychology is needed, and a thorough grounding in techniques. Nothing more. These techniques are used by civil law enforcement every day, and to good effect. I would not care to be interrogated, guilty or not, by a professional federal law enforcement professional in the service of my country, even though I would be relatively confident they would remain within the law no matter what happened. It is a gruelling and extremely unpleasant process.

I can say that many times, and have done so; in case you are tempted to think I'm a fan of Bush & Co.
I'm starting to think we might eventually agree, despite your apparently aggressive stance at the beginning of the conversation. You just have to get over this conviction that coercive interrogation cannot be separated from violence.

Revenge has no place in this beyond what is implied in locking them up, I agree. I don't agree that all that is called torture qualifies as such, and as much as I don't like anything I hear Bush say, I'm not going to make this a partisan issue, which I think many do.
I think the law above is clear, and I think where it is not, there are professional legal opinions readily available. I'm not sure whether it's a partisan issue or not; I don't intend to approach it that way, but cannot rule out a certain amount of personal bias. Frankly, I think the man is a smartass fratboi, and strongly suspect he thinks most people aren't very smart. He smirks. I don't generally think much of people who smirk. He doesn't appear to have much respect for a number of institutions in my country that are some of the most important reasons I enjoy being a citizen of it.

I think there are people who will accuse anyone in authority of torture whether justified or not. I am not such a person, nor do I have a great deal of respect for such people. However, in the current climate, I will support them over the statements you initially made, because I feel strongly that the situation is far out of control. Lines have been crossed that should never have been crossed, and my nation and my nation's foundations have been sullied, dishonored, and in my opinion spat upon. It's more important in my mind at this time that this stop than whether I agree entirely with people who feel much the same as I do. Where you and I conflict is in what I feel is a blurring of the line between torture and not-torture, and I feel that you are erring on the same side as the current administration. I will say that you don't appear from what you've said here to go nearly as far as they do.

I agree, except that too many seem to think that applies in spades during war. If you want to give yourself the luxury of dealing with every enemy combatant as you would a gang member, say, at home, then you can never win a war.
I don't think you have any real idea how harsh a coercive interrogation using completely legal methods can be. There have been documented cases of people confessing to crimes they did not commit under completely legal interrogation.

Gang members and terrorists may or may not be physically tough; what they are not is mentally tough. If they were, they would be successful at being something other than a gang member or terrorist. Most terrorists are mentally weak, and easily led; these are common characteristics of people malleable enough to be members of terrorist organizations and gangs. They are uncritical and willing to bow to authority. The ones who are tougher are vulnerable in other ways. These are generally the leaders.

What is required above all is training and experience. This is the province of the professional. Such people exist, and work for us; if they are not being used, then that is yet another example of incompetence.

As for winning, we already did that; what we have not done is win the peace. But that's a matter that has little to do with the subject at hand.
 
The best way to get information out of a person is through the use of psychoactive drugs. I'm sure the military could find something better but cocaine would probably work. Make a person high enough and they will start to tell you everything you could want to know.
No, unfortunately it's been shown that because different people react differently to drugs, you're as likely to get a fantasy as reality. The surest way is to use psychological techniques. These get them into an emotional state where they can't resist telling you what you want to know, and where they are motivated to tell you the truth. Do read that link I sent. It's pretty clear, and pretty comprehensive. This is not new. We've been doing this since Ooog's band wanted to know when their enemies were coming to the water hole.
 


Well...

wsws said:
[...] After the Supreme Court in June of 2006 struck down Bush’s military commissions and ruled that all prisoners held by the US, including alleged Al Qaeda terrorists, fall under the Geneva Conventions’ provisions banning torture and abusive treatment, Bush issued a new executive order authorizing “enhanced interrogation techniques.”

This was followed by the passage of the Military Commissions Act in October 2006, which gave congressional sanction for the administration’s policy of indefinite detention, drumhead military tribunals and interrogation methods defined under US and international law as torture, while shielding it from prosecution. It also gave the president authority to “interpret” the Geneva Conventions. [...]

A measure of the political degeneracy and complicity of the entire American political establishment in such monstrous crimes is the lack of any serious response to Bush’s adamant defense of torture. On Friday’s evening news broadcasts, Bush’s White House appearance was not even reported by two networks, CBS and ABC, and NBC made it the third story. All three devoted the bulk of their broadcasts to the admission by US track star Marion Jones that she had used steroids. [...]

No Democrat has suggested that any serious measures be taken against Bush and his co-conspirators. There have been no calls for impeachment, criminal prosecutions—which are mandated by the Geneva Conventions against government officials who authorize torture—or any other actions to hold the Bush administration accountable for flouting court rulings and breeching both international and domestic law. [...]

Source
 
OK, Elind, given it doesn't work, and given that mistakes get made and society and the individual who was tortured get to pay rather than the incompetent interrogators, what precisely was the justification for this again?

I didn't say it doesn't work, I said it doesn't work when done for the the wrong motives or objectives, and I said more too; but what the hell.
 
What I wonder, though, is how much actual hatred for our values these people have, as opposed to just forgetting those values because of fear. They certainly jump on any excuse, no matter how feeble, to betray those values every chance they get.


You are talking about the people driving that policy, right? The Neo-Cons guru Leo Strauss admired Carl Schmitt, "Hitler's lawyer", and that's what you get: Securing the "unity" of the state by demonizing an (mostly made-up) enemy while seducing the masses with propaganda, spreading fear on all sides and keeping real information for themselves. They really hate the values of the enlightenment.
 
You are talking about the people driving that policy, right? The Neo-Cons guru Leo Strauss admired Carl Schmitt, "Hitler's lawyer", and that's what you get: Securing the "unity" of the state by demonizing an (mostly made-up) enemy while seducing the masses with propaganda, spreading fear on all sides and keeping real information for themselves. They really hate the values of the enlightenment.

The people driving AND supporting the policy. Some of them are just frightened... and others are driving that fear in order to get what they want.
 
The people driving AND supporting the policy. Some of them are just frightened... and others are driving that fear in order to get what they want.


The people supporting the policy are mostly acting out of fear, even the "interrogators" themselves might think they are doing the right thing, but the architects of it know exactly what they are doing. They are everything but stupid and they know history.
 
You are talking about the people driving that policy, right? The Neo-Cons guru Leo Strauss admired Carl Schmitt, "Hitler's lawyer", and that's what you get: Securing the "unity" of the state by demonizing an (mostly made-up) enemy while seducing the masses with propaganda, spreading fear on all sides and keeping real information for themselves. They really hate the values of the enlightenment.

Well if that is the case then, you better add the DEMs under Bill Clinton to that list, as they considered OBL and Al-Qaeda their top priority when they left the white house. Were they making it up? Did they false flag the Embassy Bombings? Did they false flag all the other Al-Qaeda acts of terror.

I am sorry, as much as I despise most of what this current admin has done, the DEMs do not get a free pass...

TAM:)
 
Well if that is the case then, you better add the DEMs under Bill Clinton to that list, as they considered OBL and Al-Qaeda their top priority when they left the white house. Were they making it up? Did they false flag the Embassy Bombings? Did they false flag all the other Al-Qaeda acts of terror.

I am sorry, as much as I despise most of what this current admin has done, the DEMs do not get a free pass...

TAM:)


Hey, you agree with wsws and me. They certainly don't get a free pass but i would say that the average democrat falls more into the fear-driven category. Some people at the top of the democrats are certainly not opposed to the straussian ideas of mass control and as guilty as the architects of that mess.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom