I agree. The distinction however is between "torture" (the definition being debatable)
Not really.
http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/cat.htm says torture is "...any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity." That's according to international law. Specifically, the United Nations Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, which we signed in 1988 and ratified in 1994, making it part of the US Code. Any US citizen (and that includes all government officials and soldiers) violating this law anywhere in the world is guilty of a felony.
to gain confession and "torture" to gain information, not to mention how smart the interrogators are. My personal opinion is that it is tolerable when information may be new and actionable. After a time it is probably pointless.
Pragmatically, it is incompetent, and therefore inexcusable. Ethically, it is inexcusable. It's morally reprehensible and abhorrent, just as Ashcroft said it is. There is no possible justification, precisely because it does not work. It has no place in the repertoire of a modern society; simply because it is ethically inexcusable and pragmatically ineffective. It's also a felony, and a violent criminal offense.
Bungles galore this administration has made, but that alone doesn't address the issue.
The longer I watch, the more convinced I become that incompetence is the root of the bulk of the problems; and the ones that aren't direct results of incompetence are results of cover-ups of incompetence, and advantage being taken by unscrupulous individuals of those cover-ups.
See, you haven't been listening to me, although I may not have been terribly clear. I don't believe in inflicting pain, as in nerve pain, either. Emotional pain, nervous pain, hunger pain perhaps, disorientation pain, fear of pain; but no rack, no scalpels no drills no needles.
My issue in these arguments is that putting someone in a blindfold is considered torture by some. Perhaps not you?
See above. I think calling a blindfold torture is hyperbole. Calling waterboarding torture is not. Have you ever nearly drowned? I have. That's torture.
I take what you said above, snipped, at face value. You will note that I have always tried to talk of harsh or( devious) INTERROGATION, not inflicting pain as described. Some techniques might be borderline in that area, but my position is that you don't throw out all options in a time of war because some could be seen as such, and you certainly don't do so because of the naive opinion that this "would make us as bad as them".
The line is drawn above. If a reasonable person would conclude that an act would violate the law above, then it should not be undertaken. Judicial oversight should be sought if there is any question, and a suitable court for seeking that oversight has been provided. Matters brought before this court are national secrets, and protected under law as such.
I have no problem with coercive interrogation. It's reasonable to expect it, and it's used in civil law enforcement in this country. I have serious problems with torture, and it's my expectation that my employees (I, among others, after all do pay for their salaries) will respect the law. They are not. I have no hesitation in stating that people who do not respect and obey the law should be prosecuted, and if I had the doing of it, I'd be proceeding now.
I'd draw the line at any physical act, other than ordinary restraint. No slapping, no waterboarding, no electric shocks, no uncomfortable positions, no starvation, no cold, no loud noises, no drugs. No super high-tech pain beams. A highly coercive, even "harsh," interrogation can be conducted without these measures, and is every day. There is no law against deceit; and no law against intimidation. A good working knowledge of psychology is needed, and a thorough grounding in techniques. Nothing more. These techniques are used by civil law enforcement every day, and to good effect. I would not care to be interrogated, guilty or not, by a professional federal law enforcement professional in the service of my country, even though I would be relatively confident they would remain within the law no matter what happened. It is a gruelling and extremely unpleasant process.
I can say that many times, and have done so; in case you are tempted to think I'm a fan of Bush & Co.
I'm starting to think we might eventually agree, despite your apparently aggressive stance at the beginning of the conversation. You just have to get over this conviction that coercive interrogation cannot be separated from violence.
Revenge has no place in this beyond what is implied in locking them up, I agree. I don't agree that all that is called torture qualifies as such, and as much as I don't like anything I hear Bush say, I'm not going to make this a partisan issue, which I think many do.
I think the law above is clear, and I think where it is not, there are professional legal opinions readily available. I'm not sure whether it's a partisan issue or not; I don't intend to approach it that way, but cannot rule out a certain amount of personal bias. Frankly, I think the man is a smartass fratboi, and strongly suspect he thinks most people aren't very smart. He smirks. I don't generally think much of people who smirk. He doesn't appear to have much respect for a number of institutions in my country that are some of the most important reasons I enjoy being a citizen of it.
I think there are people who will accuse anyone in authority of torture whether justified or not. I am not such a person, nor do I have a great deal of respect for such people. However, in the current climate, I will support them over the statements you initially made, because I feel strongly that the situation is far out of control. Lines have been crossed that should never have been crossed, and my nation and my nation's foundations have been sullied, dishonored, and in my opinion spat upon. It's more important in my mind at this time that this stop than whether I agree entirely with people who feel much the same as I do. Where you and I conflict is in what I feel is a blurring of the line between torture and not-torture, and I feel that you are erring on the same side as the current administration. I will say that you don't appear from what you've said here to go nearly as far as they do.
I agree, except that too many seem to think that applies in spades during war. If you want to give yourself the luxury of dealing with every enemy combatant as you would a gang member, say, at home, then you can never win a war.
I don't think you have any real idea how harsh a coercive interrogation using completely legal methods can be. There have been documented cases of people confessing to crimes they did not commit under completely legal interrogation.
Gang members and terrorists may or may not be physically tough; what they are not is mentally tough. If they were, they would be successful at being something other than a gang member or terrorist. Most terrorists are mentally weak, and easily led; these are common characteristics of people malleable enough to be members of terrorist organizations and gangs. They are uncritical and willing to bow to authority. The ones who are tougher are vulnerable in other ways. These are generally the leaders.
What is required above all is training and experience. This is the province of the professional. Such people exist, and work for us; if they are not being used, then that is yet another example of incompetence.
As for winning, we already did that; what we have not done is win the peace. But that's a matter that has little to do with the subject at hand.