Ziggurat
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2003
- Messages
- 64,446
It quotes one guy saying that isolation can "significantly and negatively impact the ability of the source to recall information accurately."
Yeah, umm... a quote from one guy isn't scientific evidence. It's an anecdote, regardless of how well-informed that anecdote is.
That indicates to me that the data on interrogation techniques and the quality of the results they get is available.
And you know this... how? How can you tell this isn't just folk wisdom passed on to this guy? Hell, it could be true, but what I'm looking at in that quote doesn't constitute scientific evidence, nor does it actually indicate that such scientific evidence exists.
Do we have to test every possible form of coercion?
Depends on what you're trying to prove. If you're trying to prove that torture categorically doesn't work, then yes, you would need to do exactly that. Which is why I'm suggesting you formulate an argument against torture that not only doesn't rely upon it not working ever, but which will stand up even if it can be shown to work. Do you not think you can formulate such an argument? I think I can.
The article says that the show 24 was "hurting efforts to train recruits in effective interrogation techniques..."
Sounds to me like they have a set of techniques which are effective to some degree, and recruits aren't learning those particular techniques as well as they should have because they're not coming in as blank slates.
Here we see a different problem with the anti-torture argument: the idea that the issue is confined to ticking time bomb scenarios. Well, it isn't. In fact, torture might be most effective in situations where that WASN'T the case - where interrogators had time to confirm information given and re-interrogate if it was fake. There's all sorts of things you can do. I have little doubt that crudely-applied torture is not productive and can even be counter-productive, but the fact that this is what most people would use doesn't mean it's the only way to torture someone.
For example, do you know how "truth serium" (AKA sodium pentathol) works? It doesn't make you tell the truth. Hell, it doesn't even really lower your inhibitions. What it does is keep you from remembering what happened while drugged up. How is this useful? Well, you interrogate someone while under sodium pentathol, then interrogate them again later. If they don't give you the same answer both times, then you know they lied to you. And it's hard to come up with the same lie twice when you don't remember what it was the first time. There are ways to get around the problem of people "just saying anything" to stop the pain.
What objective data do they have to back them up? Where we have data, it says torture does not work.
No, you don't. What you have is anecdotes. And they could be correct, they could be representative. But it's still just anecdotes, and anecdotes don't convince everyone.
There comes a point where you have to draw a line and reach a conclusion.
Sure. But I think it's possible to draw the line you want to draw without relying upon something which you simply will not convince everyone of: namely that torture doesn't work.
Are you saying that people in the real world aren't convinced by argument?
Haven't you met such people? But I was trying to be a little more specific: there are people in the real world who will not accept an argument by anecdote (which, again, is really all you have), however well-informed those anecdotes are.
You want me to debate ethics, too?
Isn't that, in the end, what this is really about? After all, there are countless methods of interrogation which don't work (for example: the comfy chair), but there's no point in actually outlawing them just on that basis. So yes, ethics must be part of the argument, or you're not going to get anywhere.
The argument doesn't warrant that. We'll end up in the ticking-bomb scenario
And you think torture opponents can get away with ignoring that scenario? Sorry, no such luck. It is, unfortunately, too much to ask that difficult moral decisions have trivial solutions.