Torture memo...OMG

It quotes one guy saying that isolation can "significantly and negatively impact the ability of the source to recall information accurately."

Yeah, umm... a quote from one guy isn't scientific evidence. It's an anecdote, regardless of how well-informed that anecdote is.

That indicates to me that the data on interrogation techniques and the quality of the results they get is available.

And you know this... how? How can you tell this isn't just folk wisdom passed on to this guy? Hell, it could be true, but what I'm looking at in that quote doesn't constitute scientific evidence, nor does it actually indicate that such scientific evidence exists.

Do we have to test every possible form of coercion?

Depends on what you're trying to prove. If you're trying to prove that torture categorically doesn't work, then yes, you would need to do exactly that. Which is why I'm suggesting you formulate an argument against torture that not only doesn't rely upon it not working ever, but which will stand up even if it can be shown to work. Do you not think you can formulate such an argument? I think I can.

The article says that the show 24 was "hurting efforts to train recruits in effective interrogation techniques..."

Sounds to me like they have a set of techniques which are effective to some degree, and recruits aren't learning those particular techniques as well as they should have because they're not coming in as blank slates.


Here we see a different problem with the anti-torture argument: the idea that the issue is confined to ticking time bomb scenarios. Well, it isn't. In fact, torture might be most effective in situations where that WASN'T the case - where interrogators had time to confirm information given and re-interrogate if it was fake. There's all sorts of things you can do. I have little doubt that crudely-applied torture is not productive and can even be counter-productive, but the fact that this is what most people would use doesn't mean it's the only way to torture someone.

For example, do you know how "truth serium" (AKA sodium pentathol) works? It doesn't make you tell the truth. Hell, it doesn't even really lower your inhibitions. What it does is keep you from remembering what happened while drugged up. How is this useful? Well, you interrogate someone while under sodium pentathol, then interrogate them again later. If they don't give you the same answer both times, then you know they lied to you. And it's hard to come up with the same lie twice when you don't remember what it was the first time. There are ways to get around the problem of people "just saying anything" to stop the pain.

What objective data do they have to back them up? Where we have data, it says torture does not work.

No, you don't. What you have is anecdotes. And they could be correct, they could be representative. But it's still just anecdotes, and anecdotes don't convince everyone.

There comes a point where you have to draw a line and reach a conclusion.

Sure. But I think it's possible to draw the line you want to draw without relying upon something which you simply will not convince everyone of: namely that torture doesn't work.

Are you saying that people in the real world aren't convinced by argument?

Haven't you met such people? But I was trying to be a little more specific: there are people in the real world who will not accept an argument by anecdote (which, again, is really all you have), however well-informed those anecdotes are.

You want me to debate ethics, too?

Isn't that, in the end, what this is really about? After all, there are countless methods of interrogation which don't work (for example: the comfy chair), but there's no point in actually outlawing them just on that basis. So yes, ethics must be part of the argument, or you're not going to get anywhere.

The argument doesn't warrant that. We'll end up in the ticking-bomb scenario

And you think torture opponents can get away with ignoring that scenario? Sorry, no such luck. It is, unfortunately, too much to ask that difficult moral decisions have trivial solutions.
 
Imagine the mindset of the people involved in this kind of thing. Can they really switch it off when they get off work? You want your life in their hands?

An example of what torture can do to the interrogator:

Eric Fair http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/08/AR2007020801680_pf.html

The lead interrogator at the DIF had given me specific instructions: I was to deprive the detainee of sleep during my 12-hour shift by opening his cell every hour, forcing him to stand in a corner and stripping him of his clothes. Three years later the tables have turned. It is rare that I sleep through the night without a visit from this man. His memory harasses me as I once harassed him.

Do you want your life in the hands of people who cannot sleep at night? Or do you prefer to trust those that are not affected by inflicting discomfort?
 
Yeah, umm... a quote from one guy isn't scientific evidence. It's an anecdote, regardless of how well-informed that anecdote is.

Even when the guy is Col. Steven M. Kleinman, "who has served as the Pentagon's senior intelligence officer for special survival training."

A PDF from the washington post article:
http://www.fas.org/irp/dni/educing.pdf

From the "about the authors" section:
Colonel Steven M. Kleinman, USAFR, serves as the Reserve Senior Intelligence Offi cer and Mobilization Augmentee to the Director, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance, HQ Air Force Special Operations Command.

Col Kleinman formerly served as Director, Air Force Combat Interrogation Course and as DOD Senior Intelligence Officer for Special Survival Training. A graduate of the Joint Military Intelligence College, he received a Master of Science of Strategic Intelligence in August 2002. He is an independent contractor for the MITRE Corporation, where he has worked in support of the Intelligence
Science Board’s Study on Educing Information.

So I suppose he has a VERY well-informed opinion.
Do you still want to call his opinion an anecdote? Even when he's talking about a subject he is highly qualified in?

The PDF is 372 pages long.
Without reading it in full, I can tell there has indeed been research into the art of "educing infomation". We are not in the Dark Ages of intelligence gathering. That probably explains the lack of burning witches.

Depends on what you're trying to prove. If you're trying to prove that torture categorically doesn't work, then yes, you would need to do exactly that. Which is why I'm suggesting you formulate an argument against torture that not only doesn't rely upon it not working ever, but which will stand up even if it can be shown to work. Do you not think you can formulate such an argument? I think I can.

Please do. That would be helpful.
I still think those that are pro-torture have to show that it was effective in the past.

Would you counter my other argument by asking, "what if sane people could inflict torture without feeling guilty? Would you support torture then?"

So now I would have to find a third argument.

Sounds to me like they have a set of techniques which are effective to some degree, and recruits aren't learning those particular techniques as well as they should have because they're not coming in as blank slates.

Yes.
And if only more people were worried by that. To me, it is like hearing that CAM is taking over the health service.

For example, do you know how "truth serium" (AKA sodium pentathol) works? It doesn't make you tell the truth. Hell, it doesn't even really lower your inhibitions. What it does is keep you from remembering what happened while drugged up. How is this useful? Well, you interrogate someone while under sodium pentathol, then interrogate them again later. If they don't give you the same answer both times, then you know they lied to you. And it's hard to come up with the same lie twice when you don't remember what it was the first time. There are ways to get around the problem of people "just saying anything" to stop the pain.

I didn't know that.
It's interesting, thanks.

No, you don't. What you have is anecdotes. And they could be correct, they could be representative.

Anecdotes from very qualified people.
Do you really believe that these people are talking without precise data to back up their opinions? I'd like to find the time to read that PDF I linked above. But that won't be for at least a couple of weeks.

And you think torture opponents can get away with ignoring that scenario? Sorry, no such luck. It is, unfortunately, too much to ask that difficult moral decisions have trivial solutions.

I'm not dodging that.
The whole point is that if torture doesn't work, and you have only limited time and opportunity, then you risk loosing by engaging in torture.

If the pro-torture debaters meant their example as a morality tale, or to tell us that "the needs of the many out-weigh the needs of the few," then do they accept the torture of children to get parents to talk? The employment, and trusting, of psychopaths? The using up and breaking of employees with a conscience?
 
Last edited:
Even when the guy is Col. Steven M. Kleinman, "who has served as the Pentagon's senior intelligence officer for special survival training."

Yes, even then. Unless he conducted a scientific study. Which there is no claim he did.

So I suppose he has a VERY well-informed opinion.

I'm sure it is. But it's still just an opinion. That may be as good as anything available, but to confuse what is available with what is possible is a mistake.

Do you still want to call his opinion an anecdote? Even when he's talking about a subject he is highly qualified in?

Well, yes, because it still fits.

The PDF is 372 pages long.
Without reading it in full, I can tell there has indeed been research into the art of "educing infomation".

Sure. But that doesn't mean there's been much research into the effectiveness of torture. Specific techniques studied include drugs, sleep and sensory deprivation, and hypnosis. I see no indication so far that physical pain as a coercive tool was investigated in any depth.

Please do. That would be helpful.

All right. Here's one:
Permitting torture has a cost. It creates the possibility of torturing innocent people, it also creates the possibility of torturing people for information when alternatives might work, and it may damage those tasked with performing it as well. These are things we should try to avoid, as even most advocates of torture will probably agree. The question is not so much whether torture is ever justified, but rather whether or not we should permit torture as policy. If we were to do so, there is no reason to allow its use in all cases, because the costs don't go down (and possibly go up) for less significant cases, whereas the benefits do. So we'd have to task someone with deciding when it is permissible to use torture and when it is not. Can we formulate laws which make such distinctions clear? Maybe, though I doubt that's a trivial problem. Who do we trust to make such decisions? Here we run into a problem for which I don't think there is a satisfactory answer. How can we train people to make that decision, and how can we trust their decisions? The risk is not simply that we make mistakes in individual cases, but that the process may become corrupted, because of the strong human compulsion on the part of those carrying out such programs to confirm (both to their own consciences and to others) that they have not made such mistakes. And damage to the process carries an incredibly high cost. Torture may work, but the benefit to be considered is not simply the information gained by torture, but the benefit which could not be gained by other methods which don't have torture's attendant costs. This may indeed be non-zero, but how big is it? If it is less than the cost, we clearly should not engage in torture. If it is greater, then perhaps we should. But we do not, and perhaps cannot, know before hand. If we permit torture and the benefit is greater than the cost, that's OK (though there may be disagreements about the cost and where exactly that break-even point is), but if the benefit is less than the cost, then we have made a mistake. So if we allow torture, we can't know ahead of time if we'll come out ahead. If we do not permit torture and the benefit would be less than the cost, that's good, but what about the converse case? What if we do not permit torture but the benefits would be greater? Well, in a ticking time-bomb type scenario, perhaps our interrogators will break the rules. In fact, we may even hope that they break the rules in such a scenario. So what's the point of the rules if we expect them to be violated under certain circumstances? Having the rules provides a threshold: unless the stakes are sufficiently high that the price of violating the rules is judged smaller than the benefit of breaking the rules, they will be followed. In such a case, we would be betting that the benefits come out low, but hedge against scenarios in which it comes out high. If we do that, then not permitting torture becomes the safer bet than allowing torture because we can't hedge our bets the other way if we permit torture.

Would you counter my other argument by asking, "what if sane people could inflict torture without feeling guilty? Would you support torture then?"

No. I would counter that by saying that if torture is or can be made effective, interrogators risk feeling guilty for not torturing if failure to get information leads to someone's death, and that the cost of an interrogator feeling guilty may be worth the benefit for certain sorts of information. Guilt on the part of interogators increases the cost of torturing, but it doesn't mean the benefit can't ever outweigh the cost.

Do you really believe that these people are talking without precise data to back up their opinions?

Yes, I do. In fact, I very much hope they don't have such data, because if they did, it would mean someone set out to conduct e methodoligical study of torture (as in, they tortured a bunch of people) in order to get that data, and I actually hope we weren't engaged in doing that.

The whole point is that if torture doesn't work, and you have only limited time and opportunity, then you risk loosing by engaging in torture.

You risk that with any particular interrogation technique.
 
But that doesn't mean there's been much research into the effectiveness of torture. Specific techniques studied include drugs, sleep and sensory deprivation, and hypnosis. I see no indication so far that physical pain as a coercive tool was investigated in any depth.

The pdf I linked to earlier has an article by Steven M. Kleinman, the same guy I quoted above. "KUBARK Counterintelligence Interrogation Review: Observations of an Interrogator"

KUBARK endorses some use of pain. The methods were based on research into resisting Communist methods of interrogation -- including "role playing".

So there is research for Kleinman to base his opinion on. And with that infomation -- from a source that endorses coercion -- the writers of the report in the WaPost article still think that:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/15/AR2007011501204.html?nav=rss_world

There is almost no scientific evidence to back up the U.S. intelligence community's use of controversial interrogation techniques in the fight against terrorism, and experts believe some painful and coercive approaches could hinder the ability to get good information, according to a new report from an intelligence advisory group.

That leaves with you with having to argue that Kleinman (and not only him) is over-reaching/mis-representing what his data tells him. Basically, you have to accuse him of being unprofessional. That he is stating things he has no good reason to believe, when he has access to research.

Or you accept he is right about the effects of isolation -- one of the methods used by the USA. And that such coercive techniques hinder intelligence gathering.

Incidentally,
On the use of pain, Kleinman says:

Returning to the
basic definition of interrogation noted at the beginning of this paper, it consists
of no more than obtaining needed information through responses to questions.
To achieve that objective, one can “pull” (i.e., elicit compliance) or “push” (i.e.,
coerce capitulation). While the former is likely to obtain information that can
often exceed the interrogator’s expressed scope of interest — as the source often
possesses both greater depth and breadth of knowledgeability than the interrogator
might assume — the latter will, in the best of circumstances, only obtain
information responding to questions directly asked. Even then the information
will often be limited to the minimum necessary to satisfy the interrogator.

So, even at best, using coercive techniques gets you less info. You have to hope that you asked the right questions. You're not really getting co-operation.

Permitting torture has a cost.
...[risk of] torturing innocent people
...alternatives might work
...may damage those tasked with performing it


...should we permit torture as policy?
[how do we decide when the benefits are greater than the costs]
[can we formulate the laws that define circumstances allowing torture]
...Who do we trust to make such decisions?
...How can we train people to make that decision,
...the process may become corrupted,

...we do not, and perhaps cannot, know before hand [which method of interrogation will cost least, benefit most]

Thanks.
I didn't understand the bit about hedging bets.

Guilt on the part of interogators increases the cost of torturing, but it doesn't mean the benefit can't ever outweigh the cost.

See, we're back to benefit. We're back to whether torture works.

Yes, I do. In fact, I very much hope they don't have such data, because if they did, it would mean someone set out to conduct e methodoligical study of torture (as in, they tortured a bunch of people) in order to get that data, and I actually hope we weren't engaged in doing that.

The data you hope no-one has seems to be the basis of KUBARK. And the experts who have studied KUBARK think that coercive techniques used by the USA may hinder the ability of interrogators to get good infomation.
 
That leaves with you with having to argue that Kleinman (and not only him) is over-reaching/mis-representing what his data tells him. Basically, you have to accuse him of being unprofessional.

Not so. He never claimed that this was based on anything more than personal experience. That's the most he has available, but since that's the most anyone has available, I have no problem with him voicing an opinion based on that. Nor do I have a problem with people considering that opinion useful for forming their own. I'm just not willing to portray that opinion as being something more than it is. It is an expert opinion, but that's still a form of opinion.

So, even at best, using coercive techniques gets you less info.

Well, no. "experts believe some painful and coercive approaches could hinder the ability to get good information". That KUBARK report notes specifically that if you resort to torture late in the interrogation process, the subject is likely to conclude you're getting desperate, and that may strengthen their resistance. In other words, it's possible (and we know at least one way) to be counterproductive with torture. That says nothing about whether or not there are any ways to be productive.

See, we're back to benefit. We're back to whether torture works.

Well, yes. Which is why a good argument against torture I think must allow for the possibility that it can work.

The data you hope no-one has seems to be the basis of KUBARK.

Not really. There's VERY little information about torture in KUBARK, and that was pretty much just unsourced conclusions. They are plausible and likely conclusions, but I didn't see any evidence that they were scientifically obtained.

And the experts who have studied KUBARK think that coercive techniques used by the USA may hinder the ability of interrogators to get good infomation.

But that only speaks to particular techniques. You can argue against particular techniques by saying they're ineffective fairly easily. But torture isn't a specific technique, it's a gigantic category. So if you want to argue against anything falling under that category, relying on arguments about efficacy isn't very useful.
 
You realize the problem with this, don't you? You're basically saying that we should do scientifically controlled studies using torture to test its efficacy - after all, how else to prove that it doesn't work?

There is a long history of torture to study. Also, we could do scientific analysis of the torture that the Bush administration currently allows.

- certainly no evidence to that effect has been produced by opponents of torture.

The issue is torture, not other forms of interrogation.

If torture can be shown or made to be effective, would you still have any argument against it? If so, then why not rely upon that argument now?

It would certainly give me more to think about. Right now, the fact that it's inhumane AND it doesn't seem to work makes me think that it should never be used, ever.
 
There is a long history of torture to study.

Sure - as history. But history doesn't make good science.

Also, we could do scientific analysis of the torture that the Bush administration currently allows.

We could - but not everyone agrees that currently allowed practices constitute torture, and more importantly, that still only addresses the effectiveness of those particular techniques, which cannot prove that torture categorically doesn't work.
 
You fail to understand that the onus is upon those who advocate the use of torture to provide evidence that it works.

Do you advocate torture, Ziggy? How do you feel about innocent people being tortured?

Also, waterboarding is torture, no matter how hard Republicans try to convince people it's not.
 
Not so. He never claimed that this was based on anything more than personal experience.

He has more than personal experience. He has the experience of other interrogators, as catalogued but the CIA. KUBARK itself was the result, not of direct experiments into what works, but of role-playing and seeking resistance to Communist techniques of interrogation.

Having found what didn't work, the writers of KUBARK tried to come up with alternatives that might work. What happened in research terms after that, I don't know.

Unrelated to KUBARK, but still involving the CIA, is this:
http://www.berkeleydaily.org/text/article.cfm?issue=05-18-04&storyID=18888

When the Shah of Iran was deposed in 1979, the files of his much-feared CIA-trained intelligence service, SAVAK, were opened to journalists. The noted Egyptian reporter Mohammed Heikal wrote that he was shown a film of a female prisoner being stripped naked, who screamed and broke down as her nipples were burned with a lighted cigarette.

It was explained that this was a training film for other torturers. The film, Heikal wrote, was also given to the CIA, which then made copies for use by the intelligence services of Taiwan, the Philippines and Indonesia.

An Indonesian unit, Kopassus, which received special U.S. Army training in the United States, later practiced similar torture techniques in East Timor. They too made a habit of photographing their torture sessions, which became an important factor in inducing Congress to vote against further U.S. aid and training to the unit. (Ironically, former Kopassus commander Prabowo Subianto, once the Pentagon’s special favorite, was later denied a U.S. visa, under the provisions of the U.N. Convention Against Torture.)

Which clearly indicates that tortue was documented. How scientifically this was arranged, I don't know. But there is clearly data used as a basis of training.

History is not science, but historical data can be analysed objectively and within a scientific framework. The experts take a look at the past and say what they say.

Well, no. "experts believe some painful and coercive approaches could hinder the ability to get good information". [...] That says nothing about whether or not there are any ways to be productive.

It does say that effective techniques are not as easy to find as some seem to think. As elusive as perpetual motion, perhaps?

But that only speaks to particular techniques. You can argue against particular techniques by saying they're ineffective fairly easily. But torture isn't a specific technique, it's a gigantic category. So if you want to argue against anything falling under that category, relying on arguments about efficacy isn't very useful.

How exhaustive do we need the search to be?


I accept what you say about needing a bigger argument, rather than limiting it to efficacy. But the experts say there is no scientific reason to suppose it works, and that is a huge hole in the arguments of those that propose torture.
 
Last edited:
You can argue that Sylvia Brown is not psychic, but that doesn't speak about psychics having powers in general.
 
You fail to understand that the onus is upon those who advocate the use of torture to provide evidence that it works.

Maybe it should be, but if you want to keep it from being used, that simply isn't enough. Just like the onus should be on homeopathy to prove it works, but the fact that proof isn't forthcoming doesn't stop it from being used. Welcome to the real world.

Do you advocate torture, Ziggy?

Take a guess. Have I actually advocated torture anywhere within this thread? Hell, anywhere on this board?

How do you feel about innocent people being tortured?

It's a bad thing, obviously. It's also a bad thing if innocent people are sentenced to jail time too. Doesn't mean I want to get rid of jail sentences because we can't ensure no innocent people ever get sentenced. The fact that innocents might get tortured is a cost of torturing, and should be a consideration, certainly. But the existence of a cost does not in and of itself mean that we cannot or should not engage in it. On its own, this argument is nothing more than an appeal to emotion, and that's simply not good enough.
 
Sorry I have little time to read this thread so forgive me if some of this has been posted. I most certainly want to look at the torture issue including what Clinton was responsible for. However, I see only one thing under Clinton which shouldn't have been done and that was sending people to countries which we may not have publicly extradicted them to had they been arrested in the US on charges brought by other countries.

Clinton's Secret Renditions by Michael Scheuer
Mr. SCHEUER: All right. The CIA's Rendition Program began in late summer, 1995. I authored it and then ran and managed it against al-Qaeda leaders and other Sunni Islamists from August, 1995, until June, 1999.

There were only two goals for the program: First, to take men off the street who were planning or had been involved in attacks on the United States or its allies; second, to seize hard copy or electronic documents in their possession when arrested. Americans were never expected to read those, and they could provide options for follow-on operations....

...President Clinton and his national security team directed the CIA to take each captured al-Qaeda leader to the country which had an outstanding legal process for him....
He goes on to say Clinton was informed the countries these guys were turned over to might torture them.

After 9/11 Bush changed the renditions to include people not already under indictment in other countries, kept them in US custody, and began interrogations which Clinton had not done. Before Bush changed the program, Scheuer says:
First, from its start until today, the program was focused on senior al-Qaeda leaders and not aimed at the rank-and-file members. With only limited manpower to conduct the Rendition Program, CIA wanted to inflict as much damage on al-Qaeda as possible and therefore focused on senior leaders, financiers, terrorist operators, field commanders, strategists and logisticians.

Second, to the best of my knowledge, not a single target of rendition has ever been kidnapped by CIA officers. The claims to the contrary by the Swedish Government regarding Mr. Aghiza and his associate and those by the Italian Government regarding Abu Omar are either misstatements or lies by those governments.
I'm not sure how these guys were taken if not kidnapped by the CIA but I'm sure one could find out what that meant with a little research.

More on the program under Clinton from Common Dreams:
Not long ago, Scheuer, who lives in northern Virginia, spoke openly for the first time about how he and several other top C.I.A. officials set up the program, in the mid-nineties. “It was begun in desperation, ” he told me. At the time, he was the head of the C.I.A.’s Islamic-militant unit, whose job was to “detect, disrupt, and dismantle” terrorist operations. His unit spent much of 1996 studying how Al Qaeda operated; by the next year, Scheuer said, its mission was to try to capture bin Laden and his associates. He recalled, “We went to the White House”—which was then occupied by the Clinton Administration—“and they said, ‘Do it.’” He added that Richard Clarke, who was in charge of counter-terrorism for the National Security Council, offered no advice. “He told me, ‘Figure it out by yourselves,’” Scheuer said. (Clarke did not respond to a request for comment.)..
There is a lot more of Scheuer's description of the program on the CommonDreams source. I haven't read it all yet but I'll keep checking on this until I feel sufficiently informed.

So far, I see no justification for the tired claim, "Clinton did it too." Bush changed an existing program, one I might add isn't mentioned when the Bushies are trying to blame Clinton for, "swatting flies".
 
Last edited:
History is not science, but historical data can be analysed objectively and within a scientific framework. The experts take a look at the past and say what they say.

One of the problems with looking at historical uses of torture is that it's often not done for purposes we'd be interested in using it for, if we were to do it. Torture has traditionally been used primarily by authoritarian regimes, and its purpose has often been to get propaganda confessions (North Vietnamese, for example - they didn't care whether confessions were fake, so they made no effort to ensure that they were real), to scare the populace at large, and even to aclimatize followers to committing acts of brutality (the better to prepare them to suppress the population). These are different goals than getting reliable information, and if the torture techniques which were used for these goals don't work well for getting reliable information, that's not surprising, nor is it very indicative of its potential.
 
Maybe it should be, but if you want to keep it from being used, that simply isn't enough. Just like the onus should be on homeopathy to prove it works, but the fact that proof isn't forthcoming doesn't stop it from being used. Welcome to the real world.

Yes, in the real world, logic and reason seem to not apply to woo ideas like homeopathy and torture. It is enough to tell people there is no evidence to support these methods, but it isn't. No amount of evidence against such practices will deter these people, evidence doesn't play a role in their decisions.

Take a guess

Based on your apologetics defending torture, I'd say yes. However, I'd like your answer instead of guessing.

It's a bad thing, obviously. It's also a bad thing if innocent people are sentenced to jail time too. Doesn't mean I want to get rid of jail sentences because we can't ensure no innocent people ever get sentenced. The fact that innocents might get tortured is a cost of torturing, and should be a consideration, certainly. But the existence of a cost does not in and of itself mean that we cannot or should not engage in it. On its own, this argument is nothing more than an appeal to emotion, and that's simply not good enough.

The fact that innocents might get tortured is a consideration, so is the fact that it hasn't been shown to work. Other considerations is abuse of people who haven't been proven to be guilty or not. These people being tortured haven't had due process, and since torture is a form of punishment that's also another strike against torture. Is there ANY reason to think torture could even work? Is there any reason to think it's ok to use?

So far, I haven't heard any good reason to use torture on anyone, except in the bedroom.
 
Based on your apologetics defending torture, I'd say yes. However, I'd like your answer instead of guessing.

You guessed wrong. I am not in favor of torture. But I do not accept arguments solely because they provide the answer I would like either. If it's a bad argument, I won't support it. And you're providing bad arguments.

These people being tortured haven't had due process,

Surely you're not in favor of torturing people who have been convicted at trial, are you? If not, then this is a red herring. Torture could be implemented under conditions where considerable "due process" (including possibly even more "process" than anyone gets right now), so this objection cannot be a categorical objection to torture. As I said, I'm not going to accept bad arguments.

and since torture is a form of punishment that's also another strike against torture.

Well, no. It can be used as punishment, but that is not enough. Being arrested is unpleasant. Being put in jail is unpleasant. Those could be considered "punishment" as well, and they get applied to people who have not been convicted of anything. They get applied to people who are innocent, too. Those are concerns for limiting its applications, but that argument simply doesn't lead to the conclusion that we should categorically prohibit it.
 
Man, all of this argument could be easily avoided.

Ziggurat, you do not like torture. You do not think that torture should be legal. You think that, if evidence is provided that torture can actually be an effective way of gathering information, that it should still be illegal. That it being an ineffective method of gathering information is, in itself, NOT the reason why you abhor torture. Do I have your position correct?
 
You guessed wrong. I am not in favor of torture. But I do not accept arguments solely because they provide the answer I would like either. If it's a bad argument, I won't support it. And you're providing bad arguments.

What bad arguments? All of my arguments have been well reasoned, valid and are logical.

Surely you're not in favor of torturing people who have been convicted at trial, are you?

Probably not, it's another thing to consider though, the torture of innocent people.

If not, then this is a red herring.

Wrong, it's a very valid point. People should not be tortured at all, but torturing people who haven't been convicted is even more wrong.

Torture could be implemented under conditions where considerable "due process" (including possibly even more "process" than anyone gets right now), so this objection cannot be a categorical objection to torture. As I said, I'm not going to accept bad arguments.

Again, it's not a bad argument just because you think it is.

Well, no. It can be used as punishment, but that is not enough. Being arrested is unpleasant. Being put in jail is unpleasant. Those could be considered "punishment" as well, and they get applied to people who have not been convicted of anything.

But being arrested and jailed is not abuse, torture is. It's strange, but you're saying that I have bad arguments when yours are very fallacious. Comparing torture to being detained is a very poor analogy and a red herring.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom