Undesired Walrus
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2007
- Messages
- 11,691
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?
Do you think the techniques to be used on bad guys like KSM who beheadded journalist Daniel Pearl shouldn't be somewhat harsh?
My law says that if you don't win, then your laws aren't worth spittle.
George Washington had just captured ~1,000 British soldiers in the Battle of Trenton.The British had already committed atrocities against Americans, including torture. As David Hackett Fischer describes in his Pulitzer Prize winning book, Washington's Crossing, thousands of American prisoners of war were “treated with extreme cruelty by British captors.” There are accounts of injured soldiers who surrendered being murdered instead of quartered, countless Americans dying in prison hulks in New York harbor, starvation and other acts of inhumanity perpetrated against Americans confined to churches in New York City.
(emphasis mine)... You can imagine, the light of our ideals shone dimly in those early dark days, years from an end to the conflict, years before our improbable triumph and the birth of our democracy. General Washington was not that far from where the Continental Congress had met and signed the Declaration of Independence. But it is easy to imagine how far that must have seemed. General Washington announced a decision unique in human history, sending the following order for handling prisoners.
Treat them with humanity, and Let them have no reason to Complain of our Copying the brutal example of the British army in their Treatment of our unfortunate brethren.
Therefore, George Washington, our commander-in-chief before he was our President, laid down the indelible marker of our nation’s values even as we were struggling as a nation – and his courageous act reminds us that America was born out of faith in certain basic principles.
That was the obvious attempt as soon as Gitmo was stood up. Why the people captured in Afghanistan weren't held in field facilities there remains a mystery to me. He who lives by the loophole, dies by the loophole.Mistreatment and torture differ only in degree. Trying to find a difference between them is arbitrary and a waste of time. Abuse of prisoners violates the spirit and the intent of our laws. The current administration seems bent on playing rhetoric games trying to find loopholes.
Question: is your opinion equal to the force of law?Non-mistreatment includes securing the prisoners in a cell or a yard, feeding them, housing them, keeping them out of mischief, and thats about it.
Your all or nothing position is noted, even though you resort to vague descriptives in an attempt to juxtapose blatant abuse with other matters. There was a rock band called "Cheap Trick." Perhaps you were a fan?Whacking prisoners in the head, waterboarding, handcuffing naked, sleep deprivation, generally causing misery - these are abuse. Whether this is called mistreatment or torture or marklar makes no god damn difference.
In vino veritas, however, most Muslims don't care to drink alcohol, and the True Believer sort are a low bet to play that game with.Another embarrassment to the country, I can't wait until that idiot is out of office. Who is in charge of the torture program anyway? Still using pliers and water boarding, is this the 20th century?The best way to get information out of a person is through the use of psychoactive drugs. I'm sure the military could find something better but cocaine would probably work. Make a person high enough and they will start to tell you everything you could want to know.
I refer you to the Department of the Army, Field Manuals, MP branch, treatment of detainees, and to counter intelligence Field Manuals.So, Darth Rotor, what kinds of treatments to prisoners in order to get information are acceptable in your opinion?
Not even close. The difference between 2004 and now is considerably better, but this new organization is hardly the Turkish Army, and given the culture it comes from, will take (at a conservative guess) a generation to change. Point of reference? Army in El Salvador, 1980 to present.Naturally you'd look at the fact we've made no progress training the Iraqi army and blame it on them being whooses.
1 - Question: is your opinion equal to the force of law?
2 - Your all or nothing position is noted, even though you resort to vague descriptives in an attempt to juxtapose blatant abuse with other matters. There was a rock band called "Cheap Trick." Perhaps you were a fan?
There is nothing more relevant to the discussion than scientific evidence to support your claim that torture actually works to produce reliable information. If you can't prove that torture even has a chance to produce important information reliably, then every single argument of yours is pointless. Simply put, if torture doesn't work, there is no point in discussing the morality of when it should be used or not, because if it doesn't work, it is immoral to use EVER.
Ah, yes, because we don't want to subject people to torture to get dubious information that, scientifically speaking, is just as likely to be inaccurate as it is to be accurate, we "don't want to fight for our own".
I bet you laughed at the Geneva Convention, right?
No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions. It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.
What fantasy world do you live in? Where do you get this "doesn't work" stuff?
But when people like you make these absolutes that "it doesn't work", I think you must have led very sheltered lives to think you would never reveal anything if threatened with even just something unpleasant.
Most of these terrorists are just semi literate punks. Are you seriously going to tell me that they all become supermen once captured, with an undying love for their bosses, and they will never ever reveal where the bomb factory is if asked under duress?
Where does your morality come from, that it would rather ignore a possible source of information that will continue to kill your own, rather than risk harming the psyche of the enemy who wants to kill you?
I thank the atheist god that I don't have to rely on primitive philosophers like that for my defense.
No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions. It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.
It only takes one to play the Geneva Conventions game. If we play it, we get support from the world community and we make fewer recruits for the opposition.
Oops - too late.
There are two types of people in the world:
Those that stand by their word and honor their commitments, those that will screw over anybody in their way, and those that have not yet decided.
Ok - 3 types.
In the short run, the screw-overs have an advantage. In the long run I think that the screw-overs will ruin it for the rest of us.
So, your basic philosophy is that if the other nation doesn't play be the rules, we shouldn't either? Is that all you see them as, rules? I personally think torture is vile, disgusting, inhumane and most of all, unreliable. If you could simply show me scientific evidence that torture has a good success rate for producing reliable information, I might entertain your philosophical arguments as to when we should disregard humanity and use it. Until then, your arguments are just piss in the wind.
Also, since the time the Geneva conventions were authored, what's changed that has made torture acceptable to you?
Give me a break. You are now in the camp that thinks if we act nice and roll over we make friends?
Where do you get this crap that people hate us (not just us either, in case you haven't paid attention) because we are not nice enough?
I'm sure you've heard about walking softly with a big stick?
In the long run the winners will either screw it over for all, or not, depending on who the winner is.
As I already explained to one of your like thinkers, using the game analogy, only fools play by rules that that the other players don't. Hell, an elementary school child understands that.
We have this mantra repeated ad nauseam that if you twist someone's arm it's torture, and all terrorist murderers are noble people that would rather die than rat on their fellow scum.
All these "torture" hangups that ignore the fact that it doesn't have to involve pliers and scalpels, and with so little imagination.
Presumably you think you couldn't be forced to reveal anything you didn't want to, under any circumstance (go on, let your imagination go).
Tell you what...kidnap one of my children, then let me catch you. Want to bet you won't tell me where they are? Would that be scientific?
Humanity is not what you define it to be in your musings, it is what you presumably know but don't like to accept. There are many directions it can go, some the way you daydream about, and some the other way, but your directions don't matter squat if you lose.
So your assumption is that all interrogators are geniuses that can't be fooled?That's another very limited statement, that might as well be rephrased as "..scientifically speaking if the interrogator is as stupid or ignorant as the interrogated, then anything gained is likely to be useless." Duhh. But that is the logic you base your fine morals on.
So essentially, there is no Geneva Convention if you don't fight on part of a nation? That then you're given the ability to go around doing as you will to anyone you happen to not like?No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions.
Well hell yeah, I love the Geneva Convention. A good set of guidelines, and I'll wait until someone shows differently.It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.