Torture memo...OMG

My law says that if you don't win, then your laws aren't worth spittle.

2 points:
1 - Advocating torture is not helping to win. Every halfway reputable report of our mistreatment of prisoners sends recruits to our opposition.

2 - You don't get to have your own laws.
 
Think Senator Clinton is not going to make a good president? Listen to (or read) her speech from September of 2006 on the issue of torture of prisoners. She reminded us of the ideals this nation was founded on. Those are the same ideals I grew up believing made our country different. Those ideals made us American and America stood for greatness.

The British had been extremely brutal to all "insurgents" fighting for independence in America.
The British had already committed atrocities against Americans, including torture. As David Hackett Fischer describes in his Pulitzer Prize winning book, Washington's Crossing, thousands of American prisoners of war were “treated with extreme cruelty by British captors.” There are accounts of injured soldiers who surrendered being murdered instead of quartered, countless Americans dying in prison hulks in New York harbor, starvation and other acts of inhumanity perpetrated against Americans confined to churches in New York City.
George Washington had just captured ~1,000 British soldiers in the Battle of Trenton.
... You can imagine, the light of our ideals shone dimly in those early dark days, years from an end to the conflict, years before our improbable triumph and the birth of our democracy. General Washington was not that far from where the Continental Congress had met and signed the Declaration of Independence. But it is easy to imagine how far that must have seemed. General Washington announced a decision unique in human history, sending the following order for handling prisoners.

Treat them with humanity, and Let them have no reason to Complain of our Copying the brutal example of the British army in their Treatment of our unfortunate brethren.

Therefore, George Washington, our commander-in-chief before he was our President, laid down the indelible marker of our nation’s values even as we were struggling as a nation – and his courageous act reminds us that America was born out of faith in certain basic principles.
(emphasis mine)

Granted believing one's country is unique among the world and greater than any other is idealistic. But I still hold to those ideals. And it has always seemed to me that we won wars and had our military strength, not just from hardware and explosives, but because the people we would be against admired us even as their leaders tried to defeat us.

Not having that uniqueness and greatness which depends almost entirely on those idealistic goals and values is what led to our defeat in Vietnam, and it is what made the Iraq war not go the way Bush and the NeoCons imagined it unfolding. They don't get it. Many Americans don't get it.

Senator Clinton gets it.
 
Mistreatment and torture differ only in degree. Trying to find a difference between them is arbitrary and a waste of time. Abuse of prisoners violates the spirit and the intent of our laws. The current administration seems bent on playing rhetoric games trying to find loopholes.
That was the obvious attempt as soon as Gitmo was stood up. Why the people captured in Afghanistan weren't held in field facilities there remains a mystery to me. He who lives by the loophole, dies by the loophole.
Non-mistreatment includes securing the prisoners in a cell or a yard, feeding them, housing them, keeping them out of mischief, and thats about it.
Question: is your opinion equal to the force of law?
Whacking prisoners in the head, waterboarding, handcuffing naked, sleep deprivation, generally causing misery - these are abuse. Whether this is called mistreatment or torture or marklar makes no god damn difference.
Your all or nothing position is noted, even though you resort to vague descriptives in an attempt to juxtapose blatant abuse with other matters. There was a rock band called "Cheap Trick." Perhaps you were a fan?

ETA: Your post 171 was a fine one.

Related note: A few months back, Atlantic Monthly did a piece on how, over the period of some months, an interrogation unit in Iraq patiently coaxed out critical info on Al Zarqawi without using any of the above, albeit the key sources in question were kept in austere prisons. The key problem with the policy from the get go was the lack of patience, the belief that quick exploitation is a routinely successful interrogation scenario.

In LTC West's case, yes it was, but it got him fired, and all he did was scare the crap out of someone. In the case of dealing with True Believers (most Taliban operatives, and most Al Q players) the "quick" isn't even an option. A good example of how it isn't is the trio in Gitmo who hanged themselves/suicided in defiance (right out of Stockdale's book) a while back.

DR
 
Last edited:
So, Darth Rotor, what kinds of treatments to prisoners in order to get information are acceptable in your opinion?
 
Another embarrassment to the country, I can't wait until that idiot is out of office. Who is in charge of the torture program anyway? Still using pliers and water boarding, is this the 20th century?The best way to get information out of a person is through the use of psychoactive drugs. I'm sure the military could find something better but cocaine would probably work. Make a person high enough and they will start to tell you everything you could want to know.
In vino veritas, however, most Muslims don't care to drink alcohol, and the True Believer sort are a low bet to play that game with.

DR
 
So, Darth Rotor, what kinds of treatments to prisoners in order to get information are acceptable in your opinion?
I refer you to the Department of the Army, Field Manuals, MP branch, treatment of detainees, and to counter intelligence Field Manuals.

These have the force of administrative law. They are also subject to Congressional oversight, and review, and revision.

Enjoy.

I have been subject to sleep deprivation (it will absolutely screw your brain, when applied with other methods by someone who knows what he/she is doing) and know that a couple of decades ago, water boarding was routinely used as a training method on our people.

Caveat: both of these were in a training environment, with medical supervision, so a comparison to "you don't know when you are ever getting out of this" to "this crap will end in XXXX days" puts the subject is significantly different frames of mind. Suckage is still suckage.

DR
 
Naturally you'd look at the fact we've made no progress training the Iraqi army and blame it on them being whooses.
Not even close. The difference between 2004 and now is considerably better, but this new organization is hardly the Turkish Army, and given the culture it comes from, will take (at a conservative guess) a generation to change. Point of reference? Army in El Salvador, 1980 to present.

That's a generation of work.

Whoever tried to sell the soap (particularly when one sees how many Iraqi vets were blackballed by the "Out Damned Ba'athist" Policy) that any transformation would be quick was, well, selling soap. Heck, the transformation of the US military from the conscription era to the all volunteer force was hardly overnight, how could a major transformation take any less time? (For some commentary on recent efforts not in Iraq, see Robert Kaplan's pieces on Algerian and Niger militaries in his second volume of Imperial Grunts, called Hog Pilots and Blue Water Grunts. )

DR
 
Numbered for my convenience:
1 - Question: is your opinion equal to the force of law?

2 - Your all or nothing position is noted, even though you resort to vague descriptives in an attempt to juxtapose blatant abuse with other matters. There was a rock band called "Cheap Trick." Perhaps you were a fan?

1 - Of course not. However, I feel that my opinion is consistent with the intent of the US Constitution and the Geneva Conventions.

2 - What is wrong with all or nothing? What "other matters"? I disagree with any abuse of prisoners, not just the blatant kind.

PS: Cheap Trick is still around, and I was not a fan.
Too bad there is not a band called "Cheap Shot", but that probably wouldn't be funny either.
 
Sleep deprivation.. maybe. However, if it's done to the point where symptoms of insanity begin, I'd call that torture for sure. Waterboarding is torture. Just because these methods were used as "training" doesn't make it morally more correct. Is pepper spraying prisoners for information torture? I've seen marine combat training involve sparring with pepper spray in their face. I would say yes, it's still torture.

Training our soldiers to be more resilient to certain forms of torture doesn't justify using those same methods on others.
 
There is nothing more relevant to the discussion than scientific evidence to support your claim that torture actually works to produce reliable information. If you can't prove that torture even has a chance to produce important information reliably, then every single argument of yours is pointless. Simply put, if torture doesn't work, there is no point in discussing the morality of when it should be used or not, because if it doesn't work, it is immoral to use EVER.

What fantasy world do you live in? Where do you get this "doesn't work" stuff?

Clearly it is no magic solution. It is not mind reading, and the interrogator stands a good chance of coming to believe that it is, if the limitations are not understood or the techniques are misused or stupid questions are asked, or the wrong people are interrogated, and so on.

But when people like you make these absolutes that "it doesn't work", I think you must have led very sheltered lives to think you would never reveal anything if threatened with even just something unpleasant.

Most of these terrorists are just semi literate punks. Are you seriously going to tell me that they all become supermen once captured, with an undying love for their bosses, and they will never ever reveal where the bomb factory is if asked under duress?

Where does your morality come from, that it would rather ignore a possible source of information that will continue to kill your own, rather than risk harming the psyche of the enemy who wants to kill you?

I thank the atheist god that I don't have to rely on primitive philosophers like that for my defense.
 
Ah, yes, because we don't want to subject people to torture to get dubious information that, scientifically speaking, is just as likely to be inaccurate as it is to be accurate, we "don't want to fight for our own".

:rolleyes:

I bet you laughed at the Geneva Convention, right?

That's another very limited statement, that might as well be rephrased as "..scientifically speaking if the interrogator is as stupid or ignorant as the interrogated, then anything gained is likely to be useless." Duhh. But that is the logic you base your fine morals on.

No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions. It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.
 
No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions. It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.

And quaint to others, Alberto Jr.

It only takes one to play the Geneva Conventions game. If we play it, we get support from the world community and we make fewer recruits for the opposition.
Oops - too late.

There are two types of people in the world:
Those that stand by their word and honor their commitments, those that will screw over anybody in their way, and those that have not yet decided.
Ok - 3 types.
In the short run, the screw-overs have an advantage. In the long run I think that the screw-overs will ruin it for the rest of us.
 
What fantasy world do you live in? Where do you get this "doesn't work" stuff?

It hasn't been established by any science that torture works. Until you then, the burden is upon you to prove that it does. Since it's not known to work reliably, then it is definitely immoral to use to garner information. In what fantasy world do you come from where torture works to produce reliable information? Maybe you've watched too many "tough cop" movies.

But when people like you make these absolutes that "it doesn't work", I think you must have led very sheltered lives to think you would never reveal anything if threatened with even just something unpleasant.

The problem is, it hasn't been established to work at all. Feel free to prove me wrong with science.

Most of these terrorists are just semi literate punks. Are you seriously going to tell me that they all become supermen once captured, with an undying love for their bosses, and they will never ever reveal where the bomb factory is if asked under duress?

We don't know if these people are terrorists or not. A person who has no idea where "the bomb" is will likely come up with a believable lie just to get the torture to stop. Let's say the tortured were terrorist, do you think that if they are willing to kill themselves for their cause that torture would necessarily work at all? What's to stop them from telling lies about where the bomb is? All of your philosophical arguments about how torture "has to" work sometimes doesn't trump the fact that you have NO SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE to support your claim.

Where does your morality come from, that it would rather ignore a possible source of information that will continue to kill your own, rather than risk harming the psyche of the enemy who wants to kill you?

My morality comes from treating humans as human. People can be interrogated without torture. For some reason, police in the USA seem to do well interrogating people without torturing people. Is there something special about brown-skinned Islamic people that makes them impervious to the same interrogation methods?

Where does your morality come from? Would you torture one person to save the life of a few thousand? I'm guessing you would. However, that hypothetical is nonsense, it's as absurd as saying "would you crush a live infants skull to save a few thousand people?" You have absolutely no scientific basis to say that torture can save lives.

I thank the atheist god that I don't have to rely on primitive philosophers like that for my defense.

Your god has no bearing on the conversation. Your philosophy means nothing without the scientific evidence to support your premise.
 
No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions. It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.

So, your basic philosophy is that if the other nation doesn't play be the rules, we shouldn't either? Is that all you see them as, rules? I personally think torture is vile, disgusting, inhumane and most of all, unreliable. If you could simply show me scientific evidence that torture has a good success rate for producing reliable information, I might entertain your philosophical arguments as to when we should disregard humanity and use it. Until then, your arguments are just piss in the wind.

Also, since the time the Geneva conventions were authored, what's changed that has made torture acceptable to you?
 
It only takes one to play the Geneva Conventions game. If we play it, we get support from the world community and we make fewer recruits for the opposition.
Oops - too late.

Give me a break. You are now in the camp that thinks if we act nice and roll over we make friends? Where do you get this crap that people hate us (not just us either, in case you haven't paid attention) because we are not nice enough?

There are two types of people in the world:
Those that stand by their word and honor their commitments, those that will screw over anybody in their way, and those that have not yet decided.

Silly commentary. We don't screw over anybody in our way, unless they are trying the same. We don't honor commitments to anyone who doesn't honor theirs. Only a fool pretends that. We don't screw over over those who haven't decided, but we should tell them that they don't count for much if they don't have any conviction, and we will wait to see what it is. I'm sure you've heard about walking softly with a big stick?

Ok - 3 types.
In the short run, the screw-overs have an advantage. In the long run I think that the screw-overs will ruin it for the rest of us.

In the long run the winners will either screw it over for all, or not, depending on who the winner is.
 
So, your basic philosophy is that if the other nation doesn't play be the rules, we shouldn't either? Is that all you see them as, rules? I personally think torture is vile, disgusting, inhumane and most of all, unreliable. If you could simply show me scientific evidence that torture has a good success rate for producing reliable information, I might entertain your philosophical arguments as to when we should disregard humanity and use it. Until then, your arguments are just piss in the wind.

Also, since the time the Geneva conventions were authored, what's changed that has made torture acceptable to you?

Amazing repetition here, but perhaps one day I'll get it closer to understandable.

As I already explained to one of your like thinkers, using the game analogy, only fools play by rules that that the other players don't. Hell, an elementary school child understands that.

We have this mantra repeated ad nauseam that if you twist someone's arm it's torture, and all terrorist murderers are noble people that would rather die than rat on their fellow scum.

All these "torture" hangups that ignore the fact that it doesn't have to involve pliers and scalpels, and with so little imagination. Presumably you think you couldn't be forced to reveal anything you didn't want to, under any circumstance (go on, let your imagination go). Well I doubt that I could, but then I'm not such a brave person as you, in imagination at least. What can I say? Tell you what...kidnap one of my children, then let me catch you. Want to bet you won't tell me where they are? Would that be scientific?

Humanity is not what you define it to be in your musings, it is what you presumably know but don't like to accept. There are many directions it can go, some the way you daydream about, and some the other way, but your directions don't matter squat if you lose.
 
Give me a break. You are now in the camp that thinks if we act nice and roll over we make friends?

The problem is, if we ignore the conventions and torture people, we risk losing our allies. If we act according to the conventions, we might actually gain more allies.

Where do you get this crap that people hate us (not just us either, in case you haven't paid attention) because we are not nice enough?

Public opinion from other countries. The Canadians really don't like the torture policies of the Bush admin, then again, neither do a great number of USA citizens.

I'm sure you've heard about walking softly with a big stick?

I have heard this, but what does this have to do with torture? The big stick is for self-defense, torture is not.

In the long run the winners will either screw it over for all, or not, depending on who the winner is.

If we use torture for our own ends, then we're all losers. If torture works for terrorists, then why not USA citizens? We could torture anyone accused of a crime to get a confession.....


Have you ever even considered that innocent people are being tortured? What consolations do you have for those people? "Sorry we tortured you, but we had to make sure you weren't guilty."
 
As I already explained to one of your like thinkers, using the game analogy, only fools play by rules that that the other players don't. Hell, an elementary school child understands that.

But it's not a game. These aren't just rules, they are conventions of morality. We're not talking about winning a chess game, we're talking about human lives.

We have this mantra repeated ad nauseam that if you twist someone's arm it's torture, and all terrorist murderers are noble people that would rather die than rat on their fellow scum.

That's not the claim at all. The fact is that the information gathered from torture hasn't been proven reliable at all. I'm still waiting for scientific evidence from you that shows that torture actually works. Have any? What about torturing innocent people? Do you have no sympathy for innocent people who happen to have been in the wrong place at the wrong time?

All these "torture" hangups that ignore the fact that it doesn't have to involve pliers and scalpels, and with so little imagination.

Oh, I can think of many, many ways to torture people that doesn't leave marks or cause any permanent physical damage. There are psychological torture methods and drug induced methods as well. They are all immoral.

Presumably you think you couldn't be forced to reveal anything you didn't want to, under any circumstance (go on, let your imagination go).

I may or may not. However, if I was innocent or ignorant and tortured to reveal information, I'm pretty sure I'd lie and make up some story just to stop the torture. If an ignorant person would do this, why wouldn't a knowledgeable person do the same?

Tell you what...kidnap one of my children, then let me catch you. Want to bet you won't tell me where they are? Would that be scientific?

No, it would not. I think we've found your failing here. You have absolutely no idea of what good scientific method is. Then again, maybe you do and you are coming up with excuses as to why there is no science to support your claims.

Humanity is not what you define it to be in your musings, it is what you presumably know but don't like to accept. There are many directions it can go, some the way you daydream about, and some the other way, but your directions don't matter squat if you lose.

In other words, you really don't care about people being tortured as long as the government can convince you that you're safer for it. Gotcha.
 
That's another very limited statement, that might as well be rephrased as "..scientifically speaking if the interrogator is as stupid or ignorant as the interrogated, then anything gained is likely to be useless." Duhh. But that is the logic you base your fine morals on.
So your assumption is that all interrogators are geniuses that can't be fooled?

Evidence? That's something you're HEAVILY lacking, for all of your blustering.

No I don't laugh at the Geneva conventions, but if you knew squat about them you would know they were designed in a different age for wars between recognized nations, who had each accepted the conventions.
So essentially, there is no Geneva Convention if you don't fight on part of a nation? That then you're given the ability to go around doing as you will to anyone you happen to not like?

It takes two to play that game, and the Geneva Conventions is not, as you seem to think, the Ten Commandments of all Morality; but it sure seems to make a real kumbaya mantra for some.
Well hell yeah, I love the Geneva Convention. A good set of guidelines, and I'll wait until someone shows differently.

I find it intriguing that you think that we should treat soldiers with respect and morality, but as soon as they aren't part of any nation, we can do whatever the hell we feel like. Sorry, but no go.

You still have yet to demonstrate, in any verifiable manner, that torture has any place on the battlefield or that it's any bit useful.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom