Well those "some" definitions include all Christian, Jewish and Islamic beliefs. If God cannot make a true statement in the world about the world then none of those beliefs have any validity whatsoever.
Any definition of God that would be wiped out would be one involving a God that can do the illogical within the laws of logic. I doubt anyone would have a problem wiping out such a self-contradictory definition. If you want God to do the illogical, then it would obviously result in something illogical. If God can do the illogical, then he is outside of logic and logic cannot be used to prove or disprove his existance. We've already discussed that at length.
There are three possibilities: 1) no, God cannot do something that is logically self-contradictory, 2) yes, God is beyond logic and can do things that are logically self-contradictory but since we are bound by logic we cannot hope to understand them logically, 3) God could change the laws of logic to make the logically impossible logically possible (in which case your proof would no longer hold) or 4) the premise is meaningless because it is logically self-contradictory.
Personally, I vote for (4) because you are defining "free will" so that the premise logically contradicts itself, and then insisting that God must fit into this illogical definition, but then if he does you claim that God is illogical and therefore cannot exist.
In any case I have demonstrated that it does follow from the premise. If God cannot insert information then he cannot do anything at all.
Again, unless I'm completely misunderstanding the proof, you have only shown that God cannot insert a specific type of information into the world (particularly a type of information that you have defined in a self-contradictory way). Your proof absolutely depends on this specific self-contradictory action being performed. True enough, God cannot logically insert an infallibly true statement reading "This statement is false" into the world, but you haven't shown that God's insertion of the statement "Peace out!" into the world would create any logical contradiction or preclude free will in any way. If you're claiming that God cannot do
anything at all to the world which has free will, you'll have to develop a different proof (one that contains no logical self-contradictions).
You might want to discuss that with a Christian theologist before being quite sure. For example Psalm 22 is pretty universally believed to contain an infallible prediction of the free will behaviour of Christ's executioners. And there is also that whole "Revelations" thing.
As I already pointed out, many Christians who believe in predestination don't believe in free will. That passage is taken by some Christians as proof of predestination (and that we don't have free will).
As for those who
do believe in free will, they would likely disagree with your definition of free will. Your definition of free will is essentially something that is unpredictable, and yet you're insisting that if God cannot predict it then he cannot exist. Very few religions would have a problem with God not being able to predict something that even he cannot predict (or knowing something that cannot be known, or doing something that cannot be done). The discussion concerning logical self-contradictions (such as whether God can create a rock larger than he can lift) has been discussed thouroughly by Christian theologists, and has already been discussed at length on this thread. You're not really going to bring back the square circle argument again are you?
He can do anything that does not involve making any emprically measureable change to the world. I'm not sure how much that leaves.
Actually, he can logically do anything that you can define in a logically coherent way. Making a rock bigger than he can lift is not logically coherent. Predicting something that you define as unpredictable is not logically coherent. Creating a married bachelor is also logically incoherent, as is creating a true statement reading "This statement is false."
If you believe that your proof holds for all
logical actions for God, then please reformulate it to demonstrate that an omniscient God cannot participate in any
logical way whatsoever with a world in which free will exists.
And as I have already shown you can easily create a definition for a square circle if you are allowed to include the clause "...unless it involves any contradiction".
So...I guess you are going to go there after all. A square circle
always involves a contradiction, but you leave that possibility undefined in your definition. That like defining a frog as a blue animal that can fly -- unless it's not blue or can't fly. True enough, but not much of a definition.
Well put it this way round then - if God can't insert the statement he can't force a point mutation in the junk DNA of a Bufo Marinara. If God can't insert the statement he can't alter the propery of a human neuron, or inspire knowledge in a human mind. If God can't put the grafitti on the wall then he can't create the wall. What do you think that he can organise the construction and will be prevented from doing the decoration?
He can insert a statement, just not a logically self-contradictory statement (at least not while remaining within our laws of logic). He also cannot insert an infallibly true statement reading "This statement is false" within the current laws of logic. You'll have to reformulate your proof if you want the proof to pertain to doing something that is logically possible. You'll also have to show that God cannot do
any logically possible thing in a world with free will to prove your conclusion.
It is not I that demand that God do this contradictory thing. It is anybody who insists that an omniscient being is capable of participating in a universe that contains free will that demand this. I am pointing out the contradiction, nothing else.
No, I assure you, it is only those who attempt to disprove the existance of God logically who demand that God must be able to do the logically impossible within the confines of logic. The contradiction is within the question, not the answer.
-Bri