Not exactly. Without evil there can be no omnibenevolence because without the attributes of forgiveness or charity, goodness is not "all good" it is quasi-good. As Jesus stated, "So you do good to those that do good to you? Big deal, anybody can do that." He then goes on to demonstrate that the highest and most complete form of good is good in the midst of evil.
Two things here. First, to even begin making a case, we have to assume god's omnipotence, which is in no way relevant to the discussion of omnibenevolence. Not all theists, not even all Christians support the theory of omnipotence and while the idea exists in the Bible, the word does not. Second, we have to demonstrate that natural disasters are evil, which removes the word "natural" from the noun.
This is a hypothetical question, not really a logical one, so I cannot answer definitively. We must operate from what we know, and we know disasters really happen. We also know that omni-benevolence cannot logically exist without evil, which is my only point.
Omni-benevolence logically demands good and evil. The best counter to this claim is not the existence of a neutral world, but a counter presented in the link above: Why the quantity of evil? In other words, God could have demonstrated omni-benevolence with a handful of examples, why does He need millions of them?
You seem to be wanting to argue for or against God's omnipotence, which is an interesting question, but really not relevant to the issue of evil.
Flick
So in summary, God is caring, but incompetent.
I think at this point we need to define "good" and "evil", the definition I tend to work from "evil"= suffering, and "good"= the negation of suffering. Comments?
from your posts i understand that Your definition of "good" is the negation of suffering
which has already taken place, this does logicallyrequire"evil" in order to exist, but I do not agree that all other forms of "good" are just "quasi-good"
I would argue that your definition focuses too much on the process, and not on the outcome.
Is more good achieved by a hungry man finding food, or by another man giving him food? The suffering is still negated, but only one outcome is "good" by your definition.
Also by my definition of "good" and "evil", natural disasters are "evil" by definition as they casue suffering.
If you disagree with my definition of "evil", fine don't call it the problem of evil, call it the problem of suffering. The problem still stands, how is it better to allow some members of humanity to suffer, to allow god to show how "good" he is by reducing that suffering for some people, some of the time?
Actually omnipotence is relevant to the problem of evil,
assuming that god exists, he either cannot eliminate suffering, or chooses not to.
God cannot logically be both Omnipotent and Omni-benevolence (the fact that these words do not appear in the Bible is a red hearing, the concepts clearly do, a rose by any other name and all that...) therefor the popular image of god espoused by most Americans (the target of the article in the OP) must have a flawed view of what god is, if there is a god.
It is interesting that you avid my question of the elimination of good and evil as a hypothetical question,
in a conversation abbot god. The whole debate is hypothetical, until such time as we have evidence for they existence of god (or gods).