There is No God (And You Know It)

JLam

Proud Skepkid Parent
Joined
Dec 28, 2004
Messages
4,149
Read This

Perhaps the best argument for athiesm I've ever seen.
 
Last edited:
He is confusing the illogicality of the God of the Bible with the illogicality of any description of God.

It's not so much an anti-God article as an anti-God-of-Abraham (Yahweh, Jehovah, Allah) article.
And, given that, I agree with him.

But there are other notions of God.
 
Beleth,

He is confusing the illogicality of the God of the Bible with the illogicality of any description of God.

It's not so much an anti-God article as an anti-God-of-Abraham (Yahweh, Jehovah, Allah) article.
And, given that, I agree with him.

But there are other notions of God.
You've been talking with philosophers too much. ;)

There is no need for the author to clarify that he is talking specifically about the kind of sky-daddy gods that most people believe in, as opposed to vague philosophical conceptions of god which just about nobody actually believes in. For the majority of people reading the article, such a clarification would just be confusing. For those of us who are familiar with the more philosophical side of the argument, it is quite clear (as it was to you) that he is only really talking about the popular supernatural theistic gods which people around the world not only believe in, but actually think cares about them and is watching over them protectively.


Dr. Stupid
 
I thought I was actually going to read something new in the link. :(

It's the same sad argument, and unfortuneately for all you atheists out there, he basically asserts that:

The entirety of atheism is contained in this response.

I pretty much stopped reading at that sentence, but scrolled down to see the word Katrina, and figured I'd just X out.

Flick
 
I thought I was actually going to read something new in the link. :(

It's the same sad argument, and unfortuneately for all you atheists out there, he basically asserts that:



I pretty much stopped reading at that sentence, but scrolled down to see the word Katrina, and figured I'd just X out.

Flick

but do you have a decent response to "the problem of evil"?

Or do you just want to discredit all atheists because one atheist mentions a recent hurricane?
Do you discredit all theists when one uses a recent to try and prove that there is a god?
 
There is no relation between the "problem of evil" and the concept of an universe created by the volition of an entity.
The problem of evil is a problem for those who sustain a belief in a benevolent creator, not for the rest. Remenber that even the first god of the Bible was quite cruel. Hebrews believed that all bad happenings came from the god/gods.
 
There is no relation between the "problem of evil" and the concept of an universe created by the volition of an entity.
The problem of evil is a problem for those who sustain a belief in a benevolent creator, not for the rest. Remenber that even the first god of the Bible was quite cruel. Hebrews believed that all bad happenings came from the god/gods.

It is quite clear that the article was talking about the modern concept of an omi-benevolent Christan god, as espoused by the majority of Americans.

The problem of suffering portion if this this article is not aimed at those who are prepared to accept that any god that exists is, incompetent, negligent, indifferent or sadistic. The only argument aimed at those who believe in a non-omibenovlant God is "so you believe in a supernatural being? evidence please!" .
Hey, it works for me, its up to to the theists to prove their case, until that time the logical default is atheism, unless were to keep an open mind about other mythical creatures until there existence is disproved.
 
My views on the problem of evil are in this thread, toward the end:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=43127

Flick

Your argument seems to be that without evil there can be no good.
That brings two problems in firstly how does that justify natural disasters? In what way would eliminating natural disasters reduce the total "goodness" or happiness in the world?
The second problem is, if good can only exist as a contrast to evil, then why would a benevolent god create these extremes, why not just have a neutral state without suffering, but with neither the concept of "good" nor "evil"?
 
Your argument seems to be that without evil there can be no good.

Not exactly. Without evil there can be no omni-benevolence because without the attributes of forgiveness or charity, goodness is not "all good" it is quasi-good. As Jesus stated, "So you do good to those that do good to you? Big deal, anybody can do that." He then goes on to demonstrate that the highest and most complete form of good is good in the midst of evil.

That brings two problems in firstly how does that justify natural disasters?

Two things here. First, to even begin making a case, we have to assume god's omnipotence, which is in no way relevant to the discussion of omni-benevolence. Not all theists, not even all Christians support the theory of omni-potence and while the idea exists in the Bible, the word does not. Second, we have to demonstrate that natural disasters are evil, which removes the word "natural" from the noun.

In what way would eliminating natural disasters reduce the total "goodness" or happiness in the world?

This is a hypothetical question, not really a logical one, so I cannot answer definitively. We must operate from what we know, and we know disasters really happen. We also know that omnibenevolence cannot logically exist without evil, which is my only point.

The second problem is, if good can only exist as a contrast to evil, then why would a benevolent god create these extremes, why not just have a neutral state without suffering, but with neither the concept of "good" nor "evil"?

Omni-benevolence logically demands good and evil. The best counter to this claim is not the existence of a neutral world, but a counter presented in the link above: Why the quantity of evil? In other words, God could have demonstrated omni-benevolence with a handful of examples, why does He need millions of them?

You seem to be wanting to argue for or against God's omnipotence, which is an interesting question, but really not relevant to the issue of evil.

Flick
 
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years nevertheless kick and scream and threaten to turn blue in the face at the notion that God might take a mere few hundred human lifetimes in order to completely and unconditionally defeat evil and the evil one for all eternity.

Yes, I know the next line in the litany: "If there is a God, he should be able to do [fill in the blank] right now!" Sounds like a certain three-year old I remember. Yes, and Ronald Reagan could have ended the cold war on his first inauguration day; all he had to do was push the button. But, looking back, do you think that Reagan might have had some reasons for pursuing a more drawn-out strategy? Does anyone really regret the fact that he didn't nuke the Soviets the first time he had a chance? If not, then can your feeble minds perhaps stretch enough to make the connection that God, as well, might have some reason for delaying the last judgment? And that, when the day comes when we know all of the relevant facts, we too might agree that he was right to do so?
 
If God exists, either He can do nothing to stop the most egregious calamities, or He does not care to. God, therefore, is either impotent or evil. Pious readers will now execute the following pirouette: God cannot be judged by merely human standards of morality.

There was a poster who, despite his other flaws, pointed out why the Argument from Evil is not conclusive:

Harris has apparently either missed or ignored that the Problem of Evil is no longer argued against God in professional philosophy. Why? Because it cannot be proven that God, if He exists, does not have morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil - even intense (or seemingly gratuitous) evil. (source)

He isn't quite right, AFAIK, in saying that "the Problem of Evil is no longer argued against God in professional philosophy." However, the rest is about right. To point this out does not even require doing the "pirouette" of saying that "God cannot be judged by merely human standards of morality." Regular old humans can have their own morally sufficient reasons for allowing evil, which generally revolve around allowing some evil so that a greater evil would not take place. If God is omnipotent but still constrained by logic, then there is a possibility that his choices are constrained and that for whatever possibly unknown reasons, a universe that involves no suffering at all is not feasible or not the one that truly maximizes the good. The problem is that while we can protest that if God exists, then he's done a botched job of the universe and that not even the hope of a blessed life after death can make up for that, it would take a "God's-eye view" to establish that was truly the case.

This does not mean that the Argument from Evil is totally without force, since atheism more parsimoniously accounts for evil than theism. However, while the presence of evil is evidence against God, it is not sufficient evidence in and of itself to rule out an omnipotent, omnibenevolent god.
 
ehbowen --- Could you demonstrate more clearly what preventing a hurricane has in common with perpetrating a global nuclear holocaust?

Otherwise I question the validity of your analogy.
 
Not exactly. Without evil there can be no omnibenevolence because without the attributes of forgiveness or charity, goodness is not "all good" it is quasi-good. As Jesus stated, "So you do good to those that do good to you? Big deal, anybody can do that." He then goes on to demonstrate that the highest and most complete form of good is good in the midst of evil.



Two things here. First, to even begin making a case, we have to assume god's omnipotence, which is in no way relevant to the discussion of omnibenevolence. Not all theists, not even all Christians support the theory of omnipotence and while the idea exists in the Bible, the word does not. Second, we have to demonstrate that natural disasters are evil, which removes the word "natural" from the noun.



This is a hypothetical question, not really a logical one, so I cannot answer definitively. We must operate from what we know, and we know disasters really happen. We also know that omni-benevolence cannot logically exist without evil, which is my only point.



Omni-benevolence logically demands good and evil. The best counter to this claim is not the existence of a neutral world, but a counter presented in the link above: Why the quantity of evil? In other words, God could have demonstrated omni-benevolence with a handful of examples, why does He need millions of them?

You seem to be wanting to argue for or against God's omnipotence, which is an interesting question, but really not relevant to the issue of evil.

Flick

So in summary, God is caring, but incompetent. :p

I think at this point we need to define "good" and "evil", the definition I tend to work from "evil"= suffering, and "good"= the negation of suffering. Comments?


from your posts i understand that Your definition of "good" is the negation of suffering which has already taken place, this does logicallyrequire"evil" in order to exist, but I do not agree that all other forms of "good" are just "quasi-good"
I would argue that your definition focuses too much on the process, and not on the outcome.
Is more good achieved by a hungry man finding food, or by another man giving him food? The suffering is still negated, but only one outcome is "good" by your definition.
Also by my definition of "good" and "evil", natural disasters are "evil" by definition as they casue suffering.

If you disagree with my definition of "evil", fine don't call it the problem of evil, call it the problem of suffering. The problem still stands, how is it better to allow some members of humanity to suffer, to allow god to show how "good" he is by reducing that suffering for some people, some of the time?


Actually omnipotence is relevant to the problem of evil,
assuming that god exists, he either cannot eliminate suffering, or chooses not to.

God cannot logically be both Omnipotent and Omni-benevolence (the fact that these words do not appear in the Bible is a red hearing, the concepts clearly do, a rose by any other name and all that...) therefor the popular image of god espoused by most Americans (the target of the article in the OP) must have a flawed view of what god is, if there is a god.




It is interesting that you avid my question of the elimination of good and evil as a hypothetical question, in a conversation abbot god. The whole debate is hypothetical, until such time as we have evidence for they existence of god (or gods).
 
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years nevertheless kick and scream and threaten to turn blue in the face at the notion that God might take a mere few hundred human lifetimes in order to completely and unconditionally defeat evil and the evil one for all eternity.

Yes, I know the next line in the litany: "If there is a God, he should be able to do [fill in the blank] right now!" Sounds like a certain three-year old I remember. Yes, and Ronald Reagan could have ended the cold war on his first inauguration day; all he had to do was push the button. But, looking back, do you think that Reagan might have had some reasons for pursuing a more drawn-out strategy? Does anyone really regret the fact that he didn't nuke the Soviets the first time he had a chance? If not, then can your feeble minds perhaps stretch enough to make the connection that God, as well, might have some reason for delaying the last judgment? And that, when the day comes when we know all of the relevant facts, we too might agree that he was right to do so?

Exellent. I await with bated breath for evil to finally be eradicated from this world by God, who, by garsh, is giving it his best shot. Kinda like Reagan, I guess (Oh man! Someone is actually comparing Reagan to GOD!!)

Or perhaps some of the feeble minds who are defending God might just explore the notion that the delay in eradicating evil on God's part is soley the product of his non-existence.
It makes much more sense than the alternative. The apologists come out in force when faced with the concept of good and evil and an omnipotent God, but in the process only prove that all the hoops you have to jump through to justify God's behaviour is a pretty good indicator that he doesn't exist at all.
 
The apologists come out in force when faced with the concept of good and evil and an omnipotent God, but in the process only prove that all the hoops you have to jump through to justify God's behaviour is a pretty good indicator that he doesn't exist at all.

Why? You ever seen the maths needed to explain the behaviour of electrons (ok technicaly I know that the answer is no since we can't solve the equations). Does this mean we conclude that eletrons don't exist?
 
I never cease to be amazed by the fact that the same people who can so smugly accept as proven fact that a horse can be bred from a bacterium in four billion years nevertheless kick and scream and threaten to turn blue in the face at the notion that God might take a mere few hundred human lifetimes in order to completely and unconditionally defeat evil and the evil one for all eternity.

I have seen horses, and I have seen bacterium, and I have seen a lot of well supported research on evolution. I have seen how short term evolution of bacterium and other micro-organisms are having a direct effect on our day to day lives (MRSA anyone?)

I have yet to see god, or any evidence for god.

Also, if god is so set on eliminating evil why did he create it in the first place?
 
or any evidence for god.
[/I]

What a strange life you must lead. Never to have heard of the koran or the bible or torah or the veldic texts behind hinduism etc. You may not except these as enough evidence to come to the conclusion that god does exist but they are evidence non the less.

Further more the logical end point of your position is that certian roman emperors did not in fact exist nor did any of the pharos. Of course this is simply due to your failer to define your terms.
 
Why? You ever seen the maths needed to explain the behaviour of electrons (ok technicaly I know that the answer is no since we can't solve the equations). Does this mean we conclude that eletrons don't exist?

If the sole basis for the existence of god stems from the premise "You can't prove he doesn't exist" then I think that shows how incredibly weak the argument for his existence is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom