There is No God (And You Know It)

Well, then I guess the question is, what do YOU consider "proof" ?

As with anything, I would consider proof either 1) demonstrating as scientific fact that another competing theory is true or that free will cannot possibly be true, or 2) a general consensus among philosophers that a logical proof that free will cannot be true is irrefutable. In either case, I would imagine that the process would involve submitting your ideas to one or more reputable scientific or philosophical journals for peer review.

Option (1) is highly unlikely to occur since science seldom can prove anything as fact. Option (2) is perhaps more likely, but also unlikely in light of thousands of years of discussion on these topics without an irrefutable logical proof.

In either case, if you have in fact submitted irrefutable proof to peer review, it would be fairly obvious and you would very quickly become famous. Otherwise, you would probably be laughed at for claiming to have irrefutable proof of something.

-Bri
 
Option (1) is highly unlikely to occur since science seldom can prove anything as fact.

Seems to me like you believe that NOTHING is a proven fact.

Option (2) is perhaps more likely, but also unlikely in light of thousands of years of discussion on these topics without an irrefutable logical proof.

Either that, or theists simply refuse to accept the truth.
 
Seems to me like you believe that NOTHING is a proven fact.

It might be a proven fact that nothing is a proven fact, in which case I couldn't possibly believe that nothing is a proven fact!

Either that, or theists simply refuse to accept the truth.

I doubt that there would even be a consensus among atheist philosophers that such a logical argument was irrefutable (given the fact that few are). Many (if not most) atheist philosophers will admit that no proof has been thought of to date that demonstrates irrefutably that free will cannot exist.

-Bri
 
I doubt that there would even be a consensus among atheist philosophers that such a logical argument was irrefutable (given the fact that few are). Many (if not most) atheist philosophers will admit that no proof has been thought of to date that demonstrates irrefutably that free will cannot exist.
The concept is inherently logically contradictory. What more proof is needed?
 
It might be a proven fact that nothing is a proven fact, in which case I couldn't possibly believe that nothing is a proven fact!

Head. Explode. :)

I doubt that there would even be a consensus among atheist philosophers that such a logical argument was irrefutable (given the fact that few are). Many (if not most) atheist philosophers will admit that no proof has been thought of to date that demonstrates irrefutably that free will cannot exist.

Okay. Let's go with probabilities, then. Which is more likely, and would you agree that the lesser possibility is lesser by QUITE an extent ?
 
Okay. Let's go with probabilities, then. Which is more likely, and would you agree that the lesser possibility is lesser by QUITE an extent ?

I would certainly agree that based on current evidence, it is more likely that we don't have free will than that we do have free will, perhaps even much more likely. Of course, it is still possible that free will is reality. Do you agree?

-Bri
 
The concept is inherently logically contradictory. What more proof is needed?

The mere concept is inherently logically contradictory? If you are saying that under no conditions or definitions could free will possibly exist, that's a claim that would require some evidence.

I assume that this evidence will include descriptions of every condition and definition possible, along with an irrefutable logical proof of how free will by this definition cannot exist under those conditions. If there are any possible conditions or definitions for which you haven't provided irrefutable proof, then your evidence is either incomplete or your claim is false.

When you've finished compiling this evidence, please submit it to a respected philosophical journal for review.

-Bri
 
I would certainly agree that based on current evidence, it is more likely that we don't have free will than that we do have free will, perhaps even much more likely. Of course, it is still possible that free will is reality. Do you agree?

-Bri

I'll settle for that.
 
The simple point that Bri has been deliberately missing for the past 2 months is that uncaused means absence of cause. Uncaused events would happen randomly so it is useful to describe uncaused events as random.

Although his fallacy has been pointed out to him many times Bri persists with the notion that there can be different flavours of uncaused events, of which one is 'random' and another could be 'free'.

Despite his protestations to the contrary the onus is clearly upon Bri to show how an absence of a quality can have categories. You cannot have red nothing and blue nothing - only nothing.

Bri's ability to argue, misdirect and spoil suggests a sharp intelligence but one that is misused in this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom